Cytodynamics of the immune response in two lines of mice genetically selected for "high" and "low" antibody synthesis.

Two lines of mice have been separated by selective breeding for the character "agglutinin production to heterologous erythrocytes." Around the 18th generation of selection the two lines could be considered as homozygous for the character investigated. This trait is under the control of a group of additive genes. The interline difference in the production of anti-SE agglutinins was verified for the range of antigen doses from subimmunogenic to maximal. After intravenous immunization with an optimal dose of SE, the duration of the exponential rise in serum antibody was 4-5 days in both lines. At this time most of the interline difference in responsiveness is already expressed. A cytodynamic study carried out in terms of plaque-forming cells (PFC) and rosette-forming cells (RFC) in the spleen during the exponential phase showed that the principal interline difference is found in the doubling time of cells engaged in the immune response. More precise cytodynamic analysis made in terms of RFC showed that the doubling time of RFC is 9 hr in high responder and 16 hr in low responder mice. The duration of the exponential rise and the number of target cells stimulated by antigen is the same in both lines. The interline difference at the end of the exponential rise (4 days postimmunization) is larger in terms of serum antibody (30-40-fold) than in terms of PFC or RFC (20- and 11-fold, respectively). A morphological study of RFC in nonimmunized mice showed that about 90% of rosettes were formed by small lymphocytes in both lines. The remainder were medium-sized lymphocytes. At the peak of the cellular response the RFC have differentiated into large lymphocytes, blast cells, and plasma cells. The contribution of plasma cells to RFC is much greater in the high than in the low line. The cytodynamic and morphologic results presented in this article are compatible with the hypothesis that the group of genes segregated in each line during the selective breeding control and regulate the rate of multiplication and differentiation of the antibody-producing cells.

Genetic control of macrophage functions. I. Polygenic regulation of phagocytosis stimulation produced by Glyceryl Trioleate.

The phagocytic index K, established from the rate of blood clearance of colloidal carbon, measures the phagocytic activity of RE macrophages in contact with the circulating blood. The intravenous injection of glyceryl trioleate (triolein) produces a marked stimulation of the phagocytic activity of RE macrophages. This response is higher in the female than in the male mice. The phenotypic character "responsiveness of macrophage to triolein" presents large individual variants in population of random bred albinos mice. This character is submitted to polygenic regulation. Starting from a foundation population of 25 males and 25 females random bred albinos, mice, two lines were separated by selective breeding for the character "responsiveness to triolein": a "high" responder line, KTH, and a "low" responder line, KTL. After 26 consecutive generations of selective breeding, KTH mice present a very high response to triolein while KTL mice are almost irresponsive. The heritability of this character (h2) calculated from the interline divergence is of 12% plus or minus 1. This value of h2 indicates that the character investigated is determined by the cumulative effect of a group of about 27 independently segregating loci. The distribution of the character in (KTH plus KTL)F1 and their backcrosses with parental lines suggests that low responsiveness is dominant over high responsiveness. The genetic regulation of responsiveness to triolein is independent from the dose administered. These results are discussed in relation to the importance of genetic factors controlling macrophage functions involved in lipid metabolism and in the specific mechanisms of immunity.

Genetic regulation of the specific and non-specific component of immunity.

Bi-directional selective breeding for antibody (Ab) responsiveness to heterologous erythrocytes (Selection I) produced a high (H) and a low (L) responder line of mice which were also remarkably separated for Ab responses to many unrelated natural antigens (Ags) such as heterologous proteins, viruses, bacteria, parasites and haptens carried by these immunogens. The character "quantitative Ab responsiveness" is controlled by several independently segregating loci (polygenic regulation). The major genetic modification is produced at the level of macrophage activities. The Ag is slowly catabolized and persists for a long time on the macrophage membrane of the H line, whereas it is rapidly destroyed in L line macrophages. The bactericidal and bacteriostatic activity of the macrophage is also strong in the L line and weak in the H line. The opposite genetic regulation of Ab responsiveness and macrophage activity is a fundamental phenomenon for understanding natural and vaccination-induced anti-infectious immunity. The L line is more resistant than the H line against the infections due to intracellular microorganisms (Salmonellae, Yersinia, Mycobacteria, Brucellae, Leishmania) where the macrophage plays the dominant defensive barrier. The H line is more resistant than the L line to the extracellular microorganisms which are efficiently counteracted by a strong antibody response (Pneumococcus, Klebsiella, Plasmodia, Trypanosoma). The intensity of T cell-mediated immunity as measured by delayed type hypersensitivity, which is independent of the genetic regulation of antibody responsiveness, is correlated with the degree of nonspecific inflammation produced at the site of the reaction by the Ag injection in non-sensitized mice.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

[Genetic selection of mice for quantitative responsiveness of lymphocytes to phytohemagglutinin]. / Sélection génétique de souris d'après l'intensité de la transformation blastique des lymphocytes induite par la phytohémagglutinine

A two-way selection was performed in mice according to the quantitative response of small lymphocytes to the mitogenic activity of phytohaemagglutinin (PHA). The response of inguinal lymph node cells of each mouse to an optimal dose of PHA was measured by 3H-thymidine incorporation using a micro-plate method. Starting from four outbred mouse strains we mated on the one hand mice getting the best response and on the other hand mice getting the poorest response. A progressive separation of the two lines was observed. At the 7th generation a 3-fold difference was found between the two lines. A similar interline difference was observed when concanavalin A (ConA) was used as mitogen. The separation of the two lines was also evident when spleen cells or thymus cells were cultured with PHA or ConA.

Genetic difference in the proliferative response to T mitogens between Hi/PHA and Lo/PHA lymphocytes is independent of accessory cell function.

The role of the macrophage as accessory cell in the proliferative response of lymphocytes to phytohemagglutinin (PHA) was studied in two lines of mice genetically selected for high and low responsiveness to T mitogens. Adherent cell depletion of lymph node cells abrogated the low (Lo)/PHA response, but only partially inhibited the high (Hi)/PHA response. Addition of peritoneal cells provided either by Hi/PHA or by Lo/PHA mice equally restored Hi/PHA responsiveness but had only a slight reconstituting effect on the inhibited Lo/PHA response. Equivalent enhancement or suppression of proliferation of untreated lymph node cells was obtained by the addition of increasing percentages of each of the two peritoneal cell populations. However, the maximum level of the Lo/PHA response never reached that of Hi/PHA cells. These data indicate that the bidirectional selective breeding has not modified the potentialities of the macrophages as accessory cells but has resulted in an impaired response of Lo/PHA lymphocytes to the signals delivered either by accessory cells or by T mitogens.

Impact of genetically regulated T cell proliferation on acquired resistance to Listeria monocytogenes.

Two lines of mice genetically selected for high and low in vitro responses to PHA were used to evaluate the impact of T cell polyclonal expansion on acquired resistance to Listeria monocytogenes. The selective breeding induced two major consequences in low responder mice: (1) a reduction of the number of L3T4+ cells and (2) a restriction of T cell expansion upon PHA stimulation, predominantly affecting the Lyt-2+ subset, and associated with an abridgment of IL-2 production. In vivo PHA stimulation induced anti-Listeria protection in high responder mice, but was much less effective in low responder mice. Flow cytometer analysis revealed that T cell proliferation was also reduced in low responder mice during the course of Listeria infection, implying both L3T4+ and Lyt-2+ subsets. This defect did not apparently influence the kinetics of bacterial elimination in host tissues, which was similar in both lines during primary Listeria infection. In contrast, the expression of delayed-type hypersensitivity to Listeria antigens and the level of immunologic memory were significantly reduced in low responder mice. In vivo selective T cell depletion by anti-L3T4 or anti-Lyt-2 mAb allowed us to demonstrate the predominant role of Lyt-2+ cells in protection and that of L3T4+ cells in the expression of delayed-type hypersensitivity.

Genetic selection of mice for quantitative responsiveness of lymphocytes to phytohemagglutinin.

A two-way selection was performed in mice according to the quantitative in vitro response of lymph node lymphocytes to the mitogenic activity of phytohemagglutinin (PHA). The foundation population was composed of outbred mice produced by reciprocal mating of equal numbers of mice from four different colonies. The selective breeding was carried out by mating of mice at each generation giving the best or the lowest response, respectively. The progressive interline separation produced by 6 generations of selective breeding demonstrates that responsiveness to PHA is submitted to polygenic regulation. The heritability of the character investigated is 0.28 +/- 0.08. The interline separation is also found with another T mitogen, concanavalin A (Con A). In spleen cells PHA and Con A produce a similar interline difference. In contrast, the purified protein derivative of tuberculin (PPD) stimulated both lines equally, and E. coli lipopolysaccharide gave only a slightly higher response in high line. This finding implies that our selection based upon response to PHA did not influence B cell function.

In vitro viability of lymphoid cells from lines of mice genetically selected for high or low responsiveness to phytohemagglutinin.

The kinetics of viability of lymph node and spleen cells of mice genetically selected for "high" or "low" in vitro lymphocyte responsiveness to PHA were studied in PHA or PPD-stimulated short-term cultures. Lo/PHA cells were found to be less viable than Hi/PHA cells in unstimulated control cultures. PHA improved the viability of Lo/PHA cells while inducing proliferation of Hi/PHA cells with the appearance of more and larger lymphoblasts in the latter. PPD only improved the viability of spleen cell cultures, more so for the Hi/PHA line. The interline difference in thymidine uptake was smaller after PPD than after PHA stimulation. Modifications of culture conditions designed to decrease the interline difference in cell viability lessened but did not abolish the separation between the two lines for the PHA response as measured by thymidine uptake.

[Genetic regulation of T-lymphocyte responsiveness to PHA is independent of culture conditions (author's transl)]. / La régulation génétique de la réponse des lymphocytes T a la PHA est indépendante des conditions de culture.

A maximal interline separation has been obtained after 10 consecutive generations of selective breeding for the character "quantitative in vitro response of lymph node lymphocytes to the mitogenic effect of phytohaemagglutinin". At the selection limit the difference between high and low responder lines was about 20-fold. A similar interline separation has been demonstrated for the T-mitogen effect of concanavalin A. The identical response to PPD (purified protein derivative of tuberculin), a B mitogen, proved that the genetic selection has only modified the potentialities of T lymphocytes. During the selective breeding, responsiveness to PHA stimulation has been always measured under identical culture conditions. To demonstrate that the interline difference in responsiveness was due essentially to genetic factors independent of environmental effects, a systematic study of various culture conditions has been undertaken. The optimal stimulation was found after two days of culture for high line cells and after three days for low line cells. The difference between maximal responses was only slightly lower than that obtained after a two-day culture as used for the selection test. Increase in cell concentrations produced higher thymidine incorporation. In the two lines, a linear correlation was established between the cell concentration and the response produced. The maximal response given by the highest number of low line lymphocytes was equivalent to that given by a number, 11-fold smaller, of high line cells. Within certain limits, changes in the amount of tritiated thymidine added to the culture did not affect the interline separation. With a thymidine of high specific activity, a sub-evaluation of uptake by high line cells decreased the interline difference. Results in mixed culture of lymph node cells from high and low lines indicated that the low response was not due to the release of inhibiting factors or to the presence of suppressive cells in low responder mice. In conclusion, separation of these two lines was due to genetic factors acting independently of the cell culture conditions.

Effects of T mitogens on in vivo antibody production to a T-dependent antigen in lines of mice genetically selected for high or low in vitro responsiveness to PHA.

The influence of genes which regulate the in vitro T-cell proliferative response to T mitogen upon in vivo antibody production to a T-dependent antigen was studied in two lines of mice genetically selected for a high or a low in vitro lymphocyte response to phytohaemagglutinin (PHA). Kinetics of agglutinin production to increasing doses of sheep erythrocytes was similar in the two lines, except for the titres of mercaptoethanol-resistant antibodies, which were slightly lower in the low-responder line. Treatment with mitogen prior to immunization modified the antibody response in the two lines differently. This finding would indicate that the genes which regulate in vitro stimulation of T cells by PHA also control in vivo activation of T-cell subsets involved in immunoresponsiveness.

Collagen-induced arthritis in Biozzi mice. Joint involvement is not correlated with collagen II IgG2a autoantibodies nor restricted to only H-2q and H-2r.

High (H) and low (L) immune responder "Biozzi" mice, obtained by four different selections, were investigated for their ability to develop collagen-induced arthritis. Both LI and LII lines--characterized by their low antibody responses to a wide variety of Ag--developed arthritis though they do not bear the susceptible H-2q and H-2r haplotypes. Out of the two lines (HI and HII) selected for their high antibody responses and bearing H-2q, only one (HI) developed arthritis. Both the lines with amplified high or low antibody responses (HG and LG), and the lines differing in the levels of cell-mediated immunity (Hpha and Lpha), failed to develop arthritis. Collagen II autoantibodies were found in all the lines: the responses being high (HI and HG), low (LI, LII and LG), or intermediate (HII, Hpha and Lpha). The level of IgG2a autoantibodies, presumed to be the most pathogenic, was low in two (HI and LII) of the three arthritic lines, and was high in the unaffected HG line. These results show that this arthritis is not solely restricted to H-2q and H-2r haplotypes, and argue against a correlation between collagen autoantibody levels and disease incidence.

Differential expression of migration inhibitory and migration stimulatory factors in two lines of mice genetically selected for high or low responsiveness to phytohemagglutinin. 2. Effects of mitogenic or allogeneic stimulation.

Expression of migration inhibition factor (MIF) following in vitro stimulation with phytohemagglutinin (PHA) or allogeneic cells was explored in two lines of mice genetically selected for the high (Hi/PHA) or low (Lo/PHA) response of their lymphoid cells to PHA. Hi/PHA mice also have greater cell-mediated immune responses in mixed lymphocyte culture and graft-versus-host reactions, the poorer cell-mediated immune response of Lo/PHA being accompanied by a higher frequency of malignant tumours. Expression of MIF in PHA-pulsed spleen cell supernatants measured by a sensitive photoelectric method was found to be modulated by the concomitant presence of migration stimulation factor (MStF) derived from T cells. Both lymphokines were better expressed in Lo/PHA, as compared to Hi/PHA, under appropriate experimental conditions. Use of a low proliferative dose of mitogen (5 micrograms/ml PHA, 2-hour pulse) followed by culture in serum-free medium led Lo/PHA to express the highest titres of MIF, whereas a proliferative dose of PHA (50 micrograms/ml, 2-hour pulse) caused abrogation or occultation of expression of MIF and elective expression of MStF in this line. Hi/PHA mice expressed MIF equally at both mitogen doses, with transient expression of MStF followed by MIF after 50 micrograms/ml PHA, the kinetics of expression of the two lymphokines being different. Expression of MStF by spleen cells was an early event after PHA stimulation. In contrast to mitogenic stimulation, allogeneic stimulation in one-way mixed lymphocyte culture led to similar expression of MIF by both lines of mice. The implications of these findings are discussed.

T-cell compartment involvement in two high antibody responder lines of mice (HI and HII Biozzi mice) respectively susceptible and resistant to collagen-induced arthritis.

The T-cell compartment was investigated in two high antibody responder lines of mice respectively susceptible (HI) and resistant (HII) to chicken collagen (CII)-induced arthritis (CIA). Previous data had shown that both lines were high anti-CII Ab producers, without any TCR V-beta gene defect or membrane expression impairment. The present studies demonstrate that anti-CII proliferation is much lower in HII than in HI. These results are confirmed by the limiting dilution analysis of anti-CII T-precursor frequencies (1/991 in HI and 1/12175 in HII). The percentage of CD8+ T cells is constitutively higher in HII mice, this difference increasing after CII immunization. This finding suggests a suppressive effect accounting for resistance to CIA. However, no restoration of specific response was achieved by in-vivo or in-vitro depletion of CD8+ T cells. T clones specific for Chicken CII could be obtained only from primed HI mice. Four of five clones with CD8+ phenotype proliferated in vitro to native and denatured CII and showed cytotoxic function in an anti-CD3 redirected assay. The CD4+ clone was shown to proliferate on both HI and HII-pulsed APC, which rules out a major CII processing/presentation defect in HII.

Migration stimulation factor (MStF), from murine B cells, constitutively produced by a T-B hybridoma.

Hybridomas were established between murine spleen B cells and the thymoma cell line BW5147, to purify the migration stimulation factor (MStF), a molecule likely involved in immunosuppression. The parental B cells were from Lo/PHA mice previously shown to produce high levels of MStF after immunization by appropriate (tolerogenic) doses of ovalbumin. Among the positive clones, B9 was selected, since it produced high levels of MStF constitutively, and no immunoglobulin. This clone was shown to contain the genome of the B-cell fusion partner, since one of its L chain genes had undergone a VK-JK rearrangement. Isolation of MStF by size-exclusion chromatography showed 2 major peaks of activity, one of which eluted in a 20-kDa, almost protein-free fraction. This elution is unlikely to correspond to the true molecular mass, since MStF was found not to be a protein. Indeed, MStF was TCA-soluble, thermoresistant, highly hydrophobic and protease-resistant, but activity was abolished by neuraminidase digestion. The possibility of its being a small molecule transported by a protein carrier was also ruled out. These results suggest that MStF is a complex molecule containing both sialic residues and a lipid moiety. Experiments are planned to further investigate the chemical structure of this unusual B-cell factor.

Genetics of acute inflammation: inflammatory reactions in inbred lines of mice and in their interline crosses.

Acute inflammation is induced by the subcutaneous injection of swollen polyacrylamide microbeads, its intensity measured by the cell and protein concentration of the local exudates. A large and continuous range of responses is obtained in different inbred strains of mice, which suggests a polygenic control of the inflammatory response. The variable levels of the global dominance observed in F1 hybrids issued from several parental combinations indicated that the pattern of alleles controlling high or low response was different in each parental strain. Balanced intercrossing of the 8 inbred strains studied has provided a genetically heterogeneous F3 population, presenting a high variability of responses. The value of the genetic part of F3 phenotypic variance, the spread of the interstrain differences, as well as the polygenic nature of the regulation of inflammatory responses pointed out the possibility to perform a bidirectional genetic selection by using the F3 mice as the foundation population, and response to microbeads as the selective phenotypic character.

Differential expression of migration inhibitory and migration stimulatory factors in two lines of mice genetically selected for high or low responsiveness to phytohemagglutinin. 1. Migration stimulatory factor(s) from T and B cells of immune spleen.

Expression of the lymphokine migration inhibition factor in two lines of mice genetically selected for the high (Hi/PHA) or low (Lo/PHA) response of their lymph node cells to phytohemagglutinin was found to be modulated by concomitant expression of migration stimulation factor(s) [MStF(s)]. The expression of both lymphokines was dependent on genetic character and the immunizing dose of antigen. In mice immunized 5 days earlier with 50 micrograms ovalbumin in Freund's complete adjuvant (Ova in FCA immune), migration inhibition factor, assessed with a sensitive photoelectric method, was well expressed by male spleen or lymph node 24-hour culture supernatants of Lo/PHA but Hi/PHA, especially female, expressed marked MStF(s) instead. Immunization with 500 micrograms Ova in FCA markedly enhanced expression of MStF(s) in Lo/PHA but inhibited it in Hi/PHA. MStF(s) of Ova in FCA immune spleens of the two lines were found to derive from both T and B cells, B cell activity being greater. Lo/PHA were by far better expressors of both T- and B-cell-derived MStF(s) as compared to Hi/PHA (p less than 0.01). Spleen cells of mice immunized with FCA alone also expressed MStF(s) but to lesser extent than Ova in FCA immune spleens, expression by Lo/PHA B cells being significantly higher than in Hi/PHA (p less than 0.05). The MStF(s) of Ova in FCA immune spleens was found to be non-immunoglobulin in nature.

Functional differences in the specific B-cell compartment in high or low antibody responder mice.

The role of antigen-presenting cells (APC) in quantitative antibody synthesis regulation was studied in mice genetically selected for high (HI) or low (LI) antibody response. Irradiated spleen cells and enriched specific B cells from HI and LI mice co-isogenic at H-2s locus, were compared for their capacity to present chicken ovalbumin (OVA) to specific T-cell hybridomas. Minor differences were observed between HI and LI mice when three distinct hybridomas were stimulated in the presence of OVA and splenic macrophages APC. These differences were totally abolished when APC were pulsed with OVAxAb complexes. Looking at the B-cell compartment, hybridoma IL-2 responses were similar when TNP primed B cells were pulsed with OVA. However, when OVA was targeted on TNP-specific enriched B cells by pulsing with TNP-OVA, the IL-2 production by the T-cell hybridomas was stronger in the presence of HI B cells than in the presence of LI B cells. These results strongly suggest that an efficient Ag handling/processing by specific B cells is a major component of the high Ab responder status in Biozzi mice.

Susceptibility and resistance to Leishmania amazonensis in H-2q syngeneic high and low antibody responder mice (Biozzi mice).

H-2 syngeneic H and L (Biozzi) mice provide a model to study Leishmania infections in which polar resistant and susceptible phenotypes are independent from H-2 differences. High-Ab-responder (H) and low-Ab-responder (L) mice syngeneic at the H-2 locus (H-2q) were, respectively, susceptible and highly resistant to Leishmania amazonensis infection. L-mice resistance was associated with high IFN-gamma and transient IL-4 production by lymph node (LN) cells, in contrast with sustained IL-4 and decreasing IFN-gamma production by susceptible H mice. IL-12 production could be detected only in LN from resistant mice. The cytokine production pattern was consistent with preferential progression to a Th1-type response in resistant L-mice, and to a Th2-type response in susceptible H-mice. We also investigated whether this shift towards Th1- or Th2-type cytokine responses was dependent upon H or L antigen presenting cells' (APC) intrinsic ability to preferentially stimulate either T-cell subset. To this end, LN-derived T-cell lines were grown from 12-day infected mice, when both strains produced IFN-gamma and IL-4. L-derived T-cell lines developed a Th2 cytokine pattern whereas H-derived T-cell lines produced IFN-gamma, IL-4 and IL-10 whatever the APC origin (H or L) used for their derivation. This work constitutes the first characterization of cellular immune responses to the intracellular parasite, L. amazonensis in H-2 syngeneic mice, an infection model in which polar resistant and susceptible phenotypes are determined by non-MHC genes.