A soft elastomer alternative to polypropylene for pelvic organ prolapse repair: a preliminary study.

INTRODUCTION AND HYPOTHESIS: We compared the impact of a mesh manufactured from the soft elastomer polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) to that of a widely used lightweight polypropylene (PP) mesh. To achieve a similar overall device stiffness between meshes, the PDMS mesh was made with more material and therefore was heavier and less porous. We hypothesized that the soft polymer PDMS mesh, despite having more material, would have a similar impact on the vagina as the PP mesh. METHODS: PDMS and PP meshes were implanted onto the vaginas of 20 rabbits via colpopexy. Ten rabbits served as sham. At 12 weeks, mesh-vagina complexes were explanted and assessed for contractile function, histomorphology, total collagen, and glycosaminoglycan content. Outcome measures were compared using one-way ANOVA and Kruskal-Wallis testing with appropriate post-hoc testing. RESULTS: Relative to sham, vaginal contractility was reduced following the implantation of PP (p = 0.035) but not the softer PDMS (p = 0.495). PP had an overall greater negative impact on total collagen and glycosaminoglycan content, decreasing by 53% (p < 0.001) and 54% (p < 0.001) compared to reductions of 35% (p = 0.004 and p < 0.001) with PDMS. However, there were no significant differences in the contractility, collagen fiber thickness, total collagen, and glycosaminoglycan content between the two meshes. CONCLUSIONS: Despite having a substantially higher weight, PDMS had a similar impact on the vagina compared to a low-weight PP mesh, implicating soft polymers as potential alternatives to PP. The notion that heavyweight meshes are associated with a worse host response is not applicable when comparing across materials.

Comparison of 2 single incision slings on the vagina in an ovine model.

BACKGROUND: Stress urinary incontinence carries a significant healthcare burden for women worldwide. Single incision slings are minimally invasive mesh devices designed to treat stress urinary incontinence. For prolapse repair, meshes with higher porosity and lower structural stiffness have been associated with improved outcomes. OBJECTIVE: In this study, we compared the higher stiffness, lower porosity Altis sling with the lower stiffness, higher porosity Solyx sling in an ovine model. We hypothesized that SIS-B would have a negative impact on the host response. STUDY DESIGN: A total of Altis and Solyx single incision slings were implanted suburethrally into sheep according to the manufacturer's instructions on minimal tension. The mesh-urethral-vaginal complex and adjacent ungrafted vagina (no mesh control) were harvested en bloc at 3 months. Masson's trichrome and picrosirius red staining of 6 µm thin sections was performed to measure interfiber distance and tissue integration. Smooth muscle contractility to a 120 mM KCl stimulus was performed in an organ bath to measure myofiber-driven contractions. Standard biochemical assays were used to quantify glycosaminoglycan, total collagen, and elastin content, and collagen subtypes. Bending stiffness was performed in response to a uniaxial force to define susceptibility to folding/buckling. Statistical analysis was performed using Mann-Whitney, Gabriel's pairwise post hoc, Wilcoxon matched-pairs, and chi-square tests. RESULTS: The animals had similar ages (3-5 years), parity (multiparous), and weights (45-72 kg). Trichrome cross sections showed that the Altis sling buckled in a "C" or "S" shape in most samples (8 of 11), whereas buckling after Solyx sling implantation was observed in only a single sample (1 of 13; P=.004). Tissue integration, as measured by the presence of collagen or smooth muscle between the mesh fibers on trichrome 4× imaging, was increased in samples implanted with the Solyx sling compared with the Altis sling (P<.05). Total collagen content decreased significantly with both products when compared with the ungrafted vagina consistent with stress shielding. There was no difference in the 2 groups with regard to glycosaminoglycan or elastin content. The Altis sling mesh tissue complex demonstrated significantly higher amounts of both collagen types I and III than the Solyx sling-implanted tissue and the ungrafted control. Smooth muscle contractility in response to 120 mM KCl was decreased after implantation of both slings compared with the sham (P=.011 and P<.01), with no difference between mesh types (P=.099). Bending stiffness in the Altis sling was more than 4 times lower than in the Solyx, indicating an increased propensity to buckle (0.0186 vs 0.0883). CONCLUSION: The structurally stiffer Altis sling had decreased tissue integration and increased propensity to buckle after implantation. Increased collagen types I and III after the implantation of this device suggests that these changes may be associated with a fibrotic response. In contrast, the Solyx sling largely maintained a flat configuration and had improved tissue integration. The deformation of the Altis sling is not an intended effect and is likely caused by its lower bending stiffness. Both meshes induced a decrease in collagen content and smooth muscle contractility similar to previous findings for prolapse meshes and consistent with stress shielding. The long-term impact of buckling warrants further investigation.

New Zealand white rabbit: a novel model for prolapse mesh implantation via a lumbar colpopexy.

INTRODUCTION AND HYPOTHESIS: New Zealand white rabbits are an inexpensive large-animal model. This study explored the rabbit as a model for mesh-augmented colpopexy using the intra-abdominal vagina. We hypothesized that polypropylene mesh would negatively impact rabbit vaginal smooth muscle (VSM) morphology and contractile function, similar to the nonhuman primate (NHP)-the established model for prolapse mesh evaluation. METHODS: Restorelle was implanted onto the vagina of ten rabbits via lumbar colpopexy after a hysterectomy. Ten rabbits served as sham. Twelve weeks post-implantation, the vagina was excised and VSM morphology and vaginal contractility were assessed. Outcome measures were compared using independent samples t and Mann-Whitney U tests with a Bonferroni correction, where appropriate. Results from the rabbits were compared with published NHP data. RESULTS: Animals had similar age, parity and BMI. VSM was 18% thinner after Restorelle implantation, P = 0.027. Vaginal contractility was 43% decreased in response to 120 mM KCl (P = 0.003), similar to the 46% reduction observed in the NHP vagina implanted with Restorelle (P = 0.027). Three meshes wrinkled in vivo, resulting in dramatic thinning of the underlying vagina in the area of the mesh causing a mesh exposure. CONCLUSIONS: Polypropylene mesh negatively impacts VSM morphology and vaginal contractility in the rabbit, similar to the NHP, suggesting that the rabbit may serve as an alternative large-animal model. The vaginal thinning and appearance of a mesh exposure in the area of a mesh wrinkle suggest the rabbit may also serve as a model for understanding the pathophysiology of mesh exposure.

Mesh deformation: A mechanism underlying polypropylene prolapse mesh complications in vivo.

Polypropylene meshes used in pelvic organ prolapse (POP) repair are hampered by complications. Most POP meshes are highly unstable after tensioning ex vivo, as evidenced by marked deformations (pore collapse and wrinkling) that result in altered structural properties and material burden. By intentionally introducing collapsed pores and wrinkles into a mesh that normally has open pores and remains relatively flat after implantation, we reproduce mesh complications in vivo. To do this, meshes were implanted onto the vagina of rhesus macaques in nondeformed (flat) vs deformed (pore collapse +/- wrinkles) configurations and placed on tension. Twelve weeks later, animals with deformed meshes had two complications, (1) mesh exposure through the vaginal epithelium, and (2) myofibroblast proliferation with fibrosis - a mechanism of pain. The overarching response to deformed mesh was vaginal thinning associated with accelerated apoptosis, reduced collagen content, increased proteolysis, deterioration of mechanical integrity, and loss of contractile function consistent with stress shielding - a precursor to mesh exposure. Regional differences were observed, however, with some areas demonstrating myofibroblast proliferation and matrix deposition. Variable mechanical cues imposed by deformed meshes likely induce these two disparate responses. Utilizing meshes associated with uniform stresses on the vagina by remaining flat with open pores after tensioning is critical to improving outcomes. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Pain and exposure are the two most reported complications associated with the use of polypropylene mesh in urogynecologic procedures. Most meshes have unstable geometries as evidenced by pore collapse and wrinkling after tensioning ex vivo, recapitulating what is observed in meshes excised from women with complications in vivo. We demonstrate that collapsed pores and wrinkling result in two distinct responses (1) mesh exposure associated with tissue degradation and atrophy and (2) myofibroblast proliferation and matrix deposition consistent with fibrosis, a tissue response associated with pain. In conclusion, mesh deformation leads to areas of tissue degradation and myofibroblast proliferation, the likely mechanisms of mesh exposure and pain, respectively. These data corroborate that mesh implantation in a flat configuration with open pores is a critical factor for reducing complications in mesh-augmented surgeries.

Mesh induced fibrosis: The protective role of T regulatory cells.

Polypropylene mesh is widely used in urogynecologic surgery, but complications rates (pain and exposure) approach 10%. Emerging evidence implicates the adaptive immune system in regulating the foreign body response to mesh, particularly regulatory T cells (Tregs), which modify macrophage differentiation and down-regulate CD8+ effector T cells. We hypothesize that Tregs protect against a profibrotic response, a likely mechanism of pain complications. Here, thin sections of mesh-tissue complexes removed for the primary complaint of pain (N = 14) or exposure (N = 15) were labeled for CD8, CD4 (Th), and FoxP3 (Tregs) via immunofluorescence. The same sections were analyzed for localized collagen deposition via a customized semi-quantitative assessment (0.25 mm2 grid) after trichrome staining. TGF-ß1 concentrations were determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Fewer Treg and CD4+ cells were found in fibrotic areas versus non-fibrotic areas (503 and 550/cm2 fewer, respectively, both P < 0.001). TGF-ß1 was higher in mesh samples compared to autologous control biopsies. TGF-ß 1 inversely correlated with age, r -0.636(p = 0.008). No differences were found in T cell subgroups or fibrotic indices between pain and exposure groups. A moderate inverse relationship was found between TGF-ß1 and Tregs (r -0.402, P = 0.009). Tregs were present up to 12 years after mesh implantation, challenging the assumption that the adaptive immune response to a foreign body is transient. In conclusion, the inverse relationship between fibrosis and Tregs, and TGF-ß1 and Tregs points to a protective role of these cells. Similar immunologic responses in patients with pain and exposure suggest these complications exist along a spectrum. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: The use of polypropylene mesh has been associated with improved outcomes in urogynecologic surgery, but is associated with significant complications, including pain and exposure through the vaginal epithelium. The host immune response features a prolonged inflammatory reaction containing innate immune cells and T lymphocytes clustered in capsules around the mesh fibers. This study uncovers the inverse relationship between T regulatory cells and the extent of fibrosis around the mesh, suggesting an anti-fibrotic effect. In addition, concentrations of T regulatory and T effector cells and levels of fibrosis connect these two most common complications into one mechanistic pathway. These new insights into the immune response to implanted mesh are an important step in understanding the causes of these surgical complications.