Hierarchical Self-Organization of Chiral Columns from Chiral Supramolecular Spheres.

The supramolecular column is an archetypal architecture in the field of periodic liquid crystalline and crystalline arrays. Columns are generated via self-assembly, coassembly, and polymerization of monomers containing molecules shaped as discs, tapered, twin- and Janus-tapered, crowns, hat-shaped crowns, and fragments thereof. These supramolecular columns can be helical and therefore exhibit chirality. In contrast, spheres represent a fundamentally distinct architecture, generated from conical and crown-like molecules, which self-organize into body-centered cubic, Pm3̅ n cubic (also known as Frank-Kasper A15), and tetragonal (also known as Frank-Kasper σ) phases. Supramolecular spherical aggregates are not known to further assemble into a columnar architecture, except as an intermediate state between a columnar periodic array and a cubic phase. In the present work, a chiral dendronized cyclotetraveratrylene (CTTV) derivative is demonstrated to self-organize into a supramolecular column unexpectedly constructed from supramolecular spheres, with no subsequent transition to a cubic phase. Structural and retrostructural analysis using a combination of differential scanning calorimetry, X-ray diffraction (XRD), molecular modeling, and simulation of XRD patterns reveals that this CTTV derivative, which is functionalized with eight chiral first-generation minidendrons, self-organizes via a column-from-spheres model. The transition from column to column-from-spheres was monitored by circular dichroism spectroscopy, which demonstrated that both the supramolecular column and supramolecular spheres are chiral. This column-from-spheres model, which unites two fundamentally distinct self-assembled architectures, provides a new mechanism to self-organize supramolecular columnar architectures.

Increasing 3D Supramolecular Order by Decreasing Molecular Order. A Comparative Study of Helical Assemblies of Dendronized Nonchlorinated and Tetrachlorinated Perylene Bisimides.

A nonplanar, twisted, and flexible tetrachlorinated perylene bisimide (Cl4PBI) was functionalized with two AB3 minidendrons containing hydrogenated or semifluorinated dodecyl groups. The hydrogenated dendron was attached to the imide groups of Cl4PBI via m = 0, 1, and 2 methylenic units, whereas the dendron containing semifluorinated groups was attached via m = 3 or a di(ethylene oxide) linker (m = 2EO). The supramolecular structures of these compounds, determined by a combination of differential scanning calorimetry, X-ray diffraction, and solid-state NMR, were compared with those of nonchlorinated planar and rigid PBI reported previously, which demonstrated the thermodynamically controlled formation of 2D periodic arrays at high temperatures and 3D arrays at low temperatures. The molecularly less ordered Cl4PBI containing hydrogenated dendrons self-organize into exclusively 3D crystalline periodic arrays under thermodynamic control for m = 0 and 2, while the more highly molecularly ordered PBI produced less stable and ordered 3D crystals and also 2D assemblies. This induction of a higher degree of 3D order in supramolecular assemblies of the less well-ordered molecular building blocks was unanticipated. The semifluorinated dendronized Cl4PBI with m = 3 formed a 2D columnar hexagonal array under kinetic control, whereas the compound with m = 2EO formed an unusual 2D honeycomb-like hexagonal phase under thermodynamic control. These Cl4PBI compounds provide a new route to stable crystalline assemblies via thermodynamic control at lower temperatures than previously obtained with PBI, thus generating 3D order in an accessible range of temperature of interest for structural analysis and for technological applications.

Self-organizable vesicular columns assembled from polymers dendronized with semifluorinated Janus dendrimers act as reverse thermal actuators.

The synthesis and structural analysis of polymers dendronized with self-assembling Janus dendrimers containing one fluorinated and one hydrogenated dendrons are reported. Janus dendrimers were attached to the polymer backbone both from the hydrogenated and from the fluorinated parts of the Janus dendrimer. Structural analysis of these dendronized polymers and of their precursors by a combination of differential scanning calorimetry, X-ray diffraction experiments on powder and oriented fibers, and electron density maps have demonstrated that in both cases the dendronized polymer consists of a vesicular columnar structure containing fluorinated alkyl groups on its periphery. This vesicular columnar structure is generated by a mechanism that involves the intramolecular assembly of the Janus dendrimers into tapered dendrons followed by the intramolecular self-assembly of the resulting dendronized polymer in a vesicular column. By contrast with conventional polymers dendronized with self-assembling tapered dendrons this new class of dendronized polymers acts as thermal actuators that decrease the length of the supramolecular column when the temperature is increased and therefore, are called reverse thermal actuators. A mechanism for this reversed process was proposed.

Transfer, amplification, and inversion of helical chirality mediated by concerted interactions of C3-supramolecular dendrimers.

The synthesis, structural, and retrostructural analysis of two libraries containing 16 first and second generation C(3)-symmetric self-assembling dendrimers based on dendrons connected at their apex via trisesters and trisamides of 1,3,5-benzenetricarboxylic acid is reported. A combination of X-ray diffraction and CD/UV analysis methods demonstrated that their C(3)-symmetry modulates different degrees of packing on the periphery of supramolecular structures that are responsible for the formation of chiral helical supramolecular columns and spheres self-organizable in a diversity of three-dimensional (3D) columnar, tetragonal, and cubic lattices. Two of these periodic arrays, a 3D columnar hexagonal superlattice and a 3D columnar simple orthorhombic chiral lattice with P222(1) symmetry, are unprecedented for supramolecular dendrimers. A thermal-reversible inversion of chirality was discovered in helical supramolecular columns. This inversion is induced, on heating, by the change in symmetry from a 3D columnar simple orthorhombic chiral lattice to a 3D columnar hexagonal array and, on cooling, by the change in symmetry from a 2D hexagonal to a 2D centered rectangular lattice, both exhibiting intracolumnar order. A first-order transition from coupled columns with long helical pitch, to weakly or uncorrelated columns with short helical pitch that generates a molecular rotator, was also discovered. The torsion angles of the molecular rotator are proportional to the change in temperature, and this effect is amplified in the case of the C(3)-symmetric trisamide supramolecular dendrimers forming H-bonds along their column. The structural changes reported here can be used to design complex functions based on helical supramolecular dendrimers with different degree of packing on their periphery.

Programming the supramolecular helical polymerization of dendritic dipeptides via the stereochemical information of the dipeptide.

Many natural biomacromolecules are homochiral and are built from constituents possessing identical handedness. The construction of synthetic molecules, macromolecules, and supramolecular structures with tailored stereochemical sequences can detail the relationship between chirality and function and provide insight into the process that leads to the selection of handedness and amplification of chirality. Dendritic dipeptides, previously reported from our laboratory, self-assemble into helical porous columns and serve as fundamental mimics of natural porous helix-forming proteins and supramolecular polymers. Herein, the synthesis of all stereochemical permutations of a self-assembling dendritic dipeptide including homochiral, heterochiral, and differentially racemized variants is reported. A combination of CD/UV-vis spectroscopy in solution and in film, X-ray diffraction, and differential scanning calorimetry studies in solid state established the role of the stereochemistry of the dipeptide on the thermodynamics and mechanism of self-assembly. It was found that the highest degree of stereochemical purity, enantiopure homochiral dendritic dipeptides, exhibits the most thermodynamically favorable self-assembly process in solution corresponding to the greatest degree of helical order and intracolumnar crystallization in solid state. Reducing the stereochemical purity of the dendritic dipeptide through heterochirality or by partially or fully racemizing the dendritic dipeptide destructively interferes with the self-assembly process. All dendritic dipeptides were shown to coassemble into single columns regardless of their stereochemistry. Because these columns exhibit no deracemization, the thermodynamic advantage of enantiopurity and homochirality suggests a mechanism for stereochemical selection and chiral amplification.

Self-assembly of dendronized perylene bisimides into complex helical columns.

The synthesis of perylene 3,4:9,10-tetracarboxylic acid bisimides (PBIs) dendronized with first-generation dendrons containing 0 to 4 methylenic units (m) between the imide group and the dendron, (3,4,5)12G1-m-PBI, is reported. Structural analysis of their self-organized arrays by DSC, X-ray diffraction, molecular modeling, and solid-state (1)H NMR was carried out on oriented samples with heating and cooling rates of 20 to 0.2 °C/min. At high temperature, (3,4,5)12G1-m-PBI self-assemble into 2D-hexagonal columnar phases with intracolumnar order. At low temperature, they form orthorhombic (m = 0, 2, 3, 4) and monoclinic (m = 1) columnar arrays with 3D periodicity. The orthorhombic phase has symmetry close to hexagonal. For m = 0, 2, 3, 4 ,they consist of tetramers as basic units. The tetramers contain a pair of two molecules arranged side by side and another pair in the next stratum of the column, turned upside-down and rotated around the column axis at different angles for different m. In contrast, for m = 1, there is only one molecule in each stratum, with a four-strata 2(1) helical repeat. All molecules face up in one column, and down in the second column, of the monoclinic cell. This allows close and extended π-stacking, unlike in the disruptive up-down alteration from the case of m = 0, 2, 3, 4. Most of the 3D structures were observed only by cooling at rates of 1 °C/min or less. This complex helical self-assembly is representative for other classes of dendronized PBIs investigated for organic electronics and solar cells.

Self-assembly of hybrid dendrons into doubly segregated supramolecular polyhedral columns and vesicles.

The synthesis and structural analysis of supramolecular dendrimers self-assembled from 3 libraries containing 20 first-generation hybrid dendrons are reported. Combinations of benzyl ether, naphthyl methyl ether, and biphenyl methyl ether repeat units with different alkyl carboxylates at the apex of the dendron decreased its molecular solid angle to values that led to the discovery of a new mechanism of self-assembly. This new self-assembly mechanism generated a diversity of unprecedented supramolecular assemblies, including hollow and nonhollow singly or doubly segregated supramolecular columns and vesicles exhibiting polyhedral shapes. The polyhedral shape of the self-organized supramolecular dendrimers was demonstrated to be an intrinsic characteristic of all the doubly segregated structures. The self-assembly mechanism elucidated here provides access to new strategies that will be used to fabricate complex supramolecular organizations.

Self-assembly of dendritic crowns into chiral supramolecular spheres.

The synthesis and structural and retrostructural analysis of a library of dendronized cyclotriveratrylene containing seven nonchiral and seven chiral self-assembling dendrons is reported. These dendronized cyclotriveratrylenes exhibit a crown conformation that we named dendritic crown. Selected examples of dendritic crowns self-assemble into helical pyramidal columns that self-organize into columnar crystals or into 2-D columnar hexagonal lattices with intracolumnar order. A second group of dendritic crowns self-assembles into helical pyramidal columns and spherical supramolecular dendrimers that self-organize into cubic and tetragonal lattices. A third group of dendritic crowns self-assembles only in spherical supramolecular dendrimers. The helical pyramidal columns and spherical supramolecular dendrimers assembled from dendronized cyclotriveratrylene containing nonchiral dendrons are chiral but racemic while those generated from chiral dendrons exhibit amplified chirality. Structural analysis by a combination of X-ray diffraction methods and CD experiments demonstrated a new mechanism for the assembly of chiral supramolecular spheres that involves an intramolecular structure containing short fragments of helical pyramidal columns.

Self-assembly of dendronized triphenylenes into helical pyramidal columns and chiral spheres.

The synthesis and structural and retrostructural analyses of a library containing 10 triphenylenes functionalized with self-assembling benzyl ether and phenyl propyl ether dendrons are reported. These dendronized triphenylenes adopt a crown rather than discotic conformation. Their crown conformation mediates the self-assembly of the discotic triphenylene unit in helical pyramidal columns and in chiral spheres. The chiral spheres are generated from short segments of helical pyramidal columns that are spherically distorted. Therefore, the chirality of the sphere is determined by a short helical pyramidal column that represents the inner part of the supramolecular sphere. Both the helical pyramidal columns and the chiral spheres represent supramolecular architectures that were self-assembled for the first time from discotic molecules. The helical pyramidal columns self-organize in various hexagonal and rectangular lattices, while the chiral spheres self-organize into cubic and tetragonal periodic arrays and into a quasiperiodic 12-fold liquid quasicrystal. The helical sense of the helical pyramidal columns and of helical spheres is selected by a stereocenter that can be incorporated either in the alkyl groups of the dendron or in the triphenylene part of the dendritic crown via donor-acceptor interactions. The self-assembly process of the dendronized triphenylene donor can be programmed by a new supramolecular "polymer effect" generated by donor-acceptor interactions.

Elucidating the structure of the Pm3n cubic phase of supramolecular dendrimers through the modification of their aliphatic to aromatic volume ratio.

The synthesis, and structural and retrostructural analysis of a library of second-generation conical dendrons that self-assemble into spherical supramolecular dendrimers is reported. This library consists of amphiphilic dendrons with n-alkyl groups containing from 4 to 16 carbon atoms. The dendrons containing 6 to 16 carbon atoms in their n-alkyl groups self-assemble into spherical supramolecular dendrimers that self-organize in a Pm3n cubic lattice. The structural and retrostructural analysis of the Pm3n lattices generated from the supramolecular dendrimers demonstrated that the volume of the aromatic core of the spherical dendrimers is not dependent on the number of carbon atoms from their alkyl groups. This result facilitated the calculation of the average values of the absolute electron density of the aliphatic and aromatic domains of the spherical supramolecular dendrimers. The relative intensity of the higher order diffraction peaks of the Pm3n lattice increases as the volume of the aliphatic part of the sphere mediated by the number of carbon atoms in the n-alkyl groups decreases. This study demonstrates the maximum increase of the relative intensity of the higher order diffraction peaks of the Pm3n lattice generated from non-hollow supramolecular dendrimers.

Molecular structure of helical supramolecular dendrimers.

The molecular structure of helical supramolecular dendrimers generated from self-assembling dendrons and dendrimers and from self-organizable dendronized polymers was elucidated for the first time by the simulation of the X-ray diffraction patterns of their oriented fibers. These simulations were based on helical diffraction theory applied to simplified atomic helical models, followed by Cerius2 calculations based on their complete molecular helical structures. Hundreds of samples were screened until a library containing 14 supramolecular dendrimers and dendronized polymers provided a sufficient number of helical features in the X-ray diffraction pattern of their oriented fibers. This combination of techniques provided examples of single-9(2) and -11(3) helices, triple-6(1), -8(1), -9(1), and -12(1) helices, and an octa-32(1) helix that were assembled from crownlike dendrimers, hollow and nonhollow supramolecular crownlike dendrimers, hollow and nonhollow supramolecular disklike dendrimers, and hollow and nonhollow supramolecular and macromolecular helicene-like architectures. The method elaborated here for the determination of the molecular helix structure was transplanted from the field of structural biology and will be applicable to other classes of synthetic helical assemblies. The determination of the molecular structure of helical supramolecular assemblies is expected to provide an additional level of precision in the design of helical functional assemblies resembling those from biological systems.

Hollow spherical supramolecular dendrimers.

The synthesis of a library containing 12 conical dendrons that self-assemble into hollow spherical supramolecular dendrimers is reported. The design principles for this library were accessed by development of a method that allows the identification of hollow spheres, followed by structural and retrostructural analysis of their Pm3n cubic lattice. The first hollow spherical supramolecular dendrimer was made by replacing the tapered dendron, from the previously reported tapered dendritic dipeptide that self-assembled into helical pores, with its constitutional isomeric conical dendron. This strategy generated a conical dendritic dipeptide that self-assembled into a hollow spherical supramolecular dendrimer that self-organizes in a Pm3n cubic lattice. Other examples of hollow spheres were assembled from conical dendrons without a dipeptide at their apex. These are conical dendrons originated from tapered dendrons containing additional benzyl ether groups at their apex. The inner part of the hollow sphere assembled from the dipeptide resembles the path of a spherical helix or loxodrome and, therefore, is chiral. The spheres assembled from other conical dendrons are nonhelical, even when they contain stereocenters on the alkyl groups from their periphery. Functionalization of the apex of the conical dendrons with diethylene glycol allowed the encapsulation of LiOTf and RbOTf in the center of the hollow sphere. These experiments showed that hollow spheres function as supramolecular dendritic capsules and therefore are expected to display functions complementary to those of other related molecular and supramolecular structures.

Complex Arrangement of Orthogonal Nanoscale Columns via a Supramolecular Orientational Memory Effect.

Memory effects, including shape, chirality, and liquid-crystallinity, have enabled macroscopic materials with novel functions. However, the generation of complex supramolecular nanosystems via memory effects has not yet been investigated. Here, we report a cyclotriveratrylene-crown (CTV) compound that self-assembles into supramolecular columns and spheres forming, respectively, hexagonal and cubic mesophases. Upon transition from one phase to the other, an epitaxial relationship holds, via an unprecedented supramolecular orientational memory effect. Specifically, the molecular orientation and columnar character of supramolecular packing is preserved in the cubic phase, providing an otherwise inaccessible structure comprising orthogonally oriented domains of supramolecular columns. The continuous columnar character of tetrahedrally distorted supramolecular spheres self-organized from the CTV derivative in the faces of the Pm3̅n lattice is the basis of this supramolecular orientational memory, which holds throughout cycling in temperature between the two phases. This concept is expected to be general for other combinations of periodic and quasiperiodic arrays generated from supramolecular spheres upon transition to supramolecular columns.

Self-assembling phenylpropyl ether dendronized helical polyphenylacetylenes.

The first example of a self-assembling phenylpropyl ether based dendronized polymer has been reported and its preferred helical handedness has been determined. Dendronized polymer poly(10) and its nondendritic analogue poly(8) are high-cis-content polyphenylacetylenes (PPAs) prepared by using [Rh(nbd)Cl]2/NEt3 (nbd: 2,5-norbornadiene). Both polymers possess a stereocenter in their side chain, which selects a preferred helical handedness. Based on negative exciton chirality observed in the CD spectra of poly(10), we have designated this molecule as a right-handed helical polymer, which persists over a wide temperature range. Poly(10) self-organizes into both Phiioh and Phih lattices in bulk. The Phiioh-to-Phih transition is associated with thermoreversible cis-cisoidal to cis-transoidal isomerization of the helical PPA, accompanied by a dramatic decrease in the column diameter and a decrease in the pi-stacking correlation length along the column. A model for the right-handed helical dendronized PPA has been proposed wherein dendrons from adjacent column strata interdigitate to effectively fill space.

Self-assembly of semifluorinated minidendrons attached to electron-acceptor groups into pyramidal columns.

The synthesis and self-assembly of twelve semifluorinated first-generation dendrons or minidendrons attached to electron-acceptor (n-type) groups generated from various combinations of eight acceptors and three dendrons are reported. Dendrons attached to small electron-acceptor molecules mediate their self-assembly into pi-stacks located in the center of a supramolecular helical pyramidal column with the long axis of the acceptor perpendicular to the long axis of the column. Dendrons attached to large electron-acceptor molecules, such as perylene bisimide, mediate the assembly of their acceptors in an unprecedented arrangement of pi-stacks that have the long axis of the acceptors parallel to the long axis of the supramolecular pyramidal column. All supramolecular columns self-organize into various periodic columnar arrays that exhibit liquid-crystalline phases, crystalline phases, or a liquid-crystalline phase with enhanced intracolumnar order. The present study demonstrates the simplicity and the versatility of the concept of assembly of n-type electroactive groups mediated by semifluorinated dendrons and assesses the scope and limitations of this supramolecular strategy.