Competition between maturation and degradation drives human snRNA 3' end quality control.

Polymerases and exonucleases act on 3' ends of nascent RNAs to promote their maturation or degradation but how the balance between these activities is controlled to dictate the fates of cellular RNAs remains poorly understood. Here, we identify a central role for the human DEDD deadenylase TOE1 in distinguishing the fates of small nuclear (sn)RNAs of the spliceosome from unstable genome-encoded snRNA variants. We found that TOE1 promotes maturation of all regular RNA polymerase II transcribed snRNAs of the major and minor spliceosomes by removing posttranscriptional oligo(A) tails, trimming 3' ends, and preventing nuclear exosome targeting. In contrast, TOE1 promotes little to no maturation of tested U1 variant snRNAs, which are instead targeted by the nuclear exosome. These observations suggest that TOE1 is positioned at the center of a 3' end quality control pathway that selectively promotes maturation and stability of regular snRNAs while leaving snRNA variants unprocessed and exposed to degradation in what could be a widespread mechanism of RNA quality control given the large number of noncoding RNAs processed by DEDD deadenylases.

Sm complex assembly and 5' cap trimethylation promote selective processing of snRNAs by the 3' exonuclease TOE1.

Competing exonucleases that promote 3' end maturation or degradation direct quality control of small non-coding RNAs, but how these enzymes distinguish normal from aberrant RNAs is poorly understood. The Pontocerebellar Hypoplasia 7 (PCH7)-associated 3' exonuclease TOE1 promotes maturation of canonical small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs). Here, we demonstrate that TOE1 achieves specificity toward canonical snRNAs through their Sm complex assembly and cap trimethylation, two features that distinguish snRNAs undergoing correct biogenesis from other small non-coding RNAs. Indeed, disruption of Sm complex assembly via snRNA mutations or protein depletions obstructs snRNA processing by TOE1, and in vitro snRNA processing by TOE1 is stimulated by a trimethylated cap. An unstable snRNA variant that normally fails to undergo maturation becomes fully processed by TOE1 when its degenerate Sm binding motif is converted into a canonical one. Our findings uncover the molecular basis for how TOE1 distinguishes snRNAs from other small non-coding RNAs and explain how TOE1 promotes maturation specifically of canonical snRNAs undergoing proper processing.

The PARN, TOE1, and USB1 RNA deadenylases and their roles in non-coding RNA regulation.

The levels of non-coding RNAs (ncRNAs) are regulated by transcription, RNA processing, and RNA degradation pathways. One mechanism for the degradation of ncRNAs involves the addition of oligo(A) tails by non-canonical poly(A) polymerases, which then recruit processive sequence-independent 3' to 5' exonucleases for RNA degradation. This pathway of decay is also regulated by three 3' to 5' exoribonucleases, USB1, PARN, and TOE1, which remove oligo(A) tails and thereby can protect ncRNAs from decay in a manner analogous to the deubiquitination of proteins. Loss-of-function mutations in these genes lead to premature degradation of some ncRNAs and lead to specific human diseases such as Poikiloderma with Neutropenia (PN) for USB1, Dyskeratosis Congenita (DC) for PARN and Pontocerebellar Hypoplasia type 7 (PCH7) for TOE1. Herein, we review the biochemical properties of USB1, PARN, and TOE1, how they modulate ncRNA levels, and their roles in human diseases.

Clinical and genetic characterization of a Chinese family with pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7.

We report compound heterozygous variants in TOE1 in siblings of Chinese origin who presented with dyskinesia and intellectual disabilities. Our report provides further information regarding the etiology and pathogenesis of pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7 syndrome (PCH7). Clinical manifestations were obtained, and genomic DNA was collected from family members. Whole-exome and Sanger sequencing were performed to identify associated genetic variants. Bioinformatics analysis was conducted to identify and characterize the pathogenicity of the heterozygous variants. Following long-term rehabilitation, both siblings showed minimal improvement, and their condition tended to progress. Whole-exome sequencing revealed two unreported heterozygous variants, NM_025077: c.C553T (p.R185W) and NM_025077: c.G562T (p.V188L), in the TOE1 gene mapped to 1p34.1. Sanger sequencing confirmed that the two variants in the proband and her brother were inherited from their parents. The NM_025077: c.C553T (p.R185W) variant was inherited from the father, and the NM_025077: c.G562T (p.V188L) variant was inherited from the mother. Although the two variants in the TOE1 gene have not been reported previously, they were associated with PCH7 based on integrated analysis. Thus, our report contributes to our knowledge regarding the etiology and phenotype of PCH 7.

TOE1/TOE2 Interacting with GIS to Control Trichome Development in Arabidopsis.

Trichomes are common appendages originating and projecting from the epidermal cell layer of most terrestrial plants. They act as a first line of defense and protect plants against different types of adverse environmental factors. GL3/EGL3-GL1-TTG1 transcriptional activator complex and GIS family genes regulate trichome initiation through gibberellin (GA) signaling in Arabidopsis. Here, our novel findings show that TOE1/TOE2, which are involved in developmental timing, control the initiation of the main-stem inflorescence trichome in Arabidopsis. Phenotype analysis showed that the 35S:TOE1 transgenic line increases trichome density of the main-stem inflorescence in Arabidopsis, while 35S:miR172b, toe1, toe2 and toe1toe2 have the opposite phenotypes. Quantitative RT-PCR results showed that TOE1/TOE2 positively regulate the expression of GL3 and GL1. In addition, protein-protein interaction analysis experiments further demonstrated that TOE1/TOE2 interacting with GIS/GIS2/ZFP8 regulate trichome initiation in Arabidopsis. Furthermore, phenotype and expression analysis also demonstrated that TOE1 is involved in GA signaling to control trichome initiation in Arabidopsis. Taken together, our results suggest that TOE1/TOE2 interact with GIS to control trichome development in Arabidopsis. This report could provide valuable information for further study of the interaction of TOE1/TOE2 with GIS in controlling trichome development in plants.

Novel compound heterozygous variant of TOE1 results in a mild type of pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7: an expansion of the clinical phenotype.

The target of EGR1 protein 1 (TOE1) is a 3-exonuclease belonging to the Asp-Glu-Asp-Asp deadenylase family that plays a vital role in the maturation of a variety of small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs). Bi-allelic variants in TOE1 have been reported to cause a rare and severe neurodegenerative syndrome, pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7 (PCH7) (OMIM # 614,969), which is characterized by progressive neurodegeneration, developmental delay, and ambiguous genitalia. Here, we describe the case of a 5-year-6-month-old female Chinese patient who presented with cerebral dysplasia, moderate intellectual disability, developmental delay, and dystonia. Trio whole-exome sequencing revealed two previously unreported heterozygous variants of TOE1 in the patient, including a maternal inherited splicing variant c.237-2A > G and a de novo missense variant c.551G > T, p.Arg184Leu. TA clone sequencing showed trans status of the two variants, indicating the missense variant occurred on the paternal strand in the patient. Clinical features of the patient were mostly concordant with previous reports but brain deformities (enlarged lateral ventricle and deepened cerebellum sulcus without microcephaly and reduced cerebellar volume) were less severe than in typical PCH7 patients. Moreover, the patient had no gonadal malformation, which is common and variable in patients with PCH7. In summary, we report the case of a Chinese patient with atypical PCH7 caused by a novel TOE1 compound variant. Our work suggests that variations in the TOE1 gene can lead to highly variable clinical phenotypes.

ISG20 and nuclear exosome promote destabilization of nascent transcripts for spliceosomal U snRNAs and U1 variants.

Primary RNA transcripts are processed in a plethora of ways to become mature functional forms. In one example, human spliceosomal U snRNAs are matured at their 3'-end by an exonuclease termed TOE1. This process is important because mutations in TOE1 gene can cause a human genetic disease, pontocerebellar hypoplasia (PCH). Nevertheless, TOE1 may not be the only maturation exonuclease for U snRNAs in the cell. Here, we biochemically identify two exonucleolytic factors, Interferon-stimulated gene 20-kDa protein (ISG20) and the nuclear exosome as such candidates, using a newly developed in vitro system that recapitulates 3'-end maturation of U1 snRNA. However, extensive 3'-end sequencing of endogenous U1 snRNA of the knockdown (KD) cells revealed that these factors are not the maturation factors per se. Instead, the nascent transcripts of the spliceosomal U snRNAs as well as of unstable U1 variants were found to increase in quantity upon KD of the factors. These results indicated that ISG20 and the nuclear exosome promote the degradation of nascent spliceosomal U snRNAs and U1 variants, and therefore implied their role in the quality control of newly synthesized U snRNAs.

The AP2 transcription factors TOE1/TOE2 convey Arabidopsis age information to ethylene signaling in plant de novo root regeneration.

MAIN CONCLUSION: We reveal that transcription factors TOE1 and TOE2 directly inhibit the transcription of EIN3. Ethylene triggers leaf abscission and senescence during plant aging. Previous studies have shown that the transcription of ETHYLENE INSENSITIVE 3 (EIN3), which encodes a key transcription factor in ethylene signaling, is gradually upregulated during plant aging. However, it is still unknown how plants transmit their age information to achieve transcriptional control of EIN3. Here, we report that the EAR-like motif-containing transcription factors TARGET OF EAT 1 (TOE1) and its homolog TOE2 directly associated with the EIN3 promoter. The transcription of EIN3 is further enhanced in mutants of toe1 toe2 during plant aging. TOE1/TOE2 are tightly controlled by canonical microRNA 172 (miR172)-mediated plant aging signaling, which result in a decline in TOE1/TOE2 expression during aging. These results illustrate that during plant aging, the reduced expressions of TOE1/TOE2 trigger an upregulation of EIN3. Next, we took advantage of EIN3-regulated de novo root regeneration (DNRR) as an age-controlled phenotype to dissect the biological function of this regulatory circuit. The DNRR rates in toe1 toe2 are more severely decreased with plant aging; however, the simultaneous loss of ein3 and eil1 (toe1 toe2 ein3 eil1 quadruple mutants) almost completely rescued the DNRR defects. Taken together, our findings show that the plant age-regulated TOE transcription factors precisely integrate plant age information and developmental programs through direct protein-DNA interactions.

Distinct Poly(A) nucleases have differential impact on sut-2 dependent tauopathy phenotypes.

Aging drives pathological accumulation of proteins such as tau, causing neurodegenerative dementia disorders like Alzheimer's disease. Previously we showed loss of function mutations in the gene encoding the poly(A) RNA binding protein SUT-2/MSUT2 suppress tau-mediated neurotoxicity in C. elegans neurons, cultured human cells, and mouse brain, while loss of PABPN1 had the opposite effect (Wheeler et al., 2019). Here we found that blocking poly(A) tail extension with cordycepin exacerbates tauopathy in cultured human cells, which is rescued by MSUT2 knockdown. To further investigate the molecular mechanisms of poly(A) RNA-mediated tauopathy suppression, we examined whether genes encoding poly(A) nucleases also modulated tauopathy in a C. elegans tauopathy model. We found that loss of function mutations in C. elegans ccr-4 and panl-2 genes enhanced tauopathy phenotypes in tau transgenic C. elegans while loss of parn-2 partially suppressed tauopathy. In addition, loss of parn-1 blocked tauopathy suppression by loss of parn-2. Epistasis analysis showed that sut-2 loss of function suppressed the tauopathy enhancement caused by loss of ccr-4 and SUT-2 overexpression exacerbated tauopathy even in the presence of parn-2 loss of function in tau transgenic C. elegans. Thus sut-2 modulation of tauopathy is epistatic to ccr-4 and parn-2. We found that human deadenylases do not colocalize with human MSUT2 in nuclear speckles; however, expression levels of TOE1, the homolog of parn-2, correlated with that of MSUT2 in post-mortem Alzheimer's disease patient brains. Alzheimer's disease patients with low TOE1 levels exhibited significantly increased pathological tau deposition and loss of NeuN staining. Taken together, this work suggests suppressing tauopathy cannot be accomplished by simply extending poly(A) tails, but rather a more complex relationship exists between tau, sut-2/MSUT2 function, and control of poly(A) RNA metabolism, and that parn-2/TOE1 may be altered in tauopathy in a similar way.

MiR172b-TOE1/2 module regulates plant innate immunity in an age-dependent manner.

Plant innate immunity varies with age and plant developmental stages. Recently, we reported that Arabidopsis thaliana microRNA miR172b regulates FLS2 transcription through two transcription factors: TARGET OF EAT1 (TOE1) and TOE2. Although the flg22-triggered immune responses were investigated in 2-d-old or even younger toe1/toe2 mutant and miR172b over expression (OE) transgenic plants, the FLS2-mediated immune responses in older plants remain uncharacterized yet. In this work, we analyzed the flg22-triggered immune response in 6-d-old toe1/toe2 and miR172b OE plants. We found that unlike 2-d-old plants, 6-d-old Col-0, toe1/toe2 and miR172b OE plants exhibit comparable flg22-triggered immune responses. Strikingly, miR172b precursor in 6-d-old Col-0 plants upon flg22 treatment reached to a very high level, consequently, the TOE1/2 protein level under this condition was very low or almost undetectable, which explains why 6-d-old WT seedlings are very similar to toe1/toe2 seedlings or miR172b OE plants with respect to the flg22-triggered immune responses. Taken together, our study reveals that miR172b-TOE1/2 module regulates plant innate immunity in an age-dependent manner.

TOE1 is an inhibitor of HIV-1 replication with cell-penetrating capability.

Target of Egr1 (TOE1) is a nuclear protein localized primarily in nucleoli and Cajal bodies that was identified as a downstream target of the immediate early gene Egr1. TOE1 displays a functional deadenylation domain and has been shown to participate in spliceosome assembly. We report here that TOE1 can function as an inhibitor of HIV-1 replication and show evidence that supports a direct interaction of TOE1 with the viral specific transactivator response element as part of the inhibitory mechanism. In addition, we show that TOE1 can be secreted by activated CD8(+) T lymphocytes and can be cleaved by the serine protease granzyme B, one of the main components of cytotoxic granules. Both full-length and cleaved TOE1 can spontaneously cross the plasma membrane and penetrate cells in culture, retaining HIV-1 inhibitory activity. Antiviral potency of TOE1 and its cell-penetrating capability have been identified to lie within a 35-amino-acid region containing the nuclear localization sequence.

Case report: A severe clinical phenotype of pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7 with compound heterozygous variants of TOE1.

Pontocerebellar Hypoplasia (PCH) is a rare autosomal recessive hereditary neurological degenerative disease. To elaborate upon the clinical phenotypes of PCH and explore the correlation between TOE1 gene mutations and clinical phenotype, we analyze the clinical and genetic features of a Chinese infant afflicted with pontocerebellar dysplasia accompanied by gender reversal with bioinformatics methods. The main clinical features of this infant with TOE1 gene mutation included progressive lateral ventricle widening, hydrocephalus, severe postnatal growth retardation, and hypotonia, and simultaneously being accompanied by 46, XY female sex reversal. Whole exome sequencing revealed a compound heterozygous mutation in the TOE1 gene (c.299T > G, c.1414T > G), with the protein homology modeling-generated structure predicting a pathogenic variation, which is closely related to the clinical manifestations in the patient. The new mutation sites, c.299T > G and c.1414T > G, in the TOE1 gene are pathogenic variants of pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7.

Pontocerebellar Hypoplasia 7 with Novel Compound Heterozygous Variants of TOE1 in a Boy with Micropenis, Developmental Delay, and Ataxia: The First Korean Case Report.

Pontocerebellar hypoplasia (PCH) is a rare neurodegenerative disorder characterized by hypoplasia of the pons and cerebellum and global developmental delay. Among several PCH types, PCH7 is a characteristic type that manifests with not only brain lesions but also sexual developmental disorders. The causative gene, TOE1, encodes a protein involved in small ribonucleic acid maturation and processing. TOE1 mutation is associated with neuronal survival that causes hypoplasia of the cerebellum and pons. We report the case of a male patient with PCH7, developmental delay, ataxia, micropenis, and undescended testis. Genetic analysis revealed compound heterozygous missense variants (c.955C>T and c.533T>G) in the TOE1 gene.

Genetic and prenatal diagnosis of a Chinese pedigree with pathogenic TOE1 variants causing pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7.

Objective: Biallelic pathogenic variants in TOE1 cause pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7 (PCH7), a rare neurological condition characterized by psychomotor retardation, spastic paraplegia, seizures, gonadal abnormalities and brain anomalies. Currently, only 14 postnatally diagnosed PCH7 patients have been described. However, the prenatal clinical profile of PCH7 has not yet been reported.Method: Whole-exome sequencing (WES) was performed to screen for causal variants.Results: We report the pedigree of a Chinese woman with two eventful pregnancies with fetuses that showed brain anomalies, including microcephaly, cerebral anomalies, enlarged ventricles, corpus callosum thinning, abnormal lateral fissure, underdeveloped insula and pons and brainstem hypoplasia. Interestingly, corpus callosum thinning was observed in fetus 1 but not in fetus 2. An abnormal lateral fissure and an underdeveloped insula were shown in fetus 2 but not fetus 1. Biallelic variants c.716T > C (p.Phe239Ser) and c.955C > T (p.His319Tyr) in TOE1 were identified in both fetuses.Conclusion: We first describe the prenatal features of a Chinese pedigree with PCH7 caused by biallelic pathogenic variants in TOE1, with phenotypic variability observed even within the same family. Novel phenotypes, an abnormal lateral fissure and an underdeveloped insula were observed in the fetus in our study. These findings will enrich our knowledge of the clinical characteristics, management and genetic counseling of PCH7.

Novel compound heterozygous missense variants in TOE1 gene associated with pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7.

BACKGROUND: Pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7(PCH7)is a neurodegenerative disease related to autosomal recessive variants in the target of EGR1 (TOE1)gene. Biallelic mutation in the TOE1 gene causes global developmental delay, cognitive and psychomotor impairment, hypotonia, breathing abnormalities, and gonadal abnormalities. This study examined the clinical and genetic features of a 2-year-old patient carrying novel compound heterozygous variants in the TOE1 gene, mutations of previously reported 14 PCH7 patients were reviewed. METHODS: Clinical data of the 2-year-old patient were captured. Trio- whole exome sequencing (Trio-WES) was performed to identify pathogenic variants. Sanger sequencing was further used to verify the variants. In silico analysis was performed to explain the pathogenicity. RESULTS: Herein, we described the clinical features of the 2-year-old patient diagnosed with PCH7 caused by mutations in the TOE1gene. The kid was presenting with global development delay and gonadal abnormalities. Brain imaging revealed hypoplasia of the cerebellum and pons with ambiguous genitalia. Trio-WES revealed novel compound heterozygous missense variants in TOE1gene (c.911C > T p.S304L, c.161C > T p.A54V). Multiple in silico tools predicted the deleterious effects of the mutations. CONCLUSION: The novel compound heterozygous missense mutation in the TOE1 gene identified in the proband broadened the genotypic and phenotypic spectrum of disorders associated with PCH7. Our findings provide critical information for the differential diagnosis of rare neurodevelopment disorders and genetic counselling.

Knockdown of Toe1 causes developmental arrest during the morula-to-blastocyst transition in mice.

The target of EGR1 protein 1 (TOE1) is evolutionarily conserved from Caenorhabditis elegans to mammals, which plays a critical role in the maturation of a variety of small nuclear RNAs. Mutation in human TOE1 has been reported to cause pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 7, a severe neurodegenerative syndrome. However, the role of TOE1 in early embryonic development remains unclear. Herein, we found that Toe1 mRNA and protein were expressed in mouse preimplantation embryos. Silencing Toe1 by siRNA led to morula-to-blastocyst transition failure. This developmental arrest can be rescued by Toe1 mRNA microinjection. EdU incorporation assay showed a defect in blastomere proliferation within developmentally arrested embryos. Further studies revealed that Toe1 knockdown caused increased signals for γH2AX and micronuclei, indicative of sustained DNA damage. Moreover, mRNA levels of cell cycle inhibitor p21 were significantly upregulated in Toe1 knockdown embryos before developmental arrest. Together, these results suggest that TOE1 is indispensable for mouse early embryo development potentially through maintaining genomic integrity. Our findings provide further insight into the role of TOE1 in mouse preimplantation embryonic development.

Identifying the Caenorhabditis elegans vulval transcriptome.

Development of the Caenorhabditis elegans vulva is a classic model of organogenesis. This system, which starts with 6 equipotent cells, encompasses diverse types of developmental event, including developmental competence, multiple signaling events to control precise and faithful patterning of three cell fates, execution and proliferation of specific cell lineages, and a series of sophisticated morphogenetic events. Early events have been subjected to extensive mutational and genetic investigations and later events to cell biological analyses. We infer the existence of dramatically changing profiles of gene expression that accompanies the observed changes in development. Yet, except from serendipitous discovery of several transcription factors expressed in dynamic patterns in vulval lineages, our knowledge of the transcriptomic landscape during vulval development is minimal. This study describes the composition of a vulva-specific transcriptome. We used tissue-specific harvesting of mRNAs via immunoprecipitation of epitope-tagged poly(A) binding protein, PAB-1, heterologously expressed by a promoter known to express GFP in vulval cells throughout their development. The identified transcriptome was small but tightly interconnected. From this data set, we identified several genes with identified functions in development of the vulva and validated more with promoter-GFP reporters of expression. For one target, lag-1, promoter-GFP expression was limited but a fluorescent tag of the endogenous protein revealed extensive expression. Thus, we have identified a transcriptome of C. elegans vulval lineages as a launching pad for exploration of functions of these genes in organogenesis.

PARN and TOE1 Constitute a 3' End Maturation Module for Nuclear Non-coding RNAs.

Poly(A)-specific ribonuclease (PARN) and target of EGR1 protein 1 (TOE1) are nuclear granule-associated deadenylases, whose mutations are linked to multiple human diseases. Here, we applied mTAIL-seq and RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) to systematically identify the substrates of PARN and TOE1 and elucidate their molecular functions. We found that PARN and TOE1 do not modulate the length of mRNA poly(A) tails. Rather, they promote the maturation of nuclear small non-coding RNAs (ncRNAs). PARN and TOE1 act redundantly on some ncRNAs, most prominently small Cajal body-specific RNAs (scaRNAs). scaRNAs are strongly downregulated when PARN and TOE1 are compromised together, leading to defects in small nuclear RNA (snRNA) pseudouridylation. They also function redundantly in the biogenesis of telomerase RNA component (TERC), which shares sequence motifs found in H/ACA box scaRNAs. Our findings extend the knowledge of nuclear ncRNA biogenesis, and they provide insights into the pathology of PARN/TOE1-associated genetic disorders whose therapeutic treatments are currently unavailable.

PARN Modulates Y RNA Stability and Its 3'-End Formation.

Loss-of-function mutations in 3'-to-5' exoribonucleases have been implicated in hereditary human diseases. For example, PARN mutations cause a severe form of dyskeratosis congenita (DC), wherein PARN deficiency leads to human telomerase RNA instability. Since the DC phenotype in PARN patients is even more severe than that of loss-of-function alleles in telomerase components, we hypothesized that PARN would also be required for the stability of other RNAs. Here, we show that PARN depletion reduces the levels of abundant human Y RNAs, which might contribute to the severe phenotype of DC observed in patients. Depletion of PAPD5 or the cytoplasmic exonuclease DIS3L rescues the effect of PARN depletion on Y RNA levels, suggesting that PARN stabilizes Y RNAs by removing oligoadenylated tails added by PAPD5, which would otherwise recruit DIS3L for Y RNA degradation. Through deep sequencing of 3' ends, we provide evidence that PARN can also deadenylate the U6 and RMRP RNAs without affecting their levels. Moreover, we observed widespread posttranscriptional oligoadenylation, uridylation, and guanylation of U6 and Y RNA 3' ends, suggesting that in mammalian cells, the formation of a 3' end for noncoding RNAs can be a complex process governed by the activities of various 3'-end polymerases and exonucleases.