Seeing the Unseen: Mg2+, Na+, and K+ Transference Numbers in Post-Li Battery Electrolytes by Electrophoretic Nuclear Magnetic Resonance.

The growing demand for energy storage devices worldwide combined with limited resources for lithium attracts interest in other alkali or alkaline earth metals. In addition to conductivity, the cation transference number T+ is a decisive parameter to rank the electrolyte performance. However, the existing experimental methods for its determination suffer from various intrinsic problems. We demonstrate here a novel approach for T+ determination based on determining the total conductivity with impedance spectroscopy (IS) and the partial conductivity of the anion species, with the latter being obtained from the anion mobility by electrophoretic NMR. First, this eNMR/IS approach is validated by comparing T+ values from different methods in a Li-based solvate ionic liquid electrolyte. Then, it is applied to obtain T+ of cations with nuclei not detectable in NMR transport measurements, employing bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide (TFSI)-based metal salts. Solvate ionic liquids consisting of triethylene glycol dimethyl ether (G3) and Mg(TFSI)2 or NaTFSI yield values of TNa and TMg on the order of 0.4, similar to TLi. Furthermore, we apply the method to polymer electrolytes, again testing the concept with LiTFSI, and finally investigating NaTFSI, KTFSI, and Mg(TFSI)2 in poly(ethylene oxide). Values of TNa and TK are in the range of 0.14-0.2, similar to those of TLi, while Mg2+ shows a higher transference number (TMg = 0.3). The method is very versatile as it allows quantification of T+ for any type of cation, and moreover, it is applicable to highly concentrated electrolytes without suffering from assumptions about dissociation or from unknown interfacial resistances which impede electrochemical methods.

Charge Regulation at the Nanoscale as Evidenced from Light-Responsive Nanoemulsions.

Emulsions are indispensable in everyday life, and the demand for emulsions' diversity and control of properties is therefore substantial. As emulsions possess a high internal surface area, an understanding of the oil/water (o/w) interfaces at the molecular level is fundamental but often impaired by experimental limitations to probe emulsion interfaces in situ. Here, we have used light-responsive surfactants (butyl-AAP) that can photoisomerize between E and Z isomers by visible and UV light irradiation to tune the emulsion interfaces. This causes massive changes in the interface tension at the extended o/w interfaces in macroemulsions and a drastic shift in the surfactants' critical micelle concentration, which we show can be used to control both the stability and phase separation. Strikingly different from macroemulsions are nanoemulsions (RH ∼90 nm) as these are not susceptible to E/Z photoisomerization of the surfactants in terms of changes in their droplet size or ζ-potential. However, in situ second-harmonic scattering and pulsed-field gradient nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments show dramatic and reversible changes in the surface excess of surfactants at the nanoscopic interfaces. The apparent differences in ζ-potentials and surface excess provide evidence for a fixed charge to particle size ratio and the need for counterion condensation to renormalize the particle charge to a critical charge, which is markedly different compared to the behavior of very large particles in macroemulsions. Thus, our findings may have broader implications as the electrostatic stabilization of nanoparticles requires much lower surfactant concentrations, allowing for a more sustainable use of surfactants.

A Super-Ionic Solid-State Block Copolymer Electrolyte.

Polymer solid-state electrolytes offer great promise for battery materials with high energy density, mechanical stability, and improved safety. However, their low ion conductivities have so far limited their potential applications. Here, it is shown for poly(ethylene oxide) block copolymers that the super-stoichiometric addition of lithium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl) imide (LiTFSI) as lithium salt leads to the formation of a crystalline PEO block copolymer phase with exceptionally high ion conductivities and low activation energies. The addition of LiTFSI further induces block copolymer phase transitions into bi-continuous Fddd and gyroid network morphologies, providing continuous 3D conduction pathways. Both effects lead to solid-state block copolymer electrolyte membranes with ion conductivities of up to 1·10-1 S cm-1 at 90 °C, decreasing only moderately to 4·10-2 S cm-1 at room temperature, and to >1·10-3 S cm-1 at -20 °C, corresponding to activation energies as low as 0.19 eV. The co-crystallization of PEO and LiTFSI with ether and carbonate solvents is observed to play a key role to realize a super-ionic conduction mechanism. The discovery of PEO super-ionic conductivity at high lithium concentrations opens a new pathway for fabrication of solid polymer electrolyte membranes with sufficiently high ion conductivities over a broad temperature range with widespread applications in electrical devices.

Overdetermination method for accurate dynamic ion correlations in highly concentrated electrolytes.

Highly concentrated battery electrolytes exhibit a low flammability as well as a high thermal and electrochemical stability, and they typically form stable solid electrolyte interphases in contact with electrode materials. The transport properties of these electrolytes in batteries are strongly influenced by correlated movements of the ions. In the case of a binary electrolyte, the transport properties can be described by three Onsager coefficients and a thermodynamic factor. In order to determine these four target quantities, at least four experimental quantities are needed. Overdetermination by measuring five or more experimental quantities is uncommon. Here we have combined electrochemical impedance spectroscopy, electrophoretic NMR measurements and concentration cell measurements for characterizing two highly concentrated sulfolane/LiFSI electrolytes. Two sets of four experimental quantities and one set of five experimental quantities were compared with regard to the uncertainties of the resulting four target quantities. We show that the methods employing only four experimental quantities either lead to large uncertainties of the Onsager coefficients or to large uncertainties of the thermodynamic factor, while only the overdetermination by five experimental quantities leads to acceptable uncertainties of all four target quantities. The results for the Onsager coefficients are discussed with regard to dynamic ion correlations and to transport limitations in battery cells.

Heterogeneous Li coordination in solvent-in-salt electrolytes enables high Li transference numbers.

The transport properties and the underlying coordination structure of a ternary electrolyte consisting of lithium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide (LiTFSI), 1,2-dimethoxyethane (DME), and 1,3-dioxolane (DOL) is studied over a wide concentration range, up to that of a Solvent-in-Salt (SiS) electrolyte. Among other advantages for next-generation battery applications, SiS electrolytes offer a high lithium transference number (tLi) of 0.73. We analyze the transport mechanism by electrophoretic NMR (eNMR), providing the mobilities (µi) of all species. Intriguingly, in the SiS region, the mobility of the neutral species DME exceeds the cation mobility (µDME > µLi), suggesting a heterogeneous transport mechanism, where the Li+ mobility is averaged over different species. Based on Raman spectroscopy, NMR spectroscopy and MD simulations, we derive a model for a concentration-dependent Li+ coordination environment with a heterogeneous Li+ coordination in the SiS region, where the 1st coordination shell either consists of TFSI- and DOL only, or of DME, TFSI-, and DOL. Lithium ions partially coordinated by DME migrate faster in an electric field, in contrast to lithium ions solely coordinated by anions and DOL molecules, explaining the peculiarity of the rapidly migrating neutral DME molecules. Further, DME is identified as an exclusively bidentate ligand, while TFSI- and DOL act as bridging ligands coordinating different Li+ ions. Thus, Li+ coordination heterogeneity is the basis for Li+ transport heterogeneity and for achieving very high Li+ transference numbers. In addition, an effective dynamic decoupling of Li+ and anions occurs with an Onsager coefficient σ+- ≈ 0. These results provide a deeper understanding of the very efficient lithium-ion transport in SiS electrolytes, with the potential to bring further improvements for battery applications.

Diffusion and structure of propylene carbonate-metal salt electrolyte solutions for post-lithium-ion batteries: From experiment to simulation.

The diffusion of cations in organic solvent solutions is important for the performance of metal-ion batteries. In this article, pulsed field gradient nuclear magnetic resonance experiments and fully atomistic molecular dynamic simulations were employed to study the temperature-dependent diffusive behavior of various liquid electrolytes representing 1M propylene carbonate solutions of metal salts with bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide (TFSI-) or hexafluorophosphate (PF6-) anions commonly used in lithium-ion batteries and beyond. The experimental studies revealed the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficients for the propylene carbonate (PC) solvent and for the anions following an Arrhenius type of behavior. It was observed that the PC molecules are the faster species. For the monovalent cations (Li+, Na+, K+), the PC solvent diffusion was enhanced as the cation size increased, while for the divalent cations (Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+, Ba2+), the opposite trend was observed, i.e., the diffusion coefficients decreased as the cation size increased. The anion diffusion in LiTFSI and NaTFSI solutions was found to be similar, while in electrolytes with divalent cations, a decrease in anion diffusion with increasing cation size was observed. It was shown that non-polarizable charge-scaled force fields could correspond perfectly to the experimental values of the anion and PC solvent diffusion coefficients in salt solutions of both monovalent (Li+, Na+, K+) and divalent (Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+, Ba2+) cations at a range of operational temperatures. Finally, after calculating the radial distribution functions between cations, anions, and solvent molecules, the increase in the PC diffusion coefficient established with the increase in cation size for monovalent cations was clearly explained by the large hydration shell of small Li+ cations, due to their strong interaction with the PC solvent. In solutions with larger monovalent cations, such as Na+, and with a smaller solvation shell of PC, the PC diffusion is faster due to more liberated solvent molecules. In the salt solutions with divalent cations, both the anion and the PC diffusion coefficients decreased as the cation size increased due to an enhanced cation-anion coordination, which was accompanied by an increase in the amount of PC in the cation solvation shell due to the presence of anions.

Composition and Charge Compensation in Chitosan/Gum Arabic Complex Coacervates in Dependence on pH and Salt Concentration.

In this study, complex coacervates of the biopolyelectrolytes chitosan and gum arabic were investigated with respect to their composition and charge compensation depending on the pH and salt concentration. Individual polyelectrolyte yields were deduced from thermogravimetric analysis and chitosan quantification via enzymatic hydrolysis/HPLC-ELSD. The polyelectrolyte mass ratio in the complex coacervate is found to remain approximately constant irrespective of the pH, despite the latter's effect on the polyelectrolyte charge ratio. Two regimes are identified, including either chitosan charges in excess (at pH < 6.0) or gum arabic charges in excess (at pH > 6.0). The amount of extrinsic charge compensation in the complex coacervates is discussed in detail. We show for the first time that the doping level, a quantity traditionally used to describe salt-induced changes of the charge compensation in polyelectrolyte complexes, is also suitable for the description of pH-induced extrinsic charge compensation in such systems.

Confinement-enhanced Li+ ion dynamics in an ionic liquid-based electrolyte in porous material.

While Ionic Liquids (IL) are promising liquid electrolyte components for Li-ion batteries due to their high electrochemical stability and low volatility and flammability, unfavorable Lithium-anion clusters lead to poor Li+ transport properties such as low transference numbers. A confinement of ILs in nanoporous materials could overcome these problems, based on altered structural and dynamic properties of the confined ILs. We investigate the coordination and the Li+ dynamics in an IL/Li-salt mixture of 1-butyl-1-methylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluormethyl-sulfonyl)imide (Pyr14TFSA) and LiTFSA and reveal in how far the confinement has positive or negative effects on ion clustering in the electrolyte. To this end, the electrolyte is confined in mesoporous silica SBA-15 (pore diameter 8 nm or 4 nm) or the metal-organic framework (MOF) ZIF-8 (pore diameter 1.16 nm). Raman spectra elucidate the Li-anion coordination and the interaction of the ions with the walls. Temperature-dependent 7Li spin relaxation rates, analyzed within the model of Bloembergen, Purcell and Pound (BPP), allow statements on the local Li+ environment, the local Li+ dynamics and its activation. In the SBA-15 materials the Li+ coordination is unchanged with persisting Li-TFSA clusters. Furthermore, the local dynamics of Li+ is reduced upon confinement, as expected due to geometrical restrictions. At the same time, however, both structural and dynamic parameters do not show a pronounced dependence on the pore size. Surprisingly, upon confinement in ZIF-8 Li+ displays faster local dynamics and a more asymmetric environment in comparison to the bulk electrolyte. The enhanced dynamics is accompanied by a reduced coordination to TFSA-, suggesting the breakup of Li-TFSA clusters. Differences between the porous materials are attributed to the nature of the wall surface, as Raman spectra suggest that in SBA-15 the TFSA- ion is preferentially interacting with the pore walls, whereas in ZIF-8 the Pyr14+ ion is immobilized by the pore walls. These results demonstrate a strong influence of internal interfaces on IL structure and dynamics and bear potential for further tailoring ion dynamics.

A volume-based description of transport in incompressible liquid electrolytes and its application to ionic liquids.

Transference numbers play an important role in understanding the dynamics of electrolytes and assessing their performance in batteries. Unfortunately, these transport parameters are difficult to measure in highly concentrated liquid electrolytes such as ionic liquids. Also, the interpretation of their sign and magnitude has provoked an ongoing debate in the literature further complicated by the use of different languages. In this work, we highlight the role of the reference frame for the interpretation of transport parameters using our novel thermodynamically consistent theory for highly correlated electrolytes. We argue that local volume conservation is a key principle in incompressible liquid electrolytes and use the volume-based drift velocity as a reference. We apply our general framework to electrophoretic NMR experiments. For ionic liquid based electrolytes, we find that the results of the eNMR measurements can be best described using this volume-based description. This highlights the limitations of the widely used center-of-mass reference frame which for example forms the basis for molecular dynamics simulations - a standard tool for the theoretical calculation of transport parameters. It shows that the assumption of local momentum conservation is incorrect in those systems on the macroscopic scale.

Superionicity in Ionic-Liquid-Based Electrolytes Induced by Positive Ion-Ion Correlations.

In ionic-liquid (IL)-based electrolytes, relevant for current energy storage applications, ion transport is limited by strong ion-ion correlations, generally yielding inverse Haven ratios (ionicities) of below 1. In particular, Li is transported in anionic clusters into the wrong direction of the electric field, requiring compensation by diffusive anion fluxes. Here, we present a concept to exploit ion-ion correlations in concentrated IL electrolytes beneficially by designing organic cations with a Li-coordinating chain. 1H NMR and Raman spectra show that IL cations with seven or more ether oxygens in the side chain induce Li coordination to organic cations. An unusual behavior of an inverse Haven ratio of >1 is found, suggesting an ionicity larger than that of an ideal electrolyte with uncorrelated ion motion. This superionic behavior is consistently demonstrated in both NMR transport/conductivity measurements and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Key to this achievement is the formation of long-lived Li-IL cation complexes, which invert the Li drift direction, yielding positive Li+ ion mobilities for the first time in a single IL-solvent-based electrolyte. Onsager correlation coefficients are derived from MD simulations and demonstrate that the main contributions to the inverse Haven ratio, which induce superionicity, arise from enhanced Li-IL cation correlations and a sign inversion of Li-anion correlation coefficients. Thus, the novel concept of coordinating cations not only corrects the unfortunate anionic drift direction of Li in ILs but even exploits strong ion correlations in the concentrated electrolyte toward superionic transport.

Modelling viscoelastic relaxation mechanisms in thermorheologically complex Fe(III)-poly(acrylic acid) hydrogels.

Mechanical properties of hydrogels with reversible transition metal-polymer crosslinks can be flexibly tuned depending on the dissociation kinetics of the metal bond. We use rheology to investigate the sol-gel transition of a Fe(III)-poly(acrylic acid) network with varying crosslinker content and model the corresponding mechanical relaxation at different stages of gelation. The system transitions from an unentangled chain regime to a crosslink dissociation dominated regime, where the relaxation is governed by two timescales with different activation energies. To account for the interplay of chain and crosslinker dynamics, a time-temperature-superposition procedure is introduced for both processes separately, thus separating the dynamic processes in these thermorheologically complex dynamic networks. The activation energy of chain relaxation remains unchanged whether or not the chain participates in the network. To model contributions to the dynamic modulus of each process, we combine concepts from fractional viscoelasticity with a generalized Maxwell model, which describes the dynamics of an unentangled chain solution with reversible crosslinks. This allows us to quantify the evolution of viscoelastic parameters in the course of gelation, where we find that the terminal relaxation time of the gels increases less than expected at high crosslinker contents. This result is attributed to a facilitated crosslink exchange mechanism and a lower pH of the gel matrix.

Quantification of cation-cation, anion-anion and cation-anion correlations in Li salt/glyme mixtures by combining very-low-frequency impedance spectroscopy with diffusion and electrophoretic NMR.

Directional correlations between the movements of cations and anions exert a strong influence on the charge and mass transport properties of concentrated battery electrolytes. Here, we combine, for the first time, very-low-frequency impedance spectroscopy on symmetrical Li|electrolyte|Li cells with diffusion and electrophoretic NMR in order to quantify cation-cation, anion-anion and cation-anion correlations in Li salt/tetraglyme (G4) mixtures with Li salt to G4 ratios between 1 : 1 and 1 : 2. We find that all correlations are negative, with like-ion anticorrelations (cation-cation and anion-anion) being generally stronger than cation-anion anticorrelations. In addition, we observe that like-ion anticorrelations are stronger for the heavier type of ion and that all anticorrelations become weaker with decreasing Li salt to G4 ratio. These findings are in contrast to theories considering exclusively anion-cation correlations in form of ion pairs, as the latter imply positive cation-anion correlations. We analyze in detail the influence of anticorrelations on Li+ transference numbers and on the Haven ratio. In order to rationalize our results, we derive linear response theory expressions for all ion correlations. These expressions show that the Li+ ion transport under anion-blocking conditions in a battery is governed by equilibrium center-of-mass fluctuations in the electrolytes. This suggests that in future electrolyte theories and computer simulations, more attention should be paid to equilibrium center-of-mass fluctuations.

Insight into the Folding and Cooperative Multi-Recognition Mechanism in Supramolecular Anion-Binding Catalysis.

H-bond donor catalysts able to modulate the reactivity of ionic substrates for asymmetric reactions have gained great attention in the past years, leading to the development of cooperative multidentate H-bonding supramolecular structures. However, there is still a lack of understanding of the forces driving the ion recognition and catalytic performance of these systems. Herein, insight into the cooperativity nature, anion binding strength, and folding mechanism of a model chiral triazole catalyst is presented. Our combined experimental and computational study revealed that multi-interaction catalysts exhibiting weak binding energies (≈3-4 kcal mol-1 ) can effectively recognize ionic substrates and induce chirality, while strong dependencies on the temperature and solvent were quantified. These results are key for the future design of catalysts with optimal anion binding strength and catalytic activity in target reactions.

Spectral deconvolution in electrophoretic NMR to investigate the migration of neutral molecules in electrolytes.

Electrophoretic nuclear magnetic resonance (eNMR) is a powerful tool in studies of nonaqueous electrolytes, such as ionic liquids. It delivers electrophoretic mobilities of the ionic constituents and thus sheds light on ion correlations. In applications of liquid electrolytes, uncharged additives are often employed, detectable via 1 H NMR. Characterizing their mobility and coordination to charged entities is desirable; however, it is often hampered by small intensities and 1 H signals overlapping with major constituents of the electrolyte. In this work, we evaluate methods of phase analysis of overlapping resonances to yield electrophoretic mobilities even for minor constituents. We use phase-sensitive spectral deconvolution via a set of Lorentz distributions for the investigation of the migration behavior of additives in two different ionic liquid-based lithium salt electrolytes. For vinylene carbonate as an additive, no field-induced drift is observed; thus, its coordination to the Li+ ion does not induce a correlated drift with Li+ . On the other hand, in a solvate ionic liquid with tetraglyme (G4) as an additive, a correlated migration of tetraglyme with lithium as a complex solvate cation is directly proven by eNMR. The phase evaluation procedure of superimposed resonances thus broadens the applicability of eNMR to application-relevant complex electrolyte mixtures containing neutral additives with superimposed resonances.

Reply to the 'Comment on "Negative effective Li transference numbers in Li salt/ionic liquid mixtures: does Li drift in the "Wrong" direction?"' by K. R. Harris, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2018, 20, DOI: 10.1039/C8CP02595A.

We have recently directly measured the electrophoretic mobilities of the three species in "Li salt in-ionic liquid" electrolytes with a common anion by electrophoretic NMR. From the mobilities of the three species, we deduced the transference numbers and found a negative value for Li. We attributed this to a vehicle mechanism of 7Li transport, where Li is drifting in net negatively charged Li-anion clusters. In our work, as also in previous eNMR studies, ion drift velocities and thus electrophoretic mobilities are determined in the laboratory frame of reference. In his comment, Harris claims that in this frame conclusions on ion correlations are not deducable, but rather an internal reference frame, defined by the drift of one of the ions, needs to be used and that in such a reference frame no negative transference numbers would occur. While agreeing with Harris on the general relevance of reference frames in eNMR, we argue here that a reference frame of one of the ions leads to loss of information. We propose to use the reference frame of the center of mass of the electrolyte if an internal frame is required. An interesting observation is that the center of mass of an ionic liquid is drifting during the application of the short electric field pulse in eNMR. To account for this drift, we convert our data, determined from drift velocities in the laboratory frame into the center of mass frame. The results show that, independent of the reference frame chosen, using either a laboratory frame as an external frame or a center-of-mass frame as an internal frame, drift velocities of 7Li and anions are identical within error, such that the interpretation of a correlated motion of Li and anions holds.

Kinetic control in the temperature-dependent sequential growth of surface-confined supramolecular copolymers.

We report the sequential growth of supramolecular copolymers on gold surfaces, using oppositely charged dendritic peptide amphiphiles. By including water-solubilising thermoresponsive chains in the monomer design, we observed non-linear effects in the temperature-dependent sequential growth. The step-wise copolymerisation process is characterised using temperature dependent SPR and QCM-D measurements. At higher temperatures, dehydration of peripheral oligoethylene glycol chains supports copolymer growth due to more favourable comonomer interactions. Both monomers incorporate methionine amino acids but remarkably, desorption of the copolymers via competing sulphur gold interactions with the initial monomer layer is not observed. The surface-confined supramolecular copolymers remain kinetically trapped on the metal surface at near neutral pH and form viscoelastic films with a tuneable thickness.