CTLA4-Ig-Based Bifunctional Costimulation Inhibitor Blocks CD28 and ICOS Signaling to Prevent T Cell Priming and Effector Function.

CTLA4-Ig/abatacept dampens activation of naive T cells by blocking costimulation via CD28. It is an approved drug for rheumatoid arthritis but failed to deliver efficacy in a number of other autoimmune diseases. One explanation is that activated T cells rely less on CD28 signaling and use alternate coreceptors for effector function. ICOS is critical for activation of T-dependent humoral immune responses, which drives pathophysiology of IgG-mediated autoimmune diseases. In this study, we asked whether CD28 and ICOS play nonredundant roles for maintenance of T-dependent responses in mouse models. Using a hapten-protein immunization model, we show that during an ongoing germinal center response, combination treatment with CTLA4-Ig and ICOS ligand (ICOSL) blocking Ab completely dissolves ongoing germinal center responses, whereas single agents show only partial activity. Next, we took two approaches to engineer a therapeutic molecule that blocks both pathways. First, we engineered CTLA4-Ig to enhance binding to ICOSL while retaining affinity to CD80/CD86. Using a library approach, binding affinity of CTLA4-Ig to human ICOSL was increased significantly from undetectable to 15-42 nM; however, the affinity was still insufficient to completely block binding of ICOSL to ICOS. Second, we designed a bispecific costimulation inhibitor with high-affinity CTLA4 extracellular domains fused to anti-ICOSL Ab termed bifunctional costimulation inhibitor. With this bispecific approach, we achieved complete inhibition of CD80 and CD86 binding to CD28 as well as ICOS binding to ICOSL. Such bispecific molecules may provide greater therapeutic benefit in IgG-mediated inflammatory diseases compared with CTLA4-Ig alone.

Heterogeneity of non-cycling and cycling synchronized murine hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells.

Purified long-term multilineage repopulating marrow stem cells have been considered to be homogenous, but functionally these cells are heterogeneous. Many investigators urge clonal studies to define stem cells but, if stem cells are truly heterogeneous, clonal studies can only define heterogeneity. We have determined the colony growth and differentiation of individual lineage negative, rhodamine low, Hoechst low (LRH) stem cells at various times in cytokine culture, corresponding to specific cell cycle stages. These highly purified and cycle synchronized (98% in S phase at 40 h of culture) stem cells were exposed to two cytokine cocktails for 0, 18, 32, or 40 h and clonal differentiation assessed 14 days later. Total heterogeneity as to gross colony morphology and differentiation stage was demonstrated. This heterogeneity showed patterns of differentiation at different cycle times. These data hearken to previous suggestions that stem cells might be similar to radioactive isotopes; decay rate of a population of radioisotopes being highly predictable, while the decay of individual nuclei is heterogeneous and unpredictable (Till et al., 1964). Marrow stem cells may be most adequately defined on a population basis; stem cells existing in a continuum of reversible change rather than a hierarchy.

Microvesicle induction of prostate specific gene expression in normal human bone marrow cells.

PURPOSE: Transfer of genetic material from cancer cells to normal cells occurs via microvesicles. Cell specific phenotypes can be induced in normal cells by the transfer of material in microvesicles, leading to genetic changes. We report the identification and expression of prostate specific genes in normal human marrow cells co-cultured with human prostate cancer cells. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We harvested prostate tissue from 11 patients with prostate cancer. In 4 cases prostate tissue was co-cultured across from human marrow for 2 or 7 days but separated from it by a 0.4 µM polystyrene membrane. In 5 cases conditioned medium from patient cancer tissue was collected and ultracentrifuged, and microvesicles were collected for co-culture (3) and vesicle characterization (3). Explanted human marrow was harvested from cultures and RNA extracted. Real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction was done for select prostate specific genes. RESULTS: Marrow exposed to human prostate tumor or isolated microvesicles in culture in 4 and 3 cases, respectively, showed at least 2-fold or greater prostate gene expression than control marrow. In 1 case in which normal prostate was co-cultured there were no prostate gene increases in normal marrow. CONCLUSIONS: Prostate cancer tumor cells co-cultured with human bone marrow cells induce prostate specific gene expression. The proposed mechanism of transfer of genetic material is via microvesicles. This represents an opportunity for novel therapeutic agents, such as antibodies, to block microvesicle release from cancer cells or for agents that may block cells from accepting microvesicles.

Gene expression fluctuations in murine hematopoietic stem cells with cell cycle progression.

Evolving data suggest that marrow hematopoietic stem cells show reversible changes in homing, engraftment, and differentiation phenotype with cell cycle progression. Furthermore, marrow stem cells are a cycling population. Traditional concepts hold that the system is hierarchical, but the information on the lability of phenotype with cycle progression suggests a model in which stem cells are on a reversible continuum. Here we have investigated mRNA expression in murine lineage negative stem cell antigen-1 positive stem cells of a variety of cell surface epitopes and transcription regulators associated with stem cell identity or regulation. At isolation these stem cells expressed almost all cell surface markers, and transcription factors studied, including receptors for G-CSF, GM-CSF, and IL-7. When these stem cells were induced to transit cell cycle in vitro by exposure to interleukin-3 (IL-3), Il-6, IL-11, and steel factor some (CD34, CD45R c-kit, Gata-1, Gata-2, Ikaros, and Fog) showed stable expression over time, despite previously documented alterations in phenotype, while others showed variation of expression between and within experiments. These latter included Sca-1, Mac-1, c-fms, and c-mpl. Tal-1, endoglin, and CD4. These studies indicate that defined marrow stem cells express a wide variety of genes at isolation and with cytokine induced cell cycle transit show marked and reversible phenotype lability. Altogether, the phenotypic plasticity of gene expression for murine stem cells indicates a continuum model of stem cell regulation and extends the model to reversible expression with cell cycle transit of mRNA for cytokine receptors and stem cell markers.

Conversion potential of marrow cells into lung cells fluctuates with cytokine-induced cell cycle.

Green fluorescent protein (GFP)-labeled marrow cells transplanted into lethally irradiated mice can be detected in the lungs of transplanted mice and have been shown to express lung-specific proteins while lacking the expression of hematopoietic markers. We have studied marrow cells induced to transit the cell cycle by exposure to interleukin-3 (IL-3), IL-6, IL-11, and Steel factor at different times of culture corresponding to different phases of cell cycle. We have found that marrow cells at the G(1)/S interface of the cell cycle have a three-fold increase in cells that assume a nonhematopoietic or pulmonary epithelial cell phenotype and that this increase is no longer seen in late S/G(2). These cells have been characterized as GFP(+) CD45(-) and GFP(+) cytokeratin(+). Thus, marrow cells with the capacity to convert into cells with a lung phenotype after transplantation show a reversible increase with cytokine-induced cell cycle transit. Previous studies have shown that the phenotype of bone marrow stem cells fluctuates reversibly as these cells traverse the cell cycle, leading to a continuum model of stem cell regulation. The present study indicates that marrow stem cell production of nonhematopoietic cells also fluctuates on a continuum.

Alteration of marrow cell gene expression, protein production, and engraftment into lung by lung-derived microvesicles: a novel mechanism for phenotype modulation.

Numerous animal studies have demonstrated that adult marrow-derived cells can contribute to the cellular component of the lung. Lung injury is a major variable in this process; however, the mechanism remains unknown. We hypothesize that injured lung is capable of inducing epigenetic modifications of marrow cells, influencing them to assume phenotypic characteristics of lung cells. We report that under certain conditions, radiation-injured lung induced expression of pulmonary epithelial cell-specific genes and prosurfactant B protein in cocultured whole bone marrow cells separated by a cell-impermeable membrane. Lung-conditioned media had a similar effect on cocultured whole bone marrow cells and was found to contain pulmonary epithelial cell-specific RNA-filled microvesicles that entered whole bone marrow cells in culture. Also, whole bone marrow cells cocultured with lung had a greater propensity to produce type II pneumocytes after transplantation into irradiated mice. These findings demonstrate alterations of marrow cell phenotype by lung-derived microvesicles and suggest a novel mechanism for marrow cell-directed repair of injured tissue.

Stem cell continuum: directed differentiation hotspots.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the technique of stem cell-directed differentiation in the context of cell-cycle position. The hypothesis was that stem cells would have different sensitivities to an identical inductive signal through cell-cycle transit and that this would affect the outcome of its progeny. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Differentiation of murine marrow lineage(negative)rhodamine-123(low-)Hoechst-33342(low) (LRH) stem cells was determined at different points in cell cycle under stimulation by thrombopoietin, flt3 ligand, and steel factor. LRH stem cells were subcultured in granulocyte macrophage colony-stimulating factor, granulocyte colony-stimulating factor, and steel factor at different points in cell cycle and differentiation determined 14 days later. RESULTS: There was a significant, reproducible, and pronounced reversible increase in differentiation to megakaryocytes in early S-phase and to nonproliferative granulocytes in mid S-phase. Megakaryocyte hotspots also were seen on a clonal basis. Elevations of the transcription factor FOG-1 were seen at the hotspot along with increases in Nfe2 and Fli1. CONCLUSIONS: We show that the potential of marrow stem cells to differentiate changes reversibly with cytokine-induced cell-cycle transit, suggesting that stem cell regulation is not based on the classic hierarchical model, but instead on a functional continuum. We propose that there is a tight linkage of commitment to a lineage and a particular phase of cell cycle. Thus, windows of vulnerability for commitment can open and close depending on the phase of cell cycle. These data indicate that stem cell differentiation occurs on a cell-cycle-related continuum with fluctuating windows of transcriptional opportunity.

The stem cell continuum: cell cycle, injury, and phenotype lability.

The phenotype of the hematopoietic stem cell is intrinsically labile and impacted by cell cycle and the effects of tissue injury. In published studies we have shown that there are changes in short- and long-term engraftment, progenitor numbers, gene expression, and differentiation potential with cytokine-induced cell cycle transit. Critical points here are that these changes are reversible and not unidirectional weighing, heavily against a hierarchical model of stem cell regulation. Furthermore, a number of studies have now established that stem cells separated by lineage depletion and selection for Sca-1 or c-kit or low rhodamine and Hoechst staining are in fact a cycling population. Last, studies on Hoechst separated "cycling" stem cells indicates that the observed phenotype shifts relate to phase of cell cycle and are not due to in vitro exposure to cytokines. These data suggest a continuum model of stem cell regulation and further indicate that this model holds for in vivo situations. Observations that marrow cells can convert to various tissue cells under different injury conditions continue to be published despite a small, but influential, number of negative studies. Our studies and those of others indicate that conversions of marrow-derived cells to different tissue cells, such as skeletal muscle and lung, is critically dependent upon multiple variables, the most important of which is the presence of tissue injury. Variables which affect conversion of marrow cells to nonhematopoietic cells after in vivo transplantation include the nature and timing of the injury; marrow mobilization; the marrow cell type infused; the timing of cell infusion and the number of cells infused; the cell cycle state of the marrow cells, and other functional alterations in the marrow cells the treatment of the host mouse separate from specific injury; the mode of cell delivery; and possibly the presence of microvesicles from injured tissue. At least some of the highlighted negative reports on stem cell plasticity appear to be due to a failure to address these variables. Recently, we have observed that irradiated lung releases microvesicles which can enter marrow cells and lead to the marrow cells expressing lung-specific mRNA and protein. This could provide an underlying mechanism for many of the plasticity phenomena. Altogether, marrow appears to represent a highly flexible ever-changing cell system with the capacity to respond to products of injured cells and top repair a broad range of tissues.

Bone marrow production of lung cells: the impact of G-CSF, cardiotoxin, graded doses of irradiation, and subpopulation phenotype.

OBJECTIVE: Previous studies have demonstrated the production of various types of lung cells from marrow cells under diverse experimental conditions. Our aim was to identify some of the variables that influence conversion in the lung. METHODS: In separate experiments, mice received various doses of total-body irradiation followed by transplantation with whole bone marrow or various subpopulations of marrow cells (Lin(-/+), c-kit(-/+), Sca-1(-/+)) from GFP(+) (C57BL/6-TgN[ACTbEGFP]1Osb) mice. Some were given intramuscular cardiotoxin and/or mobilized with granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF). RESULTS: The production of pulmonary epithelial cells from engrafted bone marrow was established utilizing green fluorescent protein (GFP) antibody labeling to rule out autofluorescence and deconvolution microscopy to establish the colocaliztion of GFP and cytokeratin and the absence of CD45 in lung samples after transplantation. More donor-derived lung cells (GFP(+)/CD45(-)) were seen with increasing doses of radiation (5.43% of all lung cells, 1200 cGy). In the 900-cGy group, 61.43% of GFP(+)/CD45(-) cells were also cytokeratin(+). Mobilization further increased GFP(+)/CD45(-) cells to 7.88% in radiation-injured mice. Up to 1.67% of lung cells were GFP(+)/CD45(-) in radiation-injured mice transplanted with Lin(-), c-kit(+), or Sca-1(+) marrow cells. Lin(+), c-kit(-), and Sca-1(-) subpopulations did not significantly engraft the lung. CONCLUSIONS: We have established that marrow cells are capable of producing pulmonary epithelial cells and identified radiation dose and G-CSF mobilization as variables influencing the production of lung cells from marrow cells. Furthermore, the putative lung cell-producing marrow cell has the phenotype of a hematopoietic stem cell.

Stem cell biology and the plasticity polemic.

Characterization of a cord blood derived unrestricted somatic stem cell (USSC) with capacity to differentiate into hematopoietic and nonhematopoietic tissues in the absence of cell fusion has highlighted the great potential of stem cell plasticity. A great variety of stem cell types have been defined and even the most pure marrow stem cells are highly heterogeneous. Data suggest that stem cells may exist in a continuum with continually and reversibly changing phenotype. These cells also possess a capacity to produce lung, liver, skin, and skeletal muscle under conditions of tissue injury. Arguments raised against the significance of adult marrow to nonmarrow conversions including the importance of cell fusion appear fallacious. We are at the beginning of an exciting and burgeoning field of research with great clinical potential.

The stem cell continuum.

Hematopoietic stem cells have been felt to exist in a hierarchical structure with a relatively fixed phenotype at each stage of differentiation. Recent studies on the phenotype of the marrow hematopoietic stem cell indicate that it is not a fixed entity, but rather that it fluctuates and shows marked heterogeneity. Past studies have shown that stem cell engraftment characteristics, adhesion protein, and gene expression varies with the phase of the cell cycle. More recently, we demonstrated that progenitor numbers and differentiation potential also vary reversibly during one cytokine-induced cell cycle transit. We have also shown high levels of conversion of marrow cells to skeletal muscle and lung cells, indicating a different level of plasticity. Recently, we demonstrated that homing to lung and conversion to lung cells in a mouse transplant model also fluctuates reversibly with cell cycle transit. This could be considered plasticity squared. These data indicate that marrow stem cells are regulated on a continuum related to the cell cycle both as to hematopoietic and to nonhematopoietic differentiation.

Marrow cell genetic phenotype change induced by human lung cancer cells.

Microvesicles have been shown to mediate varieties of intercellular communication. Work in murine species has shown that lung-derived microvesicles can deliver mRNA, transcription factors, and microRNA to marrow cells and alter their phenotype. The present studies evaluated the capacity of excised human lung cancer cells to change the genetic phenotype of human marrow cells. We present the first studies on microvesicle production by excised cancers from human lung and the capacity of these microvesicles to alter the genetic phenotype of normal human marrow cells. We studied 12 cancers involving the lung and assessed nine lung-specific mRNA species (aquaporin, surfactant families, and clara cell-specific protein) in marrow cells exposed to tissue in co-culture, cultured in conditioned media, or exposed to isolated lung cancer-derived microvesicles. We assessed two or seven days of co-culture and marrow which was unseparated, separated by ficoll density gradient centrifugation or ammonium chloride lysis. Under these varying conditions, each cancer derived from lung mediated marrow expression of between one and seven lung-specific genes. Microvesicles were identified in the pellet of ultracentrifuged conditioned media and shown to enter marrow cells and induce lung-specific mRNA expression in marrow. A lung melanoma and a sarcoma also induced lung-specific mRNA in marrow cells. These data indicate that lung cancer cells may alter the genetic phenotype of normal cells and suggest that such perturbations might play a role in tumor progression, tumor recurrence, or metastases. They also suggest that the tissue environment may alter cancer cell gene expression.

Expression of cell cycle-related genes with cytokine-induced cell cycle progression of primitive hematopoietic stem cells.

Primitive marrow lineage-negative rhodamine low and Hoechst low (LRH) stem cells isolated on the basis of quiescence respond to the cytokines thrombopoietin, FLT3L, and steel factor by synchronously progressing through cell cycle. We have now profiled the mRNA expression, as determined by real-time RT-PCR, of 47 hematopoietic or cell cycle-related genes, focusing on the variations in the cell cycle regulators with cycle transit. LRH stem cells, at isolation, showed expression of all interrogated genes, but at relatively low levels. In our studies, there was a good deal of consistency with regard to cell cycle regulatory genes involved in the G1/S progression point of LRH murine stem cells. The observed pattern of expression of cyclin A2 is consistent with actions at these phases of cell cycle. Minimal elevations were seen at 16 h with higher elevations at 24, 32, 40, and 48 h times encompassing S, G2, and M phases. CDK2 expression pattern was also consistent with a role in G1/S transition with a modest elevation at 24 h and more substantial elevation at 32 h. The observed pattern of expression of cyclin F mRNA with marked elevations at 16-40 h was also consistent with actions in S and G2 phases. Cyclin D1 expression pattern was less consistent with its known role in G1 progression. The alterations in multiple other cell cycle regulators were consistent with previous information obtained in other cell systems. The cycle regulatory mechanics appears to be preserved across broad ranges of cell types.

Problems in the promised land: status of adult marrow stem cell biology.

Long-term engrafting marrow hematopoietic stem cells have been considered to be a quiescent stem cell in G(0). However, there are contradictory reports on this point in the literature, showing marked variability of results over time and between mice. Furthermore, there are circadian rhythms for stem cells and progenitors. In general, most studies have not taken stochastic variability or circadian rhythms into account. In addition, stem cell purification has represented the present gold standard in stem cell research. However, evidence exists that the stem cell separations leave behind most stem cells and are not random. Thus, purified stem cells may not be representative of the stem cells in the unseparated marrow cell population. The epitope-based purification of stem cells may have misled the stem cell field. Lastly, there are interesting published studies indicating that the irradiated marrow microenvironment might be toxic to marrow stem cells, limiting self-renewal capacity, and that quantitative engraftment occurs in nonablated mice. These considerations suggest that in carrying out stem cell studies, attention needs to be directed to the appropriate number of repeat experiments, to circadian rhythms, to possible purification skewing of results, and to the most appropriate transplant assay model.