Size Discrimination of Carbohydrates via Conductive Carbon Nanotube@Metal Organic Framework Composites.

Traditional chemical sensing methodologies have typically relied on the specific chemistry of the analyte for detection. Modifications to the local environment surrounding the sensor represent an alternative pathway to impart selective differentiation. Here, we present the hybridization of a 2-D metal organic framework (Cu3(HHTP)2) with single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) as a methodology for size discrimination of carbohydrates. Synthesis and the resulting conductive performance are modulated by both mass loading of SWCNTs and their relative oxidation. Liquid gated field-effect transistor (FET) devices demonstrate improved on/off characteristics and differentiation of carbohydrates based on molecular size. Glucose molecule detection is limited to the single micromolar concentration range. Molecular Dynamics (MD) calculations on model systems revealed decreases in ion diffusivity in the presence of different sugars as well as packing differences based on the size of a given carbohydrate molecule. The proposed sensing mechanism is a reduction in gate capacitance initiated by the filling of the pores with carbohydrate molecules. Restricting diffusion around a sensor in combination with FET measurements represents a new type of sensing mechanism for chemically similar analytes.

Genetic Algorithm Design of MOF-based Gas Sensor Arrays for CO2-in-Air Sensing.

Gas sensor arrays, also known as electronic noses, leverage a diverse set of materials to identify the components of complex gas mixtures. Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have emerged as promising materials for electronic noses due to their high-surface areas and chemical as well as structural tunability. Using our recently reported genetic algorithm design approach, we examined a set of 50 MOFs and searched through over 1.125 × 1015 unique array combinations to identify optimal arrays for the detection of CO2 in air. We found that despite individual MOFs having lower selectivity for O2 or N2 relative to CO2, intelligently selecting the right combinations of MOFs enables accurate prediction of the concentrations of all components in the mixture (i.e., CO2, O2, N2). We also analyzed the physical properties of the elements in the arrays to develop an intuition for improving array design. Notably, we found that an array whose MOFs have diversity in their volumetric surface areas has improved sensing. Consistent with this observation, we found that the best arrays consistently had greater structural diversity (e.g., pore sizes, void fractions, and surface areas) than the worst arrays.

Multipressure Sampling for Improving the Performance of MOF-based Electronic Noses.

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are a promising class of porous materials for the design of gas sensing arrays, which are often called electronic noses. Due to their chemical and structural tunability, MOFs are a highly diverse class of materials that align well with the similarly diverse class of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) of interest in many gas detection applications. In principle, by choosing the right combination of cross-sensitive MOFs, layered on appropriate signal transducers, one can design an array that yields detailed information about the composition of a complex gas mixture. However, despite the vast number of MOFs from which one can choose, gas sensing arrays that rely too heavily on distinct chemistries can be impractical from the cost and complexity perspective. On the other hand, it is difficult for small arrays to have the desired selectivity and sensitivity for challenging sensing applications, such as detecting weakly adsorbing gases with weak signals, or conversely, strongly adsorbing gases that readily saturate MOF pores. In this work, we employed gas adsorption simulations to explore the use of a variable pressure sensing array as a means of improving both sensitivity and selectivity as well as increasing the information content provided by each array. We studied nine different MOFs (HKUST-1, IRMOF-1, MgMOF-74, MOF-177, MOF-801, NU-100, NU-125, UiO-66, and ZIF-8) and four different gas mixtures, each containing nitrogen, oxygen, carbon dioxide, and exactly one of the hydrogen, methane, hydrogen sulfide, or benzene. We found that by lowering the pressure, we can limit the saturation of MOFs, and by raising the pressure, we can concentrate weakly adsorbing gases, in both cases, improving gas detection with the resulting arrays. In many cases, changing the system pressure yielded a better improvement in performance (as measured by the Kullback-Liebler divergence of gas composition probability distributions) than including additional MOFs. We thus demonstrated and quantified how sensing at multiple pressures can increase information content and cross-sensitivity in MOF-based arrays while limiting the number of unique materials needed in the device.

Size-Based Norfentanyl Detection with SWCNT@UiO-MOF Composites.

Single-walled carbon nanotube (SWCNT)@metal-organic framework (MOF) field-effect transistor (FET) sensors generate a signal through analytes restricting ion diffusion around the SWCNT surface. Four composites made up of SWCNTs and UiO-66, UiO-66-NH2, UiO-67, and UiO-67-CH3 were synthesized to explore the detection of norfentanyl (NF) using SWCNT@MOF FET sensors with different pore sizes. Liquid-gated FET devices of SWCNT@UiO-67 showed the highest sensing response toward NF, whereas SWCNT@UiO-66 and SWCNT@UiO-66-NH2 devices showed no sensitivity improvement compared to bare SWCNT. Comparing SWCNT@UiO-67 and SWCNT@UiO-67-CH3 indicated that the sensing response is modulated by not only the size-matching between NF and MOF channel but also NF diffusion within the MOF channel. Additionally, other drug metabolites, including norhydrocodone (NH), benzoylecgonine (BZ), and normorphine (NM) were tested with the SWCNT@UiO-67 sensor. The sensor was not responding toward NH and or BZ but a similar sensing result toward NM because NM has a similar size to NF. The SWCNT@MOF FET sensor can avoid interference from bigger molecules but sensor arrays with different pore sizes and chemistries are needed to improve the specificity.

VOC Mixture Sensing with a MOF Film Sensor Array: Detection and Discrimination of Xylene Isomers and Their Ternary Blends.

Detection and recognition of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are crucial in many applications. While pure VOCs can be detected by various sensors, the discrimination of VOCs in mixtures, especially of similar molecules, is hindered by cross-sensitivities. Isomer identification in mixtures is even harder. Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) with their well-defined, nanoporous, and versatile structures have the potential to improve the VOC sensing performance by tailoring the adsorption affinities. Here, we detect and identify ternary xylene isomer mixtures by using an array of six gravimetric, quartz crystal microbalance (QCM)-based sensors coated with selected MOF films with different isomer affinities. We use classical molecular simulations to provide insights into the sensing mechanism. In addition to the attractive interaction between the analytes and the MOF film, the isomer discrimination is caused by the rigid crystalline framework sterically controlling the access of the isomers to different adsorption sites in the MOFs. The sensor array has a very low limit of detection of 1 ppm for each pure isomer and allows the isomer discrimination in mixtures. At 100 ppm, 16 different ternary o-p-m-xylene mixtures were identified with high classification accuracy (96.5%). This work shows the unprecedented performance of MOF-sensor arrays, also referred to as MOF-electronic nose (MOF-e-nose), for sensing VOC mixtures. Based on the study, guidelines for detecting and discriminating complex mixtures of volatile molecules are also provided.

Computational Design of MOF-Based Electronic Noses for Dilute Gas Species Detection: Application to Kidney Disease Detection.

The diverse chemical composition of exhaled human breath contains a vast amount of information about the health of the body, and yet this is seldom taken advantage of for diagnostic purposes due to the lack of appropriate gas-sensing technologies. In this work, we apply computational methods to design mass-based gas sensor arrays, often called electronic noses, that are optimized for detecting kidney disease from breath, for which ammonia is a known biomarker. We define combined linear adsorption coefficients (CLACs), which are closely related to Henry's law coefficients, for calculating gas adsorption in metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) of gases commonly found in breath (i.e., carbon dioxide, argon, and ammonia). These CLACs were determined computationally using classical atomistic molecular simulation techniques and subsequently used to design and evaluate gas sensor arrays. We also describe a novel numerical algorithm for determining the composition of a breath sample given a set of sensor outputs and a library of CLACs. After identifying an optimal array of five MOFs, we screened a set of 100 simplified computer-generated, water-free breath samples for kidney disease and were able to successfully quantify the amount of ammonia in all samples within the tolerances needed to classify them as either healthy or diseased, demonstrating the promise of such devices for disease detection applications.