Molecular Crowding: The History and Development of a Scientific Paradigm.

It is now generally accepted that macromolecules do not act in isolation but "live" in a crowded environment, that is, an environment populated by numerous different molecules. The field of molecular crowding has its origins in the far 80s but became accepted only by the end of the 90s. In the present issue, we discuss various aspects that are influenced by crowding and need to consider its effects. This Review is meant as an introduction to the theme and an analysis of the evolution of the crowding concept through time from colloidal and polymer physics to a more biological perspective. We introduce themes that will be more thoroughly treated in other Reviews of the present issue. In our intentions, each Review may stand by itself, but the complete collection has the aspiration to provide different but complementary perspectives to propose a more holistic view of molecular crowding.

On the Mechanism of Self-Assembly of Fibrinogen in Thrombin-free Aqueous Solution.

Fibrinogen dissolved in 0.12 M aqueous NaCl solution at a pH of 6.6 exhibits self-assembly in response to a lowering of the NaCl concentration to values equal to or lower than 60 mM. As has been established in a preceding work (Langmuir 2019, 35, and 12113), a characteristic signature of the self-assembly triggered by a drop in ionic strength is the formation of large globular particles. Growth of these particles most likely obeys a coalescence-like process also termed a step growth process. In order to extend this knowledge, the present work first optimized the protocol, leading to highly reproducible self-assembly experiments. Based on this optimization, the work succeeded in identifying an initial stage, not yet accessible, during which rigid short fibrils grow in close analogy to the thrombin-catalyzed polymerization of fibrin. In addition, first suggestions could be made on the transformation of these fibrils into larger aggregates, which upon drying turn into thick fiber-like ropes.

Impact of Additive Hydrophilicity on Mixed Dye-Nonionic Surfactant Micelles: Micelle Morphology and Dye Localization.

The nonionic surfactant pentaethylene glycol-monododecylether C12E5 forms micelles in aqueous solutions with a lower critical solution temperature. This characteristic solution behavior of C12E5 is independent of the pH. Such micelles are used to solubilize a large variety of active guest molecules like for instance dyestuffs. An example is an acidic azo dye termed Blue used as a hair colorant. Depending on the pH, Blue gradually changes its hydrophilicity from the protonated BlueH at pH = 2 to the bivalent anion Blue2- at pH = 13 while keeping the shape and size of Blue essentially unchanged. These features of C12E5 and Blue offer the unique chance to investigate the sole impact of a tunable hydrophilicity of a guest molecule on the solution behavior of mixed micelles of the guest and C12E5. Accordingly, the present work establishes a phase diagram of Blue-C12E5 micelles and analyzes their morphology including the spatial distribution of Blue in the micelles as a function of the hydrophilicity of Blue. Small angle neutron scattering reveals the size and shape of the micelles, and detailed contrast matching of the C12E5 supported by 1H NMR with NOESY provided insight into the localization of Blue within the micelles as its hydrophilicity changes.

Ethylene glycol energetically disfavours oligomerization of pseudoisocyanine dyestuffs at crowded concentrations.

The intriguing role of the intracellular crowded environment in regulating protein aggregation remains elusive. The convolution of several factors such as the protein sequence-dependence, crowder's shape and size and diverse intermolecular interactions makes it complex to identify systematic trends. One of the ways to simplify the problem is to study a synthetic model for self-assembling proteins. In this study, we examine the aggregation behaviour of the cationic pseudoisocyanine chloride (PIC) dyestuff which is known to self-assemble and form fibril-like J-aggregates in aqueous solutions, similar to those formed by amyloid-forming proteins. Prior experimental studies have shown that polyethylene glycol impedes and Ficoll-400 promotes the self-assembly of PIC dyes. To achieve molecular insights, we examine the effect of crowding by ethylene glycol on the solvation thermodynamics of oligomerization of dyes into H-type and J-type oligomers using extensive molecular dynamics simulations. The binding free energy calculations show that the formation of J-oligomers is more favourable than that of H-oligomers in water. The stability of H- and J- tetramers and pentamers decreases in crowded solutions. The formation of oligomers is supported by the favourable change in dye-solvent interaction energy in both pure water and aqueous ethylene glycol solution although it is opposed by the reduced dye-solvent entropy. Ethylene glycol, as a molecular crowder, disfavours the H- as well as J-oligomerization via preferential binding to the dye oligomers. An unfavourable change in dye-crowder and dye-dye interaction energy on dye association makes the H-oligomer formation less favourable in crowded solution than in pure water solution. In the case of J-oligomers, however, the unfavourable change in dye-crowder interaction energy primarily contributes to making total dye-solvent energy unfavourable. The results are supported by isothermal titration calorimetry measurements where the binding of ethylene glycol to PIC molecules is found to be endothermic. The results provide an emerging view that a crowded environment can disfavour self-assembly of PIC dyes by interactions with the oligomeric states. The findings have implications in understanding the role of a crowded environment in shaping the free energy landscapes of proteins.

Comparative study of the self-assembly behaviour of 3-chloro-4-hydroxy-phenylazo dyes.

The complexity of intermolecular interactions and the difficulty to predict assembly behaviour solely based on chemical constitution was demonstrated by studying the self-assembly of three one-fold negatively charged 3-chloro-4-hydroxy-phenylazo dyes (Yellow, Blue and Red). Dye self-assembly was investigated using UV/vis- and NMR-spectroscopy, light- and small-angle neutron scattering. Significant differences between the three dyes were observed. While Yellow does not self-assemble, Red assembles into higher-order aggregates and Blue forms well-defined H-aggregate dimers with a dimerization constant of KD = (728 ± 8) L mol-1. Differences between dyes were suggested to emerge from variations in the propensity to form π-π-interactions due to electrostatic repulsion, sterical constraints and hydrogen-bonding interactions.

Comparative study of the co-assembly behaviour of 3-chloro-4-hydroxy-phenylazo dyes with DTAB.

The co-assembly of three one-fold negatively charged 3-chloro-4-hydroxy-phenylazo dyes (Yellow, Blue and Red) with the cationic surfactant dodecyltrimethylammoniumbromide (DTAB) was studied to probe dye-DTAB binding stoichiometry and assembly morphology. For each dye, phase separation was observed above a given dye : DTAB ratio with the ratio depending on the dye. While Yellow and DTAB showed liquid/liquid phase separation above Yellow : DTAB = 1 : 1.67, crystalline dye-DTAB complexes were observed for Blue-DTAB and Red-DTAB above Blue : DTAB = 1 : 2.56 and Red : DTAB = 1 : 2.94 respecively. In homogeneous solution, UV/vis spectroscopic investigations suggest stochiometries of Yellow : DTAB = 1 : 2, Blue : DTAB = 1 : 3 and Red : DTAB = 1 : 4. It was concluded, that Yellow exhibits the highest dye : DTAB binding stoichiometry in both, dye-surfactant complexes in the 2-phase region and in solution, whereas the lowest dye : DTAB binding stoichiometry was observed for Red-DTAB in both cases. The observed stoichiometries are inversely correlated to the impact dye addition has on the morphology of DTAB micelles. Generally, addition of dye to DTAB micelles leads to a reduction in spontaneous curvature of these micelles and to the formation of triaxial ellipsoidal or cylindrical micelles from oblate ellipsoidal DTAB micelles. At a DTAB concentration of 30 mM and a dye concentration of 5 mM, this effect was most pronounced for Red and least pronounced for Yellow, whilst Blue showed an intermediate effect.

Targeted Synthesis of the Type-A Particle Substructure from Enzymatically Produced Eumelanin.

Eumelanin exhibits a defined supramolecular buildup that is deprived of at least three distinct particle species. To enable the full potential of its promising material properties, access to all particle types is crucial. In this work, the first protocol for the synthesis of the intermediate type-A particles in pure and stable dispersion form is described. It is found that aggregation of type-A particles into the larger type-B variant can be inhibited by a strict pH control during the synthesis. The exact influence of pH on the supramolecular buildup is investigated via a combination of time-resolved light scattering, electron microscopy, and UV-vis spectroscopy. It is observed that a rapid buildup of type-B particles occurs without pH control and is generally dominant at lower pH values. At pH values above 6.2 however, type-A particles are gained, and no further aggregation occurs. Even more, lowering the pH of such a stable type-A dispersion at a later stage lifts the inhibition and again leads to the formation of larger particle species. The results confirm that it is easily possible to halt the aggregation of eumelanin substructures and to access them in the form of a stable dispersion. Moreover, a profound additional understanding of the supramolecular buildup is gained by the in-depth investigation of the pH influence.

Self-Assembled Fibrinogen Hydro- and Aerogels with Fibrin-like 3D Structures.

The natural blood protein fibrinogen is a highly potent precursor for the production of various biomaterials due to its supreme biocompatibility and cell interaction. To gain actual materials from fibrinogen, the protein needs to undergo fibrillogenesis, which is mostly triggered via enzymatic processing to fibrin, electrospinning, or drying processes. All of those techniques, however, strongly limit the available structures or the applicability of the material. To overcome the current issues of fibrin(ogen) as material, we herein present a highly feasible, quick, and inexpensive technique for self-assembly of fibrinogen in solution into defined, nanofibrous three-dimensional (3D) patterns. Upon interaction with specific anions in controlled environments, stable and flexible hydrogel-like structures are formed without any further processing. Moreover, the material can be converted into highly porous and elastic aerogels by lyophilization. Both of these material classes have never been described before from native fibrinogen. The observed phenomenon also represents the first enzyme-free process of fibrillogenesis from fibrinogen with significant yield in solution. The produced hydrogels and aerogels were investigated via electron microscopy, IR spectroscopy, and fluorescence spectroscopy, which also confirms the native state of the protein. Additionally, their mechanical properties were compared with actual fibrin and unstructured fibrinogen. The structural features show a striking analogy to actual fibrin, both as hydro- and aerogel. This renders the new material a highly promising alternative for fibrin in biomaterial applications. A much faster initiation of fiber formation, exclusion of possible thrombin residuals, and low-cost reagents are great advantages.

Mechanism and equilibrium thermodynamics of H- and J-aggregate formation from pseudo isocyanine chloride in water.

Pseudo isocyanine chloride (PIC) has a strong tendency to self-assemble with a concentration dependent temperature threshold separating a regime with small H-oligomers in equilibrium with monomeric PIC from a regime where large J-aggregates form. In complementing the known set of absorption spectra by the spectrum of a trimer, which represents all H-aggregates with N ≥ 3, a full description of the sample composition of PIC in the regime of oligomers became possible by means of UV-vis spectroscopy and gave access to the equilibrium thermodynamics of oligomerisation. Successful interpretation of the concentration dependent temperature threshold as a ceiling temperature of J-aggregation made also accessible equilibrium thermodynamics of the formation of J-aggregates together with a full analysis of composition also in the regime of J-aggregates. Evolution of an invariant spectrum for the J-aggregates demonstrates full consistency of the composition analysis. Complementary light scattering experiments led to a comprehensive characterisation of all aggregate species above and below the aggregation threshold. Once initiated, J-aggregates always grow to a final length of 650 nm. Time-resolved light scattering confirmed that the self-assembly of J-aggregates follows a monomer addition process in analogy to a chain growth in polymer chemistry. Initiation and growth of individual aggregates turned out to be always much faster than the progress of aggregation.

Self-Assembly of Pseudo-Isocyanine Chloride as a Sensor for Macromolecular Crowding In Vitro and In Vivo.

Pseudo-isocyanine chloride (PIC) is a cationic dyestuff that exhibits self-assembly in aqueous solution, promoted either by increasing the PIC concentration or by decreasing the temperature. PIC-aggregates exhibit a characteristic and sharp absorption band as well as a fluorescence band at a wavelength of 573 nm making PIC an interesting candidate to analyze the self-assembly process in various environments. The present work developed PIC-based, synthetic model systems, suitable to investigate how macromolecular crowding influences self-assembly processes. Four synthetic additives were used as potential crowders: Triethylene glycol (TEG), polyethylene glycol (PEG), Ficoll 400 as a highly branched polysaccharide, and sucrose corresponding to the monomeric unit of Ficoll. Combined UV/Vis spectroscopy and time-resolved light scattering revealed a strong impact of crowding based on excluded volume effects only for Ficoll 400. Sucrose had hardly any influence on the self-assembly of PIC and PEG and TEG impeded the PIC self-assembly. Development of such a PIC based model system led over to in-cell experiments. HeLa cells were infiltrated with PIC solutions well below the aggregation threshold in the infiltrating solution. In the cellular environment, PIC was exposed to a significant crowding and immediately started to aggregate. As was demonstrated by fluorescence imaging, the extent of aggregation can be modulated by exposing the cells to salt-induced osmotic stress. The results suggest future use of such a system as a sensor for the analysis of in vitro and in vivo crowding effects on self-assembly processes.

Controlling Self-Assembly with Light and Temperature.

Complexes between the anionic polyelectrolyte sodium polyacrylate (PA) and an oppositely charged divalent azobenzene dye are prepared in aqueous solution. Depending on the ratio between dye and polyelectrolyte stable aggregates with a well-defined spherical shape are observed. Upon exposure of these complexes to UV light, the trans → cis transition of the azobenzene is excited resulting in a better solubility of the dye and a dissolution of the complexes. The PA chains reassemble into well-defined aggregates when the dye is allowed to relax back into the trans isomer. Varying the temperature during this reformation step has a direct influence on the final size of the aggregates rendering temperature in an efficient way to easily change the size of the self-assemblies. Application of time-resolved small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) to study the structure formation reveals that the cis → trans isomerization is the rate-limiting step followed by a nucleation and growth process.

Self-Assembly of Fibrinogen in Aqueous, Thrombin-Free Solutions of Variable Ionic Strengths.

Fibrinogen not only forms fibrin networks if assisted by thrombin but also exhibits self-assembly in dilute aqueous solutions in the absence of thrombin. It could be shown that self-assembly can be triggered in a controlled way by diluting the ionic strength set to a value of 0.14 M NaCl in the starting solutions. The present work unravels the mechanism of this self-assembly process by means of a combination of time-resolved multiangle static and dynamic light scattering and atomic force microscopy. Analysis was carried out as a function of the ionic strength adjusted by the drop in ionic strength and at variable salt compositions at a given final ionic strength. Composition was varied by changing the ratio of NaCl and phosphate buffer. The self-assembly induced by the drop of the ionic strength depends on the final value. The lower the final ionic strength gets, the faster is the self-assembly process. The variation of the salt composition at a given ionic strength has only a marginal effect, which depends on the ionic strength. The self-assembly obeys a step-growth process, where any intermediate cluster can coalesce with any other cluster. Interpretation of the data with a kinetic model based on the approach of von Smoluchowski follows a diffusion-limited cluster aggregation at ionic strength values lower than 30 mM. At an ionic strength of 30 mM, the model has to take into account a size dependence of the rate constant, and at 60 mM a transition is observed to a reaction-limited cluster aggregation.

Ion-selective binding as a new trigger for micellization of block copolyelectrolytes with two anionic blocks.

This work presents well-defined and switchable micelles of block copolymers consisting of the two anionic polyelectrolytes sodium polyacrylate (NaPA) and sodium polystyrene sulfonate (NaPSS). Micellization occurs due to the specific binding of Ca2+ to acrylate groups, which results in neutralization of the corresponding block and thereby formation of the hydrophobic core of the micelles. In contrast, the PSS block remains charged and forms the stabilizing shell. Micellization is triggered by variations of the Ca2+ concentration or the temperature and is a fully reversible and repeatable process. Small-angle neutron scattering (SANS) could unambiguously reveal the structure of the micelles, using a partially deuterated polymer and the contrast variation technique. Considering the variety of metal cations and their broad spectrum of interactions with polyelectrolytes, this new class of like-charged block copolymers opens the door to a broad range of switchable and responsive polyelectrolyte-based systems.

Lateral association and elongation of vimentin intermediate filament proteins: A time-resolved light-scattering study.

Vimentin intermediate filaments (IFs) are part of a family of proteins that constitute one of the three filament systems in the cytoskeleton, a major contributor to cell mechanics. One property that distinguishes IFs from the other cytoskeletal filament types, actin filaments and microtubules, is their highly hierarchical assembly pathway, where a lateral association step is followed by elongation. Here we present an innovative technique to follow the elongation reaction in solution and in situ by time-resolved static and dynamic light scattering, thereby precisely capturing the relevant time and length scales of seconds to minutes and 60-600 nm, respectively. We apply a quantitative model to our data and succeed in consistently describing the entire set of data, including particle mass, radius of gyration, and hydrodynamic radius during longitudinal association.

Secondary Particle Formation during the Nonaqueous Synthesis of Metal Oxide Nanocrystals.

This study aims to elucidate the aggregation and agglomeration behavior of TiO2 and ZrO2 nanoparticles during the nonaqueous synthesis. We found that zirconia nanoparticles immediately form spherical-like aggregates after nucleation with a homogeneous size of 200 nm, which can be related to the metastable state of the nuclei and the reduction of surface free energy. These aggregates further agglomerate, following a diffusion-limited colloid agglomeration mechanism that is additionally supported by the high fractal dimension of the resulting agglomerates. In contrast, TiO2 nanoparticles randomly orient and follow a reaction-limited colloid agglomeration mechanism that leads to a dense network of particles throughout the entire reaction volume. We performed in situ laser light transmission measurements and showed that particle formation starts earlier than previously reported. A complex population balance equation model was developed that is able to simulate particle aggregation as well as agglomeration, which eventually allowed us to distinguish between both phenomena. Hence, we were able to investigate the respective agglomeration kinetics with great agreement to our experimental data.

Effect of ionic strength on the structure and elongational kinetics of vimentin filaments.

Intermediate filaments are a major structural element in the cytoskeleton of animal cells that mechanically integrate other cytoskeletal components and absorb externally applied stress. Their role is likely to be linked to their complex molecular architecture which is the product of a multi-step assembly pathway. Intermediate filaments form tetrameric subunits which assemble in the presence of monovalent salts to form unit length filaments that subsequently elongate by end-to-end annealing. The present work characterizes this complex assembly process using reconstituted vimentin intermediate filaments with monovalent salts as an assembly trigger. A multi-scale approach is used, comprising static light scattering, dynamic light scattering and quantitative scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) mass measurements. Light scattering reveals the radius of gyration (Rg), molecular weight (Mw) and diffusion coefficient (D) of the assembling filaments as a function of time and salt concentration (cS) for the given protein concentration of 0.07 g L-1. At low cS (10 mM KCl) no lateral or elongational growth is observed, whereas at cS = 50-200 mM, the hydrodynamic cross-sectional radius and the elongation rate increases with cS. Rgversus Mw plots suggest that the mass per unit length increases with increasing salt content, which is confirmed by STEM mass measurements. A kinetic model based on rate equations for a two step process is able to accurately describe the variation of mass, length and diffusion coefficient of the filaments with time and provides a consistent description of the elongation accelerated by increasing cS.

Liquid-liquid phase separation in dilute solutions of poly(styrene sulfonate) with multivalent cations: Phase diagrams, chain morphology, and impact of temperature.

The dilute solution behavior of sodium poly(styrene sulfonate) is studied in the presence of trivalent Al3+ and bivalent Ba2+ cations at various levels of excess NaCl. The study evaluates the phase behavior and the morphology of the polyelectrolyte chains with increasing extent of decoration with the Al3+ and Ba2+ cations and analyses the effect of temperature on these decorated chains. The phase behavior is presented in the form of the cation concentration versus the respective poly(styrene sulfonate) concentration, recorded at the onset of precipitation. Whereas poly(styrene sulfonate) with Al3+ exhibits a linear phase boundary, denoted as the "threshold line," which increases with increasing poly(styrene sulfonate) concentration, Ba2+ cations show a threshold line which is independent of the poly(styrene sulfonate) concentration. An additional re-entrant phase, at considerably higher cation content than those of the threshold lines, is observed with Al3+ cations but not with Ba2+ cations. The threshold line and the re-entrant phase boundary form parts of the liquid-liquid phase boundary observed at the limit of low polymer concentration. The dimensions of the polyelectrolyte chains shrink considerably while approaching the respective threshold lines on increase of the Al3+ and Ba2+ cation content. However, subtle differences occur between the morphological transformation induced by Al3+ and Ba2+. Most strikingly, coils decorated with Al3+ respond very differently to temperature variations than coils decorated with Ba2+ do. As the temperature increases, the poly(styrene sulfonate) chains decrease their size in the presence of Al3+ cations but increase in size in the presence of Ba2+ cations.

Reaction enthalpy from the binding of multivalent cations to anionic polyelectrolytes in dilute solutions.

Dilute solutions of sodium poly(styrene sulfonate) (NaPSS) in the presence of Al3+, Ca2+, and Ba2+ were analysed by means of isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) in order to investigate the heat effect of bond formation between those cations and the anionic SO3- residues of NaPSS. The selection of the cations was guided by the solution behavior of the corresponding PSS salts from a preceding study [M. Hansch et al., J. Chem. Phys. 148(1), 014901 (2018)], where bonds between Ba2+ and anionic PSS showed an increasing solubility with decreasing temperature and Al3+ exhibited the inverse trend. Unlike to Al3+ and Ba2+, Ca2+ is expected to behave as a purely electrostatically interacting bivalent cation and was thus included in the present study. Results from ITC satisfactorily succeeded to explain the temperature-dependent solution behavior of the salts with Al3+ and Ba2+ and confirmed the non-specific behavior of Ca2+. Additional ITC experiments with salts of Ca2+ and Ba2+ and sodium poly(acrylate) complemented the results on PSS by data from a chemically different polyanion. Availability of these joint sets of polyanion-cation combinations not only offers the chance to identify common features and subtle differences in the solution behavior of polyelectrolytes in the presence of multi-valent cations but also points to a new class of responsive materials.

Polyacrylates in the presence of an extraordinary monovalent cation-Solution behavior and metal nanoparticle formation.

Sodium polyacrylate (NaPA) in dilute aqueous solution at an ionic strength of [NaNO3] = 0.01M establishes a rich phase behavior in the presence of low amounts of silver cations, which were introduced at a few millimoles or less by replacing the corresponding amount of Na+ cations. Beyond an extremely low level of Ag+ cations, anionic PA chains aggregate. By increasing the concentration of Ag+, the aggregates become denser and keep on growing without limit. Once a certain range of [Ag+] is reached, the instantaneously formed dense aggregates remain stable. Irradiation of the PA aggregate solutions with UV-light induces formation of silver nanoparticles (Ag-Nps). Based on a combination of UV-vis spectroscopy, light scattering, transmission electron microscopy, and small angle neutron scattering, the mechanism of this NaPA assisted formation of Ag-Nps is studied. One focus of the study is lying on the effect of the two different solution states of dense aggregates, corresponding to the unstable growing AgPA aggregates and to the stable AgPA aggregates and another focus is aiming at the characterisation of the morphology of the generated hybrid particles composed of Ag-Nps and hosting PA chains.

Insight into the Final Step of the Supramolecular Buildup of Eumelanin.

The final step in the supramolecular buildup of eumelanin particles is investigated regarding the involved species and mechanism. Time-resolved in situ light scattering and scanning electron microscopy reveal an aggregation of particles with a narrow size distribution around 40 nm, previously only observed as substructures. These form larger particles with again very uniform size and diameters around 200 nm. Aggregation of each single particle takes only a few minutes to complete, whereas the entire process goes on for at least 3 h, partly due to the kinetics of the precursors. The individual particles also undergo an additional consolidation step toward their final form, which takes up to 24 h. Atomic force microscopy shows that the size before consolidation is around twice the size of the final particles, due to free space between the substructures. Light scattering also reveals that the aggregation is random with respect to where the particles attach, as the shape of aggregates changes from sphere to coil, before it returns to a spherical shape at the end. Application of enzyme mediated autodeposition finally shows the potential to stop the supramolecular buildup at each level, and therefore enables isolation of the respective eumelanin particles at will. This may enable the full potential for melanin materials in nanotechnology deriving from its unique (for biological polymers) properties like paramagnetism, electrical conductivity, and many more.