Feedback induction of suppressor T-cell activity.

Adoptively transferred carrier immune T cells interact with nonimmune T cells in recipients in a fashion which generates specific immunosuppression although both the immune and normal cells function quite well as helper cells when not admixed.

Genetic control of immunoregulatory circuits. Genes linked to the Ig locus govern communication between regulatory T-cell sets.

Antigen-stimulated Ly1:Qa1+ cells induce a nonimmune set of T-acceptor cells (surface phenotype Ly123+Qa1+) to participate in the generation of specific suppressive activity. The experiments reported here were designed to test the possibility that the interaction between T-inducer and T-acceptor cells might be governed by genes linked to the Ig locus. We find that inducer:acceptor interactions occur only if the inducer and acceptor T-cell sets are obtained from donor that are identical at the Ig locus and are independent of the Ig locus expressed on the B cells used for assay of T-helper activity. In addition, experiments using inducer and acceptor T cells from the congenic recombinant BAB. 14 strain show that T-T interactions are not governed by Ig-CH genes, per se. These data indicate that T-inducer: T-acceptor interactions are governed by Ig-linked genes that may control expression of VH-like structures on T cells, or control expression of as yet unidentified cell-surface molecules.

Suppressor cells: dependence on assay conditions for functional activity.

Spleen cells educated in vitro with sheep red blood cells (SRBC) suppressed the plaque-forming cell response of Mishell-Dutton assay cultures challenged with optimal doses of SRBC. Changing conditions in the assay cultures changed the effect educated cells had on the assay culture responses. For example, educated cells helped rather than suppressed assay cultures of suboptimal numbers of spleen cells. Similarly, augmentation resulted upon addition of educated cells to assay cultures challenged with suboptimal doses of SRBC. Such a reversal of regulatory effects was not observed when assay cultures were challenged with supraoptimal antigen doses. Educated cells helped assay cultures of B spleen cells, and the addition of normal T cells reinstated suppression. Furthermore, maintenance of assay cultures under stationary rather than the usual rocking conditions allowed educated cells to help rather than suppress the antibody response of assay cultures. These results show that when the response of the target population (assay cultures) is low, the regulator (educated) cells augment the response, and vice versa, supporting the hypothesis that the effect regulator cells produce depends on the activity of the cells they regulate.

Immunoglobulin idiotopes expressed by T cells. I. Expression of distinct idiotopes detected by monoclonal antibodies on antigen-specific suppressor T cells.

The idiotopic repertoire expressed by antigen-specific suppressor T cells (Ts) generated by Streptococcus pneumoniae strain R36a (Pn) in BALB/c strain mice was investigated using a panel of five monoclonal anti-idiotopic antibodies against TEPC-15/HOPC-8 myeloma proteins. Previous studies suggested that the anti-idiotopic antibodies recognize distinct idiotopic determinants within the T15 idiotype, and that Pn-reactive B cells express all of those idiotopes as shown by a specific inhibitory effect of the anti-idiotopic antibodies on induction of anti-Pn response in vitro as well as on the mature antibody plaque-forming cells. In this study we asked the question of whether anti-idiotopic (Id) can block the inductive and/or effector phases of generation of Ts which act on the Pn-reactive B cells. The presence of anti-Id during the activation of T cells with Pn did not prevent the generation of Ts. However, suppression mediated by Ts on responder lymphocytes (cultures of spleen cells or B cels) was inhibited (reversed) by four out of five anti-Id. Some of the antibodies recognize hapten (phosphorylcholine)-inhibitable Id in the paratope of Ig whereas others are directed against nonparatopic Id. These data indicate that the antigen receptor on Ts includes VH sequences both within and without the immunoglobulin in paratope, and that the Id repertoir of Ts overlaps with that of B cells.

Immunoregulatory circuits that modulate responsiveness to suppressor cell signal. Failure of B10 mice to respond to suppressor factors can be overcome by quenching the contrasuppressor circuit.

The in vitro antibody response of spleen cells from B10 strain mice is not suppressed by factor preparations made by primed Ly-2 T cells, although these preparations can suppress the in vitro antibody response of spleen cells from other mouse strains (1-3)2. The factor preparations from Ly-2 cells contain at least two separable activities: one that acts as a suppressor moiety (Ly-2 T cell suppressor factor [Ly-2 TsF]) and a second factor that acts as an inducer of contrasuppression (Ly-2 TcsiF); the latter initiates a series of cellular interactions that leads to the inhibition of suppression that we refer to as contrasuppression. Removal of components (either cellular or humoral) of the contrasuppressor circuit makes spleen cells from B10 strain mice as easily suppressible as are those of other mouse strains. Thus, removal of the contrasuppressor inducer cell and/or its biologically active product with the use of an anit-J serum, or removal of the functional acceptor of the inducer cell with the same or other (Ly-2; Qa-1) antisera breaks the B10 suppressor barrier. Contrasuppressive activity. but not helper activity can be eluted from anit-I-J immunoabsorbents. The addition of B10 T cells to either B6 or B10 spleen cell culture deprived of acceptor cells for the TcsiF reconstitutes contrasuppression more efficiently than does the addition of C57BL/6 T cells. Ly-2 TcsiF is more cross-reactive than is Ly-2 TsF so that absorption of factor preparations from sheep erythrocyte-primed Ly-2 cells with horse erythrocytes also breaks the B10 suppressor barrier. The hyperresponsiveness of splenic T cells from B10 strains to Ly-2 TcsiF may be an in vitro exaggeration of a normal in vivo process. Thus it is possible that one can take advantage of this unusual situation to help dissect out the cellular and subcellular components of T cell circuits that moldulate sensitivity to immunoregulatory signals.

Immunoregulatory circuits among T-cell sets. Identification of a subpopulation of T-helper cells that induces feedback inhibition.

Purified Ly1 cells induce other T-cell sets to exert potent feedback inhibitory activity and this T-T interaction has been shown to play an important role in regulating in vivo immune responses. Approximately 2/3 of Ly1 cells also express the Qa1 surface phenotype (Ly1:Qa1+ cells). The experiments reported here indicate that Ly1:Qal+ cells are responsible for induction of feedback inhibition and that signals from both Ly1:Qal+ cells and Ly1:Qal- cells are required for optimal formation of antibody by B cells.

Contrasuppression. A novel immunoregulatory activity.

We have described an interaction between two T cells subsets that results in interference with the expression of Ly-1-, 2+ (Ly-2) T cell-mediated suppression. We refer to this novel immunoregulatory activity as contrasuppression. The T cell responsible for the induction of contrasuppression (inducer cell) expresses the phenotype Ly-1-, 2+;I-J+;Qa-1+. This phenotype distinguishes it from the suppressor effector cells which we find to be I-J-2.3. An I-J+ soluble mediator from the contrasuppressor inducer cell acts on another cell (acceptor cell) that expresses the phenotype Ly-1+, 2+; I-J+; Qa-1+. This phenotype distinguishes it from T helper cells. Both the inducer cell (or its biologically active mediator) and its acceptor cell are required for the expression of contrasuppression. Because contrasuppressor cells can block the suppressive activity of cell-free mediators released by Ly-2 suppressor T cells, the mechanism of contrasuppression is either separated from or in addition to the inactivation of suppressor cells themselves. The potential importance of contrasuppressor activity in the regulation of suppressor T cell activity in allowing immunologic memory to be expressed and in permitting microenvironmental immune regulation is discussed.

Immunoregulatory circuits among T-cell sets. I. T-helper cells induce other T-cell sets to exert feedback inhibition.

These experiments test the hypothesis that cells carrying the Ly1+23- surface phenotype are programmed exclusively for helper and not suppressive activity regardless of external conditions such as the mode or type of antigen stimulation. To this end, we have stimulated purified populations of Ly1 cells with antigen in vitro using conditions devised to induce unselected T cells to express optimal levels of antigen specific T-suppressor activity. We find that after such stimulation, Ly1 cells generate SRBC-specific T-helper activity but not T-suppressive activity. These findings establish that the Ly1.2+,2.2/3.2- surface phenotype is a stable, and probably invariant, marker of T cells that are programmed to express only helper activity and have lost the capacity to directly suppress the antibody response. These findings support the concept that the genetic program for a single differentiated set of cells combines information for cell surface phenotype and function. We also demonstrate that antigen-stimulated Ly1 cells, in addition to inducing B cells to secrete antibody, can induce or activate other sets of resting T cells to develop profound suppressive effects. The surface phenotype of this feedback suppressive T-cell set is shown to be: Ly1+2+3+Qa1+. These findings, taken together, indicate that activation of resting Ly123 cells by immune Ly1 TH cells may represent an important homeostatic immunoregulatory mechanism.

Glycosylphosphatidylinositol: a candidate system for interleukin-2 signal transduction.

The mechanism of interleukin-2 (IL-2) signal transduction was analyzed by use of an inducible B lymphoma. Like normal antigen-activated B lymphocytes, the lymphoma cells respond to IL-2 by proliferating and differentiating into antibody-secreting cells; both responses are blocked by a second interleukin, IL-4. Analyses of the signaling pathway showed that IL-2 stimulated the rapid hydrolysis of an inositol-containing glycolipid to yield two possible second messengers, a myristylated diacylglycerol and an inositol phosphate-glycan. The myristylated diacylglycerol response exhibited the same IL-2 dose dependence as the growth and differentiative responses, and the generation of both hydrolysis products was inhibited by IL-4. These correlations implicate the glycosyl-phosphatidylinositol system in the intracellular relay of the IL-2 signal.

Feedback suppression: an immunoregulatory circuit.

The basic elements of the feedback suppression circuit of T cell interactions are summarized. Ly1 T cells can be stimulated directly to become inducers of Ly2+ T suppressor cells or helper cells for B cells that produce antibody to erythrocyte antigens. Ly2 cells can be activated to become suppressors only in the presence of Ly1 cells. An Ly1,2,3, cell is the acceptor of the Ly1 inducer signal. Using an intermediate culture technique, it can be shown that Ly1 inducers are a target of suppressor T cell activity.

Cloned T cells with "co-helper" activity. I. Biologic activities of the clone.

Clones of sheep erythrocyte-(SRBC) specific helper T cells with the surface phenotype Thy-1+, Ly-1+, Ly-2- have been derived that grow in vitro in the absence of exogenous antigen or added growth factors. The IL 2-independent clone, 101.6 has been shown to produce a supernatant factor that augments the primary anti-SRBC but not anti-burro RBC responses of whole spleen cells or Ly-1 T plus B cell cultures. The supernatant does not help B cells directly. This augmenting activity is terminated "co-helper" because the enhancement requires the presence of normal Ly-1 T cells. The supernatant of 101.6 was not shown to contain IL 2; co-helper activity was distinguishable from IL 2 activity by absorption with SRBC but not with Con A blasts, and we observed that co-helper activity does not act on spleen cells that differ at the major histocompatibility complex.

Suppressive effects of insulin and insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF1) on immune responses.

This paper describes conditions wherein the serum peptides insulin and IGF1, which are typically associated with growth-promoting functions, can suppress in vitro immune responses. IL 2-induced proliferation of lymphocytes as well as in vitro antibody-producing cultures are suppressed by physiologic concentrations of IGF1 or by superphysiologic concentrations of insulin. Suppression of IL 2-induced proliferation is not overcome by increasing the IL 2 concentration and is mediated only during the first 24 to 48 hr of the 110-hr incubation period required to measure the proliferative response to IL 2. By analogy to other biologic systems, these effects of insulin and of IGF1 are probably mediated by occupancy of the IGF1-receptor, which is cross-occupied by insulin at superphysiologic concentrations. These data support the possibility of a novel function for these endocrine and endocrine-like peptides and also expands their range of biologic activities to within the immune system.

Interleukin 2-dependent phosphorylation of interleukin 2 receptors and other T cell membrane proteins.

The addition of IL 2 to Con A-activated splenic T cells induced the rapid and time-dependent phosphorylation of membrane proteins with m.w. of 115,000 to 105,000, 90,000, and 66,000, and to a lesser extent 55,000 to 58,000, 40,000, and 34,000. Immunoprecipitations conducted with an anti-IL 2 receptor antibody indicated that the murine IL 2 receptor (55,000 to 58,000) was included in the set of IL 2-dependent phosphoproteins. Phosphorylation of these same proteins was also seen after IL 2 treatment of PHA-activated T cells and of the IL 2-dependent line CTLL-2. Membrane phosphorylation was dependent on physiologically relevant IL 2 concentrations (0.2 to 1 ng/ml), and was detected as early as 1 min after IL 2 addition, with maximal levels of phosphorylation achieved by 15 min. In contrast to these observations, the pattern of cytoplasmic protein phosphorylation remained unchanged after IL 2 addition, although IL 2 did augment the level of preexisting cytoplasmic phosphorylation induced by lectin. The pattern of membrane protein phosphorylation induced by IL 2 also overlapped in part with that induced after stimulation of Con A-activated T cells with the phorbol ester PMA. IL 2-stimulated phosphorylation was inhibited by the addition of agents that both stimulate cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinases and block lymphocyte mitogenesis. No effect was seen upon addition of agents that enhance cyclic GMP-dependent protein kinases. These observations support a role for specific membrane as opposed to cytoplasmic protein phosphorylation in the regulation of lymphocyte growth by IL 2, and also suggest that protein kinase A, and perhaps protein kinase C, participate as regulators of the IL 2 signaling mechanism.

Recall of specific suppression: co-dominance of suppression after primary or secondary antigen stimulation.

Mouse spleen cells primed in vivo with beta-galactosidase (GZ), and cultured in vitro with trinitrophenyl beta-galactosidase (TNP-GZ), make a very poor anti-TNP response compared to cultures of normal spleen cells. The lack of response is caused by active suppression as indicated by cell mixture experiments. At 2-months following priming, while the helper effect predominates, suppression can be recalled by rechallenge of the mice with GZ. Both primary suppression (after a single injection) and secondary suppression (after two injections) reduce the response of normal or carrier-primed helper cells at equivalent cell ratios in mixture experiments. Both kinds of suppression are carrier specific, slectively suppress high avidity antibody production, and require cell division to suppress the response of normal cells. The only difference between primary and secondary suppression is that primary suppression is obliterated in cultures which are not challenged with antigen until 24 hr after cultures are established. Secondary suppression is still observed when cultures receive TNP-GZ at 24 hr. Suppression appears to be an early component of both primary and secondary responses. The regulatory function of such suppression may be the delay of antibody secretion.

Induction of specific suppressor T cells in vitro.

We describe conditions for generating sheep red blood cell-specific suppressor T cells in Mishell-Dutton cultures. The production of specific suppressor cells is favored by increasing antigen dose in the initial culture but can be produced by transferring more cells when lower doses of antigen are used. Transfer of small numbers of cells cultured with low doses of antigen leads to a specific helper effect. Transfer of large numbers of educated cells leads to nonspecific suppression. Suppression can be effected by the effluent cells from nylon wool columns which do not make detectable PFC. A fraction of these cells become resistant to treatment with anti-T cell sera and complement after culture. The suppressor cells are radiation sensitive and must be able to synthesize protein to suppress. They take 2 to 3 days of education to reach maximum suppressive efficiency and will not suppress cultures if added 2 to 3 days after culture initiation. Their production is favored by the absence of mercaptoethanol, suggesting that the observed suppression is not "too much help". The ability to generate specific suppressor cells in vitro should be of great benefit in determining the factors that regulate their appearance in vivo.

Modulation of help and suppression in a hapten-carrier system.

Provision of beta-galactosidase (GZ) under defined conditions of dose and time can either help or suppress a subsequent response to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-GZ in CBA/J mice. The optimal helper effect occurs when 10(7) spleen cells from mice primed 9 or more days previously with 10 mug GZ are adoptively transferred to irradiated recipients which are than challenged with 10 mug TNP50GZ. Optimum suppression results from the transfer of spleen cells from mice primed 3 days previously with 100 mug GZ and challenge of recipients with TMP150GZ. Both help and suppression are carrier-specific and mediated by T cells. In experiments where helper or suppressor cells were mixed with normal cells, the anti-TNP response was proportional to the number of primed cells transferred. The results point to a wave of suppression as the initial event after immunization, which is succeeded by period in which the helper effect dominates.

Antigen-antibody complexes produced in chickens tolerant to bovine serum albumin.

A radioimmunoassay for circulating soluble antigen-antibody complexes is described. The assay detects complexes either in antigen or antibody excess. Soluble complexes were found in the sera of chickens tolerant to bovine serum albumin (BSA). The complexes appeared in the serum as soon as 7 days following neonatal induction of tolerance. The amount of complexes reached a peak between 1 to 2 weeks of age and disappeared by 6 weeks when responsiveness returned. The complexes were found in the bottom third of a 10 to 40% sucrose density gradient and by analytical ultracentrifugation indicated a size of 22.8S. If tolerant chickens were challenged with BSA at 2, 4 or 6 weeks, the disappearance of complexes was not accelerated, and a proportion of the previously tolerant chickens exhibited a heightened antibody response.

Suppressor cells in mice infected with Trypanosoma brucei.

Within 2 to 3 days of infection with Trypanosoma brucei strain S42, the ability of spleen cells from infected CBA mice to mount a primary in vitro antibody response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) is profoundly reduced, and suppressor cells are generated as detected by cell mixture experiments. Suppressor cell activity lies in the T and adherent cell compartments of spleens from infected mice, but not in the B cell compartment, although antibody responses to a thymus-independent antigen, DNP-Ficoll, are significantly reduced. Suppression of antibody responses of normal spleen cells depends on viable cells from infected mice. The trypanosome, itself, plays no direct role in suppression, and we have ruled out the possibility of antigenic competition as a mechanism of suppression. Our data is consistent with the model of suppressor T cells induced by concanavalin A mitogenesis. We hypothesize that trypanosome antigens may directly stimulate T cells with the concomitant release of factors with affinity for macrophage surfaces thus becoming suppressive for T and B cell responses.

Immunochemical characterization of the mucoid exopolysaccharide of Pseudomonas aeruginosa.

Alginic acid-like mucoid exopolysaccharide was isolated from three strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa obtained from the sputa of patients with cystic fibrosis. Purified mucoid antigens were greater than 99% uronic acid. With a hemagglutination assay, antibody responses to the mucoid exopolysaccharide were documented after immunization of rabbits with either whole mucoid organisms or purified mucoid exopolysaccharide. The mucoid antigen from one strain (no. 2192) was composed predominantly of a single serologic epitope shared among 40 alginate exopolysaccharides from different clinical isolates. The mucoid exopolysaccharide from the other two strains (nos. 1 and 258) had a serotype-specific determinant in addition to the common epitope. Analyses of antibody in sera from normal adults, children, and patients with cystic fibrosis culture-positive and culture-negative for mucoid P. aeruginosa showed a highly significant (P less than 0.001) association between increased hemagglutination titers and positive cultures for mucoid P. aeruginosa.

Role of Ly-1:Qa1- and Ly-1:Qa1+ inducer T cells in activation of Ly-23 effectors of suppression of antibody production in mice.

Ly-2+ effectors of T cell-mediated suppression require inducing signals from antigen and a helper cell bearing the Ly-1+:Qa1+ surface phenotype. In this report, we have further examined the helper cell requirements for suppressor cell induction of antibody production in mice. By using the T cell subset education procedure in vitro, we have activated T cells to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) antigens and then purified Ly-2 cells before testing for suppressor activity in assay cultures of defined T and B cell subsets. We have confirmed our previous observations that Ly-1+:Qa1+ cells are required for activation of T suppressors, but have found that under the appropriate conditions, there is not a strict requirement for the Ly-123 subset of T cells. Furthermore, if Ly-23 cells are stimulated in the presence of Ly-1+:Qa1- T cells, effective suppressors can be obtained only if a source of Ly-1:Qa1+ inducers is added to the assay culture. If Ly-23 cells are activated by antigen in the absence of Ly-1 cells, subsequent exposure to the Ly-1+:Qa1+ subset under the conditions tested here is not sufficient to activate suppressors. These results show that effectors of suppression, like B cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes, may respond to two helper cells.