A Comparative Analysis of Data Analysis Tools for Data-Independent Acquisition Mass Spectrometry.

Data-independent acquisition (DIA) mass spectrometry-based proteomics generates reproducible proteome data. The complex processing of the DIA data has led to the development of multiple data analysis tools. In this study, we assessed the performance of five tools (OpenSWATH, EncyclopeDIA, Skyline, DIA-NN, and Spectronaut) using six DIA datasets obtained from TripleTOF, Orbitrap, and TimsTOF Pro instruments. By comparing identification and quantification metrics and examining shared and unique cross-tool identifications, we evaluated both library-based and library-free approaches. Our findings indicate that library-free approaches outperformed library-based methods when the spectral library had limited comprehensiveness. However, our results also suggest that constructing a comprehensive library still offers benefits for most DIA analyses. This study provides comprehensive guidance for DIA data analysis tools, benefiting both experienced and novice users of DIA-mass spectrometry technology.

Optimizing Spectronaut Search Parameters to Improve Data Quality with Minimal Proteome Coverage Reductions in DIA Analyses of Heterogeneous Samples.

Data-independent acquisition has seen breakthroughs that enable comprehensive proteome profiling using short gradients. As the proteome coverage continues to increase, the quality of the data generated becomes much more relevant. Using Spectronaut, we show that the default search parameters can be easily optimized to minimize the occurrence of false positives across different samples. Using an immunological infection model system to demonstrate the impact of adjusting search settings, we analyzed Mus musculus macrophages and compared their proteome to macrophages spiked withCandida albicans. This experimental system enabled the identification of "false positives" as Candida albicans peptides and proteins should not be present in the Mus musculus-only samples. We show that adjusting the search parameters reduced "false positive" identifications by 89% at the peptide and protein level, thereby considerably increasing the quality of the data. We also show that these optimized parameters incurred a moderate cost, only reducing the overall number of "true positive" identifications across each biological replicate by <6.7% at both the peptide and protein level. We believe the value of our updated search parameters extends beyond a two-organism analysis and would be of great value to any DIA experiment analyzing heterogeneous populations of cell types or tissues.

Evaluation of PAC and FASP Performance: DIA-Based Quantitative Proteomic Analysis.

The aim of this study was to compare filter-aided sample preparation (FASP) and protein aggregation capture (PAC) starting from a three-species protein mix (Human, Soybean and Pisum sativum) and two different starting amounts (1 and 10 µg). Peptide mixtures were analyzed by data-independent acquisition (DIA) and raw files were processed by three commonly used software: Spectronaut, MaxDIA and DIA-NN. Overall, the highest number of proteins (mean value of 5491) were identified by PAC (10 µg), while the lowest number (4855) was identified by FASP (1 µg). The latter experiment displayed the worst performance in terms of both specificity (0.73) and precision (0.24). Other tested conditions showed better diagnostic accuracy, with specificity values of 0.95-0.99 and precision values between 0.61 and 0.86. In order to provide guidance on the data analysis pipeline, the accuracy diagnostic of three software was investigated: (i) the highest sensitivity was obtained with Spectronaut (median of 0.67) highlighting the ability of Spectronaut to quantify low-abundance proteins, (ii) the best precision value was obtained by MaxDIA (median of 0.84), but with a reduced number of identifications compared to Spectronaut and DIA-NN data, and (iii) the specificity values were similar (between 0.93 and 0.99). The data are available on ProteomeXchange with the identifier PXD044349.

Protein Contaminants Matter: Building Universal Protein Contaminant Libraries for DDA and DIA Proteomics.

Mass spectrometry-based proteomics is constantly challenged by the presence of contaminant background signals. In particular, protein contaminants from reagents and sample handling are almost impossible to avoid. For data-dependent acquisition (DDA) proteomics, an exclusion list can be used to reduce the influence of protein contaminants. However, protein contamination has not been evaluated and is rarely addressed in data-independent acquisition (DIA). How protein contaminants influence proteomic data is also unclear. In this study, we established new protein contaminant FASTA and spectral libraries that are applicable to all proteomic workflows and evaluated the impact of protein contaminants on both DDA and DIA proteomics. We demonstrated that including our contaminant libraries can reduce false discoveries and increase protein identifications, without influencing the quantification accuracy in various proteomic software platforms. With the pressing need to standardize proteomic workflow in the research community, we highly recommend including our contaminant FASTA and spectral libraries in all bottom-up proteomic data analysis. Our contaminant libraries and a step-by-step tutorial to incorporate these libraries in various DDA and DIA data analysis platforms can be valuable resources for proteomic researchers, freely accessible at https://github.com/HaoGroup-ProtContLib.

Data-independent Acquisition Improves Quantitative Cross-linking Mass Spectrometry.

Quantitative cross-linking mass spectrometry (QCLMS) reveals structural detail on altered protein states in solution. On its way to becoming a routine technology, QCLMS could benefit from data-independent acquisition (DIA), which generally enables greater reproducibility than data-dependent acquisition (DDA) and increased throughput over targeted methods. Therefore, here we introduce DIA to QCLMS by extending a widely used DIA software, Spectronaut, to also accommodate cross-link data. A mixture of seven proteins cross-linked with bis[sulfosuccinimidyl] suberate (BS3) was used to evaluate this workflow. Out of the 414 identified unique residue pairs, 292 (70%) were quantifiable across triplicates with a coefficient of variation (CV) of 10%, with manual correction of peak selection and boundaries for PSMs in the lower quartile of individual CV values. This compares favorably to DDA where we quantified cross-links across triplicates with a CV of 66%, for a single protein. We found DIA-QCLMS to be capable of detecting changing abundances of cross-linked peptides in complex mixtures, despite the ratio compression encountered when increasing sample complexity through the addition of E. coli cell lysate as matrix. In conclusion, the DIA software Spectronaut can now be used in cross-linking and DIA is indeed able to improve QCLMS.

Isolation and Identification of Plasma Extracellular Vesicles Protein Biomarkers.

Extracellular vesicles (EVs) have emerged as a valuable source for disease biomarkers and an alternative drug delivery system due to their ability to carry cargo and target specific cells. Proper isolation, identification, and analytical strategy are required for evaluating their potential in diagnostics and therapeutics. Here, a method is detailed to isolate plasma EVs and analyze their proteomic profiling, combining EVtrap-based high-recovery EV isolation, phase-transfer surfactant method for protein extraction, and mass spectrometry qualitative and quantitative strategies for EV proteome characterization. The pipeline provides a highly effective EV-based proteome analysis technique that can be applied for EV characterization and evaluation of EV-based diagnosis and therapy.

High-Throughput Plasma Proteomic Profiling.

Plasma and serum are rich sources of proteins that are commonly used for clinical proteome profiling and biomarkers discovery. However, high-throughput plasma proteome profiling and quantitative analysis using mass spectrometry are challenging because of the large dynamic range of protein abundance and complexity. To overcome these challenges, we developed a convenient high-throughput workflow of depleted plasma using the 4D-Proteomics feature of the Bruker timsTOF Pro mass spectrometer with data-dependent (PASEF) and data-independent acquisition (diaPASEF) method that can potentially be used in a clinical proteome profiling and biomarker discoveries. This workflow is robust, optimal for high throughput, high proteome depth, and is reproducible. In our sample preparation steps, we used immuno-depletion steps to remove high-abundance plasma proteins, and without any further cleanup steps, we can use depleted plasma samples directly for enzymatic digestion. Immuno-depletion steps and 4D-Proteomics features of timsTOF Pro increase the plasma proteome depth, and accuracy with the identification of >800 protein groups.

Data Processing and Analysis for DIA-Based Phosphoproteomics Using Spectronaut.

Data-independent acquisition (DIA) for liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) can improve the depth and reproducibility of the acquired proteomics datasets. DIA solves some limitations of the conventional data-dependent acquisition (DDA) strategy, for example, bias in intensity-dependent precursor selection and limited dynamic range. These advantages, together with the recent developments in speed, sensitivity, and resolution in MS technology, position DIA as a great alternative to DDA. Recently, we demonstrated that the benefits of DIA are extendable to phosphoproteomics workflows, enabling increased depth, sensitivity, and reproducibility of our analysis of phosphopeptide-enriched samples. However, computational data analysis of phospho-DIA samples have some specific challenges and requirements to the software and downstream processing workflows. A step-by-step guide to analyze phospho-DIA raw data using either spectral libraries or directDIA in Spectronaut is presented here. Furthermore, a straightforward protocol to perform differential phosphorylation site analysis using the output results from Spectronaut is described.

Assessing the Relationship Between Mass Window Width and Retention Time Scheduling on Protein Coverage for Data-Independent Acquisition.

Due to the technical advances of mass spectrometers, particularly increased scanning speed and higher MS/MS resolution, the use of data-independent acquisition mass spectrometry (DIA-MS) became more popular, which enables high reproducibility in both proteomic identification and quantification. The current DIA-MS methods normally cover a wide mass range, with the aim to target and identify as many peptides and proteins as possible and therefore frequently generate MS/MS spectra of high complexity. In this report, we assessed the performance and benefits of using small windows with, e.g., 5-m/z width across the peptide elution time. We further devised a new DIA method named RTwinDIA that schedules the small isolation windows in different retention time blocks, taking advantage of the fact that larger peptides are normally eluting later in reversed phase chromatography. We assessed the direct proteomic identification by using shotgun database searching tools such as MaxQuant and pFind, and also Spectronaut with an external comprehensive spectral library of human proteins. We conclude that algorithms like pFind have potential in directly analyzing DIA data acquired with small windows, and that the instrumental time and DIA cycle time, if prioritized to be spent on small windows rather than on covering a broad mass range by large windows, will improve the direct proteome coverage for new biological samples and increase the quantitative precision. These results further provide perspectives for the future convergence between DDA and DIA on faster MS analyzers.