Structure-activity relationships of 17alpha-derivatives of estradiol as inhibitors of steroid sulfatase.

The steroid sulfatase or steryl sulfatase is a microsomal enzyme widely distributed in human tissues that catalyzes the hydrolysis of sulfated 3-hydroxy steroids to the corresponding free active 3-hydroxy steroids. Since androgens and estrogens may be synthesized inside the cancerous cells starting from dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate (DHEAS) and estrone sulfate (E(1)S) available in blood circulation, the use of therapeutic agents that inhibit steroid sulfatase activity may be a rewarding approach to the treatment of androgeno-sensitive and estrogeno-sensitive diseases. In the present study, we report the chemical synthesis and biological evaluation of a new family of steroid sulfatase inhibitors. The inhibitors were designed by adding an alkyl, a phenyl, a benzyl, or a benzyl substituted at position 17alpha of estradiol (E(2)), a C18-steroid, and enzymatic assays were performed using the steroid sulfatase of homogenized JEG-3 cells or transfected in HEK-293 cells. We observed that a hydrophobic substituent induces powerful inhibition of steroid sulfatase while a hydrophilic one was weak. Although a hydrophobic group at the 17alpha-position increased the inhibitory activity, the steric factors contribute to the opposite effect. As exemplified by 17alpha-decyl-E(2) and 17alpha-dodecyl-E(2), a long flexible side chain prevents adequate fitting into the enzyme catalytic site, thus decreasing capacity to inhibit the steroid sulfatase activity. In the alkyl series, the best compromise between hydrophobicity and steric hindrance was obtained with the octyl group (IC(50) = 440 nM), but judicious branching of side chain could improve this further. Benzyl substituted derivatives of estradiol were better inhibitors than alkyl analogues. Among the series of 17alpha-(benzyl substituted)-E(2) derivatives studied, the 3'-bromobenzyl, 4'-tert-butylbenzyl, 4'-butylbenzyl, and 4'-benzyloxybenzyl groups provided the most potent inhibition of steroid sulfatase transformation of E(1)S into E(1) (IC(50) = 24, 28, 25, and 22 nM, respectively). As an example, the tert-butylbenzyl group increases the ability of the E(2) nucleus to inhibit the steroid sulfatase by 3000-fold, and it also inhibits similarly the steroid sulfatase transformations of both natural substrates, E(1)S and DHEAS. Interestingly, the newly reported family of steroid sulfatase inhibitors acts by a reversible mechanism of action that is different from the irreversible mechanism of the known inhibitor estrone sulfamate (EMATE).

Potent inhibition of steroid sulfatase activity by 3-O-sulfamate 17alpha-benzyl(or 4'-tert-butylbenzyl)estra-1,3,5(10)-trienes: combination of two substituents at positions C3 and c17alpha of estradiol.

Steroid sulfates are precursors of hormones that stimulate androgen- and estrogen-dependent cancers. Thus, steroid sulfatase, the enzyme that catalyzes conversion of DHEAS and E1S to the corresponding unconjugated steroids DHEA and E1, appears to be one of the key enzymes regulating the level of active androgenic and estrogenic steroids. Since 17alpha-substituted benzylestradiols and 3-O-sulfamate estrone (EMATE) represent two families of steroid sulfatase inhibitors that probably act through different mechanisms, we synthesized compounds 3-O-sulfamate 17alpha-benzylestradiol (4) and 3-O-sulfamate 17alpha-(tert-butylbenzyl)estradiol (5) that contain two kinds of substituents on the same molecule. In our enzymatic assay using a homogenate of human embryonal (293) cells transfected with steroid sulfatase, compounds 4 and 5 were found to be more potent inhibitors than already known steroid sulfatase inhibitors that have only a C17alpha-substituent or only a C3-sulfamate group (EMATE). The IC50 values of 4 and 5 were, respectively, 0.39 and 0.15 nM for the transformation of E1S to E1 and 4.1 and 1.4 nM for the transformation of DHEAS to DHEA. Compound 5 inhibited the steroid sulfatase activity in intact transfected (293) cell culture assays by inactivating the enzyme activity. Compound 5 also inactivates the steroid sulfatase activity at lower concentration than EMATE in microsomes of transfected (293) cells. In this assay, an excess of natural substrate E1S protects enzyme against inactivation by 5 or EMATE. Furthermore, the unsulfamoylated analogue of 5, compound 3, did not inactivate the steroid sulfatase.

17Alpha-alkan (or alkyn) amide derivatives of estradiol as inhibitors of steroid-sulfatase activity.

To develop inhibitors of steroid sulfatase without residual estrogenic activity, we have designed a series of estradiol (E2) derivatives bearing an alkan (or alkyn) amide side chain at position 17alpha. A hydrophobic alkyl group was selected from our previous study where 17alpha-octyl-E2 was found to inhibit strongly the steroid-sulfatase activity. Furthermore, it is known that an alkylamide side chain blocks the estrogen-receptor activation. Starting from ethynylestradiol, the chemical synthesis of target compounds was short and efficient with overall yields of 22-42% (3 or 4 steps). Among these compounds, N-octyl,N-methyl-3-(3',17'beta-dihydroxy-1',3',5'(10')-estratrien- 17'alpha-yl)-propanamide (15) was the most potent inhibitor, with an IC50 value of 0.08 microM for the transformation of estrone sulfate (E1S) to estrone (E1) by homogenated JEG-3 cells. N-butyl, N-hexyl, and N,N-dioctyl propanamide derivatives of E2 (IC50 values of 6.4, 2.8, and >20 microM, respectively) were less potent inhibitors than N-octyl analog 15. Furthermore, the unsaturated propynamide analog of 15 gave lower inhibition (four times) than the saturated compound. Compound 15 is also about 100-fold more effective in interacting with the enzyme than substrate E1S itself. The ability of target compounds to bind the estrogen receptor, to stimulate the proliferation of estrogen-sensitive ZR-75-1 cells, or to inhibit the E2-stimulation of ZR-75-1 cells was also evaluated. Although a mixed estrogenic/anti-estrogenic activity was obtained for tested compounds at 1 microM, no estrogenic activity was observed at 0.03 microM for 15. In conclusion, a promising inhibitor of steroid-sulfatase activity was obtained by introducing a hydrophobic octyl group in a 17alpha-propanamide side chain of E2, but further structure-activity relationships (SAR) studies are necessary to minimize the residual estrogenic activity.

Synthesis and steroid sulphatase inhibitory activity of C19- and C21-steroidal derivatives bearing a benzyl-inhibiting group.

Two series of compounds, benzyl alkylated at position 17alpha and 20 of androstane and pregnane, respectively, were synthesised and tested for steroid sulphatase inhibition. We compared the ability of the compounds to inhibit steroid sulphatase obtained from two different sources (homogenates of transfected HEK-293 cells and Jeg-3 cells) and with two types of substrate (DHEAS or E(1)S). The inhibitory activity of 17alpha-benzyl-5alpha-androstane-3beta,17beta-diol (7), 17alpha-benzyl-5-androstene-3beta,17beta-diol (9), 17alpha-benzyl-4,17beta-dihydroxy-4-androsten-3-one (15) and 20-benzyl-5-pregnene-3beta,20alpha-diol (16) has proven to be superior to that of danazol, the first steroid sulphatase inhibitor to be reported, but still lower than that of the potent inhibitor estrone-3-O-sulphamate. The inhibitory activity of compound 7 was as potent as that of its previously reported estrane analogue, 17alpha-benzyl estradiol. Benzyl alkylated compounds with no OH group on the A-ring (with a 4-OCH(3), 4-Cl, or 4-H and their precursor epoxides), as well as a series of basic steroids without a benzyl group (ADT, epi-ADT, 3alpha-diol, 3beta-diol, DHEA, Delta(5)-diol, DHT, T, Preg and Prog), did not show steroid sulphatase inhibition. We have thus demonstrated that the steroid sulphatase inhibitory effect of a benzyl group, previously observed for an estrane nucleus, can be extended to certain androstane and pregnane nuclei bearing a 3beta-OH or a 4-OH group. Inhibitors 7, 9, 15 and 16 did not induce any proliferative effect on androgen-sensitive Shionogi cells. However, when tested on oestrogen-sensitive ZR-75-1 cells, a proliferative effect was observed for 7 and 9, but not for 15 and 16.

17 alpha-alkyl- or 17 alpha-substituted benzyl-17 beta-estradiols: a new family of estrone-sulfatase inhibitors.

A series of 17 alpha-derivatives of 17 beta-estradiol was synthesized and tested for their ability to inhibit the estrone-sulfatase activity transforming estrone sulfate to estrone. A strong inhibitory activity was obtained when an alkyl side chain or a substituted benzyl was introduced at position 17 alpha of estradiol. The 17 alpha-(3'-bromobenzyl)-estradiol (26) and 17 alpha-(4'-t-butylbenzyl)-estradiol (30) were the most potent estrone-sulfatase inhibitors obtained in our study with IC50 values of 24 and 28 nM, respectively. They also represent a new family of estrone-sulfatase inhibitors. These compounds are about 300-fold more effective in interacting with the enzyme than the substrate estrone sulfate itself.

C16 and C17 derivatives of estradiol as inhibitors of 17 beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase type 1: chemical synthesis and structure-activity relationships.

As a first part of our research focused on the synthesis of 17 beta-HSD type 1 inhibitors without estrogenic activity, we needed to identify a small, easy-to-handle pharmacophore able to block the enzymatic activity. Previous studies on the active site of the enzyme by affinity labeling gave us a basis for the design of steroidal inhibitors derivatives. Several estradiol derivatives bearing a short (three carbons) side chain in position 17 alpha or 16 alpha were synthesized and tested for their ability to inhibit the transformation of estrone into estradiol by 17 beta-HSD type 1 (cytosolic fraction of human placenta). We found that 16 alpha-derivatives of estradiol gave better 17 beta-HSD inhibition than their corresponding 17 alpha analogs. Among several chemical groups used in this study, we conclude that better 17 beta-HSD inhibition was obtained for compounds with a good leaving group at the end of side chain. Thus, an iodopropyl or a bromopropyl side chain at C16 alpha of estradiol (E2) inhibit efficiently the 17 beta-HSD type 1 with IC50 values of 0.42 and 0.46 microM, respectively. Their 17-keto analogs inhibit also the enzyme activity similarly. Since this kind of compounds inhibit the 17 beta-HSD type 1 in time-dependent manner and that enzymatic activity cannot be restored later, we conclude to inhibitor of inactivator type. This conclusion is in accordance with the correlation observed between the ability of leaving group to dissociate and their potency to inhibit 17 beta-HSD type 1. We have also observed that additional addition of untritiated estrone protect the enzyme against the inactivation caused by 16 alpha-bromopropyl-E2 suggesting a competitive inhibitor of 17 beta-HSD. The bromopropyl pharmacophore was then selected to be further added onto an antiestrogenic steroid nucleus.