Postoperative pain and infection are the most frequent reasons for legal action after knee arthroscopy: a 5-year review based on two private insurance French companies after arthroscopy.

PURPOSE: The objective of this study was to determine the reasons for complaints and describe the judicial means upstream of France's courts following arthroscopy. METHODS: This is a retrospective observational study including all compensation records related to arthroscopic surgery, collected from the two leading French insurance organizations: MACSF and Branchet companies, from 2014 to 2018. Three medical experts performed the protocol and analysis. RESULTS: Finally, 247 procedures were included. The most common motives were: the appearance or persistence of pain (43.7%), postoperative infection (29.1%), technical errors (10.5%), nerve damage (5.7%), arterial lesions (2.8%), side errors (2.4%). Knee arthroscopies were more at risk of legal action for infection (p = 0.0006), and for disappointing results or persistent pain (p = 0.001). The first recourse was the conciliation and compensation commission (CCI) in 136 cases (55.1%), the civil court (TGI) in 88 cases (35.6%) and amicable settlement in 23 cases (9.3%). The mean time between surgery and the complaint was 32.8 ± 25.7 months, and was shorter in the case of an amicable procedure (p < 0.001). The lawsuit's mean duration was 15.6 ± 11.2 months, but longer in case of civil proceedings (p < 0.0001). The experts found no negligence in 81.8% of cases (n = 202). Infections were the leading cause of recourse to the conciliation and compensation commission (p < 0.0001), while technical errors were the main reason for complaints settled in an amicable procedure (p = 0.035). It was found more proven negligence in case of amicable procedures (p < 0.0001). The mean amount of compensation was 60,968.45€. No significant difference could be found regarding the median values of compensation between the reason of complaint. The amount of compensation was higher in civil court proceedings than in any others (p = 0.02). CONCLUSION: The main reasons for arthroscopy litigation in France are reported in this study, specifying how they are managed upstream of possible legal proceedings. The knee is the main joint involved. Patient information, close follow-up associated with early and appropriate management of complications are the main ways to reduce complaints. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: IV.

A growing stake in orthopaedic surgery and traumatology for the future management of obese patients.

The prevalence of obesity is increasing. In orthopaedic surgery, the impact of obesity is felt. The aim is to take stock of the consequences of obesity for patients at each stage of management. In this mini-review, we identify the main pathophysiological factors, specific orthopaedic complications and consequences to consider at each stage of management. Obese patients are subjected to a chronic inflammatory state and biomechanical stress. This augments the risk of sepsis and trauma, musculoskeletal damage, the frequency of organ failure and thus, morbidity and mortality. This results in more complex and longer supportive care. At each stage of care, surgeons and doctors have to adapt to optimize care. It is necessary to obtain timely and accurate information from the patient. Patient information is necessary. Being obese in orthopaedics is a factor in poor prognosis. Treatments need to be adapted. This requires specific preparation at each step.

Initial management of complex hand injuries in military or austere environments: how to defer and prepare for definitive repair?

INTRODUCTION: The damage control orthopedics (DCO) concept is a sequential surgical management strategy indicated when ideal primary treatment is not possible or suitable. DCO principles are routinely applied to hand traumas in wartime practice, but could also be useful in a civilian setting when immediate specialized management cannot be carried out. METHODS: The authors report three typical observations of soldiers treated for a complex hand trauma on the field by orthopedic surgeons from the French Military Health Service (FMHS). Application of the hand DCO concept is analyzed and discussed considering the literature and the FMHS experience. RESULTS: With regards to treating the hand, DCO necessitates a meticulous debridement with precise wound assessment, the frequent use of a primary definitive internal fixation by K-wires, and the possibility of a temporary coverage. These simple and fast procedures help avoid infection and prepare the hand for secondary repair. CONCLUSION: Hand DCO can be applied by any surgeon in various situations: in association with polytrauma, complex injuries requiring multiple reconstructions, or delayed transfer to a specialized center.

Concomitant Vascular War Trauma Saturating a French Forward Surgical Team Deployed to Support the Victims of the Syrian War (2013). Interest of the Vascular Damage Control.

Vascular injuries from war require an emergency treatment whose objective is to quickly obtain hemostasis and the restoration of arterial flow. In this context of heavy trauma and limited means, damage control surgery is recommended and is based on the use of temporary vascular shunts (TVSs). We report the management of the simultaneous arrival of 2 vascular injuries of war in a field hospital. Patient 1 presented a ballistic trauma of the elbow with a section of the humeral artery (Gustillo IIIC). A TVS was set up during the external fixation of the elbow. Final revascularization was carried out and aponevrotomies of the forearm were performed. Patient 2 had a riddled knee with an open fracture of the femur, an avulsion of the popliteal artery, and a hemorrhagic shock. A strategy of damage control surgery was carried out with placing an arterial and venous shunt. Aponevrotomies of the leg were carried out before casting. For the traumatisms of the arteries of the members, the use of shunts is reserved for the lesions of the proximal vessels. Many vascular shunts available have the same performances to restore the arterial flow and prevent secondary thrombosis. The time before the final revascularization depends on the clinical condition of the patient. The value of anticoagulation in these cases was not shown.

Management of Posterior Digital Skin Defect by Pico Negative Pressure Wound Therapy: A Case Report and Literature Review.

The use of negative pressure therapy for digital skin loss is uncommon. A reason for this is the difficulty of applying dressings to the hand, which are often difficult to seal. However, negative pressure therapy offers some benefits, especially when associated with local infection. We present a nonspecific, simple and original technique using a Pico negative pressure dressing that may be easily applied in daily practice.

Surgical solutions for preoperative skin preparation in total hip arthroplasty: A cost-effectiveness analysis of Betadine® and Chloraprep™.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of our study was to compare the cost of surgical site skin preparation using ChloraPrep™ (2% chlorhexidine gluconate [CHG] and 70% isopropyl alcohol [IPA]) with skin cleansing using Betadine® Surgical Scrub and Betadine® 5% solution (povidone-iodine [PVI]) in total hip arthroplasty (THA). HYPOTHESIS: The hypothesis was that the ChloraPrep™ skin disinfection protocol reduces the cost of perioperative antisepsis. METHODS: A prospective database was created for all THAs performed at our university hospital between November 1st, 2020, and December 31st, 2020. Each surgeon was randomly assigned one type of antiseptic prior to the start of the study: one surgeon to the ChloraPrep™ group and one to the Betadine® group. In both groups, the enrollment stopped at the 15th patient. The costs related to consumables, waste disposal, and operating room occupancy time of each protocol were then assessed for each patient. RESULTS: The mean duration of the ChloraPrep™ protocol was 3.5±0.3minutes compared to 13.5±0.9minutes for the Betadine® protocol. The overall cost of a surgical site skin preparation involving all three steps was on average €46.8±4.2 for the ChloraPrep™ group compared to €155±10.9 for the Betadine® group (p<0.0001). DISCUSSION: Not only is the effectiveness of ChloraPrep™ already recognized but it also appears to have health economic benefits. However, further studies are needed to confirm this finding. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III, case control study.

Sexual activity resumption after total hip arthroplasty: A satisfaction survey in 101 patients.

BACKGROUND: We are not aware of studies conducted in France to assess information provided by surgeons about the impact of total hip arthroplasty (THA) on sexual activity or sexual activity resumption after THA. The objectives of this study in a cohort of patients seen after THA were to evaluate: (1) the time to sexual activity resumption, (2) whether sexual activity resumption was discussed with the surgeon and whether the patients wanted information on this point, and (3) the modalities and experience of sexual activity resumption according to demographic features. HYPOTHESIS: Age and sex influence the timing and modalities of sexual activity resumption after THA. METHODS: We conducted a single-centre prospective cohort study in consecutive patients who received follow-up for 6months after THA. Each patient completed an anonymised questionnaire on preoperative sexual activity, modalities of postoperative sexual activity resumption, information delivered by the surgeon, and expectations regarding the delivered information. The patients also specified their age and sex on the questionnaire. RESULTS: Of 101 included patients, 49 were still sexually active before surgery. Of these 49 patients, 35 (71.4%) reported no difference in the frequency of sexual activity before and after THA. Only 4 (8.2%) patients did not resume sexual activity during follow-up. Older age was associated with a lower demand for information [odds ratio, 0.95; 95% confidence interval: 0.91-0.99 (p=0.01)]. Compared to the females, the males more often recovered similar sexual activity to that before surgery regarding frequency [18/20 vs. 17/29 (p=0.02)] and quality of sexual positions [15/20 vs. 9/29 (p=0.003)]. Males resumed sexual activity on average during the first 3weeks [10/20 (p=0.02)], compared to after 6weeks for most females [13/29 (p=0.03)]. Age was not associated with the time to sexual activity resumption [ρ=0.0868; 95% confidence interval: -0.205 to 0.365 (p=0.56)]. DISCUSSION: Among patients who were sexually active before surgery, 71.4% reported having resumed the same frequency of sexual activity 6months after surgery. The main difficulty in both males and females was fear of prosthetic hip dislocation, which was related in part to insufficient preoperative information. Males resumed sexual activity earlier than did females. In patients who were sexually active before surgery, age was not associated with the resumption of sexual activity after surgery. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: IV, prospective study with no control group.

Preoperative information: Written first?

Patient information is now an ethical and legal obligation in France; it is the physician who is required to provide proof. The Law of March 4, 2002 and the code of ethics and main legal and regulatory texts are, however, imprecise on some points. Written documents, although not stipulated in law, are in practice essential, supplementing the indispensable oral information given by the surgeon in individual personalized interview. Patients remember only some of this information, and overestimate their own understanding of it. Written documents are therefore essential to compensate for this. Their contents need validation by scientific societies. In case of disagreement, the medical file is the essential means of assessing information quality, and should be kept up to date as rigorously as possible. A key document is the letter summarizing the preoperative consultation, validating surgery, which should be drawn up in a manner that meets the obligation to inform. Signed consent is not mandatory in law, but is necessary in practice and should be archived. For judges, proof of information is based on several elements: the complete structured letter to the patient and community physician plus the signed information sheet and consent form constitute solid evidence and all three should be included in the medical file. Information has now become a part of health-care in itself. In a context of increasing litigation, "defensive medicine" is still to be avoided but physicians should have their own check-lists so as to be in a position to prove delivery of structured information if called upon to do so. In the absence of proven information, patients can plead loss of chance and/or prejudice for lack of preparation and/or infringement of dignity, and claim damages from the courts.

Long-Term Results of a Monocentric Series of Soldiers After Latarjet Procedure for Anterior Shoulder Instability. Implications for the Assessment of Soldiers' Medical Ability.

Introduction: Stabilizing surgery of the shoulder with a coracoid graft according to Latarjet is a recognized surgical treatment for anterior instability of the shoulder. This pathology frequently affects soldiers. Postoperatively, the potential risk of recurrence or of secondary shoulder arthritis can limit the practitioner in their ability assessment. The aim of this study is to analyze the long-term outcomes of this surgery in a military population, in order to assess the possible implications for French soldiers' medical ability. Material and Methods: Twenty soldiers operated on the shoulder by Latarjet procedure by the same surgeon were retrospectively reviewed after more than 15 yr. All of them did regular physical activity for leisure or competitions. None had preoperative osteoarthritis injuries. The number of dislocation recurrences, the functional score, and the rate of radiographic osteoarthritis were assessed. Results: After more than 16.3 yr (extremes: 15-24 yr), none displayed a dislocation recurrence. The average Rowe's score was 91.8 ± 9.9. The average subjective shoulder value was 89.2 ± 9.7. All patients had resumed sport. Three of them developed level 1 or 2 radiological signs of osteoarthritis according to Samilson. No level 3 or 4 osteoarthritis was found. Among all the patients, 14 still did regular physical activity. Discussion: In view of our results and of those from the literature, the results of treatment for anterior shoulder instability with the Latarjet procedure are good, even very good in the long term. These data must be considered to favor this procedure for soldiers with shoulder instability and from a medico-administrative viewpoint for military patients in order to pursue their careers without any job restrictions.

Surgical support during the terrorist attacks in Paris, November 13, 2015: Experience at Bégin Military Teaching Hospital.

BACKGROUND: Recent conflicts have allowed the French Army Health Service to improve management quality for wartime-injured people during military operations. On November 13, 2015, it was in Paris that France was directly attacked and Bégin Military Teaching Hospital, like several hospitals in Paris, had to face a large number of gunshot victims. Thanks to our operational experience, injured people hospitalized in military hospitals benefited from a management based on triage and damage control (DC) principles. METHODS: Forty-five patients were taken care of in our hospital with an average age of 32 years. During triage, eight patients were categorized T1 (with four extreme emergencies) and 10 were classified T2 and 27 as T3. Twenty-two patients underwent emergency surgery, 15 for soft tissue lesions of limbs, 8 for ballistic fractures (one of which was a cervical wound), and 5 for abdominal wounds. Two patients classified T1 died early. RESULTS: In total, more than 50 operations were performed including iterative debridements, bone fixation, three amputations, and two flaps. After 9 months, all of the patients had healed. One woman with limb stiffness required an arthrolysis. CONCLUSION: This event showed that terrorist attacks and mass casualties with war wounds can occur in France. Acquired experience regarding war wounds by the French Army Health Service is precious. Everyone must understand the importance of triage and the principles of damage control. Every hospital must be ready to face this type of massive influx of injured people (white plan). LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Epidemiological study, level V.

How to reconstruct an upper full-thickness abdomen wall defect in austere environment? Interests of the pedicled myofascial latissimis dorsi flap.

Upper abdominal wall defects secondary to trauma are not amenable to immediate closure in most cases. After a primary coverage, the definitive reconstruction can be done at a later date, using prosthetic mesh or flap. The majority of these complex procedures is, however, not available in the austere environment. The authors report a clinical case of upper full-thickness defects of the abdominal wall secondary to an explosion in Afghanistan. The patient was managed by a French Forward Surgical Team. The defect was immediately reconstructed in a one-stage surgery using a pedicled myofascial latissimus dorsi flap with good functional results. The pedicled latissimus dorsi flap is commonly used for coverage of both extrathoracic and intrathoracic defects. It is, therefore, possible to extend the harvesting of the muscle to the thoracolumbar fascia and the posterior third of the iliac crest. It provides a very large flap to cover an upper full-thickness abdomen wall defect. The harvest technique is simple, short, and largely accessible to a general surgeon. It provides immediate and definitive closure with a short hospital stay, what is clearly adapted in austere environment.

How to Cover Soft-Tissue Defects After Injuries to the Leg in Precarious Conditions.

BACKGROUND: In precarious conditions, bone exposure on the leg is synonymous with amputation. The authors describe their experiences with such injuries in 15 patients. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Fifteen patients were operated by the same surgeon in Afghanistan and Ivory Coast for bone exposure on the leg after war or roadcrash injuries. A flap was performed after an initial debridement and external fixation. The delay between the flap and the first injury was about 42 days. RESULTS: The duration of hospitalization following the flap was about eight days. Cicatrization was complete after 25 days. Three patients had complications: one partial necrosis of the skin, one sepsis, and one patient had a leg amputation. DISCUSSION: In precarious conditions, the management of bone exposure in local civilians and soldiers is limited by the conditions in their country or the conditions at the field hospital. The treatment must be simple and reliable because it may be difficult to perform patient follow-up. A pedicled flap provides new vascularized tissue with anti-infectious properties. Classical indications are: muscular flaps for the proximal and the middle part of the leg; sural flaps for the middle and the distal-third part. In substantial soft-tissue defects, amputation must be discussed. CONCLUSION: The pedicled flap is an essential technique for fighting against infection, especially in cases where only poor technical and medicinal resources are available. This simple and reliable technique allows most tissue defects on the leg to be covered.