Sodium triple quantum MR signal extraction using a single-pulse sequence with single quantum time efficiency.

PURPOSE: Sodium triple quantum (TQ) signal has been shown to be a valuable biomarker for cell viability. Despite its clinical potential, application of Sodium TQ signal is hindered by complex pulse sequences with long scan times. This study proposes a method to approximate the TQ signal using a single excitation pulse without phase cycling. METHODS: The proposed method is based on a single excitation pulse and a comparison of the free induction decay (FID) with the integral of the FID combined with a shifting reconstruction window. The TQ signal is calculated from this FID only. As a proof of concept, the method was also combined with a multi-echo UTE imaging sequence on a 9.4 T preclinical MRI scanner for the possibility of fast TQ MRI. RESULTS: The extracted Sodium TQ signals of single-pulse and spin echo FIDs were in close agreement with theory and TQ measurement by traditional three-pulse sequence (TQ time proportional phase increment [TQTPPI)]. For 2%, 4%, and 6% agar samples, the absolute deviations of the maximum TQ signals between SE and theoretical (time proportional phase increment TQTPPI) TQ signals were less than 1.2% (2.4%), and relative deviations were less than 4.6% (6.8%). The impact of multi-compartment systems and noise on the accuracy of the TQ signal was small for simulated data. The systematic error was <3.4% for a single quantum (SQ) SNR of 5 and at maximum <2.5% for a multi-compartment system. The method also showed the potential of fast in vivo SQ and TQ imaging. CONCLUSION: Simultaneous SQ and TQ MRI using only a single-pulse sequence and SQ time efficiency has been demonstrated. This may leverage the full potential of the Sodium TQ signal in clinical applications.

Comparison of triple quantum (TQ) TPPI and inversion recovery TQ TPPI pulse sequences at 9.4 and 21.1 T.

PURPOSE: Both sodium T1 triple quantum (TQ) signal and T1 relaxation pathways have a unique sensitivity to the sodium molecular environment. In this study an inversion recovery time proportional phase increment (IRTQTPPI) pulse sequence was investigated for simultaneous and reliable quantification of sodium TQ signal and bi-exponential T1 relaxation times. METHODS: The IRTQTPPI sequence combines inversion recovery TQ filtering and time proportional phase increment. The reliable and reproducible results were achieved by the pulse sequence optimized in three ways: (1) optimization of the nonlinear fit for the determination of both T1-TQ signal and T1 relaxation times; (2) suppression of unwanted signals by assessment of four different phase cycles; (3) nonlinear sampling during evolution time for optimal scan time without any compromises in fit accuracy. The relaxation times T1 and T2 and the TQ signals from IRTQTPPI and TQTPPI were compared between 9.4 and 21.1 T. The motional environment of the sodium nuclei was evaluated by calculation of correlation times and nuclear quadrupole interaction strengths. RESULTS: Reliable measurements of the T1-TQ signals and T1 bi-exponential relaxation times were demonstrated. The fit parameters for all four phase cycles were in good agreement with one another, with a negligible influence of unwanted signals. The agar samples yielded normalized T1-TQ signals from 3% to 16% relative to single quantum (SQ) signals at magnetic fields of both 9.4 and 21.1 T. In comparison, the normalized T2-TQ signal was in the range 15%-35%. The TQ/SQ signal ratio was decreased at 21.1 T as compared with 9.4 T for both T1 and T2 relaxation pathways. The bi-exponential T1 relaxation time separation ranged from 15 to 18 ms at 9.4 T and 15 to 21 ms at 21.1 T. The T2 relaxation time separation was larger, ranging from 28 to 35 ms at 9.4 T and 37 to 40 ms at 21.1 T. CONCLUSION: The IRTQTPPI sequence, while providing a less intensive TQ signal than TQTPPI, allows a simultaneous and reliable quantification of both the T1-TQ signal and T1 relaxation times. The unique sensitivities of the T1 and T2 relaxation pathways to different types of molecular motion provide a deeper understanding of the sodium MR environment.

Protein conformational changes affect the sodium triple-quantum MR signal.

The aim of this study was to investigate possible sodium triple-quantum (TQ) signal dependence on pH variation and protein unfolding which may happen in vivo. The model system, composed of bovine serum albumin (BSA), was investigated over a wide pH range of 0.70 to 13.05 and during urea-induced unfolding. In both experimental series, the sodium and BSA concentration were kept constant so that TQ signal changes solely arose from an environmental change. The experiments were performed using unique potential to detect weak TQ signals by implementing a TQ time proportional phase increment pulse sequence. At a pH of 0.70, in which case the effect of the negatively charged groups was minimized, the minimum TQ percentage relative to single-quantum of 1.34% ± 0.05% was found. An increase of the pH up to 13.05 resulted in an increase of the sodium TQ signal by 225%. Urea-induced unfolding of BSA, without changes in pH, led to a smaller increase in the sodium TQ signal of up to 40%. The state of BSA unfolding was verified by fluorescence microscopy. Results of both experiments were well fitted by sigmoid functions. Both TQ signal increases were in agreement with an increase of the availability of negatively charged groups. The results point to vital contributions of the biochemical environment to the TQ MR signals. The sodium TQ signal in vivo could be a valuable biomarker of cell viability, and therefore possible effects of pH and protein unfolding need to be considered for a proper interpretation of changes in sodium TQ signals.

Sodium MRI of glioma in animal models at ultrahigh magnetic fields.

High magnetic fields expand our capability to use sodium MRI for biomedical applications. The central goal of this review is devoted to the unique features of sodium MRI in tumor animal models, mainly in glioma, performed at 9.4 and 21.1 T. The ability of sodium MRI to monitor tumor response to therapy was evaluated. It is noteworthy that sodium MRI can detect glioma response to chemotherapy earlier than diffusion MRI. Especially attractive is the ability of sodium MRI to predict tumor therapeutic resistance before therapy. The non-invasive prediction of tumor chemo-resistance by sodium MRI presents a potential to individualize strategies for cancer treatment. Specifics of sodium MRI and technical aspects of imaging are also presented.

(39) K and (23) Na relaxation times and MRI of rat head at 21.1 T.

At ultrahigh magnetic field strengths (B0 ≥ 7.0 T), potassium ((39) K) MRI might evolve into an interesting tool for biomedical research. However, (39) K MRI is still challenging because of the low NMR sensitivity and short relaxation times. In this work, we demonstrated the feasibility of (39) K MRI at 21.1 T, determined in vivo relaxation times of the rat head at 21.1 T, and compared (39) K and sodium ((23) Na) relaxation times of model solutions containing different agarose gel concentrations at 7.0 and 21.1 T. (39) K relaxation times were markedly shorter than those of (23) Na. Compared with the lower field strength, (39) K relaxation times were up to 1.9- (T1 ), 1.4- (T2S ) and 1.9-fold (T2L ) longer at 21.1 T. The increase in the (23) Na relaxation times was less pronounced (up to 1.2-fold). Mono-exponential fits of the (39) K longitudinal relaxation time at 21.1 T revealed T1 = 14.2 ± 0.1 ms for the healthy rat head. The (39) K transverse relaxation times were 1.8 ± 0.2 ms and 14.3 ± 0.3 ms for the short (T2S ) and long (T2L ) components, respectively. (23) Na relaxation times were markedly longer (T1 = 41.6 ± 0.4 ms; T2S = 4.9 ± 0.2 ms; T2L = 33.2 ± 0.2 ms). (39) K MRI of the healthy rat head could be performed with a nominal spatial resolution of 1 × 1 × 1 mm(3) within an acquisition time of 75 min. The increase in the relaxation times with magnetic field strength is beneficial for (23) Na and (39) K MRI at ultrahigh magnetic field strength. Our results demonstrate that (39) K MRI at 21.1 T enables acceptable image quality for preclinical research. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Toward 20 T magnetic resonance for human brain studies: opportunities for discovery and neuroscience rationale.

An initiative to design and build magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and spectroscopy (MRS) instruments at 14 T and beyond to 20 T has been underway since 2012. This initiative has been supported by 22 interested participants from the USA and Europe, of which 15 are authors of this review. Advances in high temperature superconductor materials, advances in cryocooling engineering, prospects for non-persistent mode stable magnets, and experiences gained from large-bore, high-field magnet engineering for the nuclear fusion endeavors support the feasibility of a human brain MRI and MRS system with 1 ppm homogeneity over at least a 16-cm diameter volume and a bore size of 68 cm. Twelve neuroscience opportunities are presented as well as an analysis of the biophysical and physiological effects to be investigated before exposing human subjects to the high fields of 14 T and beyond.

In vivo chlorine and sodium MRI of rat brain at 21.1 T.

OBJECT: MR imaging of low-gamma nuclei at the ultrahigh magnetic field of 21.1 T provides a new opportunity for understanding a variety of biological processes. Among these, chlorine and sodium are attracting attention for their involvement in brain function and cancer development. MATERIALS AND METHODS: MRI of (35)Cl and (23)Na were performed and relaxation times were measured in vivo in normal rat (n = 3) and in rat with glioma (n = 3) at 21.1 T. The concentrations of both nuclei were evaluated using the center-out back-projection method. RESULTS: T 1 relaxation curve of chlorine in normal rat head was fitted by bi-exponential function (T 1a = 4.8 ms (0.7) T 1b = 24.4 ± 7 ms (0.3) and compared with sodium (T 1 = 41.4 ms). Free induction decays (FID) of chlorine and sodium in vivo were bi-exponential with similar rapidly decaying components of [Formula: see text] ms and [Formula: see text] ms, respectively. Effects of small acquisition matrix and bi-exponential FIDs were assessed for quantification of chlorine (33.2 mM) and sodium (44.4 mM) in rat brain. CONCLUSION: The study modeled a dramatic effect of the bi-exponential decay on MRI results. The revealed increased chlorine concentration in glioma (~1.5 times) relative to a normal brain correlates with the hypothesis asserting the importance of chlorine for tumor progression.

In vivo magnetic resonance imaging of sodium and diffusion in rat glioma at 21.1 T.

Sodium and diffusion magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in intracranial rat 9L gliomas were evaluated over 6-8 days using the advanced sensitivity of sodium MRI at 21.1 T. Glioma doubling time was 2.4-2.6 days. Glioma sodium signal was detected using the ultra-short echo time of 0.15 ms. The high resolution 3D sodium MRI with pixels of 0.125 µL allowed for minimizing a partial volume effect often relevant to the MRI of low intensity signals. Tumor sodium and diffusion MRI were evaluated for two separate subclones of 9L cells with different resistance to 1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosurea detected by pre-surgery assays. In vivo, after implantation, resistant 9L cells created tumors with significantly reduced sodium concentrations (57 ± 3 mM) compared with nonresistant 9L cells (78 ± 3 mM). The corresponding differences in diffusion were less, but also statistically significant. During tumor progression, an increase of glioma sodium concentration was observed in both cell types with a rate of 2.4-5.8 %/day relative to normal brain. Tumor diffusion was not significantly changed at this time, indicative of no alterations in glioma cellularity. Thus, changes in sodium during tumor progression reflect increasing intracellular sodium concentration and mounting metabolic stress. These experiments also demonstrate an enhanced sensitivity of sodium MRI to reflect tumor cell resistance.

Sodium MRI in a rat migraine model and a NEURON simulation study support a role for sodium in migraine.

INTRODUCTION: Increased lumbar cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) sodium has been reported during migraine. We used ultra-high field MRI to investigate cranial sodium in a rat migraine model, and simulated the effects of extracellular sodium on neuronal excitability. METHODS: Behavioral changes in the nitroglycerin (NTG) rat migraine model were determined from von Frey hair withdrawal response and photography. Central sensitization was measured by counting cFos-immunoreactive cells in the trigeminal nucleus caudalis (TNC). Sodium was quantified in vivo by ultra-high field sodium MRI at 21 Tesla. Effects of extracellular sodium on neuronal excitability were modeled using NEURON software. RESULTS: NTG decreased von Frey withdrawal threshold (p=0.0003), decreased eyelid vertical height:width ratio (p<0.0001), increased TNC cFos stain (p<0.0001), and increased sodium between 7.5 and 17% in brain, intracranial CSF, and vitreous humor (p<0.05). Simulated neurons exposed to higher sodium have more frequent and earlier spontaneous action potentials, and corresponding earlier sodium and potassium currents. CONCLUSIONS: In the rat migraine model, sodium rises to levels that increase neuronal excitability. We propose that rising sodium in CSF surrounding trigeminal nociceptors increases their excitability and causes pain and that rising sodium in vitreous humor increases retinal neuronal excitability and causes photosensitivity.

Statistical tensor analysis of the MQ MR signals generated by weak quadrupole interactions.

Multiple quantum NMR signals that appear in the presence of weak quadrupole interactions were formulated using statistical tensors (Fano, 1957). The approach aimed to present a concise and a computer-based tool for a detailed analysis and modification of the MQ pulse sequences. The calculation avoids a lengthy procedure of utilizing exponential operators and, moreover, the same formulae are applicable for any interval in the TQ pulse sequence, as well as any spin value. The quantum operator algebra was implemented using "Mathematica" software (Wolfram Inc.). The results of tensor's evolutions in the TQ pulse sequence were graphically illustrated using corresponding spherical harmonics. The visualization takes into consideration the parity properties of irreducible tensors and the corresponding spherical harmonics.

Use of MRI, metabolomic, and genomic biomarkers to identify mechanisms of chemoresistance in glioma.

Gliomas are the most common form of central nervous system tumor. The most prevalent form, glioblastoma multiforme, is also the most deadly with mean survival times that are less than 15 months. Therapies are severely limited by the ability of these tumors to develop resistance to both radiation and chemotherapy. Thus, new tools are needed to identify and monitor chemoresistance before and after the initiation of therapy and to maximize the initial treatment plan by identifying patterns of chemoresistance prior to the start of therapy. Here we show how magnetic resonance imaging, particularly sodium imaging, metabolomics, and genomics have all emerged as potential approaches toward the identification of biomarkers of chemoresistance. This work also illustrates how use of these tools together represents a particularly promising approach to understanding mechanisms of chemoresistance and the development individualized treatment strategies for patients.

Variability and uncertainty in the rodent controlled cortical impact model of traumatic brain injury.

BACKGROUND: Controlled cortical impact (CCI) has emerged as one of the most flexible and clinically applicable approaches for the induction of traumatic brain injury (TBI) in rodents and other species. Although this approach has been shown to model cognitive and functional outcomes associated with TBI in humans, recent work has shown that CCI is limited by excessive variability in lesion size despite attempts to control velocity, impact depth, and dwell time. NEW METHOD: Thus, this work used high-speed imaging to evaluate the delivery of cortical impact and permit the identification of specific parameters associated with technical variability in the CCI model. RESULTS: Variability is introduced by vertical oscillations that result in multiple impacts of varying depths, lateral movements after impact, and changes in velocity, particularly at the prescribed impact depth. CONCLUSIONS: Together these data can inform future work to design modifications to commonly used CCI devices that produce TBI with less variability in severity and lesion size.

Comparison of potassium and sodium binding in vivo and in agarose samples using TQTPPI pulse sequence.

Potassium and sodium specific binding in vivo were explored at 21.1T by triple quantum (TQ) magnetic resonance (MR) signals without filtration to achieve high sensitivities and precise quantifications. The pulse sequence used time proportional phase increments (TPPI). During simultaneous phase-time increments, it provided total single quantum (SQ) and TQ MR signals in the second dimension at single and triple quantum frequencies, respectively. The detection of both TQ and SQ signals was performed at identical experimental conditions and the resulting TQ signal equals 60±3% of the SQ signal when all ions experience sufficient time for binding. In a rat head in vivo the TQ percentage relative to SQ for potassium is 41.5±3% and for sodium is 16.1±1%. These percentages were compared to the matching values in an agarose tissue model with MR relaxation times similar to those of mammalian brain tissue. The sodium TQ signal in agarose samples decreased in the presence of potassium, suggesting a competitive binding of potassium relative to sodium ions for the same binding sites. The TQTPPI signals correspond to almost two times more effective binding of potassium than sodium. In vivo, up to ∼69% of total potassium and ∼27% of total sodium can be regarded as bound or experiencing an association time in the range of several milliseconds. Experimental data analyses show that more than half of the in vivo total sodium TQ signal could be from extracellular space, which is an important factor for quantification of intracellular MR signals.

Tracking protein function with sodium multi quantum spectroscopy in a 3D-tissue culture based on microcavity arrays.

The aim of this study was to observe the effects of strophanthin induced inhibition of the Na-/K-ATPase in liver cells using a magnetic resonance (MR) compatible bioreactor. A microcavity array with a high density three-dimensional cell culture served as a functional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) phantom for sodium multi quantum (MQ) spectroscopy. Direct contrast enhanced (DCE) MRI revealed the homogenous distribution of biochemical substances inside the bioreactor. NMR experiments using advanced bioreactors have advantages with respect to having full control over a variety of physiological parameters such as temperature, gas composition and fluid flow. Simultaneous detection of single quantum (SQ) and triple quantum (TQ) MR signals improves accuracy and was achieved by application of a pulse sequence with a time proportional phase increment (TQTPPI). The time course of the Na-/K-ATPase inhibition in the cell culture was demonstrated by the corresponding alterations of sodium TQ/SQ MR signals.

Sodium and proton diffusion MRI as biomarkers for early therapeutic response in subcutaneous tumors.

The ability to quantitate early effects of tumor therapeutic response using noninvasive imaging would have a major impact in clinical oncology. One area of active research interest is the ability to use MR techniques to detect subtle changes in tumor cellular density. In this study, sodium and proton diffusion MRI were compared for their ability to detect early cellular changes in tumors treated with a cytotoxic chemotherapy. Subcutaneous 9L gliosarcomas were treated with a single dose of 1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea. Both sodium and diffusion imaging modalities were able to detect changes in tumor cellularity as early as 2 days after treatment, which continued to evolve as increased signal intensities reached a maximum approximately 8 days posttreatment. Early changes in tumor sodium and apparent diffusion coefficient values were predictive of subsequent tumor shrinkage, which occurred approximately 10 days later. Overall, therapeutical induced changes in sodium and diffusion values were found to have similar dynamic and spatial changes. These findings suggest that these imaging modalities detected similar early cellular changes after treatment. The results of this study support the continued clinical testing of diffusion MRI for evaluation of early tumor treatment response and demonstrate the complementary insights of sodium MRI for oncology applications.

Sodium 3D COncentration MApping (COMA 3D) using (23)Na and proton MRI.

Functional changes of sodium 3D MRI signals were converted into millimolar concentration changes using an open-source fully automated MATLAB toolbox. These concentration changes are visualized via 3D sodium concentration maps, and they are overlaid over conventional 3D proton images to provide high-resolution co-registration for easy correlation of functional changes to anatomical regions. Nearly 5000/h concentration maps were generated on a personal computer (ca. 2012) using 21.1T 3D sodium MRI brain images of live rats with spatial resolution of 0.8×0.8×0.8 mm(3) and imaging matrices of 60×60×60. The produced concentration maps allowed for non-invasive quantitative measurement of in vivo sodium concentration in the normal rat brain as a functional response to migraine-like conditions. The presented work can also be applied to sodium-associated changes in migraine, cancer, and other metabolic abnormalities that can be sensed by molecular imaging. The MATLAB toolbox allows for automated image analysis of the 3D images acquired on the Bruker platform and can be extended to other imaging platforms. The resulting images are presented in a form of series of 2D slices in all three dimensions in native MATLAB and PDF formats. The following is provided: (a) MATLAB source code for image processing, (b) the detailed processing procedures, (c) description of the code and all sub-routines, (d) example data sets of initial and processed data. The toolbox can be downloaded at: http://www.vuiis.vanderbilt.edu/~truongm/COMA3D/.

Initial in vivo rodent sodium and proton MR imaging at 21.1 T.

The first in vivo sodium and proton magnetic resonance (MR) images and localized spectra of rodents were attained using the wide bore (105 mm) high resolution 21.1-T magnet, built and operated at the National High Magnetic Field Laboratory (Tallahassee, FL, USA). Head images of normal mice (C57BL/6J) and Fisher rats (approximately 250 g) were acquired with custom designed radiofrequency probes at frequencies of 237/900 MHz for sodium and proton, respectively. Sodium MR imaging resolutions of approximately 0.125 microl for mouse and rat heads were achieved by using a 3D back-projection pulse sequence. A gain in SNR of approximately 3 for sodium and approximately 2 times for proton were found relative to corresponding MR images acquired at 9.4 T. 3D Fast Low Angle Shot (FLASH) proton mouse images (50x50x50 microm(3)) were acquired in 90 min and corresponding rat images (100x100x100 microm(3)) within a total time of 120 min. Both in vivo large rodent MR imaging and localized spectroscopy at the extremely high field of 21.1 T are feasible and demonstrate improved resolution and sensitivity valuable for structural and functional brain analysis.

Proton and sodium MRI assessment of emerging tumor chemotherapeutic resistance.

The ultimate goal of any cancer therapy is to target the elimination of neoplastic cells. Although newer therapeutic strategies are in constant development, therapeutic assessment has been hampered by the inability to assess, rapidly and quantitatively, efficacy in vivo. Diffusion imaging and, more recently, sodium MRI have demonstrated their distinct abilities to detect therapy-induced alterations in tumor cellularity, which has been demonstrated to be indicative of therapeutic efficacy. More importantly, both imaging modalities detect tumor response much earlier than traditional methodologies that rely on macroscopic volumetric changes. In this study, the correlation between tumor sodium and diffusion was further tested to demonstrate the sensitivity of sodium imaging to gauge tumor response to therapy by using a 9L rat gliosarcoma treated with varying doses of BCNU [1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea]. This orthotopic model has been demonstrated to display variability in response to BCNU therapy where initial insult has been shown to lead to drug-resistance. In brief, a single 26.6 mg/kg BCNU dose yielded dramatic responses in both diffusion and sodium MRI. However, a second equivalent BCNU dose yielded a much smaller change in diffusion and sodium, suggesting a drop in tumor sensitivity to BCNU. The MRI responses of animals treated with 13.3 mg/kg BCNU were much lower and similar responses were observed after the initial and secondary applications of BCNU. Furthermore, these results were further validated using volumetric measurements of the tumor and also ex vivo determination of tumor sensitivity to BCNU. Overall, these experiments demonstrate the sensitivity and applicability of sodium and diffusion MRI as tools for dynamic assessment of tumor response to therapy.

Sodium magnetic resonance imaging of chemotherapeutic response in a rat glioma.

This study investigates the comparative changes in the sodium MRI signal and proton diffusion following treatment using a 9L rat glioma model to develop markers of earliest response to cancer therapy. Sodium MRI and proton diffusion mapping were performed on untreated (n = 5) and chemotherapy 1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea-treated rats (n = 5). Animals were scanned serially at 2- to 3-day intervals for up to 30 days following therapy. The time course of Na concentration in a tumor showed a dramatic increase in the treated brain tumor compared to the untreated tumor, which correlates in time with an increase in tumor water diffusion. The largest posttreatment increase in sodium signal occurred 7-9 days following treatment and correlated to the period of the greatest chemotherapy-induced cellular necrosis based on diffusion and histopathology. Both Na MRI and proton ADC mapping revealed early changes in tumor sodium content and cellularity. This study demonstrates the possibility of Na MRI to function as a biomarker for monitoring early tumor treatment and validates the use of monitoring changes in diffusion MRI values for assessing tumor cellularity.

A conjugate of a tumor-targeting ligand and a T cell costimulatory antibody to treat brain tumors.

T cell immunotherapy is a potential strategy for the treatment of brain tumors because it offers a high degree of specificity, the ability to extravasate into solid tumors, and the potential for eliciting a long-term protective immune response. Various approaches have been developed to overcome T cell immune tolerance to cancer, including the use of cytokines and bispecific antibodies. T cell stimulation with the proinflammatory cytokine IL-12 can elicit antitumor immunity. T cell activation can be increased using bispecific antibodies against activating molecules on the surface of T cells and a tumor antigen. We studied the effects of systemic IL-12 administration in combination with a conjugate of an anti-CD28 antibody and a ligand for the folate receptor. The high affinity folate receptor is expressed on endogenously arising choroid plexus tumors of SV11 mice, which are transgenic for large T antigen under the control of the SV40 promoter. SV11 mice are immunocompetent, yet immunologically tolerant to large T antigen expressed by choroid plexus tumors. MRI analysis showed that the administration of IL-12 and anti-CD28 Fab/folate significantly slowed tumor growth. Proliferating CD8(+) T cells were found in choroid plexus tumors of treated animals. Treatment of animals with IL-12 + anti-CD28 Fab/folate prolonged survival compared to IL-12 alone. Cytokine treatment combined with tumor-targeted costimulation may be a useful adjunct treatment.