Identification of a bidirectional splicing enhancer: differential involvement of SR proteins in 5' or 3' splice site activation.

The adenovirus E1A pre-mRNA undergoes alternative splicing whose modulation occurs during infection, through the use of three different 5' splice sites and of one major or one minor 3' splice site. Although this pre-mRNA has been extensively used as a model to compare the transactivation properties of SR proteins, no cis-acting element has been identified in the transcript sequence. Here we describe the identification and the characterization of a purine-rich splicing enhancer, located just upstream of the 12S 5' splice site, which is formed from two contiguous 9-nucleotide (nt) purine motifs (Pu1 and Pu2). We demonstrate that this sequence is a bidirectional splicing enhancer (BSE) in vivo and in vitro, because it activates both the downstream 12S 5' splice site through the Pu1 motif and the upstream 216-nt intervening sequence (IVS) 3' splice site through both motifs. UV cross-linking and immunoprecipitation experiments indicate that the BSE interacts with several SR proteins specifically, among them 9G8 and ASF/SF2, which bind preferentially to the Pu1 and Pu2 motifs, respectively. Interestingly, we show by in vitro complementation assays that SR proteins have distinct transactivatory properties. In particular, 9G8, but not ASF/SF2 or SC35, is able to strongly activate the recognition of the 12S 5' splice site in a BSE-dependent manner in wild-type E1A or in a heterologous context, whereas ASF/SF2 or SC35, but not 9G8, activates the upstream 216-nt IVS splicing. Thus, our results identify a novel exonic BSE and the SR proteins which are involved in its differential activity.

The 216-nucleotide intron of the E1A pre-mRNA contains a hairpin structure that permits utilization of unusually distant branch acceptors.

A recently characterized 216-nucleotide intron-splicing reaction occurs within the adenovirus E1A pre-mRNA through the use of three branch acceptor sites, located at 59, 55, and 51 nucleotides from the 3' splice site. To investigate the role of the cis-acting sequence elements in the selection of such unusually distant branch sites, transcripts differing in sequence downstream of the branch sites were analyzed for in vitro splicing. Initial results suggested that secondary structure could be involved in the use of distant branch sites. The involvement of a hairpin structure, including a nine-G C-base-pair stem, was supported by the results of site-directed mutagenesis analyses. Mutations that destroyed or weakened this hairpin resulted in an inefficient splicing reaction. In contrast, complementary mutation or deletion of two bulges, which involved a restoration or reinforcement of the hairpin, resulted in a reactivation or improvement of the splicing efficiency, respectively. Therefore, we conclude that the hairpin structure shortens the operational distance between the 3' splice site and the branch acceptors and brings the branch sites into the branch-permissive window, 18 to 40 nucleotides upstream of the 3' splice site. Our results confirm the importance of the constraint of distance for the splicing reaction and show that this constraint may be overcome by means of a stable hairpin formation.

Differential block of U small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particle interactions during in vitro splicing of adenovirus E1A transcripts containing abnormally short introns.

We have studied the consequences of decreasing the donor site-branch site distance on splicing factor-splice site interactions by analyzing alternative splicing of adenovirus E1A pre-mRNAs in vitro. We show that the proximal 13S donor site has a cis-inhibiting effect on the 9S and 12S mRNA reactions when it is brought too close to the common branch site, suggesting that the factor interactions in the common 3' part of the intron are impaired by the U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particle (snRNP) binding to the displaced 13S donor site. Further analysis of the interactions was carried out by studying complex assembly and the accessibility to micrococcal nuclease digestion of 5'-truncated E1A substrates containing only splice sites for the 13S mRNA reaction. A deletion which brings the donor site- branch site distance to 49 nucleotides, which is just below the minimal functional distance, results in a complete block of the U4-U5-U6 snRNP binding, whereas a deletion 15 nucleotides larger results in a severe inhibition of the formation of the U2 snRNP-containing complexes. Sequence accessibility analyses performed by using the last mini-intron-containing transcript demonstrate that the interactions of U2 snRNP with the branch site are strongly impaired whereas the initial bindings of U1 snRNP to the donor site and of specific factors to the 3' splice site are not significantly modified. Our results strongly suggest that the interaction of U1 snRNP with the donor site of a mini-intron is stable enough in vitro to affect the succession of events leading to U2 snRNP binding with the branch site.

Distinctive features of Drosophila alternative splicing factor RS domain: implication for specific phosphorylation, shuttling, and splicing activation.

The human splicing factor 2, also called human alternative splicing factor (hASF), is the prototype of the highly conserved SR protein family involved in constitutive and regulated splicing of metazoan mRNA precursors. Here we report that the Drosophila homologue of hASF (dASF) lacks eight repeating arginine-serine dipeptides at its carboxyl-terminal region (RS domain), previously shown to be important for both localization and splicing activity of hASF. While this difference has no effect on dASF localization, it impedes its capacity to shuttle between the nucleus and cytoplasm and abolishes its phosphorylation by SR protein kinase 1 (SRPK1). dASF also has an altered splicing activity. While being competent for the regulation of 5' alternative splice site choice and activation of specific splicing enhancers, dASF fails to complement S100-cytoplasmic splicing-deficient extracts. Moreover, targeted overexpression of dASF in transgenic flies leads to higher deleterious developmental defects than hASF overexpression, supporting the notion that the distinctive structural features at the RS domain between the two proteins are likely to be functionally relevant in vivo.

The RNA-binding protein TIA-1 is a novel mammalian splicing regulator acting through intron sequences adjacent to a 5' splice site.

Splicing of the K-SAM alternative exon of the fibroblast growth factor receptor 2 gene is heavily dependent on the U-rich sequence IAS1 lying immediately downstream from its 5' splice site. We show that IAS1 can activate the use of several heterologous 5' splice sites in vitro. Addition of the RNA-binding protein TIA-1 to splicing extracts preferentially enhances the use of 5' splice sites linked to IAS1. TIA-1 can provoke a switch to use of such sites on pre-mRNAs with competing 5' splice sites, only one of which is adjacent to IAS1. Using a combination of UV cross-linking and specific immunoprecipitation steps, we show that TIA-1 binds to IAS1 in cell extracts. This binding is stronger if IAS1 is adjacent to a 5' splice site and is U1 snRNP dependent. Overexpression of TIA-1 in cultured cells activates K-SAM exon splicing in an IAS1-dependent manner. If IAS1 is replaced with a bacteriophage MS2 operator, splicing of the K-SAM exon can no longer be activated by TIA-1. Splicing can, however, be activated by a TIA-1-MS2 coat protein fusion, provided that the operator is close to the 5' splice site. Our results identify TIA-1 as a novel splicing regulator, which acts by binding to intron sequences immediately downstream from a 5' splice site in a U1 snRNP-dependent fashion. TIA-1 is distantly related to the yeast U1 snRNP protein Nam8p, and the functional similarities between the two proteins are discussed.

Characterization of SRp46, a novel human SR splicing factor encoded by a PR264/SC35 retropseudogene.

The highly conserved SR family contains a growing number of phosphoproteins acting as both essential and alternative splicing factors. In this study, we have cloned human genomic and cDNA sequences encoding a novel SR protein designated SRp46. Nucleotide sequence analyses have revealed that the SRp46 gene corresponds to an expressed PR264/SC35 retropseudogene. As a result of mutations and amplifications, the SRp46 protein significantly differs from the PR264/SC35 factor, mainly at the level of its RS domain. Northern and Western blot analyses have established that SRp46 sequences are expressed at different levels in several human cell lines and normal tissues, as well as in simian cells. In contrast, sequences homologous to SRp46 are not present in mice. In vitro splicing studies indicate that the human SRp46 recombinant protein functions as an essential splicing factor in complementing a HeLa cell S100 extract deficient in SR proteins. In addition, complementation analyses performed with beta-globin or adenovirus E1A transcripts and different splicing-deficient extracts have revealed that SRp46 does not display the same activity as PR264/SC35. These results demonstrate, for the first time, that an SR splicing factor, which represents a novel member of the SR family, is encoded by a functional retropseudogene.

Splicing of the E2A premessenger RNA of adenovirus serotype 2. Multiple pathways in spite of excision of the entire large intron.

During the early period of infection, the 4.9 kb (kb = 10(3) bases) E2A premRNA of adenovirus serotype 2 is matured mainly into a 2.0 kb mRNA by excision of introns of 2233 and 626 nucleotides. In order to define all the possible steps of splicing occurring in vivo, we characterized splicing intermediates present after a limiting treatment of cells with cycloheximide. Three complementary methods of analysis were used: RNA transfer analysis, S1 nuclease mapping and complementary DNA-RNase assay. Our principal conclusions concerning the poly(A)+ species are as follows. The RNA intermediate family detected is more complex than expected, since two major RNA intermediates of 4.6 kb and 4.3 kb, two minor intermediates of 2.9 kb and 2.6 kb, and a 2.3 kb RNA, which represents a minor alternative mRNA form, are revealed. Despite its large size and the presence of multiple internal donor and acceptor signals, intron 1 is exclusively excised as a whole. Intron 2 is either primarily excised as a whole, removing the standard 626-nucleotide sequence, or a smaller sequence of 337 nucleotides is removed, generating the 2.3 kb alternative mRNA. Kinetics of the ligation reaction demonstrate that the minimal time for excision of intron 2 is no more than two minutes, indicating a high level of co-ordination of the multiple individual reactions occurring during excision of an intron. Besides the major pathway for E2A premRNA splicing, namely the excision first of intron 2, followed by the excision of intron 1 after a lag time of five minutes, a minor pathway (used with a frequency of 10%) can be detected where the order of intron excision was inverted. With the alternative variant of excision of intron 2, at least three different pathways are therefore used to mature the E2A premRNA. RNA intermediates resulting from the cleavage at the 5' end of introns and branching can be detected by S1 mapping experiments, but their low accumulative level (1% relatively to the initial premRNA) precluded their direction by RNA transfer experiments and their complete characterization.

Remodelling of the host cell RNA splicing machinery during an adenovirus infection.

Adenovirus makes extensive use of RNA splicing to produce a complex set of spliced mRNAs during virus replication. All transcription units, except pIX and IVa2, encode multiple alternatively spliced mRNAs. The accumulation of viral mRNAs is subjected to a temporal regulation, a mechanism that ensures that proteins that are needed at certain stages of the viral life cycle are produced. The complex interaction between host cell RNA splicing factors and viral regulatory elements has been studied intensely during the last decade. Such studies have begun to produce a picture of how adenovirus remodels the host cell RNA splicing machinery to orchestrate the shift from the early to the late profile of viral mRNA accumulation. Recent progress has to a large extent focused on the mechanisms regulating E1A and L1 alternative splicing. Here we will review the current knowledge of cis-acting sequence element, trans-acting factors and mechanisms controlling E1A and L1 alternative splicing.

An exon skipping-associated nonsense mutation in the dystrophin gene uncovers a complex interplay between multiple antagonistic splicing elements.

A nonsense mutation c.4250T>A (p.Leu1417X) in the dystrophin gene of a patient with an intermediate phenotype of muscular dystrophy induces partial in-frame skipping of exon 31. On the basis of UV cross-linking assays and pull-down analysis, we present evidence that the skipping of this exon is because of the creation of an exonic splicing silencer, which acts as a highly specific binding site (UAGACA) for a known repressor protein, hnRNP A1. Recombinant hnRNP A1 represses exon inclusion both in vitro and in vivo upon transient transfection of C2C12 cells with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) minigenes carrying the c.4250T>A mutation. Furthermore, we identified a downstream splicing enhancer in the central region of exon 31. This region functions as a Tra2beta-dependent exonic splicing enhancer (ESE) in vitro when inserted into a heterologous splicing reporter, and deletion of the ESE showed that incorporation of exon 31 depends on the Tra2beta-dependent enhancer both in the wild-type and mutant context. We conclude that dystrophin exon 31 contains juxtaposed sequence motifs that collaborate to regulate exon usage. This is the first elucidation of the molecular mechanism leading to exon skipping in the dystrophin gene and allowing the occurrence of a milder phenotype than the expected DMD phenotype. The knowledge of which cis-acting sequence within an exon is important for its definition will be essential for the alternative gene therapy approaches based on modulation of splicing to bypass DMD-causing mutations in the endogenous dystrophin gene.

Alternative splicing of intron 3 of the serine/arginine-rich protein 9G8 gene. Identification of flanking exonic splicing enhancers and involvement of 9G8 as a trans-acting factor.

9G8 protein belongs to the conserved serine/arginine-rich (SR) protein family, whose members exhibit multiple functions in constitutive and alternative splicing. We have previously shown that 9G8 primary transcripts are subjected to alternative splicing by excision/retention of intron 3 and to a tissue specific modulation. Because both 5'- and 3'-splice sites of intron 3 appear to be suboptimal in vertebrates, we tested the 9G8 intron 3 as a novel model system of alternative splicing. By using an in vitro approach and a mutational analysis, we have identified two purine-rich exonic splicing enhancers (ESE) located in exon 4 and a (GAA)(3) enhancer located in exon 3. These elements act in concert to promote efficient splicing activation both in vitro and in vivo. Titration experiments with an excess of exonic enhancers or SR-specific RNA targets strongly suggest that SR proteins are specifically involved in the activation process. Although ASF/SF2 was expected to interact the most efficiently with ESE according to the enhancer sequences, UV cross-linking coupled or not to immunopurification demonstrates that 9G8 is highly recruited by the three ESE, followed by SC35. In contrast, ASF/SF2 only binds significantly to the (GAA)(3) motif. S100 complementation experiments with individual SR proteins demonstrate that only 9G8 is able to fully restore splicing of intron 3. These results, and the fact that the exon 3 and 4 ESE sequences are conserved in vertebrates, strongly suggest that the alternative splicing of intron 3 represents an important step in the regulation of the expression of 9G8.

In vitro splicing of adenovirus E1A transcripts: characterization of novel reactions and of multiple branch points abnormally far from the 3' splice site.

During the analysis of the in vitro alternative splicing of the natural E1A transcript of adenovirus, other minor reactions were detected (Schmitt et al., 1987, Cell 50, 31-39). We report here their characterization. The first reaction concerns the excision of a 216 nucleotide intron delineated by the 9S 5' splice site and a 3' splice site 216 nucleotides downstream. It can occur on the premRNA transcript and the 13S and 12S mRNA species. Strikingly, the reaction uses one of 3 branch points located 51, 55 or 59 residues upstream of the 3' splice site, a distance which is unusually long since all the branch points mapped up to now are located between 18-37 nucleotides of the 3' splice site. The dramatic accumulation of the corresponding lariat intermediates, likely related to this long spacing indicates that the second splicing step is relatively unefficient. The second kind of reaction analysed is a cryptic splicing which uses a 3' splice site generated by the junction of the 13S mRNA exons, and leads to the formation of psi 12S and psi 9S mRNAs. In vitro, this reaction occurs only from a 13S mRNA transcript, and not from the 13S mRNA newly formed in the splicing assay, consistent with what has been observed in vivo. Thus, both the well known alternative and the minor reactions occurring in vivo from E1A premRNA and mRNAs are detected in vitro, implying that most of the alternative splicing machinery is reconstituted in the in vitro system.

Contrasted cis-acting effects of downstream 5' splice sites on the splicing of a retained intron: the adenoviral E1A pre-mRNA model.

The adenoviral E1A pre-mRNA contains an upstream intron (the 216 nucleotide intron) which is spliced only weakly both in vivo and in vitro. We have chosen the E1A transcript as a model to analyse, in vitro, the role of downstream cis-elements involved in the alternative splicing of this retained intron. By using a series of constructs containing specific deletions, mutations and/or truncations, we show that the 13S 5' splice site, positioned 259 nucleotides downstream of the 216 nucleotide intron, is the main cis-element which activates the splicing of this intron. Our results establish the importance of a downstream 5' splice site for the activation of the 3' splice site, which is known to be suboptimal within this retained intron. Unexpectedly, the 12S 5' splice site, although positioned at an ideal distance (121 nucleotides) from the upstream intron, does not exhibit such a cis-acting effect. In contrast, its improvement to a consensus sequence may even result in a slight negative cis-acting effect in the presence of the 13S 5' splice site, which is the first observation of such a feature. We have shown that this unexpected behaviour is due, at least partly, to the unusual characteristics of the wild-type upstream intron, which requires a hairpin structure between the branch sites and the 3' splice site to reduce the operational distance between these two sites. Possible mechanisms involved in the contrasted cis-acting effects of the 13S and 12S 5' splice sites are discussed.

Comparison of the nuclear ribonucleoproteins containing the transcripts of adenovirus-2 and HeLa cell dna.

A method as devised allowing the preparation of hnRNA-containing ribonucleproteins (hnRNP) frm HeLa cells infected with adenovirus type 2 under conditions where the extraction of viral replication complexes as minimal. Approximately 60% of the RNA from such hnRNP hybridized with adenovirus DNA. The hnRNP from infected cells had the same general characteristics as those from uninfected cells. Their size was heterogeneous (30-260 S) and depended upon that of their RNA. Their CsCl densities were identical (1.39-1.40 g/ml), indicating the same protein:RNA ratio. Their proteins were found in the same molecular weight range, between 25 000 and 200 000. The major proteins of hnRNP from HeLa cells were present in hnRNP from adenovirus-infected cells. As 60% of the cellular RNA was replaced by adenovirus RNA in hnRNP, this in dicated that there was not stringent specificity in the RNA-protein interactions. The relative proportions of the proteins were identifical in both cases, suggesting that the hnRNP assembly was independent of nucleotide sequences at least for the major proteins. The hnRNP from infected and uninfected cells differed by the size of their RNA, which was larger after infection, and by the presence of six additional minor polypeptides after infection. However, it cannot be excluded that the presence of these polypeptides in hnRNP resulted from non-specific adsorption.

High specificity of the cDNA-RNase assay to detect accurate splicing in vitro.

e previously developed a splicing assay (Keohavong et al., 1982) that we designated as a cDNA-RNase assay to analyze the ligation reaction between exons of premessenger RNA during in vivo or in vitro splicing. It was important to determine the specificity of this splicing assay, since the accuracy of in vitro splicing must always be demonstrated clearly. To do this, we constructed DNA probes derived from adenovirus E1A cDNA carrying deletions or insertions of 2-6 bases. After hybridizing them to the wild-type mRNA, the ability of single-strand-specific RNases to detect small mismatches of the RNA-DNA hybrids was examined. The demonstration that an imprecision in the splicing reaction of as little as 2 nucleotides can be detected with an efficiency of 99% indicates the high specificity of the splicing assay and its usefulness for the verification of accurate splicing in in vitro systems.