Examination of abiotic cofactor assembly in photosynthetic biomimetics: site-specific stereoselectivity in the conjugation of a ruthenium(II) tris(bipyridine) photosensitizer to a multi-heme protein.

To understand design principles for assembling photosynthetic biohybrids that incorporate precisely-controlled sites for electron injection into redox enzyme cofactor arrays, we investigated the influence of chirality in assembly of the photosensitizer ruthenium(II)bis(2,2'-bipyridine)(4-bromomethyl-4'-methyl-2,2'-bipyridine), Ru(bpy)2(Br-bpy), when covalently conjugated to cysteine residues introduced by site-directed mutagenesis in the triheme periplasmic cytochrome A (PpcA) as a model biohybrid system. For two investigated conjugates that show ultrafast electron transfer, A23C-Ru and K29C-Ru, analysis by circular dichroism spectroscopy, CD, demonstrated site-specific chiral discrimination as a factor emerging from the close association between [Ru(bpy)3]2+ and heme cofactors. CD analysis showed the A23C-Ru and K29C-Ru conjugates to have distinct, but opposite, stereoselectivity for the Λ and Δ-Ru(bpy)2(Br-bpy) enantiomers, with enantiomeric excesses of 33.1% and 65.6%, respectively. In contrast, Ru(bpy)2(Br-bpy) conjugation to a protein site with high flexibility, represented by the E39C-Ru construct, exhibited a nearly negligible chiral selectivity, measured by an enantiomeric excess of 4.2% for the Λ enantiomer. Molecular dynamics simulations showed that site-specific stereoselectivity reflects steric constraints at the conjugating sites and that a high degree of chiral selectivity correlates to reduced structural disorder for [Ru(bpy)3]2+ in the linked assembly. This work identifies chiral discrimination as means to achieve site-specific, precise geometric positioning of introduced photosensitizers relative to the heme cofactors in manner that mimics the tuning of cofactors in photosynthesis.

Electron Paramagnetic Resonance Characterization of the Triheme Cytochrome from Geobacter sulfurreducens.

Periplasmic cytochrome A (PpcA) is a representative of a broad class of multiheme cytochromes functioning as protein "nanowires" for storage and extracellular transfer of multiple electrons in the δ-proteobacterium Geobacter sulfurreducens. PpcA contains three bis-His coordinated hemes held in a spatial arrangement that is highly conserved among the multiheme cytochromes c3 and c7 families, carries low potential hemes, and is notable for having one of the lowest number of amino acids utilized to maintain a characteristic protein fold and site-specific heme function. Low temperature X-band electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy has been used to characterize the electronic configuration of the Fe(III) and the ligation mode for each heme. The three sets of EPR signals are assigned to individual hemes in the three-dimensional crystal structure. The relative energy levels of the Fe(III) 3d orbitals for individual hemes were estimated from the principal g-values. The observed g-tensor anisotropy was used as a probe of electronic structure of each heme, and differences were determined by specifics of axial ligation. To ensure unambiguous assignment of highly anisotropic low-spin (HALS) signal to individual hemes, EPR analyses of iron atom electronic configurations have been supplemented with investigation of porphyrin macrocycles by one-dimensional 1H NMR chemical shift patterns for the methyl substituents. Within optimized geometry of hemes in PpcA, the magnetic interactions between hemes were found to be minimal, similar to the c3 family of tetraheme cytochromes.

Cofactor-specific photochemical function resolved by ultrafast spectroscopy in photosynthetic reaction center crystals.

High-resolution mapping of cofactor-specific photochemistry in photosynthetic reaction centers (RCs) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides was achieved by polarization selective ultrafast spectroscopy in single crystals at cryogenic temperature. By exploiting the fixed orientation of cofactors within crystals, we isolated a single transition within the multicofactor manifold, and elucidated the site-specific photochemical functions of the cofactors associated with the symmetry-related active A and inactive B branches. Transient spectra associated with the initial excited states were found to involve a set of cofactors that differ depending upon whether the monomeric bacteriochlorophylls, BChl(A), BChl(B), or the special pair bacteriochlorophyll dimer, P, was chosen for excitation. Proceeding from these initial excited states, characteristic photochemical functions were resolved. Specifically, our measurements provide direct evidence for an alternative charge separation pathway initiated by excitation of BChl(A) that does not involve P*. Conversely, the initial excited state produced by excitation of BChl(B) was found to decay by energy transfer to P. A clear sequential kinetic resolution of BChl(A) and the A-side bacteriopheophytin, BPh(A), in the electron transfer proceeding from P* was achieved. These experiments demonstrate the opportunity to resolve photochemical function of individual cofactors within the multicofactor RC complexes using single crystal spectroscopy.

Multimerization of solution-state proteins by tetrakis(4-sulfonatophenyl)porphyrin.

Surface binding and interactions of anionic porphyins bound to cationic proteins have been studied for nearly three decades and are relevant as models for protein surface molecular recognition and photoinitiated electron transfer. However, interpretation of data in nearly all reports explicitly or implicitly assumed interaction of porphyrin with monodisperse proteins in solutions. In this report, using small-angle X-ray scattering with solution phase samples, we demonstrate that horse heart cytochrome (cyt) c, triheme cytochrome c7 PpcA from Geobacter sulfurreducens, and hen egg lysozyme multimerize in the presence of zinc tetrakis(4-sulfonatophenyl)porphyrin (ZnTPPS). Multimerization of cyt c showed a pH dependence with a stronger apparent binding affinity under alkaline conditions and was weakened in the presence of a high salt concentration. Ferric-cyt c formed complexes larger than those formed by ferro-cyt c. Free base TPPS and FeTPPS facilitated formation of complexes larger than those of ZnTPPS. No increase in protein aggregation state for cationic proteins was observed in the presence of cationic porphyrins. All-atom molecular dynamics simulations of cyt c and PpcA with free base TPPS corroborated X-ray scattering results and revealed a mechanism by which the tetrasubstituted charged porphyrins serve as bridging ligands nucleating multimerization of the complementarily charged protein. The final aggregation products suggest that multimerization involves a combination of electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions. The results demonstrate an overlooked complexity in the design of multifunctional ligands for protein surface recognition.

Solar water splitting Pt-nanoparticle photosystem I thylakoid systems: Catalyst identification, location and oligomeric structure.

Photosynthetic conversion of light energy into chemical energy occurs in sheet-like membrane-bound compartments called thylakoids and is mediated by large integral membrane protein-pigment complexes called reaction centers (RCs). Oxygenic photosynthesis of higher plants, cyanobacteria and algae requires the symbiotic linking of two RCs, photosystem II (PSII) and photosystem I (PSI), to split water and assimilate carbon dioxide. Worldwide there is a large research investment in developing RC-based hybrids that utilize the highly evolved solar energy conversion capabilities of RCs to power catalytic reactions for solar fuel generation. Of particular interest is the solar-powered production of H2, a clean and renewable energy source that can replace carbon-based fossil fuels and help provide for ever-increasing global energy demands. Recently, we developed thylakoid membrane hybrids with abiotic catalysts and demonstrated that photosynthetic Z-scheme electron flow from the light-driven water oxidation at PSII can drive H2 production from PSI. One of these hybrid systems was created by self-assembling Pt-nanoparticles (PtNPs) with the stromal subunits of PSI that extend beyond the membrane plane in both spinach and cyanobacterial thylakoids. Using PtNPs as site-specific probe molecules, we report the electron microscopic (EM) imaging of oligomeric structure, location and organization of PSI in thylakoid membranes and provide the first direct visualization of photosynthetic Z-scheme solar water-splitting biohybrids for clean H2 production.

Structural and spectropotentiometric analysis of Blastochloris viridis heterodimer mutant reaction center.

Heterodimer mutant reaction centers (RCs) of Blastochloris viridis were crystallized using microfluidic technology. In this mutant, a leucine residue replaced the histidine residue which had acted as a fifth ligand to the bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) of the primary electron donor dimer M site (HisM200). With the loss of the histidine-coordinated Mg, one bacteriochlorophyll of the special pair was converted into a bacteriopheophytin (BPhe), and the primary donor became a heterodimer supermolecule. The crystals had dimensions 400 x 100 x 100 microm, belonged to space group P4(3)2(1)2, and were isomorphous to the ones reported earlier for the wild type (WT) strain. The structure was solved to a 2.5 A resolution limit. Electron-density maps confirmed the replacement of the histidine residue and the absence of Mg. Structural changes in the heterodimer mutant RC relative to the WT included the absence of the water molecule that is typically positioned between the M side of the primary donor and the accessory BChl, a slight shift in the position of amino acids surrounding the site of the mutation, and the rotation of the M194 phenylalanine. The cytochrome subunit was anchored similarly as in the WT and had no detectable changes in its overall position. The highly conserved tyrosine L162, located between the primary donor and the highest potential heme C(380), revealed only a minor deviation of its hydroxyl group. Concomitantly to modification of the BChl molecule, the redox potential of the heterodimer primary donor increased relative to that of the WT organism (772 mV vs. 517 mV). The availability of this heterodimer mutant and its crystal structure provides opportunities for investigating changes in light-induced electron transfer that reflect differences in redox cascades.

ENDOR study of charge migration in photosynthetic arrays of Rhodobacter sphaeroides.

The chemistry of bacterial photosynthesis begins in the photosynthetic reaction centre (RC), a protein complex containing a series of electron donor and acceptor molecules. Although the pigments of the RC can absorb light to operate the photochemistry, the bulk of the light is captured in special pigmented proteins, the light harvesting complexes (LHCs), that then transfer the energy to the RC. Ordinarily, the LHCs do not participate in chemical reactions during photosynthesis such that LHCs do not become oxidised upon light irradiation. However, upon chemical oxidation in the dark, cation radicals of bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) can be formed in the light harvesting complex 1 (LH1) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. As observed by continuous-wave electron-paramagnetic resonance (EPR), the charges of the BChl(+) cations migrate rather freely about the LH1 complex as in a molecular wire. Remarkably, these LH1 molecular wires continue to function in the frozen, solid state. To investigate the nature of electron-hole transfer and to corroborate the process as revealed by EPR, electron-nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) was recorded at 80 K. ENDOR observed only monomeric bacteriochlorophyll cations. Their signal intensity decreased with increased oxidation while the EPR signal narrowed and increased in size. At the increased oxidation state, the possibility of spin-spin exchange between two BChl(+)s within LH1 versus electron-hole transfer is addressed. An energy landscape of the BChl(+)s in the LH1 is proposed to explain the EPR and ENDOR results.

Mimicking Natural Photosynthesis: Designing Ultrafast Photosensitized Electron Transfer into Multiheme Cytochrome Protein Nanowires.

Efficient nanomaterials for artificial photosynthesis require fast and robust unidirectional electron transfer (ET) from photosensitizers through charge-separation and accumulation units to redox-active catalytic sites. We explored the ultrafast time-scale limits of photo-induced charge transfer between a Ru(II)tris(bipyridine) derivative photosensitizer and PpcA, a 3-heme c-type cytochrome serving as a nanoscale biological wire. Four covalent attachment sites (K28C, K29C, K52C, and G53C) were engineered in PpcA enabling site-specific covalent labeling with expected donor-acceptor (DA) distances of 4-8 Å. X-ray scattering results demonstrated that mutations and chemical labeling did not disrupt the structure of the proteins. Time-resolved spectroscopy revealed three orders of magnitude difference in charge transfer rates for the systems with otherwise similar DA distances and the same number of covalent bonds separating donors and acceptors. All-atom molecular dynamics simulations provided additional insight into the structure-function requirements for ultrafast charge transfer and the requirement of van der Waals contact between aromatic atoms of photosensitizers and hemes in order to observe sub-nanosecond ET. This work demonstrates opportunities to utilize multi-heme c-cytochromes as frameworks for designing ultrafast light-driven ET into charge-accumulating biohybrid model systems, and ultimately for mimicking the photosynthetic paradigm of efficiently coupling ultrafast, light-driven electron transfer chemistry to multi-step catalysis within small, experimentally versatile photosynthetic biohybrid assemblies.

Simple host-guest chemistry to modulate the process of concentration and crystallization of membrane proteins by detergent capture in a microfluidic device.

This paper utilizes cyclodextrin-based host-guest chemistry in a microfluidic device to modulate the crystallization of membrane proteins and the process of concentration of membrane protein samples. Methyl-beta-cyclodextrin (MBCD) can efficiently capture a wide variety of detergents commonly used for the stabilization of membrane proteins by sequestering detergent monomers. Reaction Center (RC) from Blastochloris viridis was used here as a model system. In the process of concentrating membrane protein samples, MBCD was shown to break up free detergent micelles and prevent them from being concentrated. The addition of an optimal amount of MBCD to the RC sample captured loosely bound detergent from the protein-detergent complex and improved sample homogeneity, as characterized by dynamic light scattering. Using plug-based microfluidics, RC crystals were grown in the presence of MBCD, giving a different morphology and space group than crystals grown without MBCD. The crystal structure of RC crystallized in the presence of MBCD was consistent with the changes in packing and crystal contacts hypothesized for removal of loosely bound detergent. The incorporation of MBCD into a plug-based microfluidic crystallization method allows efficient use of limited membrane protein sample by reducing the amount of protein required and combining sparse matrix screening and optimization in one experiment. The use of MBCD for detergent capture can be expanded to develop cyclodextrin-derived molecules for fine-tuned detergent capture and thus modulate membrane protein crystallization in an even more controllable way.

Bidirectional Photoinduced Electron Transfer in Ruthenium(II)-Tris-bipyridyl-Modified PpcA, a Multi-heme c-Type Cytochrome from Geobacter sulfurreducens.

PpcA, a tri-heme cytochrome c7 from Geobacter sulfurreducens, was investigated as a model for photosensitizer-initiated electron transfer within a multi-heme "molecular wire" protein architecture. Escherichia coli expression of PpcA was found to be tolerant of cysteine site-directed mutagenesis, demonstrated by the successful expression of natively folded proteins bearing cysteine mutations at a series of sites selected to vary characteristically with respect to the three -CXXCH- heme binding domains. The introduced cysteines readily reacted with Ru(II)-(2,2'-bpy)2(4-bromomethyl-4'-methyl-2,2'-bipyridine) to form covalently linked constructs that support both photo-oxidative and photo-reductive quenching of the photosensitizer excited state, depending upon the initial heme redox state. Excited-state electron-transfer times were found to vary from 6 × 10(-12) to 4 × 10(-8) s, correlated with the distance and pathways for electron transfer. The fastest rate is more than 10(3)-fold faster than previously reported for photosensitizer-redox protein constructs using amino acid residue linking. Clear evidence for inter-heme electron transfer within the multi-heme protein is not detected within the lifetimes of the charge-separated states. These results demonstrate an opportunity to develop multi-heme c-cytochromes for investigation of electron transfer in protein "molecular wires" and to serve as frameworks for metalloprotein designs that support multiple-electron-transfer redox chemistry.

Characterization of expressed pigmented core light harvesting complex (LH 1) in a reaction center deficient mutant of Blastochloris viridis.

The utility of photosynthetically defective mutants in the purple photosynthetic bacterium Blastochloris viridis (formerly Rhodopseudomonas viridis)was demonstrated with construction of a reaction-center deficient mutant, LH 1-H. This LH 1-H mutant has a photosynthetic apparatus in which most of the puf operon genes were deleted, resulting in an organism containing only the genes for the light harvesting polypeptides and the H subunit of the reaction center. This B. viridisstrain containing a truncation of the puf operon was characterized by gel electrophoresis, lipid-to-protein ratio analysis, optical spectroscopy, electron paramagnetic resonance and transmission electron microscopy. Optical and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopies revealed no photoactivity in this LH 1-H mutant consistent with the absence of intact reaction centers. Electron paramagnetic resonance evidence for assembled LH 1 complexes suggested that the interactions between light harvesting polypeptide complexes in membranes were largely unchanged despite the absence of their companion reaction center cores. The observed increase in the lipid-to-protein ratio was consistent with modified interactions between LH 1s, a view supported by transmission electron microscopy analysis of membrane fragments. The results show that B. viridis can serve as a practical system for investigating structure-function relationships in membranes and photosynthesis through the construction of photosynthetically defective mutants.

Cryogenic Charge Transport in Oxidized Purple Bacterial Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes.

We report on the analysis of the inter-bacteriochlorophyll a (BChla) charge-transport process that occurs in oxidized purple bacterial light-harvesting 1 (LH1) complexes. Experimentally, charge migration within oxidized LH1 is monitored by following the temperature-dependent changes of the BChla(•)(+) electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) line-shape characteristics. At 6 K, a Gaussian-shaped spectrum with a 1.3-mT width is detected. These characteristics indicate that at extremely low temperatures charge transport is substantially slowed so that the unpaired electron is localized on one or two BChlas. At higher temperatures, the spectra exhibit non-Gaussian line shapes and decreased line widths. These characteristics are engendered by charge migration. We have analyzed the temperature dependence of the transport process through EPR spectral simulations. The simulations incorporated a nonadiabatic model for electron transfer. The temperature dependence could be adequately described on the basis of an electron-transfer model that accounts for the effects of slow medium relaxation, whereas a satisfactory description could not be obtained on the basis of conventional multimode models for transport. The results of our analysis are consistent with the notion that the protein functions as the primary solvent for the redox centers and are in accord with the view that the protein behaves as a frozen glass, even at room temperature, with respect to the low-frequency vibrational motions coupled to electron transfer.

Exploring electron spin-spin interactions of paramagnetic iron and radical cations of bacteriochlorophyll from oxidized LH1 in the presence of electron transfer in the frozen state.

Cation free radicals of bacteriochlorophyll (BChl(+)) are formed in the light harvesting complex 1 (LH1) of photosynthetic bacteria upon oxidation by potassium ferricyanide. Unusually narrow EPR line widths are observed for BChl(+) in the frozen state. These narrow line widths are consistent with a molecular-wire behavior where rapid electron/hole transfer occurs between the BChl constituents of the pigment array responsible for light harvesting in bacterial photosynthesis. However, in addition to electron/hole transfer, two distinct types of spin-spin exchange could contribute the EPR line width narrowing, thus obfuscating the determination of LH1 as a molecular wire. First, because excess ferricyanide ion is always present during the EPR measurements, electron spin-spin interactions between the paramagnetic ferricyanide and BChl(+) could be a major source of the EPR line width changes previously attributed solely to electron/hole hopping within the array of BChl molecules in a LH1 unit. Fixing the potential of the ferricyanide/ferrocyanide redox couple gives a constant concentration of paramagnetic iron as the amount of BChl oxidized in LH1 changes. As long as the fraction of oxidized BChl in LH1 remains the same, the EPR line width is found independent of the concentration of the ferricyanide oxidant. Additionally, the trend in EPR line width as a function of temperatures depends only on the fraction of oxidized BChl and not on the concentration of ferricyanide ion. Second, spin-spin exchange interactions between BChl(+)s within LH1 rings could also change the EPR line width. Using LH1 preparations containing at most a few BChl cations per LH1 complex also eliminates the occurrence of significant electron spin-spin exchange as a cause of the observed line width narrowing in minimally oxidized LH1. This investigation of the two types of electron spin-spin exchange interactions demonstrates (1) that electron/hole hopping can take place in oxidized LH1 without involvement of paramagnetic ferricyanide or spin-spin exchange between BChl(+)s and (2) that LH1 maintains a molecular-wire nature at cryogenic temperatures.

Cryogenic structure of the photosynthetic reaction center of Blastochloris viridis in the light and dark.

The structure of the Blastochloris viridis photosynthetic reaction center has been determined at 100 K by flash-freezing crystals. A data set to 2.2 A resolution provides a well determined model of the wild-type protein. Of particular interest are the position, occupancy and heterogeneity of the Q(B)-binding site. Data were also collected from a crystal frozen immediately after illumination. The data support predominant binding of Q(B) in the proximal position in both the neutral and charge-separated states.

Specific radiation damage illustrates light-induced structural changes in the photosynthetic reaction center.

The photosynthetic reaction center of the purple non-sulfur bacterium Blastochloris viridis was frozen in the presence and absence of illumination. Differences in the resulting datasets are monitored using the difference Fourier method. Radiation damage is localized to those parts of the protein that are significant for electron transfer, and show changes that are sensitive to oxidation and protonation state.

Time-resolved crystallographic studies of light-induced structural changes in the photosynthetic reaction center.

Light-induced structural changes in the bacterial reaction center were studied by a time-resolved crystallographic experiment. Crystals of protein from Blastochloris viridis (formerly Rhodopseudomonas viridis) were reconstituted with ubiquinone and analyzed by monochromatic and Laue diffraction, in the dark and 3 ms after illuminating the crystal with a pulsed laser (630 nm, 3 mJ/pulse, 7 ns duration). Refinement of monochromatic data shows that ubiquinone binds only in the "proximal" Q(B) binding site. No significant structural difference was observed between the light and dark datasets; in particular, no quinone motion was detected. This result may be reconciled with previous studies by postulating equilibration of the "distal" and "proximal" binding sites upon extended dark adaption, and in which movement of ubiquinone is not the conformational gate for the first electron transfer between Q(A) and Q(B).