Photosystem 2 and the oxygen evolving complex: a brief overview.

These special issues of photosynthesis research present papers documenting progress in revealing the many aspects of photosystem 2, a unique, one-of-a-kind complex system that can reduce a plastoquinone to a plastoquinol on every second flash of light and oxidize 2 H2O to an O2 on every fourth flash. This overview is a brief personal assessment of the progress observed by the author over a four-decade research career, including a discussion of some remaining unsolved issues. It will come as no surprise to readers that there are remaining questions given the complexity of PS2, and the efforts that have been needed so far to uncover its secrets. In fact, most readers will have their own lists of outstanding questions.

Charge separation in the photosystem II reaction center resolved by multispectral two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy.

The photosystem II reaction center (PSII RC) performs the primary energy conversion steps of oxygenic photosynthesis. While the PSII RC has been studied extensively, the similar time scales of energy transfer and charge separation and the severely overlapping pigment transitions in the Qy region have led to multiple models of its charge separation mechanism and excitonic structure. Here, we combine two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (2DES) with a continuum probe and two-dimensional electronic vibrational spectroscopy (2DEV) to study the cyt b559-D1D2 PSII RC at 77 K. This multispectral combination correlates the overlapping Qy excitons with distinct anion and pigment-specific Qx and mid-infrared transitions to resolve the charge separation mechanism and excitonic structure. Through extensive simultaneous analysis of the multispectral 2D data, we find that charge separation proceeds on multiple time scales from a delocalized excited state via a single pathway in which PheoD1 is the primary electron acceptor, while ChlD1 and PD1 act in concert as the primary electron donor.

pH optimum of the photosystem II H2O oxidation reaction: effects of PsbO, the manganese-stabilizing protein, Cl- retention, and deprotonation of a component required for O2 evolution activity.

Hydroxide ion inhibits Photosystem II (PSII) activity by extracting Cl(-) from its binding site in the O(2)-evolving complex (OEC) under continuous illumination [Critchley, C., et al. (1982) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 682, 436]. The experiments reported here examine whether two subunits of PsbO, the manganese-stabilizing protein, bound to eukaryotic PSII play a role in protecting the OEC against OH(-) inhibition. The data show that the PSII binding properties of PsbO affect the pH optimum for O(2) evolution activity as well as the Cl(-) affinity of the OEC that decreases with an increasing pH. These results suggest that PsbO functions as a barrier against inhibition of the OEC by OH(-). Through facilitation of efficient retention of Cl(-) in PSII [Popelkova, H., et al. (2008) Biochemistry 47, 12593], PsbO influences the ability of Cl(-) to resist OH(-)-induced release from its site in the OEC. Preventing inhibition by OH(-) allows for normal (short) lifetimes of the S(2) and S(3) states in darkness [Roose, J. L., et al. (2011) Biochemistry 50, 5988] and for maximal steady-state activity by PSII. The data presented here indicate that activation of H(2)O oxidation occurs with a pK(a) of ∼6.5, which could be a function of deprotonation of one or more amino acid residues that reside near the OEC active site on the D1 and CP43 intrinsic subunits of the PSII reaction center.

Binding stoichiometry and affinity of the manganese-stabilizing protein affects redox reactions on the oxidizing side of photosystem II.

It has been reported previously that the two subunits of PsbO, the photosystem II (PSII) manganese stabilizing protein, have unique functions in relation to the Mn, Ca(2+), and Cl(-) cofactors in eukaryotic PSII [Popelkova; (2008) Biochemistry 47, 12593]. The experiments reported here utilize a set of N-terminal truncation mutants of PsbO, which exhibit altered subunit binding to PSII, to further characterize its role in establishing efficient O(2) evolution activity. The effects of PsbO binding stoichiometry, affinity, and specificity on Q(A)(-) reoxidation kinetics after a single turnover flash, S-state transitions, and O(2) release time have been examined. The data presented here show that weak rebinding of a single PsbO subunit to PsbO-depleted PSII repairs many of the defects in PSII resulting from the removal of the protein, but many of these are not sustainable, as indicated by low steady-state activities of the reconstituted samples [Popelkova; (2003) Biochemistry 42 , 6193]. High affinity binding of PsbO to PSII is required to produce more stable and efficient cycling of the water oxidation reaction. Reconstitution of the second PsbO subunit is needed to further optimize redox reactions on the PSII oxidizing side. Native PsbO and recombinant wild-type PsbO from spinach facilitate PSII redox reactions in a very similar manner, and nonspecific binding of PsbO to PSII has no significance in these reactions.

Structure and function of photosystems I and II.

Oxygenic photosynthesis, the principal converter of sunlight into chemical energy on earth, is catalyzed by four multi-subunit membrane-protein complexes: photosystem I (PSI), photosystem II (PSII), the cytochrome b(6)f complex, and F-ATPase. PSI generates the most negative redox potential in nature and largely determines the global amount of enthalpy in living systems. PSII generates an oxidant whose redox potential is high enough to enable it to oxidize H(2)O, a substrate so abundant that it assures a practically unlimited electron source for life on earth. During the last century, the sophisticated techniques of spectroscopy, molecular genetics, and biochemistry were used to reveal the structure and function of the two photosystems. The new structures of PSI and PSII from cyanobacteria, algae, and plants has shed light not only on the architecture and mechanism of action of these intricate membrane complexes, but also on the evolutionary forces that shaped oxygenic photosynthesis.

Function of PsbO, the photosystem II manganese-stabilizing protein: probing the role of aspartic acid 157.

The D157N, D157E, and D157K mutations in the psbO gene encoding the photosystem II (PSII) manganese-stabilizing protein from spinach, exhibit near-wild-type PSII binding but are significantly impaired in O(2) evolution activity and Cl(-) retention by PSII [Popelkova et al. (2009) Biochemistry 48, 11920-11928]. To better characterize the role of PsbO-Asp157 in eukaryotic PSII, the effect of mutations in Asp157 on heat-induced changes in PsbO solution structure, O(2) release kinetics, and PSII redox reactions both within and outside the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) have been examined. The data presented here show that Asn, Glu, or Lys mutations in PsbO-Asp157 modify PsbO thermostability in solution, which is consistent with the previously reported perturbation of the functional assembly of PsbO-Asp157 mutants into PSII that caused inefficient Cl(-) retention by PSII. Fluorescence decay signals from PSII reconstituted with Asp157 mutants indicate that that the Q(A)(-) to Q(B) transition on the PSII reducing side is unaffected, but complex alterations are detected on the PSII oxidizing side that affect the recombination of Q(A)(-) with the O(2)-evolving complex. In addition, oxygen yield on the first flash is increased, which indicates an impaired ability of mutant-reconstituted PSII samples to decay back to the S(1) state in the dark.

Asp157 is required for the function of PsbO, the photosystem II manganese stabilizing protein.

PsbO, the photosystem II manganese stabilizing protein, contains an aspartate residue [Asp157 (spinach numbering)], which is highly conserved in eukaryotic and prokaryotic PsbOs. The homology model of the PSII-bound conformation of spinach PsbO presented here positions Asp157 in the large flexible loop of the protein. We have characterized site-directed mutants (D157N, D157E, and D157K) of spinach PsbO that were rebound to PsbO-depleted PSII to probe the role of Asp157. Structural data revealed that PsbO Asp157 mutants exhibit near-wild-type solution structure at 25 degrees C, but functional analyses of the mutants showed that these are the first genetically modified PsbO proteins from spinach that combine wild-type PSII binding behavior with significantly impaired O(2) evolution activity; all of the mutants reconstituted approximately 30% of control O(2) evolution activity. PsbO Asp157 has been proposed to be a part of a putative H(2)O/H(+) channel that links the active site of the oxygen-evolving complex with the lumen [De Las Rivas, J., and Barber, J. (2004) Photosynth. Res. 81, 329-343]. Unsuccessful attempts to use chemical rescue to enhance the activity restored by Asp157 mutants could indicate that this residue is not involved in a proton transfer network. It is shown, however, that these mutants are deficient in restoring efficient Cl(-) retention by PSII.

Site-directed mutagenesis of conserved C-terminal tyrosine and tryptophan residues of PsbO, the photosystem II manganese-stabilizing protein, alters its activity and fluorescence properties.

The extrinsic photosystem II PsbO subunit (manganese-stabilizing protein) contains near-UV CD signals from its complement of aromatic amino acid residues (one Trp, eight Tyr, and 13 Phe residues). Acidification, N-bromosuccinimide modification of Trp, reduction or elimination of a disulfide bond, or deletion of C-terminal amino acids abolishes these signals. Site-directed mutations that substitute Phe for Trp241 and Tyr242, near the C-terminus of PsbO, were used to examine the contribution of these residues to the activity and spectral properties of the protein. Although this substitution is, in theory, conservative, neither mutant binds efficiently to PSII, even though these proteins appear to retain wild-type solution structures. Removal of six residues from the N-terminus of the W241F mutant restores activity to near-wild-type levels. The near-UV CD spectra of the mutants are modified; well-defined Tyr and Trp peaks are lost. Characterizations of the fluorescence spectra of the full-length WF and YF mutants indicate that Y242 contributes significantly to PsbO's Tyr fluorescence emission and that an excited-state tyrosinate could be present in PsbO. Deletion of W241 shows that this residue is a major contributor to PsbO's fluorescence emission. Loss of function is consistent with the proposal that a native C-terminal domain is required for PsbO binding and activity, and restoration of activity by deletion of N-terminal amino acids may provide some insights into the evolution of this important photosynthetic protein.

Inorganic cofactor stabilization and retention: the unique functions of the two PsbO subunits of eukaryotic photosystem II.

Eukaryotic PsbO, the photosystem II (PSII) manganese-stabilizing protein, has two N-terminal sequences that are required for binding of two copies of the protein to PSII [Popelkova, H., et al. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 10038-10045; Popelkova, H., et al. (2003) Biochemistry 42, 6193-6200]. In the work reported here, a set of selected N-terminal truncation mutants of PsbO that affect subunit binding to PSII were used to determine the effects of PsbO stoichiometry on the Mn, Ca(2+), and Cl(-) cofactors and to characterize the roles of each of the PsbO subunits in PSII function. Results of the experiments with the PsbO-depleted PSII membranes reconstituted with the PsbO deletion mutants showed that the presence of PsbO does not affect Ca(2+) retention by PSII in steady-state assays of activity, nor is it required for Ca(2+) to protect the Mn cluster against reductive inhibition in darkness. In contrast to the results with Ca(2+), PsbO increases the affinity of Cl(-) for the active site of the O(2)-evolving complex (OEC) as expected. These results together with other data on activity retention suggest that PsbO can stabilize the Mn cluster by facilitating retention of Cl(-) in the OEC. The data presented here indicate that each of two copies of PsbO has a distinctive function in PSII. Binding of the first PsbO subunit fully stabilizes the Mn cluster and enhances Cl(-) retention, while binding of the second subunit optimizes Cl(-) retention, which in turn maximizes O(2) evolution activity. Nonspecific binding of some PsbO truncation mutants to PSII has no functional significance.

S-state dependence of the calcium requirement and binding characteristics in the oxygen-evolving complex of photosystem II.

The functional role of the Ca (2+) ion in the oxygen-evolving complex of photosystem II is not yet clear. Current models explain why the redox cycle of the complex would be interrupted after the S 3 state without Ca (2+), but the literature shows that it is interrupted after the S 2 state. Reinterpretation of the literature on methods of Ca (2+) depletion [Miqyass, M., van Gorkom, H. J., and Yocum, C. F. (2007) Photosynth. Res. 92, 275-287] led us to propose that all S-state transitions require Ca (2+). Here we confirm that interpretation by measurements of flash-induced S-state transitions in UV absorbance. The results are explained by a cation exchange at the Ca (2+) binding site that, in the absence of the extrinsic PsbP and PsbQ polypeptides, can occur in minutes in low S-states and in seconds in high S-states, depending on the concentration of the substituting cation. In the S 2(K (+)) or S 2(Na (+)) state a slow conformational change occurs that prevents recovery of the slow-exchange situation on return to a lower S-state but does not inhibit the S-state cycle in the presence of Ca (2+). The ratio of binding affinities for monovalent vs divalent cations increases dramatically in the higher S-states. With the possible exception of S 0 to S 1, all S-state transitions specifically require Ca (2+), suggesting that Ca (2+)-bound H 2O plays an essential role in a H (+) transfer network required for H (+)-coupled electron transfer from the Mn cluster to tyrosine Z.

Reconstitution of the photosystem II Ca2+ binding site.

The roles of Ca(2+) in H(2)O oxidation may be as a site of substrate binding, and as a structural component of the photosystem II O(2)-evolving complex. One indication of this dual role of the metal is revealed by probing the Mn cluster in the Ca(2+) depleted O(2) evolving complex that retains extrinsic 23- and 17-kDa polypeptides with reductants (NH(2)OH and hydroquinone) [Biochemistry 41 (2002) 958]. Calcium appears to bind to photosystem II at a site where it could bind substrate H(2)O. Equilibration of Ca(2+) with this binding site is facilitated by increased ionic strength, and incubation of Ca(2+) reconstitution mixtures at 22 degrees C accelerates equilibration of Ca(2+) with the site. The Ca(2+) reconstituted enzyme system regains properties of unperturbed photosystem II: Sensitivity to NH(2)OH inhibition is decreased, and Cl(-) binding with increased affinity can be detected. The ability of ionic strength and temperature to facilitate rebinding of Ca(2+) to the intact O(2) evolving complex suggests that the structural environment of the oxidizing side of photosystem II may be flexible, rather than rigid.

Vibronic coherence in oxygenic photosynthesis.

Photosynthesis powers life on our planet. The basic photosynthetic architecture consists of antenna complexes that harvest solar energy and reaction centres that convert the energy into stable separated charge. In oxygenic photosynthesis, the initial charge separation occurs in the photosystem II reaction centre, the only known natural enzyme that uses solar energy to split water. Both energy transfer and charge separation in photosynthesis are rapid events with high quantum efficiencies. In recent nonlinear spectroscopic experiments, long-lived coherences have been observed in photosynthetic antenna complexes, and theoretical work suggests that they reflect underlying electronic-vibrational resonances, which may play a functional role in enhancing energy transfer. Here, we report the observation of coherent dynamics persisting on a picosecond timescale at 77 K in the photosystem II reaction centre using two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy. Supporting simulations suggest that the coherences are of a mixed electronic-vibrational (vibronic) nature and may enhance the rate of charge separation in oxygenic photosynthesis.

PsbO, the manganese-stabilizing protein: analysis of the structure-function relations that provide insights into its role in photosystem II.

The minireview presented here summarizes current information on the structure and function of PsbO, the photosystem II (PSII) manganese-stabilizing protein, with an emphasis on the protein's assembly into PSII, and its function in facilitating rapid turnovers of the oxygen evolving reaction. Two putative mechanisms for functional assembly of PsbO, which behaves as an intrinsically disordered polypeptide in solution, into PSII are proposed. Finally, a model is presented for the role of PsbO in relation to the function of the Mn, Ca(2+), and Cl(-) cofactors that are required for water oxidation, as well as for the action of hydroxide and small Mn reductants that inhibit the function of the active site of the oxygen-evolving complex.

The double mutation ΔL6MW241F in PsbO, the photosystem II manganese stabilizing protein, yields insights into the evolution of its structure and function.

The W241F mutation in spinach manganese-stabilizing protein (PsbO) decreases binding to photosystem II (PSII); its thermostability is increased and reconstituted activity is lower [Wyman et al. (2008) Biochemistry 47, 6490-6498]. The results reported here show that W241F cannot adopt a normal solution structure and fails to reconstitute efficient Cl(-) retention by PSII. An N-terminal truncation of W241F, producing the ΔL6MW241F double mutant that resembles some features of cyanobacterial PsbO, significantly repairs the defects in W241F. Our data suggest that the C-terminal F→W mutation likely evolved in higher plants and green algae in order to preserve proper PsbO folding and PSII binding and assembly, which promotes efficient Cl(-) retention in the oxygen-evolving complex.

Current status of the role of Cl(-) ion in the oxygen-evolving complex.

This minireview summarizes the current state of knowledge concerning the role of Cl(-) in the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) of photosystem II (PSII). The model that proposes that Cl(-) is a Mn ligand is discussed in light of more recent work. Studies of Cl(-) specificity, stoichiometry, kinetics, and retention by extrinsic polypeptides are discussed, as are the results that fail to detect Cl(-) ligation to Mn and results that show a lack of a requirement for Cl(-) in PSII-catalyzed H(2)O oxidation. Mutagenesis experiments in cyanobacteria and higher plants that produce evidence for a correlation between Cl(-) retention and stable interactions among intrinsic and extrinsic polypeptides are summarized, and spectroscopic data on the interaction between PSII and Cl(-) are discussed. Lastly, the question of the site of Cl(-) action in PSII is discussed in connection with the current crystal structures of the enzyme.

Mutagenesis of basic residues R151 and R161 in manganese-stabilizing protein of photosystem II causes inefficient binding of chloride to the oxygen-evolving complex.

Manganese-stabilizing protein of photosystem II, an intrinsically disordered polypeptide, contains a high ratio of charged to hydrophobic amino acid residues. Arg151 and Arg161 are conserved in all known MSP sequences. To examine the role of these basic residues in MSP structure and function, three mutants of spinach MSP, R151G, R151D, and R161G, were produced. Here, we present evidence that replacement of Arg151 or Arg161 yields proteins that have lower PSII binding affinity, and are functionally deficient even though about 2 mol of mutant MSP/mol PSII can be rebound to MSP depleted PSII membranes. R161G reconstitutes O(2) evolution activity to 40% of the control, while R151G and R151D reconstitute only 20% of the control activity. Spectroscopic and biochemical techniques fail to detect significant changes in solution structure. More extensive O(2) evolution assays revealed that the Mn cluster is stable in samples reconstituted with each mutated MSP, and that all three Arg mutants have the same ability to retain Ca(2+) as the wild-type protein. Activity assays exploring the effect of these mutations on retention of Cl(-), however, showed that the R151G, R151D, and R161G MSPs are defective in Cl(-) binding to the OEC. The mutants have Cl(-) K(M) values that are about four (R161G) or six times (R151G and R151D) higher than the value for the wild-type protein. The results reported here suggest that conserved positive charges on the manganese-stabilizing protein play a role in proper functional assembly of the protein into PSII, and, consequently, in retention of Cl(-) by the O(2)-evolving complex.

Reduction-induced inhibition and Mn(II) release from the photosystem II oxygen-evolving complex by hydroquinone or NH2OH are consistent with a Mn(III)/Mn(III)/Mn(IV)/Mn(IV) oxidation state for the dark-adapted enzyme.

Hydroxylamine and hydroquinone were used to probe the oxidation states of Mn in the oxygen-evolving complex of dark-adapted intact (hydroxylamine) and salt-washed (hydroquinone) photosystem II. These preparations were incubated in the dark for 24 h in the presence of increasing reductant/photosystem II ratios, and the loss of oxygen evolution activity and of Mn(II) was determined for each incubation mixture. Monte Carlo simulations of these data yielded models that provide insight into the structure, reactivity, and oxidation states of the manganese in the oxygen-evolving complex. Specifically, the data support oxidation states of Mn(III)(2)/Mn(IV)(2) for the dark stable S(1) state of the O(2)-evolving complex. Activity and Mn(II) loss data were best modeled by assuming an S(1) --> S(-)(1) conversion of intermediate probability, a S(-)(1) --> S(-)(3) reaction of high probability, and subsequent step(s) of low probability. This model predicts that photosystem II Mn clusters that have undergone an initial reduction step become more reactive toward a second reduction, followed by a slower third reduction step. Analysis of the Mn(II) release parameters used to model the data suggests that the photosystem II manganese cluster consists of three Mn atoms that exhibit a facile reactivity with both reductants, and a single Mn that is reducible but sterically trapped at or near its binding site. Activity assays indicate that intact photosystem II centers reduced to S(-)(1) can evolve oxygen upon illumination, but that these centers are inactive in preparations depleted of the extrinsic 23 and 17 kDa polypeptides. Finally, it was found that a substantial population of the tyrosine D radical is reduced by hydroxylamine, but a smaller population reacts with hydroquinone over the course of a 24 h exposure to the reductant.

Assembly and function of the photosystem II manganese stabilizing protein: lessons from its natively unfolded behavior.

The Photosystem II (PS II) manganese stabilizing protein (MSP) possesses characteristics, including thermostability, ascribed to the natively unfolded class of proteins (Lydakis-Simantiris et al. (1999) Biochemistry 38: 404-414). A site-directed mutant of MSP, C28A, C51A, which lacks the -S-S- bridge, also binds to PS II at wild-type levels and reconstitutes oxygen evolution activity [Betts et al. (1996) Biochim Biophys Acta 1274: 135-142], although the mutant protein is even more disordered in solution. Both WT and C28A, C51A MSP aggregate upon heating, but an examination of the effects of protein concentration and pH on heat-induced aggregation showed that each MSP species exhibited greater resistance to aggregation at a pH near their pI (5.2) than do either bovine serum albumin (BSA) or carbonic anhydrase, which were used as model water soluble proteins. Increases in pH above the pI of the MSPs and BSA enhanced their aggregation resistance, a behavior which can be predicted from their charge (MSP) or a combination of charge and stabilization by -S-S- bonds (BSA). In the case of aggregation resistance by MSP, this is likely to be an important factor in its ability to avoid unproductive self-association reactions in favor of formation of the protein-protein interactions that lead to formation of the functional oxygen evolving complex.

Structure and activity of the photosystem II manganese-stabilizing protein: role of the conserved disulfide bond.

The 33-kDa manganese-stabilizing protein (MSP) of Photosystem II (PS II) maintains the functional stability of the Mn cluster in the enzyme's active site. This protein has been shown to possess characteristics similar to those of the intrinsically disordered, or natively unfolded proteins. Alternately it was proposed that MSP should be classified as a molten globule, based in part on the hypothesis that its lone disulfide bridge is necessary for structural stability and function in solution. A site-directed mutant MSP (C28A,C51A) that eliminates the disulfide bond reconstitutes O(2) evolution activity and binds to MSP-free PS II preparations at wild-type levels. This mutant was further characterized by incubation at 90 degrees C to determine the effect of loss of the disulfide bridge on MSP thermostability and solution structure. After heating at 90 degrees C for 20 min, C28A,C51A MSP was still able to bind to PS II preparations at molar stoichiometries similar to those of WT MSP and reconstitute O(2) evolution activity. A fraction of the protein aggregates upon heating, but after resolubilization, it regains the ability to bind to PS II and reconstitute O(2) evolution activity. Characterization of the solution structure of C28A,C51A MSP, using CD spectroscopy, UV absorption spectroscopy, and gel filtration chromatography, revealed that the mutant has a more disordered solution structure than WT MSP. The disulfide bond is therefore unnecessary for MSP function and the intrinsically disordered characteristics of MSP are not dependent on its presence. However, the disulfide bond does play a role in the solution structure of MSP in vivo, as evidenced by the lability of a C20S MSP mutation in Synechocystis 6803.