Older nursing home residents have a cardiac arrest survival rate similar to that of older persons living in the community.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the survival rates of older nursing home residents after cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and to compare it with that of older persons who experienced cardiac arrest in an outpatient setting. To identify patient characteristics, arrest characteristics, and effort characteristics that are associated with higher survival rates. DESIGN: Retrospective review of emergency medical service charts and hospital medical records of a cohort of older nursing home residents (n = 114) after cardiopulmonary resuscitation and a matched cohort of community-residing older persons (n = 228) matched on age, gender, and year of cardiac arrest. SETTING: A large metropolitan city served by a tiered emergency medical service. MEASUREMENTS: Independent variables related to patient, cardiac arrest, and resuscitation effort characteristics. Dependent variables were defined as immediate survival after cardiopulmonary resuscitation and survival status at discharge. RESULTS: The mean age of nursing home residents was 80.3 years; 62.3% were females. The majority of cardiac arrests for both groups were unwitnessed (67%) and had agonal rhythms (asystole and electromechanical dissociation). Emergency medical service efforts were similar for the two cohorts. Among nursing home residents, 26.3% had a return of blood pressure for more than 5 minutes, 70.2% were pronounced dead in the emergency room, and 10.5% were discharged from hospitals alive. In the matched community-residing subjects, 22.7% had a return of blood pressure, 78.1% were pronounced dead in the emergency room, and 9.2% were discharged alive. Between-group comparisons of these variables revealed no significant differences even though our sample size was adequate. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that survival after cardiac arrest of older persons residing in nursing homes is low; however, with an appropriate CPR/DNR selection process and an effective emergency medical system, survival of certain groups of nursing home residents following cardiac arrest could be comparable to that of community residing older persons. Despite the reasonably good survival rates for older persons seen above, our analyses indicated that patients who have unwitnessed arrests are not likely to survive to discharge and that patients with initial rhythms such as asystole or electromechanical dissociation rarely survive. These data suggest that patients who have an unwitnessed arrest in the nursing home should not receive resuscitation attempts, and in those patients for whom paramedics are called, resuscitation efforts should not proceed any further if their original rhythm is asystole or electromechanical dissociation. Thus, modification in nursing home policies regarding CPR efforts is needed.

Attitudes towards CPR training and performance in family members of patients with heart disease.

Considering that heart patients may be at higher risk for cardiac arrest, this study was conducted to evaluate the preparedness and willingness of cardiac patient family members to perform cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). A cross-sectional survey of 100 family members of cardiac patients was conducted at a tertiary care emergency department over a 1.5-month period. Response rate was 95%. While 49% reported prior CPR training, only 7% trained within the past year. The majority received training (59%) because of a school or job requirement with only 8% trained because of 'concern for a family member.' The most frequent reasons for not being trained were 'never thought about it' or 'not interested' (57%). However, 49% of the untrained group did report an interest in future training. While 2% of respondents recalled a healthcare professional suggesting such training, 58% stated they would be influenced positively by such a recommendation. The most frequently reported barriers to performing CPR included fear of harming the patient or a lack of knowledge and skill to help. Despite a presumed higher risk for sudden cardiac death, most family members of cardiac patients do not maintain skills in basic CPR. Healthcare professionals may have the ability to significantly alter this concerning statistic through education and routine recommendations to patients' families.

Initial countershock in the treatment of asystole.

BACKGROUND: Routine provision of defibrillatory countershock (CS) in the initial management of asystolic cardiac arrest has been advocated because certain cases of ventricular fibrillation (VF) may present as asystole (AS). OBJECTIVE: To determine the value of initial CS versus endotracheal intubation and pharmacologic therapy alone in the treatment of asystolic cardiac arrest. DESIGN/PARTICIPANTS: A retrospective analysis of data collected prospectively during a multicenter study of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. The study subjects were all patients whose initial cardiac arrest rhythm was AS and were treated with standard advanced cardiac life support (ACLS). SETTING: Six urban emergency medical services (EMS) systems. INTERVENTION: Patients in AS were treated initially with CS followed by ACLS therapy (CS Group), and were compared to those patients receiving endotracheal intubation and pharmacologic therapy alone (No CS Group). OUTCOME MEASURES: Those receiving initial CS were compared to those not receiving CS using both Chi-square and logistic regression analysis. Outcome parameters included: rates of return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC), emergency department admission, hospital admission and hospital discharge. RESULTS: Of the 194 patients presenting with AS, 77 received CS as their initial therapy. Of these, 13 (16.9%) had ROSC compared to 27 of the 117 (23.1%) from the No CS Group (P = 0.30). Emergency department and hospital admission rates were not significantly different; 13.0% versus 18.0% (P = 0.36), and 13.0% versus 11.1% (P = 0.69) for CS versus No CS, respectively. None of the patients in the CS Group were discharged alive versus two (1.7%) from No CS (P = 0.52). Of 42 patients with bystander-witnessed cardiac arrests, 13.3% in the CS Group had ROSC compared to 40.7% in the No CS Group (P = 0.07). Emergency department admission rates were 6.7% for the CS Group and 33.3% for the No CS Group (P = 0.07); while hospital admission rates were 6.7% and 22.2%, respectively (P = 0.39). When these comparisons were adjusted for bystander-initiated CPR, CPR interval, and paramedic response interval, the P-values became 0.10, 0.05 and 0.17, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Although, statistically, the results for both groups were not distinguishable, outcomes for asystolic patients had a tendency to be better when the initial therapy did not involve CS. Larger study populations are recommended to confirm these preliminary observations.

Clinical predictors of the adult respiratory distress syndrome.

One hundred thirty-six patients meeting our criteria for one or more of eight clinical conditions were prospectively observed for the development of the adult respiratory distress syndrome. A high risk population was identified, including those with sepsis syndrome (38 percent), documented aspiration of gastric contents (30 percent), multiple emergency transfusions (24 percent), and pulmonary contusion (17 percent). The risk from multiple major fractures appeared low but contributed to the risk from other factors. The risk associated with just one factor (25 percent) was compounded by the presence of two (42 percent) and three (85 percent) simultaneous factors, and this finding was more predictive of ARDS than the injury severity score or initial arterial oxygenation. Of the ARDS cases, 76 percent occurred in the initial 24 hours after meeting the criteria. ARDS did not occur after 72 hours unless there was late development of sepsis (3 of 136 patients).

Hypertonic saline-dextran solutions for the prehospital management of traumatic hypotension.

We report the results of the first clinical study on the use of a hypertonic saline-dextran solution for the prehospital management of hypotensive victims of penetrating trauma. During a 4-month period, 48 trauma patients with penetrating injuries and a prehospital systolic blood pressure of 90 mm Hg or less were infused in-field with 250 ml of either a hypertonic saline-dextran solution or the crystalloid plasmalyte A. There were no complications associated with the infusion of the hypertonic saline-dextran solution, and execution of the protocol by paramedic personnel was both safe and uniformly successful. The potential impact of this solution on medical care and the results of this feasibility study justify the initiation of a larger prospective, randomized clinical trial on the efficacy of this solution in the prehospital setting.

Acute post-traumatic respiratory physiology and insufficiency.

This article reviews the physiologic mechanisms by which acute injury results in respiratory insufficiency. It delineates the need for oxygenation versus ventilatory support and provides a pragmatic approach to dealing with the proper early respiratory support of the victim of chest trauma as well as the rationale for various immediate treatment modalities. In addition, it discusses various assessment techniques and clinical clues that predict the onset of late respiratory complications in the patient with serious injuries.

Ensuring the chain of recovery for stroke in your community.

Until recently, the prehospital and ED management of nonhemorrhagic stroke was largely supportive care. Studies have now demonstrated the potential of certain therapeutic interventions to reverse the debilitating consequences of such strokes. The clinical benefit for such interventions and the risk of significant therapeutic complications are highly time-dependent. To optimize the chances of a better outcome for the patient with stroke, each community must establish and continue to refine a chain of recovery for stroke patients. The chain of recovery is a metaphor that describes a series of sequential actions that must take place in a timely fashion to optimize the chances of recovery from stroke. Each of these sequential actions forms an individual link in the chain, and each link must be intact. The links include: identification of the onset of stroke symptoms by the patient or bystanders; dispatch life support services, which preferably include enhanced 9-1-1 and medically supervised and trained dispatchers who can rapidly deploy the closest responders and transport units; emergency medical services (EMS) personnel who can rapidly assess and transport the stroke patient to the closest appropriate center capable of providing advanced stroke diagnostics and interventions; en route notification of the receiving facility so that appropriate personnel can be readied for rapid diagnosis and intervention; and receiving facilities capable of providing rapid diagnosis and advanced treatment of stroke, including the availability of specialists who can evaluate underlying etiologies as well as plan future therapies and rehabilitation. To ensure that the chain of recovery is in place, aggressive public education campaigns should be implemented to increase the probability that stroke symptoms and signs will be recognized as soon as possible by patients and bystanders. In addition, because most of the current training programs for EMS dispatchers and EMS personnel are lacking with regard to stroke, it is recommended that such personnel and their EMS system managers be updated on current management and treatment strategies for stroke.

Incidence, source, and nature of complaints received in a large, urban emergency medical services system.

OBJECTIVE: To document the incidence, source, and reasons for all complaints received by a large municipal emergency medical services (EMS) program. METHODS: A retrospective review of all complaints received during three consecutive years (1990-1992) in a centralized EMS system serving a large municipality (population 2 million). All cases were categorized by year, source, and nature of the complaint. RESULTS: In the three study years, EMS responded to 416,892 incidents with nearly a half-million patient contacts. Concurrently, 371 complaints were received (incidence of 1.12 per thousand); 132 in 1990, 129 in 1991, and 110 in 1992. Most complaints involved either: 1) allegations of "rude or unprofessional conduct" (34%), 2) "didn't take patient to the hospital" (19%), or 3) "problems with medical treatment" (13%). Only 1.6% (n = 6) were response-time complaints. Other complaints included "lost/damaged property," "taken to the wrong hospital," "inappropriate billing," and "poor driving habits." The most common sources were patient's families (39%) and the patients themselves (30%). Only 7.8% were from health care providers. CONCLUSION: Reviews of complaints provide information regarding EMS system performance and reveal targets for quality improvement. For the EMS system examined, this study suggests a future training focus on interpersonal skills and heightened sensitivities, not only toward patients, but also toward bystanders and family members.

Traumatic brain injuries evaluated in U.S. emergency departments, 1992-1994.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the incidence and patient characteristics of traumatic brain injuries (TBIs) treated in U.S. emergency departments (EDs). METHODS: A secondary analysis was performed on data from the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey administered from 1992 to 1994. An ED visit was determined to represent a case of TBI if the case record contained ICD-9-CM codes of 800.0-801.9, 803.0-804.9, or 850.0-854.1. RESULTS: The average annual estimate of new TBI treated in U.S. EDs was 1,144,807, equaling 444 per 100,000 persons (95% CI = 390 to 498), which represents approximately 3,136 new cases of TBI per day and accounts for 1.3% of all ED visits. Males were 1.6 times as likely as females to suffer TBI until the age of 65 years, when the female rate exceeded the male. The rate for blacks was 35% higher than that for whites. The highest overall incidence rate of TBI occurred in the less-than-5-year age group (1,091 per 100,000), closely followed by the more-than-85-year age group (1,026 per 100,000). Falls represented the most common mechanism of TBI injury, followed by motor vehicle-related trauma. CONCLUSIONS: This study underscores the ongoing need for effective surveillance of all types of TBI and evaluation of prevention strategies targeting high-risk individuals. It serves as a clinically grounded and ED-based corroboration of prior survey research, providing a basis for comparison of incidence rates over time and a tool with which to measure the efficacy of future interventions.

The clinical entity of adult respiratory distress syndrome. Definition, prediction, and prognosis.

This article discusses the clinical entity of the adult respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), its manifestations, and its natural history. The problems of defining the syndrome and its associated risk factors are delineated. In addition, the article reviews the experimental, retrospective, and prospective studies of ARDS risk factors, as well as the clinical correlations with mortality.

Field management and critical care in mass disasters.

As previously discussed, the majority of injury cases do not necessarily involve dramatic life-saving actions, but rather very rudimentary, promptly applied precautions. For most victims of trauma, therefore, we offer reassurance and simple compassion in their time of need. One of the more important lessons to be learned here is that, beyond prehospital injury "management" or "treatment," we should always remember to provide the best possible prehospital injury care. By responding as soon as possible and by delivering reassurance and compassion to those who are injured and frightened, we are providing one of the most sacred aspects of the Hippocratic mission. Despite wonderful technologic advances and the need for aggressiveness in disaster management, these humanistic values must always be maintained by those to whom care is entrusted. Successful transport of disaster victims, whether in the prehospital phase or during interhospital transfer, requires careful attention to treatment priorities, such as simple measures for airway control and ventilation, and care to prevent further injuries by appropriate immobilization techniques. The use of fully equipped teams of multidisciplinary critical care specialists in mass disaster situations is in its infancy. It is clear that with properly adapted hardware and personnel trained to function in adverse environments while effectively delivering intensive care to a large number of patients with a variety of clinical syndromes, survival can be significantly increased for the most acutely ill.

Reappraising the prehospital care of the patient with major trauma.

Recent research efforts have demonstrated that many long-standing practices for the prehospital resuscitation of trauma patients may be inappropriate, particularly in certain circumstances. Traditional practices, such as application of antishock garments and IV fluid administration, may even be detrimental in certain patients with uncontrolled bleeding. Endotracheal intubation, although potentially capable of prolonging a patient's ability to tolerate circulatory arrest, may be harmful if overzealous ventilation further compromises cardiac output in such severe hemodynamic instability. If these procedures delay patient transport, any benefit they may offer could be outweighed by delaying definitive care. To improve current systems of trauma care, future trauma research must address the different mechanisms of injury, the anatomic areas involved, and the physiologic staging in a given patient.

The development of emergency medical dispatch in the USA: a historical perspective.

Emergency medical dispatch has evolved over the last 25 years from a system designed to limit abuse of the emergency medical services (EMS) to a sophisticated part of the total EMS response. Its current goal is to send the right thing to the right person at the right time in the right way and to do the right thing until help arrives. The historical development of emergency medical dispatch in the USA is outlined decade by decade. In addition, the current state of emergency medical dispatch is reviewed and future directions are discussed.

How to monitor the effectiveness of an emergency medical dispatch system: the Houston model.

The use of priority dispatch systems for emergency medical services (EMS) is widespread throughout the United States and in several other countries. It is essential that any such system be monitored to prove that it is safe and effective. A study of the EMS system in Houston, Texas, USA, has previously reported that the priority dispatch system can safely and reliably identify EMS incidents requiring only basic life support; the methods by which this was achieved are outlined here. In addition, the current and pending revisions to the Houston Fire Department Dispatch Quality Management Programme are discussed.

Evolving challenges in prehospital trauma services. Current issues and suggested evaluation tools.

For the past two decades, prehospital trauma care has been addressed almost generically in terms of the related approaches to epidemiology, research, and management. However, evolving directions in research have helped emergency medical services (EMS) practitioners to delineate more focused treatment strategies according to the mechanisms of injury, anatomic involvement, and the patient's clinical condition. Recent studies in the areas of trauma-associated circulatory arrest, severe blunt head injury, and post-traumatic hemorrhage following penetrating truncal injury suggest that current standard approaches to patient care should be reconsidered. In turn, this need for re-examination of trauma management strategies calls for the development of appropriate evaluation tools within EMS systems. Proper research design is dependent upon several key issues including: 1) the type of study (system study versus examination of a specific intervention); 2) the population under study; 3) physiological and anatomical scoring method; 4) prospective definitions of interventions and meaningful outcome variables (both morbidity and mortality); 5) relative outcome compared to known standards; and 6) prospective determination of statistical requirements.

Emergency medical vehicle collisions in an urban system.

INTRODUCTION: Emergency medical services collisions (EMVCs) are a largely unexplored area of emergency medical services (EMS) research. Factors that might contribute to an EMVC are numerous and include use of warning lights and siren (WL&S). Few of these factors have been evaluated scientifically. Similarly, the incidence and severity of EMVCs is poorly documented in the literature. This study sought to define the incidence and severity of, and where possible, identify any contributing factors to EMVCs in a large urban system. METHODS: Retrospective study of all collisions involving vehicles assigned to the EMS Division of the Houston Fire Department in calendar year 1993. Fifty-one ambulances were operational 24 hours per day during calendar year 1993. Houston EMS received 150,000 requests for assistance, made 180,000 vehicular responses, and accrued 2,651,760 miles in 1993. RESULTS: Eighty-six EMVCs were identified during the study period. The gross incidence rate was therefore 3.2 EMVC/100,000 miles driven or 4.8 collisions/10,000 responses. Of the 86 EMVCs, 74 (86%) files were complete and available for evaluation. Major collisions, determined according to injuries or vehicular damage, accounted for 10.8% of all EMVCs. There were 17 persons transported to hospitals from EMS collisions, yielding an injury incidence of 0.64 injuries/100,000 miles driven or 0.94 injuries/10,000 responses. There were no fatalities. The majority of collisions (85.1%) occurred at some site other than an intersection. There was no statistical association between occurrence at an intersection and severity, day versus night, weekend versus weekday, presence or absence of precipitation, or use of WL & S versus severity of collision. Drivers with a history of previous EMVCs were involved in 33% of all collisions. The presence of prior EMVCs was associated (p < 0.001) with the number of persons transported from the collision to a local hospital. Five drivers, all with previous EMVCs, accounted for 88.2% (15/17) of all injuries. CONCLUSIONS: A few drivers with previous EMVCs account for a disproportionate number of EMVCs and nearly 90% of all injuries. This risk factor--history of previous EMVC--has not been reported in the EMS literature. It is postulated that this factor ultimately will prove to be the major determinant of EMVCs. Data collection of EMS collisions needs to be standardized and a proposed collection tool is provided.

Agreement between paramedic-estimated weights and subsequent hospital measurements in adults with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the accuracy of paramedic estimates of adult body weights in cardiac arrest cases. HYPOTHESIS: Paramedics could accurately estimate the weights of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients. DESIGN: Retrospective data analysis of a 15-month, multicenter study involving nontraumatic out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients. Paramedic estimates of body weights were compared to weights measured in the hospital. Patients were included in the analysis only if both a paramedic weight and a measured in-hospital weight were recorded. SETTING: Six urban emergency medical services systems. PARTICIPANTS: The study population included adults with return of spontaneous circulation who subsequently were admitted to the hospital. MEASUREMENTS: Pearson correlation analysis of paramedic-estimated weights and measured weights. RESULTS: Among the 133 study patients, the correlation coefficient (R) for paramedic estimates and the actual measured weight was 0.93. Paramedic estimates of weight were within 10% of the measured weights in 74% of the patients, and within 20% of measured weights in 93% of the patients. CONCLUSION: Paramedic weight estimates correlated well with measured weights.

Advances in resuscitative trauma care.

Over the last two decades, experimental and clinical data have begun to shape a more discriminating approach to intravascular (IV) fluid infusions in the resuscitation of trauma patients with presumed internal hemorrhage. This approach takes into account the presence of potentially uncontrollable hemorrhage (e.g., deep intra-abdominal or intra-thoracic injury) versus a controllable source (e.g. distal extremity wound). This limitation on fluid resuscitation is particularly applicable in the case of patients with penetrating truncal injury being transported rapidly to a nearby definitive care center. Meanwhile, longstanding debates over the type of fluid that should be infused remain largely unresolved and further complicated by recent clinical trials that did not demonstrate support for either hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers or hypertonic saline. However, there is also growing evidence that does support the increased use of fresh frozen plasma as well as tourniquets, and intra-osseous devices. While a more discriminating approach to fluid infusions have evolved, it has also become clear that positive pressure ventilatory support should be limited in the face of potential severe hemorrhage due to the accompanying reductions in venous return. Controversies over prehospital endotracheal tube placement are confounded by this factor as well as the effects of paramedic deployment strategies and related skills usage. Beyond these traditional areas of focus, a number of very compelling clinical observations and an extensive body of experimental data has generated a very persuasive argument that intravenous estrogen and progesterone may be of value in trauma management, particularly severe traumatic brain injury and burns.