Author Correction: Self-assembled poly-catenanes from supramolecular toroidal building blocks.

An amendment to this paper has been published and can be accessed via a link at the top of the paper.

Self-assembled poly-catenanes from supramolecular toroidal building blocks.

Mechanical interlocking of molecules (catenation) is a nontrivial challenge in modern synthetic chemistry and materials science1,2. One strategy to achieve catenation is the design of pre-annular molecules that are capable of both efficient cyclization and of pre-organizing another precursor to engage in subsequent interlocking3-9. This task is particularly difficult when the annular target is composed of a large ensemble of molecules, that is, when it is a supramolecular assembly. However, the construction of such unprecedented assemblies would enable the visualization of nontrivial nanotopologies through microscopy techniques, which would not only satisfy academic curiosity but also pave the way to the development of materials with nanotopology-derived properties. Here we report the synthesis of such a nanotopology using fibrous supramolecular assemblies with intrinsic curvature. Using a solvent-mixing strategy, we kinetically organized a molecule that can elongate into toroids with a radius of about 13 nanometres. Atomic force microscopy on the resulting nanoscale toroids revealed a high percentage of catenation, which is sufficient to yield 'nanolympiadane'10, a nanoscale catenane composed of five interlocked toroids. Spectroscopic and theoretical studies suggested that this unusually high degree of catenation stems from the secondary nucleation of the precursor molecules around the toroids. By modifying the self-assembly protocol to promote ring closure and secondary nucleation, a maximum catenation number of 22 was confirmed by atomic force microscopy.

Photoresponsive Supramolecular Polymers Capable of Intrachain Folding and Interchain Aggregation.

The competition between polymer chain folding and aggregation is a critical structuring process that determines the physical properties of synthetic and biopolymers. However, supramolecular polymer systems that exhibit both processes have not yet been reported. We herein introduce a system in which folded supramolecular polymers spontaneously undergo interchain aggregation due to a rearrangement in internal molecular order, converting them into crystalline aggregates. These folded supramolecular polymers slowly crystallize over the course of half a day, due to their characteristic higher-order structures. However, the photoisomerization of the trans-azobenzene incorporated into the monomer to the cis isomer leads to unfolding of the polymer, accelerating the intrachain and interchain molecular ordering to a few hours. The intermediate structures visualized by AFM demonstrate that the unfolding is coupled with interchain aggregation.

Impact of Ring-Closing on the Photophysical Properties of One-Dimensional π-Conjugated Molecular Aggregate.

The self-assembled state of molecules plays a pivotal role in determining how inherent molecular properties transform and give rise to supramolecular functionalities and has long attracted attention. However, understanding the influence of morphologies spanning the nano- to mesoscopic scales of supramolecular assemblies derived from identical intermolecular interactions has been notoriously challenging due to dynamic structural change and monomer exchange of assemblies in solution. In this study, we demonstrate that curved one-dimensional molecular assemblies (supramolecular polymers) of lengths of around 70-200 nm, originating from the same luminescent molecule, exhibit distinct photoluminescent properties when they form closed circular structures (toroids) versus when they possess chain termini in solution (random coils). By exploiting the difference in kinetic stability between the toroids and random coils, we developed a dialysis protocol to selectively purify the former. It was revealed that these terminus-free closed structures manifest higher energy and more efficient luminescence compared with their mixed state with random coils. Time-resolved fluorescence measurements unveiled that random coils, due to their dynamic structural fluctuation in solution, generate local defects throughout the main chain, leading to luminescence from lower energy levels. In mixtures of the two assemblies, luminescence was exclusively observed from such a lower energy level of random coils, a result attributed to energy transfer between the assemblies. This work emphasizes that for identical supramolecular assemblies, only averaged properties have traditionally been considered, but their structures at the nano- to mesoscopic scale are important especially if they have a certain degree of shape persistency even in solution.

Amplification of Molecular Asymmetry during the Hierarchical Self-Assembly of Foldable Azobenzene Dyads into Nanotoroids and Nanotubes.

The amplification of molecular asymmetry through self-assembly is a phenomenon that not only comprehends the origin of homochirality in nature but also produces chiroptically active functional materials from molecules with minimal enantiomeric purity. Understanding how molecular asymmetry can be transferred and amplified into higher-order structures in a hierarchical self-assembly system is important but still unexplored. Herein, we present an intriguing example of the amplification of molecular asymmetry in hierarchically self-assembled nanotubes that feature discrete and isolatable toroidal intermediates. The hierarchical self-assembly is initiated via asymmetric intramolecular folding of scissor-shaped azobenzene dyads furnished with chiral side chains. When scalemic mixtures of the enantiomers are dissolved in a non-polar solvent and cooled to 20 °C, single-handed nanotoroids are formed, as confirmed using atomic force microscopy and circular dichroism analyses. A strong majority-rules effect at the nanotoroid level is observed and can be explained by a low mismatch penalty and a high helix-reversal penalty. The single-handed nanotoroids stack upon cooling to 0 °C to exclusively afford their respective single-handed nanotubes. Thus, the same degree of amplification of molecular asymmetry is realized at the nanotube level. The internal packing efficiency of molecules within nanotubes prepared from the pure enantiomers or their scalemic mixtures is likely different, as suggested by the absence of higher-order structure (supercoil) formation in the latter. X-ray diffraction analysis of the anisotropically oriented nanotube films revealed looser molecular packing within the scalemic nanotubes, which clearly reflects the lower enantiomeric purity of their internal chiral side chains.

Supramolecular Polymer Polymorphism: Spontaneous Helix-Helicoid Transition through Dislocation of Hydrogen-Bonded π-Rosettes.

Polymorphism, a phenomenon whereby disparate self-assembled products can be formed from identical molecules, has incited interest in the field of supramolecular polymers. Conventionally, the monomers that constitute supramolecular polymers are engineered to facilitate one-dimensional aggregation and, consequently, their polymorphism surfaces primarily when the states of assembly differ significantly. This engenders polymorphs of divergent dimensionalities such as one- and two-dimensional aggregates. Notwithstanding, realizing supramolecular polymer polymorphism, wherein polymorphs maintain one-dimensional aggregation, persists as a daunting challenge. In this work, we expound upon the manifestation of two supramolecular polymer polymorphs formed from a large discotic supramolecular monomer (rosette), which consists of six hydrogen-bonded molecules with an extended π-conjugated core. These polymorphs are generated in mixtures of chloroform and methylcyclohexane, attributable to distinctly different disc stacking arrangements. The face-to-face (minimal displacement) and offset (large displacement) stacking arrangements can be predicated on their distinctive photophysical properties. The face-to-face stacking results in a twisted helix structure. Conversely, the offset stacking induces inherent curvature in the supramolecular fiber, thereby culminating in a hollow helical coil (helicoid). While both polymorphs exhibit bistability in nonpolar solvent compositions, the face-to-face stacking attains stability purely in a kinetic sense within a polar solvent composition and undergoes conversion into offset stacking through a dislocation of stacked rosettes. This occurs without the dissociation and nucleation of monomers, leading to unprecedented helicoidal folding of supramolecular polymers. Our findings augment our understanding of supramolecular polymer polymorphism, but they also highlight a distinctive method for achieving helicoidal folding in supramolecular polymers.

A Coformer Approach for Supramolecular Polymerization at High Concentrations.

Insolubility of functional molecules caused by polymorphism sometimes poses limitations for their solution-based processing. Such a situation can also occur in the preparation processes of supramolecular polymers formed in a solution. An effective strategy to address this issue is to prepare amorphous solid states by introducing a "coformer" molecule capable of inhibiting the formation of an insoluble polymorph through co-aggregation. Herein, inspired by the coformer approach, we demonstrated a solubility enhancement of a barbiturate π-conjugated compound that can supramolecularly polymerize through six-membered hydrogen-bonded rosettes. Our newly synthesized supramolecular coformer molecule features a sterically demanding methyl group in the π-conjugated unit of the parent molecule. Although the parent molecule exhibits low solubility in nonpolar solvents due to the formation of a crystalline polymorph comprising a tape-like hydrogen-bonded array prior to the supramolecular polymerization, mixing with the coformer compound enhanced the solubility by inhibiting mesoscopic organization of the tapes. The two monomers were then co-polymerized into desired helicoidal supramolecular polymers through the formation of heteromeric rosettes.

Harmonizing Topological Features of Self-Assembled Fibers by Rosette-Mediated Random Supramolecular Copolymerization and Self-Sorting of Monomers by Photo-Cross-Linking.

Random copolymerization is an effective approach to synthesize the desired polymers by harmonizing distinct properties of different monomers. For supramolecular polymers in which monomer binding is inherently dynamic, it is difficult to achieve random copolymerization of monomers with distinct molecular structures and properties due to an enthalpic advantage upon self-recognition (self-sorting). Herein, we demonstrate an example of thermodynamically controlled random supramolecular copolymerization of two monomers functionalized with barbituric acid via the formation of six-membered hydrogen-bonded rosette intermediates to exhibit structural harmonization of the two main-chain motifs, i.e., intrinsically curved and linear motifs. One monomer based on naphthalene chromophore exclusively forms toroidal fibers, whereas another one bearing additional photoreactive diacetylene moiety affords linearly elongated fibers. Supramolecular copolymerization of the two monomers is achieved by cooling hot monomer mixtures in a nonpolar solvent, which results in the formation of thermodynamically stable spirally folded yet elongated fibers. Atomic force microscopic observations and theoretical simulations of the experimental data obtained by absorption spectroscopy reveal the homopolymerization of the diacetylene-functionalized monomer in the high-temperature region, followed by the incorporation of the naphthalene monomer in the medium-temperature region to form supramolecular copolymers with random monomer sequence. Finally, we demonstrate that the random copolymerization process can be switched to a narcissistically self-sorting one by deactivating monomer exchange through the photo-cross-linking of the diacetylene-functionalized monomers.

Scissor-Shaped Photochromic Dyads: Hierarchical Self-Assembly and Photoresponsive Property.

Unique relationships between hierarchically organized biological nanostructures and functions have motivated chemists to construct sophisticated artificial nanostructured systems from small and simple synthetic molecules through self-assembly. As one of such sophisticated systems, we have investigated scissor-shaped photochromic dyads that can hierarchically self-assemble into discrete nanostructures showing photoresponsive properties. We synthesized various azobenzene dyads and found that these dyads adopt intramolecularly folded conformation like a closed scissor, and then self-assemble into toroidal nanostructures by generating curvature. The toroids further organize into nanotubes and further into helical supramolecular fibers depending on the nature of alkyl substituents. All of these nanostructures can be dissociated and reorganized through the photoisomerization of azobenzene units. On the other hand, the introduction of stilbene chromophores instead of azobenzenes leads to one-dimensional supramolecular polymerization, which upon the intramolecular photocyclization of stilbene chromophores shifts to curved self-assembly leading to helicoidal fibers with distinct supramolecular chirality.

Biasing the Hierarchy Motifs of Nanotoroids: from 1D Nanotubes to 2D Porous Networks.

Hierarchical organization of self-assembled structures into superstructures is omnipresent in Nature but has been rarely achieved in synthetic molecular assembly due to the absence of clear structural rules. We herein report on the self-assembly of scissor-shaped azobenzene dyads which form discrete nanotoroids that further organize into 2D porous networks. The steric demand of the peripheral aliphatic units diminishes the trend of the azobenzene dyad to constitute stackable nanotoroids in solution, thus affording isolated (unstackable) nanotoroids upon cooling. Upon drying, these nanotoroids organize at graphite surface to form well-defined 2D porous networks. The photoirradiation with UV and visible light enabled reversible dissociation and reconstruction of nanotoroids through the efficient trans↔cis isomerization of azobenzene moieties in solution.

Diarylethene-Powered Light-Induced Folding of Supramolecular Polymers.

Helical folding of randomly coiled linear polymers is an essential organization process not only for biological polypeptides but also for synthetic functional polymers. Realization of this dynamic process in supramolecular polymers (SPs) is, however, a formidable challenge because of their inherent lability of main chains upon changing an external environment that can drive the folding process (e.g., solvent, concentration, and temperature). We herein report a photoinduced reversible folding/unfolding of rosette-based SPs driven by photoisomerization of a diarylethene (DAE). Temperature-controlled supramolecular polymerization of a barbiturate-functionalized DAE (open isomer) in nonpolar solvent results in the formation of intrinsically curved, but randomly coiled, SPs due to the presence of defects. Irradiation of the randomly coiled SPs with UV light causes efficient ring-closure reaction of the DAE moieties, which induces helical folding of the randomly coiled structures into helicoidal ones, as evidenced by atomic force microscopy and small-angle X-ray scattering. The helical folding is driven by internal structure ordering of the SP fiber that repairs the defects and interloop interaction occurring only for the resulting helicoidal structure. In contrast, direct supramolecular polymerization of the ring-closed DAE monomers by temperature control affords linearly extended ribbon-like SPs lacking intrinsic curvature that are thermodynamically less stable compared to the helicoidal SPs. The finding represents an important concept applicable to other SP systems; that is, postpolymerization (photo)reaction of preorganized kinetic structures can lead to more thermodynamically stable structures that are inaccessible directly through temperature-controlled protocols.

Non-uniform Photoinduced Unfolding of Supramolecular Polymers Leading to Topological Block Nanofibers.

Synthesis of one-dimensional nanofibers with distinct topological (higher-order structural) domains in the same main chain is one of the challenging topics in modern supramolecular polymer chemistry. Non-uniform structural transformation of supramolecular polymer chains by external stimuli may enable preparation of such nanofibers. To demonstrate feasibility of this post-polymerization strategy, we prepared a photoresponsive helically folded supramolecular polymers from a barbiturate monomer containing an azobenzene-embedded rigid π-conjugated scaffold. In contrast to previous helically folded supramolecular polymers composed of a more flexible azobenzene monomer, UV-light induced unfolding of the newly prepared helically folded supramolecular polymers occurred nonuniformly, affording topological block copolymers consisting of folded and unfolded domains. The formation of such blocky copolymers indicates that the photoinduced unfolding of the helically folded structures initiates from relatively flexible parts such as termini or defects. Spontaneous refolding of the unfolded domains was observed after visible-light irradiation followed by aging to restore fully folded structures.

Supramolecular Polymers Capable of Controlling Their Topology.

One important class of supramolecular materials is one-dimensionally elongated supramolecular polymers, in which monomers are associated by reversible intermolecular interactions, yielding a fibrous morphology. Unlike frequently reported conventional supramolecular polymers based on, for instance, host-guest interactions, those composed of one-dimensionally stacked π-conjugated molecules can be encoded with high degrees of internal order by cooperative association of the rigid aromatic monomers, endowing such supramolecular polymers with extraordinary properties and functionality. However, their internal order has not yet been exploited to manipulate the complex landscape of well-defined states of the supramolecular polymer backbone, which may induce new functionalities beyond the intrinsic properties of the backbones. This Account will focus on the inceptive phase of our research on supramolecular polymers with high degrees of internal order able to impart intrinsic curvature to their backbones. Initially, we developed a naphthalene molecule functionalized with barbituric acid, which forms uniform toroidal short fibers with diameters of approximately 16 nm via the formation of hydrogen-bonded cyclic hexamers (rosettes). As we thought the uniformity of the toroid size to arise from the intrinsic curvature generated upon stacking of the rosettes, we exploited this intrinsic curvature to design continuously curved extended supramolecular polymers by extension of such molecular π-systems. The intrinsic curvature produced by the monomers with more expanded π-systems indeed gave us access to higher-order structures (topologies) ranging from randomly folded to helically folded coils in extended supramolecular polymers. We will discuss the kinetic aspects of the generation of intrinsic curvature for topology control, including the formation of toroidal structures resulting from ring-closing processes. For extended supramolecular polymers with well-defined topologies, we will discuss manipulation of a complex landscape of well-defined states by external stimuli. The incorporation of a photoresponsive azobenzene chromophore in the original naphthalene molecular scaffold allowed us to reversibly destroy or recover the curvature of the main chain through trans- cis photoisomerization. By means of this photocontrollable curvature, we have demonstrated light-induced unfolding of helically folded structures into entirely stretched structures. Furthermore, a direct extension of the π-conjugated core provided us with access to unprecedented supramolecular polymers with emergent time-dependent topology transitions. Molecules with a naphthalene core conjugated with two phenylene units kinetically afforded supramolecular polymers that consist of helically folded and misfolded domains. Upon aging the supramolecular polymer solution, we observed spontaneous folding of the misfolded domains in a time scale of days, eventually obtaining a supramolecular polymer topology analogous to the tertiary structure of proteins. These supramolecular polymers with unrivaled and active topologies provide new prospects for supramolecular polymers as one-dimensional nanomaterials.

Effect of an Aromatic Solvent on Hydrogen-Bond-Directed Supramolecular Polymerization Leading to Distinct Topologies.

Beyond phenomenon, self-assembly of synthetic molecules, is now becoming an essential tool to design supramolecular materials not only in the thermodynamically stable state but also in kinetically trapped states. However, an approach to design complex self-assembly processes comprising different types of self-assembled states remains elusive. Herein, an example of such systems is demonstrated based on a unique supramolecular polymer mediated by supermacrocyclization of hydrogen-bonding π-conjugated molecules. By adding an aromatic solvent into nonpolar solutions of the monomer, spontaneous nucleation triggered by supermacrocyclization was suppressed so that isothermal supramolecular polymerization could be achieved from kinetically formed topological variants and amorphous agglomerates to afford helicoidal structures hitherto obtainable only with very slow cooling of a hot solution. By increasing the proportion of aromatic solvent further, another self-assembly path was found, based on competing extended hydrogen-bonded motifs affording crystalline nanowires.

Systematic Synthesis of Tetrathia[8]circulenes: The Influence of Peripheral Substituents on the Structures and Properties in Solution and Solid States.

We developed the diversity-oriented approach for the synthesis of tetrathia[8]circulenes with a variety of peripheral substituents. Iridium-catalyzed direct C-H borylation of tetrathienylene provided 1,4,7,10-tetraboryltetrathienylene as a major product. 1,4,7,10-Tetraboryltetrathienylene served as an a key intermediate to achieve the selective synthesis of octasubstituted or tetrasubstituted tetrathia[8]circulenes via rhodium-catalyzed annulation with symmetric internal alkynes or sequential Sonogashira-Hagihara coupling and base-promoted intramolecular cyclization. A variety of substituents were installed at the peripheral positions of tetrathia[8]circulenes systematically. The self-assembling behavior of tetrathia[8]circulenes was investigated using 1H NMR and AFM measurements. The number and the chain length of alkyl groups exerted a significant influence on the aggregation ability and the crystal packing structures of tetrathia[8]circulenes in both solution and solid states. We also found that the molecular arrangement of the self-assembled tetrathia[8]circulene molecules affected the hole mobility assessed by the FP-TRMC method.

Hierarchical self-assembly of an azobenzene dyad with inverted amide connection into toroidal and tubular nanostructures.

Inversion of the connectivity of amide groups in foldable azobenzene dyads with chiral side chains, which can self-assemble into toroids and nanotubes, significantly increases the thermal stability of these aggregates. The results can be explained by the geometrical difference of the amide groups. On the other hand, the side chain chirality is disregarded because the chiral centers are distant from the amide groups.

Topological Impact on the Kinetic Stability of Supramolecular Polymers.

Kinetically formed metastable molecular assemblies have attracted increasing interest especially in the field of supramolecular polymers. In most cases, metastable assemblies are ensemblies of aggregates based on the same supramolecular motif but with different lengths or sizes, and therefore their kinetic stabilities are experimentally indistinguishable. Herein, we demonstrate a topological effect on kinetic stabilities in a complex mixture of metastable supramolecular polymers. Our azobenzene-incorporated monomer upon heating in nonpolar solvent at ambient temperature kinetically forms complex mixtures of supramolecular polymers with cyclized and open-ended randomly coiled topologies. Upon further heating, we obtained thermodynamically stable twisted fibrils organizing into crystalline fibers. Through the direct visualization of the complex supramolecular polymer mixtures by atomic force microscopy, we demonstrate that the cyclized supramolecular polymer has superior kinetic stability compared to the open-ended species toward the thermal transformation into twisted fibrils. Since the superior kinetic stability of the cyclized species can be attributed to the absence of aggregate termini, we could convert them fully into the thermodynamic species through photoinduced opening of the cyclized structures.

Mechanistic Insights into the Self-Assembly of an Acid-Sensitive Photoresponsive Supramolecular Polymer.

The supramolecular polymerization of an acid-sensitive pyridyl-based ligand (L1 ) bearing a photoresponsive azobenzene moiety was elucidated by mechanistic studies. Addition of trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) led to the transformation of the antiparallel H-bonded fibers of L1 in methylcyclohexane into superhelical braid-like fibers stabilized by H-bonding of parallel-stacked monomer units. Interestingly, L1 dimers held together by unconventional pyridine-TFA N⋅⋅⋅H⋅⋅⋅O bridges represent the main structural elements of the assembly. UV-light irradiation caused a strain-driven disassembly and subsequent aggregate reconstruction, which ultimately led to short fibers. The results allowed to understand the mechanism of mutual influence of acid and light stimuli on supramolecular polymerization processes, thus opening up new possibilities to design advanced stimuli-triggered supramolecular systems.

Triplet-Triplet Annihilation-Based Upconversion Sensitized by a Reverse Micellar Assembly of Amphiphilic Ruthenium Complexes.

We have developed a new photon upconversion (UC) system utilizing a new amphiphilic sensitizer 1a that comprises a hydrophilic ruthenium complex and a lipophilic bisanthracene appendage. At concentrations higher than 5 µM in toluene, the sensitizer 1a formed a reverse micellar assembly which facilitated the triplet sensitization of 9,10-diphenylanthracene (DPA) more efficiently than homogeneously dispersed solutions to enhance the UC efficiency up to 38.2%. The Stern-Volmer analyses revealed the stepwise triplet-triplet energy transfers (TTET): (1) intramicellar energy transfer from the ruthenium core to the bisanthracene surface and (2) diffusion-dependent energy transfer from the surface to DPA. On these bases, it can be assumed that the reverse micellar assemblies accelerate the former TTET process to enhance the UC efficiency.