Iron-sulfur clusters: nature's modular, multipurpose structures.

Iron-sulfur proteins are found in all life forms. Most frequently, they contain Fe2S2, Fe3S4, and Fe4S4 clusters. These modular clusters undergo oxidation-reduction reactions, may be inserted or removed from proteins, can influence protein structure by preferential side chain ligation, and can be interconverted. In addition to their electron transfer function, iron-sulfur clusters act as catalytic centers and sensors of iron and oxygen. Their most common oxidation states are paramagnetic and present significant challenges for understanding the magnetic properties of mixed valence systems. Iron-sulfur clusters now rank with such biological prosthetic groups as hemes and flavins in pervasive occurrence and multiplicity of function.

Role of the mitochondrial Hsp70s, Ssc1 and Ssq1, in the maturation of Yfh1.

The mitochondrial matrix of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae contains two molecular chaperones of the Hsp70 class, Ssc1 and Ssq1. We report that Ssc1 and Ssq1 play sequential roles in the import and maturation of the yeast frataxin homologue (Yfh1). In vitro, radiolabeled Yfh1 was not imported into ssc1-3 mutant mitochondria, remaining in a protease-sensitive precursor form. As reported earlier, the Yfh1 intermediate form was only slowly processed to the mature form in Deltassq1 mitochondria (S. A. B. Knight, N. B. V. Sepuri, D. Pain, and A. Dancis, J. Biol. Chem. 273:18389-18393, 1998). However, the intermediate form in both wild-type and Deltassq1 mitochondria was entirely within the inner membrane, as it was resistant to digestion with protease after disruption of the outer membrane. Therefore, we conclude that Ssc1, which is present in mitochondria in approximately a 1,000-fold excess over Ssq1, is required for Yfh1 import into the matrix, while Ssq1 is necessary for the efficient processing of the intermediate to the mature form in isolated mitochondria. However, the steady-state level of mature Yfh1 in Deltassq1 mitochondria is approximately 75% of that found in wild-type mitochondria, indicating that this retardation in processing does not dramatically affect cellular concentrations. Therefore, Ssq1 likely has roles in addition to facilitating the processing of Yfh1. Twofold overexpression of Ssc1 partially suppresses the cold-sensitive growth phenotype of Deltassq1 cells, as well as the accumulation of mitochondrial iron and the defects in Fe/S enzyme activities normally found in Deltassq1 mitochondria. Deltassq1 mitochondria containing twofold-more Ssc1 efficiently converted the intermediate form of Yfh1 to the mature form. This correlation between the observed processing defect and suppression of in vivo phenotypes suggests that Ssc1 is able to carry out the functions of Ssq1, but only when present in approximately a 2,000-fold excess over normal levels of Ssq1.

Oxygen sensing by the global regulator, FNR: the role of the iron-sulfur cluster.

FNR is a global regulator that controls transcription of genes whose functions facilitate adaptation to growth under O2 limiting conditions. It has long been appreciated that the activity of FNR must be regulated by O2 availability, since FNR dependent gene expression is observed in vivo only under anaerobic conditions, while similar levels of this protein are present in both aerobic and anaerobic grown cells. Recent progress in this field has shown that anaerobically purified FNR contains a [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster and that this [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster is sufficiently unstable toward O2 to make it suitable as an O2 sensor. The presence of the [4Fe-4S] cluster increases dimerization of FNR which is correlated with an increase in site-specific DNA binding of FNR, a property expected of transcription factors of the FNR/CRP family. According to Mössbauer spectroscopy on purified FNR and cells containing overexpressed FNR, the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster of FNR is converted by O2 to a [2Fe-2S]2+ in high yield. The [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster can be reconverted to the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster on reduction with dithionite in vitro raising the possibility that the [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster is a biologically inactive intermediate which may be more readily available for reconstitution into the [4Fe-4S]2+ form than the Fe-free apoform. The ability to observe, by Mössbauer spectroscopy, the Fe-S clusters of FNR in cells containing high levels of FNR should be of value in further unraveling how FNR functions in vivo. Attempts to reduce the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster of FNR with dithionite indicated that the redox potential of the +1/+2 couple is < or = -650 mV and that the [4Fe-4S]+ cluster form is, therefore, not likely to occur in vivo.

Trails of inquiry and thought leading toward today's bioenergetics.

Significant experimental observations and concepts leading from various sources toward today's bioenergetics are briefly sketched. To limit the essay to manageable proportions main consideration is given to origins in research on metabolism and biological oxidations and attendant energy conversions. Relevant data and dates are summarized in table form.

Oxido-reductive titrations of cytochrome c oxidase followed by EPR spectroscopy.

Experiments are described on oxido-reductive titrations of cytochrome c oxidase as followed by low-temperature EPR and reflectance spectroscopy. The reductants were cytochrome c or NADH and the oxidant ferricyanide. Experiments were conducted in the presence and absence of either cytochrome c or carbon monoxide, or both. An attempt is made to provide a complete quantitative balance of the changes observed in the major EPR signals. During reduction, the maximal quantity of heme represented in the high-spin ferric heme signals (g approximately 6; 2) is 25% of the total heme present, and during reoxidation 30%. With NADH reduction there is little difference between the pattern of disappearance of the low-spin ferric heme signals in the absence or presence of cytochrome c. The copper and high-spin heme signals, however, disappear at higher titrant concentrations in the presence of cytochrome c than in its absence. In these titrations, as well as in those with ferrocytochrome c, the quantitative balance indicates that, in addition to EPR-detectable components, EPR-undetectable components are also reduced, increasingly so at higher titrant concentrations. The quantity of EPR-undectable components reduced appears to be inverely related to pH. A similar inverse relationship exists between pH and appearance of high-spin signals during yhe titration. At pH 9.3 the quantity of heme represented in the high-spin signals is less than 5%, whereas it approximately doubles from pH 7.4 to pH 6.1. In the presence of CO less of the low-spin heme and copper signals disappears for the same quantity of titrant consumed, again implying reduction of EPR undetectable components. At least one of these components is represented in a broad absorption band centered at 655 nm. The stoichiometry observed on reoxidation, particularly in the presence of CO, is not compatible with the notion that the copper signal represents 100% of the active copper of the enzyme as a pair of interacting copper atoms.

The oxygen reactions of reduced cytochrome c oxidase. Position of a form with an unusual EPR signal in the sequence of early intermediates.

The order of appearance of intermediates in the reoxidation of reduced cytochrome c oxidase by oxygen has been examined. Particular emphasis was placed on determining where the intermediate with the EPR signal at g = 5, 1.78, 1.69 (Shaw, R.W., Hansen, R.E. and Beinert, H. (1978) J. Biol. Chem. 253, 6637--6640) appears in the sequence of events during reoxidation. Flash photolysis of reduced, CO-complexed samples of cytochrome c oxidase in the presence of oxygen in a buffer containing 30% (v/v) ethylene glycol at 77 K and 195 K has been used to generate states of partial reoxidation. The intermediate with the EPR signal at g = 5, 1.78, and 1.69 can be detected as a product of the photolysis and subsequent oxidation but does not appear until the photolyzed sample is incubated at temperatures well above 196 K. In the course of the reoxidation, the intermediate characterized by the g = 5, 1.78, 1.69 signal occurs in the reaction sequence after the states referred to as 'Compound A' and 'Compound B' (Chance, B., Saronio, C., and Leigh, J.S. (1975) J. Biol. Chem. 250, 9226--9237). Its appearance is within the time range reported for the formation of 'oxygenated' cytochrome c oxidase (Orii, Y. (1979) in Cytochrome Oxidase (King, T.E., Orii, Y., Chance, B. and Okunuki, K., eds.), pp. 331--340, Elsevier/North-Holland Biomedical Press, Amsterdam).

Responses of the a3 component of cytochrome c oxidase to substrate and ligand addition.

We have previously described a transient high spin ferric heme species in cytochrome c oxidase (EC 1.9.3.1) which represent a3+(3) (Beinert, H. and Shaw, R.W.(1977) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 462, 12u--130), and can be detected and quantitatively determined by EPR. We have now used out ability to generate this species to study reactions of a3+(3) with substrates and ligands and also responses to pH changes. This was accomplished by multiple rapid mixing and freezing techniques in conjunction with low temperature EPR and optical reflectance spectroscopies. The substrates used were O2 and ferrocytochrome c and the ligands cyanide, sulfide, azide and carbon monoxide. Contrary to the oxidized, resting form of the enzyme, the transient high spin species of a3+(3) reacts within less than 10 ms stoichiometrically with cyanide and sulfide and at a slower rate with azide. The transient a3+(3) species responds to O2 and CO by changes in signal size or shape, although no oxidoreduction is involved, indicating that a3+(3) registers the presence of these gases. The high spin signal of the transient species is readily abolished by ferrocytochrome c or on raising the pH. Decreasing the pH induces a shift from the rhombic towards the axial component of the signal. Since the responses to CO and pH are analogous for the rhombic transient species to those observed with the rhombic high spin ferric heme species produced on partial reduction, it is suggested that the rhombic signals represent a3+(3) in either case. In all these experiments, in which EPR detectable a3+(3) was observed in large yield, no extra signals for copper or correspondingly increased intensity in the copper signal at g = 2 were seen. The relationship is discussed of the obviously reactive transient species of a3+(3) to other 'activated' species that have been reported and to the oxidized resting form of the enzyme, which is known to react only slowly with ligands and to respond sluggishly to substrate.

Kinetic studies on cytochrome c oxidase by combined epr and reflectance spectroscopy after rapid freezing.

1. Techniques and experiments are described concerned with the millisecond kinetics of EPT-detectable changes brought about in cytochrome c oxidase by reduced cytochrome c and, after reduction with various agents, by reoxidation with O2 or ferricyanide. Some experiments in the presence of ligands are also reported. Light absorption was monitored by low-temperature reflectance spectroscopy. 2. In the rapid phase of reduction of cytochrome c oxidase by cytochrome c (less than 50 ms) approx. 0.5 electron equivalent per heme a is transferred mainly to the low-spin heme component of cytochrome c oxidase and partly to the EPR-detectable copper. In a slow phase (less than 1 s) the copper is reoxidized and high-spin ferric heme signals appear with a predominant rhombic component. Simultaneously the absorption band at 655 nm decreases and the Soret band at 444 nm appears between the split Soret band (442 and 447 nm) of reduced cytochrome a. 3. On reoxidation of reduced enzyme by oxygen all EPR and optical features are restored within 6 ms. On reoxidation by O2 in the presence of an excess of reduced cytochrome c, states can be observed where the low-spin heme and copper signals are largely absent but the absorption at 655 nm is maximal, indicating that the low-spin heme and copper components are at the substrate side and the component(s) represented in the 655 nm absorption at the O2 side of the system. On reoxidation with ferricyanide the 655 nm absorption is not readily restored but a ferric high-spin heme, represented by a strong rhombic signal, accumulates. 4. On reoxidation of partly reduced enzyme by oxygen, the rhombic high-spin signals disappear within 6 ms., whereas the axial signals disappear more slowly, indicating that these species are not in rapid equilibrium. Similar observations are made when partly reduced enzyme is mixed with CO. 5. The results of this and the accompanying paper are discussed and on this basis an assignment of the major EPR signals and of the 655 nm absorption is proposed, which in essence is that published previously (Hartzell, C.R., Hansen, R.E. and Beinert, H. (1973) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S. 70, 2477-2481). Both the low-spin (g=o; 2.2; 1.5) and slowly appearing high-spin (g=6; 2) signals are attributed to ferric cytochrome a, whereas the 655 nm absorption is thought to arise from ferric cytochrome a3, when it is present in a state of interaction with EPR-undectectable copper. Alternative possibilities and possible inconsistencies with this proposal are discussed.

Multiple frequency EPR studies on three forms of oxidized cytochrome c oxidase.

Bovine heart mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase (cytochrome aa3) (EC 1.9.3.1) has been demonstrated to occur in several forms when the redox centers in the protein are thought to be fully oxidized. We report here the results of extensive EPR studies at 3, 8.9, 9.2, 9.4, 15 and 34 GHz on the resting state, the alternative resting state (with g = 12 at 9 GHz) and pulsed state (with g = 5 signal at 9 GHz). Theoretical consideration is given to all binary spin-coupling possibilities under the constraint that the iron atoms are either ferric or ferrous and the copper atoms are either cupric or cuprous. We conclude that the g = 12 signal can arise from any spin system with S greater than 1 and D = 0.15 cm-1. The g = 5 signals originate from an excited, integer-spin system with D = 0.035 cm-1, which is approximately 7 cm-1 above the ground state (not observed in EPR). It is pointed out that in interpretations of data and elaboration of suitable models in this field, the implications of spin-coupling should be considered in a comprehensive and not in a selective way. At 3 GHz, EPR spectra of CuA in the resting, pulsed and anaerobically oxidized states show that this center is identical in its EPR for all three states.

Studies on the origin of the near-infrared (800-900 nm) absorption of cytochrome c oxidase.

Data are presented which were collected in the course of the past ten years and bear on the correlation of absorbance at 800 nm and the EPR signal at g = 2 ('copper signal') of cytochrome c oxidase in various states of oxidation and ligation. Both EPR and optical reflectance spectra were obtained at low temperature (-170 to -190 degrees C). For some sets of samples spectra were recorded in the range 500-1100 nm. A particular efFort was made to study this correlation with what are called 'mixed valence' states (Greenwood, C., Wilson, M.T. and Brunori, M. (1974) Biochem. J. 137, 205-215), when cytochrome a and the EPR-detectable copper are thought to be oxidized and the other components reduced and vice versa. These data show no evidence that the copper component of cytochrome oxidase which has so far not been detected by EPR makes a contribution to the absorption between 800 and 900 nm exceeding 10-15% of the total, which is close to or within the error of the respective measurements. For the various states of the oxidase examined in this work the 700-800 nm region did not appear to be more useful than the 800-900 nm region for determining the state of the EPR-undetectable copper in a reliable way. These conclusions are in agreement with results presented previously from other laboratories concerning the relationship of optical (approx. 800 nm) and EPR spectroscopic (g = 2) data obtained with the enzyme.

Analysis of the electron paramagnetic resonance spectrum of the cobalamin intermediate in ribonucleotide reduction.

EPR absorption-derivative lineshapes have been computed and least-squares fitted to the spectrum of the intermediate derived from 5'-deoxy-5'-adenosylcobalamin in the ribonucleotide reductase reaction. A Gaussian-type intrinsic lineshape was assumed and the effects of inhomogenous broadening, rotation of coordinate axes of the A-tensor relative to the g-tensor, angular dependence of transition probability and ligand hyperfine splitting have also been investigated. When the overall spectrum was computed as the sum of the lineshapes corresponding to two distinct Co(II) species, A and B, each having rhombic symmetry, the least squares procedure converged to a much better fit than with a single species, and matched almost all of the features of the experimental spectrum. The magnetic properties of A and B were compared with those of a series of other Co(II) complexes by a plot of g - g versus A - A. The results eliminate cobalt with 5-coordination to nitrogen for A and B, and suggest low-spin cobalt complexes having strongly distorted 6-fold coordination. The possibility that the sixth, symmetry-decreasing ligand is the oxygen molecule is excluded by the chemistry of the system and by the EPR properties of previously reported cob(II)alamins. It is suggested that the sixth ligand is a carbonyl, amide or sulfhydryl group of an enzyme sidechain which is inserted off-axis into the coordination position so as to exert the observed symmetry-lowering effect.

Dual-mode EPR spectrometry of O2-pulsed cytochrome c oxidase.

O2-activated bovine heart cytochrome c oxidase has been examined by dual-mode EPR spectrometry. Resonances have been observed at g = 10 and 4.5 in the parallel mode and at g = 10, 5, 1.8 and 1.7 in the normal mode. The bulk of these signals are interpreted to come from a stoichiometric S = 2 system with magnitude of a = 0.17 cm-1, D = +2.1 cm-1, magnitude of E = 0.026 cm-1, g = 2. Exchange coupling between cytochrome a3 and CuB is not indicated.

Studies on the spin-spin interaction between flavin and iron-sulfur cluster in an iron-sulfur flavoprotein.

When the di- or trimethylamine dehydrogenases (trimethylamine:(acceptor) oxidoreductase (demethylating), EC 1.5.99.7) of certain methylotrophic bacteria are reduced by two electrons with substrate unusual EPR signals arise at g = 2 and g = 4 (Steenkamp, D.J. and Beinert, H. (1982) Biochem. J. 207, 233-239; 241-252) indicative of spin-spin interaction between the FMN and iron-sulfur compounds of these enzymes. An attempt is made to understand, describe and simulate these spectra in terms of a triplet state with possible contributions from both dipolar and anisotropic exchange (J) interactions. No direct measurement of J is available, but various approaches to setting limits to J are outlined. According to these, J approximately 0.4 to 3 cm-1 or 15 to 50 cm-1. The spectra show, in the g = 2 region, a pair of rather sharp inner and a pair of broad outer lines; the latter broaden as well as move out from the center with increasing time (after substrate addition) and substrate concentration, while there is little change of g = 4. The best fits to such spectra were obtained by assuming distribution of D and E values, depending on substrate effects and arriving presumably from 'g-strain'. The fact that both shapes and intensities at g = 2 and g = 4 could be reproduced simultaneously at two frequencies indicates that the assumptions underlying our approaches and interpretations are permissible and reasonable, although we cannot claim their uniqueness. The distance between the centers of the spin densities of the flavin radical and the Fe-S cluster is thought to lie between the limits 3 to 5 A if the asymmetries in the spin-spin interaction are magnetic dipole-dipole in origin. Because there is an indication that the interaction is anisotropic exchange, the upper limit is less stringent.

A spin-label study of the disposition of the Fe-S cluster with respect to the active center of aconitase.

It has been reported by Johnson et al. ((1977) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 74, 384-389) that phenacyl bromide reacts with a single reactive sulfhydryl group of aconitase, abolishing enzyme activity. Substrate or analogs have a protective effect. This group is therefore at the catalytic site of the enzyme. Aconitase is also known to be an Fe-S protein, paramagnetic as obtained on purification (Ruzicka and Beinert (1978) J. Biol. Chem. 253, 2514-2517). We have attempted to obtain information on the location of the Fe-S cluster of aconitase with respect to the catalytically active site by attaching nitroxide-labelled sulfhydryl reagents of the bromoacyl and maleimide type to the sensitive sulfhydryl group. The EPR signals of those spin-labelled sulfhydryl reagents that abolish enzyme activity disappear during reaction with aconitase. EPR spectra at 13 K of the product obtained by reaction of three spin labels (two maleimides and one bromoacyl) with aconitase included a half-field transition at g approximately equal to 4.0 which is characteristic of spin-spin interaction. On the basis of calculations of the dependence of the intensity of the half-field transition on the distance between two interacting unpaired electrons (Eaton and Eaton, (1982) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 104, 5002-5003) the distances between the nitroxide N-O bond and the center of the Fe-S cluster for the three spin labels were calculated to be 10.5, 11 and 13 A. Combined distance and orientation data for the three spin labels indicate that the reactive sulfhydryl group is about 12 A from the center of the Fe-S cluster.

Fe-S proteins in sensing and regulatory functions.

In the past five to ten years, it has become increasingly apparent that the function of Fe-S clusters is not limited to electron transfer, a function implicit in their discovery. We now know that the vulnerability of these structures to oxidative destruction is used by nature in sensing O2, iron, and possibly also nitric oxide. Changes in the oxidation state of Fe-S clusters can also serve as a reversible switch.

Crystal structures of aconitase with trans-aconitate and nitrocitrate bound.

Crystal structures of mitochondrial aconitase with the inhibitors trans-aconitate and nitrocitrate bound to the [4Fe-4S] cluster have been solved and refined at 2.05 A resolution with R-factors of 0.168 and 0.172, respectively. Crystallization of aconitase with the substrates citrate and cis-aconitate has not been possible because the enzyme turns over and selects enzyme with isocitrate bound into the crystal lattice. Therefore we have analyzed crystal structures of the enzyme complexed with inhibitor analogs of these two substrates. The structure with nitrocitrate bound provides a model for citrate binding. The structure with trans-aconitate bound provides a model for cis-aconitate binding in two ways: Fe4 of the [4Fe-4S] cluster is five-coordinate and the carbon at the C beta position is trigonal. These results allow the model for the reaction mechanism to be extended to all three natural substrates of aconitase. The results support a model in which citrate and isocitrate form similar chelate structures related by 180 degrees rotation about the C alpha-C beta bond while the intermediate cis-aconitate binds in either of two ways (citrate mode or isocitrate mode). In both inhibitor complexes a H2O molecule is also bound to Fe4. In the structure with nitrocitrate bound, partial occupancy of sulfate in the active site is observed accompanied by hydroxyl binding to Fe4. Comparison of the structures with isocitrate, trans-aconitate, nitrocitrate and sulfate bound reveals preferred orientations for the three types of oxygens ligated to Fe4 (carboxyl, hydroxyl and H2O) supporting the proposed roles for His101, Asp165 and His167 in the catalytic mechanism.

Crystals and structures of cytochrome c oxidases--the end of an arduous road.

Crystal structures of cytochrome c oxidases, one of which is the largest membrane-bound protein complex crystallized to date in a form suitable for X-ray diffraction, have recently been solved. The information from these accomplishments confirms many of the structural properties known from earlier spectroscopic and analytical studies, and provides a basis for understanding the complex mechanisms of electron transfer and proton pumping.

Redox control of gene expression involving iron-sulfur proteins. Change of oxidation-state or assembly/disassembly of Fe-S clusters?

Attention is drawn to a mechanism of redox control of gene expression involving Fe-S proteins which depends on the disassembly and reassembly of Fe-S clusters rather than a change in oxidation state. Iron Regulatory Protein (IRP)/aconitase and FNR are discussed as examples for such a mechanism.

Heterogeneity in an isolated membrane protein. Has the 'authentic cytochrome oxidase' been identified?

The criteria of homogeneity or native state of a protein are prone to become ambiguous when applied to membrane proteins, such as cytochrome-c oxidase, which are purified by extraction with detergents. Properties of the purified material depend on the detergent used and on details of the purification protocol followed with any single batch of a preparation. We present arguments to show that the evidence presently available in published form does not justify the designation [(1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 3160-3164] of one type of preparation as being closer to the native state than others.