Identity elements for specific aminoacylation of yeast tRNA(Asp) by cognate aspartyl-tRNA synthetase.

The nucleotides crucial for the specific aminoacylation of yeast tRNA(Asp) by its cognate synthetase have been identified. Steady-state aminoacylation kinetics of unmodified tRNA transcripts indicate that G34, U35, C36, and G73 are important determinants of tRNA(Asp) identity. Mutations at these positions result in a large decrease (19- to 530-fold) of the kinetic specificity constant (ratio of the catalytic rate constant kcat and the Michaelis constant Km) for aspartylation relative to wild-type tRNA(Asp). Mutation to G10-C25 within the D-stem reduced kcat/Km eightfold. This fifth mutation probably indirectly affects the presentation of the highly conserved G10 nucleotide to the synthetase. A yeast tRNA(Phe) was converted into an efficient substrate for aspartyl-tRNA synthetase through introduction of the five identity elements. The identity nucleotides are located in regions of tight interaction between tRNA and synthetase as shown in the crystal structure of the complex and suggest sites of base-specific contacts.

Magnesium-dependent alternative foldings of active and inactive Escherichia coli tRNA(Glu) revealed by chemical probing.

A stable conformer of Escherichia coli tRNA(Glu), obtained in the absence of Mg(2+), is inactive in the aminoacylation reaction. Probing it with diethylpyrocarbonate, dimethyl sulfate and ribonuclease V1 revealed that it has a hairpin structure with two internal loops; the helical segments at both extremities have the same structure as the acceptor stem and the anticodon arm of the native conformer of tRNA(Glu)and the middle helix is formed of nucleotides from the D-loop (G15-C20:2) and parts of the T-loop and stem (G51-C56), with G19 bulging out. This model is consistent with other known properties of this inactive conformer, including its capacity to dimerize. Therefore, this tRNA requires magnesium to acquire a conformation that can be aminoacylated, as others require a post-transcriptional modification to reach this active conformation.

Search of essential parameters for the aminoacylation of viral tRNA-like molecules. Comparison with canonical transfer RNAs.

Comparative structural and functional results on the valine and tyrosine accepting tRNA-like molecules from turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV) and brome mosaic virus (BMV), and the corresponding cognate yeast tRNAs are presented. Novel experiments on TYMV RNA include design of variant genes of the tRNA-like domain and their transcription in vitro by T7 RNA polymerase, analysis of their valylation catalyzed by yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase, and structural mapping with dimethyl sulfate and carbodiimide combined with graphical modelling. Particular emphasis is given to conformational effects affecting the valylation capacity of the TYMV tRNA-like molecule (e.g., the effect of the U43----C43 mutation). The contacts of the TYMV and BMV RNAs with valyl- and tyrosyl-tRNA synthetases are compared with the positions in the molecules affecting their aminoacylation capacities. Finally, the involvement of the putative valine and tyrosine anticodons in the tRNA-like valylation and tyrosylation reactions is discussed. While an anticodon-like sequence participates in the valine identity of TYMV RNA, this seems not to be the case for the tyrosine identity of BMV RNA despite the fact that the tyrosine anticodon has been shown to be involved in the tyrosylation of canonical tRNA.

Contact areas of the turnip yellow mosaic virus tRNA-like structure interacting with yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase.

The tRNA-like structure of turnip yellow mosaic virus is known to be efficiently recognized and aminoacylated by valyl-tRNA synthetase. The present work reports domains in the isolated tRNA-like fragment (159 terminal nucleotides at the 3'-end of the two viral RNAs) in contact with purified yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase. These domains were determined in protection experiments using chemical and enzymatic structural probes. In addition, new data, re-enforcing the validity of the tertiary folding model for the native RNA, are given. In particular, at the level of the amino acid accepting arm it was found that the two phosphate groups flanking the three guanine residues of loop I are inaccessible to ethylnitrosourea. This is in agreement with a higher-order structure of this loop involving "pseudo knotting", as proposed by Rietveld et al. (1982). Valyl-tRNA synthetase efficiently protects the viral RNA against digestion by single-strand-specific S1 nuclease at the level of the anticodon loop. With cobra venom ribonuclease, specific for double-stranded regions of RNA, protection was detected on both sides of the anticodon arm and at the 5'-ends of loop I, a region that is involved in the building up of the acceptor arm. Loop II, which is topologically homologous to the T-loop of canonical tRNA was likewise protected. Weak protection was observed between arms I and II, and at the 3'-side of arm V. This arm, located at the 5'-side of arm IV (homologous to the D-arm of tRNA), does not participate in the pseudo-knotted model of the valine acceptor arm. Ethylnitrosourea was used to determine the phosphates of the tRNA-like structure in close contact with the synthetase. These are grouped in several stretches scattered over the RNA molecule. In agreement with the nuclease digestion results, protected phosphates are located in arms I, II, and III. Additionally, this chemical probe permits detection of other protected phosphates on the 3'-side of arm IV and on both sides of arm V. When displayed in the three-dimensional model of the tRNA-like structure, protected areas are localized on both limbs of the L-shaped RNA. It appears that valyl-tRNA synthetase embraces the entire tRNA-like structure. This is reminiscent of the interaction model of canonical yeast tRNAVal with its cognate synthetase.

Solution structure of the 3'-end of brome mosaic virus genomic RNAs. Conformational mimicry with canonical tRNAs.

The conformation of the last 201 nucleotides located at the 3'-end of brome mosaic virus (BMV) RNAs was investigated in solution using different chemical and enzymatic probes. Bases were probed with dimethylsulfate (which methylates N-1 positions of A, N-3 positions of C and N-7 positions of G), a carbodiimide (which modifies N-1 positions of G and N-3 positions of U) and diethylpyrocarbonate (which modifies N-7 positions of A). Ribonucleases T1, U2 and S1 were used to map unpaired nucleotides and ribonuclease V1 to monitor paired bases or stacked nucleotides. Cleavage or modification sites were detected by gel electrophoresis either indirectly by analyzing DNA sequence patterns generated by primer extension with reverse transcriptase of the modified RNAs or by direct identification within the statistical cleavage patterns of the RNA. On the basis of these biochemical results, an atomic model was built by computer modeling and its stereochemistry refined. The deduced secondary structure of the RNA confirms data previously proposed by others but contains additional base-pairs (A27-U32, A28-G31, G41-A134, G64-C68, U80-A99, G81-A98, G88-U91, G100-U126, U104-U125, G162-G166 and A172-A191), one new tertiary long-range interaction (U103-U164) and a small triple helical conformation with (G41-A134)-A18 and (C42-G133)-A17 interactions. The new secondary structure also indicates the existence of a second pseudoknot involving pairing between residues A181 to A184 and residues U197 to U194, outside the domain conferring tyrosylation ability to BMV RNA. The main outcome from the model stems from its intricate folding, which allows a new assignment for the domains mimicking the anticodon- and D-loop regions of tRNA. Interestingly, the stem and loop region found structurally to be analogous to the anticodon arm of tRNA(Tyr) does not contain the tyrosine anticodon involved in the aminoacylation process. The structural analogies with canonical tRNA(Tyr) illustrate the functional mimicry existing between the BMV RNA structure and canonical tRNA(Tyr) that allows for their efficient aminoacylation by tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase. This structural model rationalizes mutagenic and footprinting data that have established the importance of specific regions of the viral RNA for recognition by its replicase, (ATP,CTP):tRNA nucleotidyl-transferase and yeast tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase. The new fold has biological implications that can be used as a predictive tool for elaborating new experiments.

Major identity determinants for enzymatic formation of ribothymidine and pseudouridine in the T psi-loop of yeast tRNAs.

Almost all transfer RNA molecules sequenced so far contain two universal modified nucleosides at positions 54 and 55, respectively: ribothymidine (T54) and pseudouridine (psi 55). To identify the tRNA elements recognized by tRNA:m5uridine-54 methyltransferase and tRNA:pseudouridine-55 synthase from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a set of 43 yeast tRNA(Asp) mutants were used. Some variants contained point mutations, while the others included progressive reductions in size down to a tRNA minisubstrate consisting of the T psi-loop with only one G.C base-pair as stem (9-mer). All substrates (full-sized tRNA(Asp) and various minihelices) were produced in vitro by T7 transcription and tested using yeast extract (S100) as a source of enzymatic activities and S-adenosyl-L-methionine as a methyl donor. The results indicate that the minimal substrate for enzymatic formation of psi 55 is a stem/loop structure with only four G.C base-pairs in the stem, while a longer stem is required for efficient T54 formation. None of the conserved nucleotides (G53, C56, A58 and C61) and U54 for psi 55 or U55 for T54 formation can be replaced by any of the other three canonical nucleotides. Yeast tRNA:m5uridine-54 methyltransferase additionally requires the presence of a pyrimidine-60 in the loop. Interestingly, in a tRNA(Asp) variant in which the T psi-loop was permuted with the anticodon-loop, the new U32 and U33 residues derived from the T psi-loop were quantitatively converted to T32 and psi 33, respectively. Structural mapping of this variant with ethylnitrosourea confirmed that the intrinsic characteristic structure of the T psi-loop was conserved upon permutation and that the displaced anticodon-loop did not acquire a T psi-loop structure. These results demonstrate that a local conformation rather than the exact location of the U-U sequence within the tRNA architecture is the important identity determinant for recognition by yeast tRNA:m5uridine-54 methyltransferase and tRNA:pseudouridine-55 synthase.

Effect of conformational features on the aminoacylation of tRNAs and consequences on the permutation of tRNA specificities.

The structure and function of in vitro transcribed tRNA(Asp) variants with inserted conformational features characteristic of yeast tRNA(Phe), such as the length of the variable region or the arrangement of the conserved residues in the D-loop, have been investigated. Although they exhibit significant conformational alterations as revealed by Pb2+ treatment, these variants are still efficiently aspartylated by yeast aspartyl-tRNA synthetase. Thus, this synthetase can accommodate a variety of tRNA conformers. In a second series of variants, the identity determinants of yeast tRNA(Phe) were transplanted into the previous structural variants of tRNA(Asp). The phenylalanine acceptance of these variants improves with increasing the number of structural characteristics of tRNA(Phe), suggesting that phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase is sensitive to the conformational frame embedding the cognate identity nucleotides. These results contrast with the efficient transplantation of tRNA(Asp) identity elements into yeast tRNA(Phe). This indicates that synthetases respond differently to the detailed conformation of their tRNA substrates. Efficient aminoacylation is not only dependent on the presence of the set of identity nucleotides, but also on a precise conformation of the tRNA.

Molecular recognition of the identity-determinant set of isoleucine transfer RNA from Escherichia coli.

Molecular recognition of Escherichia coli tRNA(Ile) by the cognate isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase (IleRS) was studied by analyses of chemical footprinting with N-nitroso-N-ethylurea and aminoacylation kinetics of variant tRNA(Ile) transcripts prepared with bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase. IleRS binds to the acceptor, dihydrouridine (D), and anticodon stems as well as to the anticodon loop. The "complete set" of determinants for the tRNA(Ile) identity consists of most of the nucleotides in the anticodon loop (G34, A35, U36, t6A37 and A38), the discriminator nucleotide (A73), and the base-pairs in the middle of the anticodon, D and acceptor stems (C29.G41, U12.A23 and C4.G69, respectively). As for the tertiary base-pairs, two are indispensable for the isoleucylation activity, whereas the others are dispensable. Correspondingly, some of the phosphate groups of these dispensable tertiary base-pair residues were shown to be exposed to N-nitroso-N-ethylurea when tRNA(Ile) was bound with IleRS. Furthermore, deletion of the T psi C-arm only slightly impaired the tRNA(Ile) activity. Thus, it is proposed that the recognition by IleRS of all the widely distributed identity determinants is coupled with a global conformational change that involves the loosening of a particular set of tertiary base-pairs of tRNA(Ile).

Stimulatory effect of ammonium sulfate at high concentrations on the aminoacylation of tRNA and tRNA-like molecules.

The influence of various salts on the aminoacylation of tRNA(Val) and the tRNA-like structure from turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA by yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase has been studied. As expected, increasing the concentration of salts inhibits the enzymatic reaction. However, in the presence of high concentration of ammonium sulfate, and only this salt, the inhibitory effect is suppressed. Under such conditions, the aminoacylation becomes comparable to that measured in the absence of salt. It was shown that ammonium sulfate affects both the catalytic rate of the reaction and the affinity between valyl-tRNA synthetase and the RNAs. Because the affinity between the partners in the complex is increased when the concentration of the salt is high, it is suggested that hydrophobic effects are involved in tRNA/synthetase interactions.

Efficient aminoacylation of a yeast tRNA(Asp) transcript with a 5' extension.

A yeast aspartic acid tRNA with a 5' extension of 14 nucleotides was obtained by in vitro transcription with T7 DNA dependent RNA polymerase. This transcript, called extended tRNA(Asp) transcript, retains its aspartylation capacity with the same Km and only three times reduced kcat values as compared to those measured for canonical tRNA(Asp). This result indicates that the 5' extension of the amino acid acceptor stem of tRNA(Asp) does not interfere with recognition by aspartyl-tRNA synthetase. However, in contrast to the wild-type tRNA(Asp) transcript, the 5' extended molecule presents a reduced capacity to be mischarged by arginyl-tRNA synthetase, suggesting the existence of different structural requirements in aspartyl- and arginyl-tRNA synthetases for tRNA(Asp) recognition.

Valylation of tRNA-like transcripts from cloned cDNA of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA demonstrate that the L-shaped region at the 3' end of the viral RNA is not sufficient for optimal aminoacylation.

Clones containing different lengths of cDNA corresponding to the 3' region of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA were constructed and transcribed in vitro into the corresponding RNAs. Each transcript contained the L-shaped tRNA domain (N = 82) plus (i) in the case of 3 upstream sequences up to N = 93, 109 and 258; and (ii) in all cases an additional 6 nucleotide-stretch at the 5' end derived from the T7 promoter. The valylation of these molecules, as well as that of a fragment (N = 159) purified from viral RNA, was studied. Although all transcripts could be valylated by wheat germ valyl-tRNA synthetase, the 3 shorter fragments showed incomplete charging and slower rates, due mainly to lower Vmax values. Thus, although the tRNA-like L-shaped structure is the functional core permitting amino-acylation, upstream nucleotides between positions 82 and 159 play an important role in allowing the highest rates and levels of valylation. Structural arguments supporting this view are discussed.

Non-canonical substrates of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases: the tRNA-like structure of brome mosaic virus genomic RNA.

A 3-D model of the tyrosylable tRNA-like domain of the genomic brome mosaic virus RNAs was built by computer modelling based on solution probing of the molecule with different chemical and enzymatic reagents. This model encompasses four major structural domains, including two peculiar substructures oriented perpendicularly and mimicking a tRNA structure, and a fifth domain which makes the connection with the rest of the viral RNA. After recalling the different steps that led to the present structural knowledge of the BMV tRNA-like domain, we review its novel structural features revealed by the modelling and that did not appear in older versions of 3-D models of this structure. These features comprise additional base-pairs, hairpin loops, new tertiary long-range interactions, and a second pseudoknot. The main goal of this paper is to strengthen the validity of the model by establishing correlations between the putative 3-D conformation and the functional properties of the domain. For that, we show how the present structural model rationalises mutagenic and footprinting data that have established the importance of specific regions of the RNA for its recognition and aminoacylation by yeast tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase. We discuss further how the model corroborates mutational analyses performed to understand recognition of this RNA domain by the (ATP,CTP):tRNA nucleotidyl-transferase and by the viral replicase. The published mutants of the BMV tRNA-like domain fall into two classes. In one class, the mutants leave unchanged the overall architecture of the molecule, thereby affecting functions directly. In the second class, the overall architecture of the mutants is perturbed, and thus functions are affected indirectly.

The TYMV tRNA-like structure.

The genomic RNA from turnip yellow mosaic virus presents a 3'-end functionally and structurally related to tRNAs. This report summarizes our knowledge about the peculiar structure of the tRNA-like domain and its interaction with tRNA specific proteins, like RNAse P, tRNA nucleotidyl-transferase, aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, and elongation factors. It discusses also the biological role of this structure in the viral life cycle. A brief survey of our knowledge of other tRNA mimicries in biological systems, as well as their relevance for understanding canonical tRNA, will also be presented.

A pseudoknotted tRNA variant is a substrate for tRNA (cytosine-5)-methyltransferase from Xenopus laevis.

tRNA post-transcriptional modification enzymes of Xenopus laevis were proposed previously to belong to two major groups according to their sensitivity to structural perturbations in their substrates. To further investigate the structural variations tolerated by these enzymes, the tRNA-like domain of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA (88 nucleotides in length) has been microinjected into the oocytes of Xenopus laevis. This RNA possesses 12 potential target nucleotides for modification within a structure including a pseudoknotted folding, an extended anticodon stem, and unusual D-loop/T-loop interactions. Results indicate that only cytosine-42, a position equivalent to C-49 in canonical tRNAs, was quantitatively modified into m5C in the microinjected RNA. Modification was detected to high levels, indicating that at least one enzyme tolerates non-canonical structural features.

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases: a new image for a classical family.

The aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) are a family of enzymes well known for their role in protein synthesis. More recent investigations have discovered that this classic family of enzymes is actually capable of a broad repertoire of functions which not only impact protein synthesis, but extend to a number of other critical cellular activities. Specific aaRSs play roles in cellular fidelity, tRNA processing, RNA splicing, RNA trafficking, apoptosis, transcriptional and translational regulation. A recent EMBO workshop entitled 'Structure and Function of Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetases' (Mittelwihr, France, October 10-15, 1998), highlighted the diversity of the aaRSs' role within the cell. These novel activities as well as significant advances in delineating mechanisms of substrate specificity and the aminoacylation reaction affirm the family of aaRSs as pharmaceutical targets.

Aspartate identity of transfer RNAs.

Structure/function relationships accounting for specific tRNA charging by class II aspartyl-tRNA synthetases from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Escherichia coli and Thermus thermophilus are reviewed. Effects directly linked to tRNA features are emphasized and aspects about synthetase contribution in expression of tRNA(Asp) identity are also covered. Major identity nucleotides conferring aspartate specificity to yeast, E coli and T thermophilus tRNAs comprise G34, U35, C36, C38 and G73, a set of nucleotides conserved in tRNA(Asp) molecules of other biological origin. Aspartate specificity can be enhanced by negative discrimination preventing, eg mischarging of native yeast tRNA(Asp by yeast arginyl-tRNA synthetase. In the yeast system crystallography shows that identity nucleotides are in contact with identity amino acids located in the catalytic and anticodon binding domains of the synthetase. Specificity of RNA/protein interaction involves a conformational change of the tRNA that optimizes the H-bonding potential of the identity signals on both partners of the complex. Mutation of identity nucleotides leads to decreased aspartylation efficiencies accompanied by a loss of specific H-bonds and an altered adaptation of tRNA on the synthetase. Species-specific characteristics of aspartate systems are the number, location and nature of minor identity signals. These features and the structural variations in aspartate tRNAs and synthetases are correlated with mechanistic differences in the aminoacylation reactions catalyzed by the various aspartyl-tRNA synthetases. The reality of the aspartate identity set is verified by its functional expression in a variety of RNA frameworks. Inversely a number of identities can be expressed within a tRNA(Asp) framework. From this emerged the concept of the RNA structural frameworks underlying expression of identities which is illustrated with data obtained with engineered tRNAs. Efficient aspartylation of minihelices is explained by the primordial role of G73. From this and other considerations it is suggested that aspartate identity appeared early in the history of tRNA aminoacylation systems.

Conformation in solution of yeast tRNA(Asp) transcripts deprived of modified nucleotides.

A synthetic gene of yeast aspartic acid tRNA with a promoter for phage T7 RNA polymerase was cloned in Escherichia coli. The in vitro transcribed tRNA(Asp) molecules are deprived of modified nucleotides and retain their aspartylation capacity. The solution conformation of these molecules was mapped with chemical structural probes and compared to that of fully modified molecules. Significant differences in reactivities were observed in Pb2+ cleavage of the RNAs and in modification of the bases with dimethyl sulphate. The most striking result concerns C56, which becomes reactive in unmodified tRNA(Asp), indicating the disruption of the C56-G19 base pair involved in the D- and T-loop interaction. The chemical data indicate that unmodified tRNA(Asp) transcripts possess a relaxed conformation compared to that of the native tRNA. This conclusion is confirmed by thermal melting experiments. Thus it can be proposed that post-transcriptional modifications of nucleotides in tRNA stabilize the biologically active conformations in these molecules.

Exploring the aminoacylation function of transfer RNA by macromolecular engineering approaches. Involvement of conformational features in the charging process of yeast tRNA(Asp).

This report presents the conceptual and methodological framework that presently underlies the experiments designed to decipher the structural features in tRNA important for its aminoacylation by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. It emphasizes the importance of conformational features in tRNA for an optimized aminoacylation. This is illustrated by selected examples on yeast tRNA(Asp). Using the phage T7 transcriptional system, a series of tRNA(Asp) variants were created in which conformational elements were modified. It is shown that aspartyl-tRNA synthetase tolerates conformational variability in tRNA(Asp) at the level of the D-loop and variable region, of the tertiary Levitt base-pair 15-48 which can be inverted and in the T-arm in which residue 49 can be excised. However, changing the anticodon region completely abolishes the aspartylation capacity of the variants. Transplanting the phenylalanine identity elements into a different tRNA(Asp) variant presenting conformational characteristics of tRNA(Phe) converts this molecule into a phenylalanine acceptor but is less efficient than wild-type tRNA(Phe). This engineered tRNA completely loses its aspartylation capacity, showing that some aspartic acid and phenylalanine identity determinants overlap. The fact that chimeric tRNA(Asp) molecules with altered anticodon regions lose their aspartylation capacity demonstrates that this region is part of the aspartic acid identity of tRNA(Asp).

3-D graphics modelling of the tRNA-like 3'-end of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA: structural and functional implications.

The tRNA-like structure of the aminoacylatable 3'-end of turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV) RNA was submitted to 3-D graphics modelling. A model of this structure has been inferred previously from both biochemical results and sequence comparisons which presents a new RNA folding feature, the "pseudoknot". It has been verified that this structure can be constructed without compromising accepted RNA stereochemical rules, namely base stacking and preferential 3'-endo sugar pucker. The model has aided interpretation of previous structural mapping experiments using chemical and enzymatic probes, and new accessibilities of residues could be predicted and tested. Pseudoknots have been considered as potential splice sites because they form antiparallel helical segments in a single RNA molecule. We have examined this possibility with the constructed 3-D model and could verify the hypothesis on a structural basis. The model presents a striking similarity with canonical tRNA and allows a valuable comparison between the protection patterns of yeast tRNA(Val) and tRNA-like viral RNA by cognate yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase against structural probes.