The quality of systematic reviews and other synthesis in the time of COVID-19.

COVID-19 research has been produced at an unprecedented rate and managing what is currently known is in part being accomplished through synthesis research. Here we evaluated how the need to rapidly produce syntheses has impacted the quality of the synthesis research. Thus, we sought to identify, evaluate and map the synthesis research on COVID-19 published up to 10 July 2020. A COVID-19 literature database was created using pre-specified COVID-19 search algorithms carried out in eight databases. We identified 863 citations considered to be synthesis research for evaluation in this project. Four-hundred and thirty-nine reviews were fully assessed with A MeaSurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews (AMSTAR-2) and rated as very low-quality (n = 145), low-quality (n = 80), medium-quality (n = 208) and high-quality (n = 151). The quality of these reviews fell short of what is expected for synthesis research with key domains being left out of the typical methodology. The increase in risk of bias due to non-adherence to systematic review methodology is unknown and prevents the reader from assessing the validity of the review. The responsibility to assure the quality is held by both producers and publishers of synthesis research and our findings indicate there is a need to equip readers with the expertise to evaluate the review conduct before using it for decision-making purposes.

Iatrogenic facial nerve injuries during chronic otitis media surgery: a multicentre retrospective study.

OBJECTIVES: To give an insight into why, when and where iatrogenic facial nerve (FN) injuries may occur and to explain how to deal with them in an emergency setting. DESIGN AND SETTING: Multicentre retrospective study in eight tertiary referral hospitals over 17 years. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty patients with partial or total FN injury during surgery for chronic otitis media (COM) were revised. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Indication and type of surgery, experience of the surgeon, intra- and postoperative findings, value of CT scanning, patient management and final FN outcome were recorded. RESULTS: In 12 cases, the nerve was completely transected, but the surgeon was unaware in 11 cases. A minority of cases occurred in academic teaching hospitals. Tympanic segment, second genu and proximal mastoid segments were the sites involved during injury. The FN was not deliberately identified in 18 patients at the time of injury, and nerve monitoring was only applied in one patient. Before revision surgery, CT scanning correctly identified the lesion site in 11 of 12 cases and depicted additional lesions such as damage to the lateral semicircular canal. A greater auricular nerve graft was interposed in 10 cases of total transection and in one partially lesioned nerve: seven of them resulted in an HB III functional outcome. In two of the transected nerves, rerouting and direct end-to-end anastomosis was applied. A simple FN decompression was used in four cases of superficially traumatised nerves. CONCLUSIONS: We suggest checklists for preoperative, intraoperative and postoperative management to prevent and treat iatrogenic FN injury during COM surgery.

[Innovations in interventional radiology applied to the field of otolaryngology: A pictorial essay].

The management of hypervascular ENT tumors is usually complex and requires a multidisciplinary approach because of the risk of serious intra-operative bleeding and of potential injuries to cranial nerves and/or large cervical vessels. Over the last four decades, advances in neuro-interventional radio­logical procedures have produced a range of adjunctive endo­vascular techniques in addition to conventional surgery. A pictorial essay in ENT specialty is presented in this article highlighting the most relevant innovations in interventional radiology.

[Facial nerve monitoring during middle ear surgery: Results of a French survey]. / Surveillance électrophysiologique peropératoire du nerf facial en chirurgie otologique: résultats d'un sondage national français.

INTRODUCTION: Facial nerve injury is a rare complication of middle ear surgery. To date there is no widely accepted consensus on the use of intraoperative facial nerve monitoring during middle ear surgery, whereas its use has been proved as a valuable adjunct in neurotologic surgery. The purpose of our study was to identify introperative facial nerve monitoring practice patterns in France for middle ear surgery. METHODS: A 19-item survey has been made up by three experienced otologists under the auspices of the French Otology and Neurotology Association. With the support of the French Society of Otolaryngology--Head and Neck Surgery, the survey was electronically sent by email to 1249 practicing ENT with a valid email address. Answers were analyzed two months later. RESULTS: Among 1249 email sent, 299 were opened (24%) and 83 answers were collected (6,6%). Of the respondents, 66% had access to intraoperative facial nerve monitoring. Otolaryngologists involved in academic setting were influenced by their teaching duty in 27%. Intraoperative facial nerve monitoring should not be required for stapes surgery, ossiculoplasty, myringoplasty for, respectively, 92%, 93 % and 98% of the respondents. In cochlear implantation, 78% of ear surgeons used facial nerve monitoring. Answers were more controversial for chronic ear surgery, ear atresia and middle ear implant. Revision surgery and CT scan can influence answers. CONCLUSION: Despite a low response rate, results of this national survey revealed interesting findings. For most of the respondents, intraoperative facial nerve monitoring was not indicated in stapes surgery, myringoplasty and ossiculoplasty. The use of intraoperative facial nerve monitoring for cochlear implantation was supported by the majority of respondents. Variations in response rate were more significant for chronic ear surgery, including middle ear cholesteatoma, and for ear atresia surgery.

Burnout in ENT France: Update and risk factors; a STROBE analysis.

BACKGROUND: Burnout can significantly impact practitioners and their co-workers, and hence patients. There are no data for the prevalence of burnout in French ENT specialists, or for associated risk factors. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A French national cross-sectional online survey was performed on the initiative of the ENT National Professional Council (CNPORL), contacting all ENT specialists whose e-mail address was known to the French Society of ENT, the National Professional Council or the National ENT Union. The 22-question Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI) was sent out, along with 16 extra questions on possible risk factors. OBJECTIVES: The study sought to assess the prevalence and severity of burnout, using the MBI, and to analyze risk factors. RESULTS: Among the 1936 physicians, 406 contacted responded to the questionnaire (21%). Mean age was 47±14 years (range, 25-77 years); 53% male, 47% female. 196 (48%) reported burnout, including 20 (5%) severe burnout. Independent risk factors for burnout of whatever severity, comprised social interaction issues, history of identified burnout, and medicolegal pressures. Social interaction issues were independently associated with specifically severe burnout. CONCLUSIONS: Burnout affected almost half of respondents. There are identifiable risk factors, for which improvements could be implemented.

Silent sinus syndrome with interfrontal sinus retraction: A 3-case series using CARE methodology.

INTRODUCTION: Silent sinus syndrome (SSS) is a rare entity, almost exclusively involving the maxillary sinus, frontal location being very rarely reported. The aim of the present study was to describe clinical and radiological characteristics and surgical treatment using the CARE methodology. RESULTS: One woman and 2 men were referred for chronic unilateral frontal pain with imagery showing silent sinus syndrome. All showed partial or complete liquid opacification of the affected sinus associated with a thin interfrontal sinus (IFS) retracted toward the affected sinus. Functional endoscopic sinus surgery was performed in all cases, with good functional results. DISCUSSION: We describe 3 cases of SSS with IFS involvement. The frontal sinus wall seemed most vulnerable, probably most liable to be weakened by atelectasis. The study suggests that frontal SSS can be an etiology in chronic frontal sinusitis. Preoperative findings of IFS retraction are useful for surgical restoration of frontal sinus ventilation, relieving chronic pain and preventing complications.

French adaptation and validation of the Stapesplasty Outcome Test (SPOT-25), following COSMIN guidelines.

AIMS: Otosclerosis can severely impact quality of life, but no questionnaire is available in French. The present study aimed to adapt and validate a French version of the SPOT-25. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A controlled prospective study was conducted between September 2021 and April 2022. The translation used the "forward-backward" technique and statistical validation was performed in non-operated adult otosclerosis patients (cases) and a control group. Assessment Internal consistency, discrimination performance and test-retest reliability were assessed on global score, subscores and items. RESULTS: Fifty-one cases and 58 control subjects filled out the test questionnaire and 35 of the 51 cases, also filled out the retest. Internal consistency on Cronbach alpha was 0.95 for the cases. Median total SPOT-25 score was 44 (range, 10-78) for cases and 2 (range, 0-33) for controls (p= P<0.0001). Test-retest reliability on intraclass correlation coefficient was excellent (ICC=0.92; [95% CI, 0.84-0.96]). Individual items all showed satisfactory performance. CONCLUSION: The French version of SPOT-25 was short and easy to use, with satisfactory performance in assessing quality of life in otosclerosis patients.

Middle ear osteoma: a rare cause of conductive hearing loss with normal tympanic membrane.

Osteomas of the temporal bone are benign osseous tumors usually located to the external auditory canal. Osteomas involving the middle ear are very rare. We report the case of a patient presenting with a progressive hearing loss caused by a middle ear osteoma involving the incus and contiguous to the tympanic segment of the facial nerve. This report highlights the value of CT scan in the work-up of conductive or mixed hearing loss with normal tympanic membrane. The management of middle ear osteoma is discussed.

[Arachnoid granulations of the posterior temporal bone wall: report of two cases]. / Granulations arachniïdiennes de la face postérieure du rocher : à propos de deux cas.

Arachnoid granulations play a role in CSF drainage. They are primarily located adjacent to cerebral venous sinuses. They may arise on a bony surface causing progressive bony erosion. We report two cases of arachnoid granulations eroding the posterior wall of the temporal bone. The aim of this paper was to illustrate the clinical presentation, and the imaging findings of arachnoid granulation of the posterior wall of the temporal bone. They remain asymptomatic in most cases, but they might cause a communication between the subarachnoid space and mastoid air cells, increasing the risk of bacterial meningitis, subdural empyema, and other intracranial infections. Differential diagnoses are also described, including endolymphatic sac tumours.

[Objective tinnitus and essential palatal tremor in children: report of a case]. / Acouphènes objectifs et myoclonies vélaires: à propos d'un cas chez l'enfant.

Palatal tremor is a rare neurotological disorder responsible for objective tinnitus in children. Palatal tremor may be symptomatic of an underlying neurological disease or essential when a cause cannot be identified. We report a case of an essential palatal tremor in a 10-year-old girl complaining of clicking tinnitus. No treatment was undergone as she was not obviously bothered by the ear-clicking sound. Different treatment modalities have been used for distressing tinnitus related to palatal myoclonus. Recently several publications reported satisfactory results with botulinum toxin injection, which seems to be the treatment of choice.

[Radiation-induced head and neck pain: Management with botulinum toxin a injections]. / Douleurs post-radiques après radiothérapie pour cancer des voies aérodigestives superieures : traitement par injections de toxine botulique A.

PURPOSE: To report the results of Botulinum Toxin A (BTA) for radiation-induced head and neck pain. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This single-center retrospective study included all the patients treated at our institution with botulinum toxin A injections for radiation-induced head and neck pain between 2006 and 2017. Pain was evaluated by each patient on a visual analogue scale (VAS) (between 0 and 10) before, and 1 month after the injection. RESULTS: Sixteen patients were included in this series. The mean value of the pain was 8.5 before and 8 after the first injection. The difference was statistically significant (p<0.01). Major response occurred in 15 patients (VAS≤3 after BTA) and complete response in 11 patients (VAS=0 after BTA). CONCLUSION: Botulinum toxin is an effective treatment for radiation-induced head and neck pain.

Management of otitis media with effusion in children. Société française d'ORL et de chirurgie cervico-faciale clinical practice guidelines.

The Société française d'ORL et de chirurgie cervico-faciale clinical practice guidelines concern the management of otitis media with effusion (OME) in children under the age of 12 years. They are based on extensive review of MEDLINE and Cochrane Library publications in English or French from 1996 to 2016 concerning the methods of diagnosis and assessment of otitis media with effusion, as well as the efficacy of tympanostomy tubes and medical and surgical treatments of OME.

[Superior semicircular canal dehiscence mimicking otosclerosis: usefulness of imaging]. / Déhiscence du canal semi-circulaire antérieur mimant une otospongiose: intérêt de l'imagerie.

OBJECTIVES: To emphasize the role of computerized tomography (CT) in the etiologic work-up of stapes surgery failure. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Helical high resolution CT scan of the temporal bone with axial and coronal views and multiplanar reconstructions was performed in a patient who had undergone unsuccessful stapedectomy. RESULTS: CT scan demonstrated a well located prosthesis, the absence of the radiological hallmarks of otosclerosis, and revealed a superior semicircular canal dehiscence (SSCD). The diagnosis of SSCD was retrospectively considered accountable for the preoperative clinical and audiometric presentation that had mimicked otosclerosis. CONCLUSION: CT is the diagnostic test of choice in elucidating stapes surgery failure (with persistent or recurrent conductive hearing loss), whereas SSCD should be systematically considered among its causes.

[Interests of the ultrasound-guidance in the treatment of drooling through botulinum toxin injections, our experience over 10 years]. / Intérêt de l'échoguidage dans le traitement du bavage par injections de toxine botulique, notre expérience sur 10 ans.

OBJECTIVES: To report about our 10 years' experience about the treatment of drooling by ultrasound guided botulinum toxin injections. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Retrospective monocentric study including all the patients suffering from drooling and treated by ultrasound-guided botulinum toxin injections into the salivary glands between 2004 and 2015. The etiology of r drooling, the doses of toxin, the injected glands, the size of the glands measured by ultrasonography, the effectiveness of the treatment and the side effects were assessed. RESULTS: Two hundred and ninety-two injections sessions were performed in 61 patients. Exactly 70.5 % of patients reported an improvement after the first session. Parkinson's disease was the main etiology of drooling (43 % of the patients). Eleven patients reported side effects. The salivary gland volume reduced after treatment in 46 % of the patients. DISCUSSION: The interest of ultrasound-guidance is to make sure about the intraglandular injection, to lower the risk for extraglandular diffusion of the toxin responsible for swallowing disorders and to allow for an adaptation of the doses to the volume of the salivary glands, which may vary during treatment.

[Imaging in adult chronic otitis]. / Imagerie des otites chroniques de l'adulte.

Chronic otitis media (COM) can be divided into two subtypes: COM with cholesteatoma (including precholesteatomatous states) is an aggressive form of otitis. Surgical treatment is mandatory because of the risk for labyrinthine or cerebromeningeal complications. CT is very important in the preoperative work-up (extension of cholesteatoma, anatomic variants). In patients who have undergone middle ear surgery, CT and presently MRI play an increasing role in the detection of recurrent or relapsing cholesteatoma. COM without cholesteatoma does not have an osteolytic potential, but may leave auditive sequelae that in selected cases may warrant surgical treatment to improve hearing. CT is useful in the etiological work-up of patients with severe hypoacusis. CT also plays an important role in cases of surgical failure, to detect a dislocation of the ossiculoplasty or impairment of the middle ear caused by fluid effusion. The objective of this paper is to specify the indications, the results and the limits of pre- and postoperative imaging in COM.

[MRI of the temporal bone]. / IRM du temporal.

Lesions arising within the temporal bone, where audition and balance receptors are located, are multiple. Beginning with a short clinical and technical overview, this presentation aims to review the most common temporal bone lesions, according to their location. Tumors and malignant otitis externa are the most common lesions of the external auditory canal. MRI features of cholesteatoma redux, transtegmental masses, and paragangliomas are described in the middle ear MRI study. The diagnosis of petrous apex abnormalities is emphasized: cholesterol granuloma, malignant tumor, epidermoid cyst, cholesteatoma, and petrositis. The diagnostic value of CT scan associated with MRI is stressed. This study also includes the main aspects of facial nerve lesions and vascular abnormalities of the area on MRI. The conclusion summarizes the main indications of temporal bone MRI.

[Useful imaging of the ear]. / Radio-anatomie utile de l'oreille.

Good anatomical knowledge is necessary to make an effective diagnosis in ear pathology. The purpose of this article is to summarize the main landmarks of the ear. Anatomic definitions of the external ear, middle ear, and bony labyrinth are described on routine spiral CT, and the anatomic definition of the membranous labyrinth and the cochleovestibular nerve on MRI is reviewed.

[Middle ear cholesteatoma]. / Cholestéatome de l'oreille moyenne.

Cholesteatoma is a serious form of chronic otitis media. The aim of this paper is to present the state of the art of disease management, including recent data from the literature and the authors' derived from their Mentors' teaching, Professor Pierre Roulleau (Paris, France) and Professor Robert Charachon (Grenoble, France). The main recent advances concern the use of cartilage grafts to reconstruct the canal wall and/or tympanic membrane (allowing a significant reduction in residual cholesteatoma) and progress in medical imaging allowing more acute preoperative determination of extension of the cholesteatoma (in order to propose an optimally designed surgical technique) and a less invasive postoperative follow-up.

[Far-advanced otosclerosis]. / Surdités mixtes profondes par otospongiose.

OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to report a series of patients with far-advanced otosclerosis who were unable to benefit from hearing aids. Among patients with profound hearing loss, it is particularly useful to diagnose far-advanced otosclerosis even if relatively rare, because stapes surgery can improve hearing to a level allowing conventional hearing aid use (sometime the only choice before cochlear implant). MATERIAL AND METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed the charts of 7 patients (9 operated ears) in order to highlight diagnostic criteria, surgical indications and results of stapes surgery (stapedectomy or stapedotomy). RESULTS: Diagnosis of far-advanced otosclerosis was based on clinical presentation, course of hearing loss, positive family history of otosclerosis, and results of CT scan which was helpful in all the cases. Obliterative otosclerosis was found in 55% of the cases. Success of stapes surgery was observed in 89%, with no significant difference between stapedectomy or stapedotomy. CONCLUSION: Although rare, far-advanced otosclerosis must be diagnosed because patients can benefit from stapes surgery (and subsequently fitting of appropriate hearing aids).