Definitions and methods of cost assessment: an intensivist's guide. ESICM section on health research and outcome working group on cost effectiveness.

OBJECTIVE: To define the different types of costs incurred in the care of critically ill patients and to describe some of the most commonly used methods for measuring and allocating these costs. DESIGN: Literature review. Definitions for opportunity, direct and indirect, fixed, variable, marginal, and total costs are described and interpreted in the context of the critical care setting. Two main methods of costing are described: the 'top-down' and 'bottom-up' methods together with a number of cost proxies, such as the use of weighted hospital days, diagnosis-related groups, severity and activity scores, and effective costs per survivor. CONCLUSIONS: The assessment and allocation of costs to critically ill patients is complex and as a result of the different definitions and methods used, meaningful comparisons between studies are plagued with difficulty. When undertaking a study looking to measure costs, it is important to state: (a) the aim of the cost assessment study; (b) the perspective (point of view); (c) the type of costs that need to be measured; and (d) the time span of assessment. By being explicit about the rationale of the study and the methods used, it is hoped that the results of economic evaluations will be better understood, and hence implemented within the critical care setting.

A new method of accurately identifying costs of individual patients in intensive care: the initial results.

OBJECTIVES: To analyse the patient-related and non-patient-related costs of intensive care using an activity-based costing methodology. DESIGN: A retrospective cost analysis of 68 patients admitted sequentially over a 10-week period. SETTING: The Adult General Intensive Care Unit of the Royal Hallamshire Hospital, Sheffield. RESULTS: The results showed large variations in the costs obtained for individual patients. The calculation of the costs for the initial period of stay showed a wide variation depending on whether the costs were determined per calendar day or per first 24-h period. Significant correlations of costs between the first 24 h of stay and the admitting Acute Physiology and Chronic Health II score (p < 0.004) and daily costs with the Therapeutic Intervention Scoring System scores (p < 0.0001) were found. The average daily patient-related cost of care was Pounds 592. Overhead costs were calculated at Pounds 560 per patient day, which made the total cost of a day's treatment in intensive care Pounds 1152. CONCLUSIONS: The use of average costs or scoring systems to cost intensive care is limited, as these methods cannot determine actual resource usage in individual patients. The methodology described here allows all the resources used by an individual patient or group of patients to be identified and thus provides a valuable tool for economic evaluations of different treatment modalities.

Cost considerations for the use of low-air-loss bed therapy in adult intensive care.

The aim of this study was to consider the costs of low-air-loss bed therapy in the adult intensive care unit (ICU). A retrospective cost analysis was performed on 269 consecutive patients, 63 of whom had received low-air-loss bed therapy. Patients' APACHE II scores, length of stay (LOS), average daily TISS and ICU outcomes were also collected. Patients' APACHE II and LOS were further studied using odds ratios to test for an association between these factors and likelihood of receiving bed therapy. A prospective 10-week study to identify the amount of nursing time spent repositioning patients was also performed. The results of this study found the bed therapy to represent approximately 3% of the total average cost of care per patient. Patients requiring the bed therapy had higher APACHE II scores on admission, higher average daily TISS points and a longer length of ICU stay. Study of the odds ratios would suggest that the likelihood of patients receiving low-air-loss bed therapy increases if their APACHE II score on admission is between 11 and 20 and they stay > 4.5 days in the ICU. The results of the prospective study found the daily cost of repositioning patients to be 172.80 Pounds per patient.

Clinical applications of electrical impedance tomography.

This article is a preliminary review of the possible clinical applications of electrical impedance tomography (EIT). The applications to, for example, the central nervous, respiratory, cardiovascular and digestive systems are covered. It is concluded that the area of greatest potential application of EIT is monitoring cardiopulmonary function, but that studies on much larger groups of patients than have been carried out hitherto are required to fully assess the potential of EIT as a clinical tool.

The cost of a hospital ward in Europe: is there a methodology available to accurately measure the costs?

Costing health care services has become a major requirement due to an increase in demand for health care and technological advances. Several studies have been published describing the computation of the costs of hospital wards. The objective of this article is to examine the methodologies utilised to try to describe the basic components of a standardised method, which could be applied throughout Europe. Cost measurement however is a complex matter and a lack of clarity exists in the terminology and the cost concepts utilised. The methods discussed in this review make it evident that there is a lack of standardized methodologies for the determination of accurate costs of hospital wards. A standardized costing methodology would facilitate comparisons, encourage economic evaluation within the ward and hence assist in the decision-making process with regard to the efficient allocation of resources.

International Programme for Resource Use in Critical Care (IPOC)--a methodology and initial results of cost and provision in four European countries.

BACKGROUND: A standardized top-down costing method is not currently available internationally. An internally validated method developed in the UK was modified for use in critical care in different countries. Costs could then be compared using the World Health Organization's Purchasing Power Parities (WHO PPPs). METHODS: This was an observational, retrospective, cross-sectional, multicentre study set in four European countries: France, UK, Germany and Hungary. A total of 329 adult intensive care units (ICUs) participated in the study. RESULTS: The costs are reported in international dollars ($) derived from the WHO PPP programme. The results show significant differences in resource use and costs of ICUs over the four countries. On the basis of the sum of the means for the major components, the average cost per patient day in UK hospitals was $1512, in French hospitals $934, in German hospitals $726 and in Hungarian hospitals $280. CONCLUSIONS: The reasons for such differences are poorly understood but warrant further investigation. This information will allow us to better adjust our measures of international ICU costs.

Minor procedures in the accident and emergency department: can Entonox help?

The efficacy of Entonox as a supplement to local anaesthesia for minor surgical procedures was studied. Eighty-five patients undergoing surgery for the incision and drainage of a subcutaneous abscess using a local anaesthetic were involved in a trial to ascertain the level of pain associated with such procedures and to investigate the possibility of using on-demand Entonox to supplement the local anaesthesia provided. Patients received either the standard local anaesthesia, or, alternatively, the local anaesthesia was supplemented with oxygen or Entonox via on-demand apparatus. Patients indicated on three linear visual analogue scales their pain, anxiety and total discomfort, and also on a cartoon pain rating scale, at different stages during the operation. Results showed that there was no statistically significant reduction in pain provided by the Entonox, despite general patient approval. Both oxygen and Entonox showed some anxiolytic properties. Pure oxygen was also seen to produce a rise in heart rate, while both gases (pure oxygen and Entonox) caused an increase in diastolic blood pressure. It was also seen that the patient's short term memory of the pain experienced was unaffected by pure oxygen or Entonox.

Postoperative analgesia after triple nerve block for fractured neck of femur.

Fifty patients with fractured neck of femur that required surgical correction with either a compression screw or pin and plate device were randomly allocated to receive one of two anaesthetic techniques, general anaesthesia combined with either opioid supplementation or triple nerve block (three in one block) with subcostal nerve block. The nerve blocks significantly reduced the quantity of opioid administered after operation; 48% of these patients required no additional analgesia in the first 24 hours. Plasma prilocaine levels in these patients were well below the toxic threshold, and peak absorption occurred 20 minutes after the injection. No untoward sequelae were associated with the nerve blocks.

Status asthmaticus. Management of status asthmaticus complicated by surgical emphysema--avoidance of intermittent positive pressure ventilation.

The management of a case of status asthmaticus complicated by surgical emphysema is described. In view of voice changes, intubation was necessary but intermittent positive pressure ventilation was considered unwise, because of the surgical emphysema. A means of maintaining adequate sedation in an intubated patient whilst allowing spontaneous respiration is outlined.

Laminar flow enclosure-a possible risk to the patient.

A retrospective comparison was made between two groups of 50 adult patients who underwent open-heart surgery in an operating suite with two adjacent rooms, one of which was equipped with a laminar flow enclosure. Core and body surface temperatures were measured at 15-min intervals for the 1st h after commencement of surgery. Patients in a laminar flow enclosure showed a significantly greater decrease in core temperature with time. Possible means of counteracting this are suggested.

Use of etomidate in an intensive care unit.

A resumé of two studies and retrospective survey of 52 patients in an intensive care unit receiving infusions of etomidate has demonstrated that the technique can be used effectively and safely to provide sedation in patients requiring artificial ventilation and those breathing spontaneously. In both studies all measured respiratory and cardiovascular indices remained within normal limits. There was a low incidence of muscle movements in all groups and there was no nausea, vomiting, or allergic reactions. Additionally, the technique was readily accepted by the patients.

Evaluation of proposed casemix criteria as a basis for costing patients in the adult general intensive care unit.

This study analyses the relationship between the actual patient-related costs of care calculated for 145 patients admitted sequentially to an adult general intensive care unit and a number of factors obtained from a previously described consensus of opinion study. The factors identified in the study were suggested as potential descriptors for the casemix in an intensive care unit that could be used to predict the costs of care. Significant correlations between the costs of care and severity of illness, workload and length of stay were found but these failed to predict the costs of care with sufficient accuracy to be used in isolation to define isoresource groups in the intensive care unit. No associations between intensive care unit mortality, reason for admission and intensive and unit treatments and costs of care were found. Based on these results, it seems that casemix descriptors and isoresource groups for the intensive care unit that would allow costs to be predicted cannot be defined in terms of single factors.

The effect of dobutamine on middle cerebral artery blood velocity in volunteers: a preliminary study.

Five volunteers given dobutamine up to 4 micrograms/kg/min had significant increases in mean arterial blood pressure, systolic blood pressure, and stroke volume (P less than 0.05). Heart rate did not increase significantly. Pulsatility index, an index of middle cerebral artery maximum blood velocity waveform shape increased significantly in the dobutamine group (P less than 0.05). Time-averaged mean velocity did increase during the dobutamine infusion but the change was not statistically significant. Dobutamine significantly alters the blood velocity profile of the middle cerebral artery in volunteers even in low doses of 4 micrograms/kg/min. Transcranial Doppler may be a useful technique to monitor changes in cerebral artery blood velocity dynamics induced by dobutamine. These measurements can be performed easily and repeatedly at the bedside.

Evaluation of a local anaesthesia regimen following mastectomy.

Breast surgery can be emotionally distressing and physically painful. Acute pain following surgery is often related mainly to the axillary surgery and is aggravated by arm and shoulder movement. We conducted a prospective double-blind, randomised, placebo-controlled trial to determine the influence of local anaesthetic irrigation of axillary wound drains on postoperative pain during the first 24 h following a modified Patey mastectomy (mastectomy with complete axillary node clearance). The treatment group received bupivacaine irrigation through the axillary wound drain 4-hourly for 24 h postoperatively. Controls received irrigation with normal saline. Morphine via a patient controlled analgesia pump was used for postoperative analgesia. Morphine consumption, visual analogue and verbal rating pain scores were recorded. There were no statistical differences in morphine requirements or pain scores between the two groups, nor were there differences in anti-emetic or supplemental analgesic consumption. Bupivacaine irrigation used in this manner does not appear to offer an effective contribution to postoperative analgesia.

Variations in expenditure between adult general intensive care units in the UK.

This paper presents the findings from the second pilot study of the cost block method in 21 adult general intensive care units (ICUs). The aim of this study was to explore the possible reasons for the variation in cost identified in a previous pilot study of 11 ICUs. Data were collected for the six cost blocks for the financial year 1996/97. Multivariate analysis showed that 93% of the variation in expenditure on disposable equipment could be explained by the number of ICU beds, the number of admissions and the presence of a high-dependency unit (HDU). Ninety-two per cent of the variation in nursing staff expenditure was explained by the number of ICU beds and the presence of an HDU. Hospital type and the number of patient days explained 76% of the variation in expenditure on consultant staff. Sixty-four per cent of the variation in drug and fluid expenditure was explained by the number of patient days.

A computerized prospective audit of cardiopulmonary resuscitation in the accident and emergency department.

A prospective survey of cardiopulmonary resuscitation is in progress in the Accident and Emergency Department of the Royal Hallamshire Hospital. During the 12 months from January 1985 to January 1986, 123 cardiac arrests were treated in the accident department. Ninety of these arrests occurred outside the hospital; nine of these patients survived to leave hospital. Of the 33 people arresting in the department, 10 survived to leave hospital. The causes of death are presented.