High Variability in Type and Indications for Bone Void Filler in Tibial Plateau Fracture Repair.

Tibial plateau fractures are a common injury treated by orthopaedic trauma surgeons. Depression of the articular surface of the tibial plateau is often an associated injury pattern. The methods used to address depressed tibial plateau fractures can vary, as it has yet to be determined if the type of bone void filler utilized affects the long-term functional outcomes of patients with tibial plateau fractures. A 28-question survey was created to better elucidate the current practices used by orthopaedic surgeons and the factors influencing the selection of bone void fillers for treatment of these injuries. The survey was distributed online to Orthopaedic Trauma Association (OTA) members. There were 106 orthopaedic surgeons that completed the survey with a wide range of responses. The survey determined the current practice of orthopaedic surgeons varies widely when selecting bone void fillers in the treatment of depressed tibial plateau fractures. (Journal of Surgical Orthopaedic Advances 32(3):156-159, 2023).

The EMS stress view: occult pelvic instability revealed by pre-hospital pelvic binder placement.

PURPOSE: To describe and evaluate the serendipitous pelvic binder stress radiographs of lateral compression type (LC) pelvic ring injuries. METHODS: This was a retrospective case series performed at a single, level I academic trauma center from 2016 to 2018. All patients presenting with a minimally displaced LC pelvic ring injury were reviewed (< 10 cm displacement on static pelvic radiographs). Patients with X-rays (XR) in a pelvic binder (EMS stress) and with the pelvic binder removed were included. Pelvic ring stability was determined by attending surgeon evaluation of EMS stress radiographs versus static XR of the pelvis. Patients were treated non-operatively and allowed to weight bear or taken to the operating room for exam under anesthesia (EUA) and potential operative fixation. Clinical success of treatment was determined by evaluation of further displacement at the completion of their most recent follow-up. RESULTS: Thirty-seven patients of the initial 398 reviewed met inclusion criteria. Fourteen of 37 patients (38%) were categorized as stable with no significant pelvis displacement seen on EMS stress and were treated non-operatively without further sequelae (4.6 months mean follow-up). The remaining 23/37 (62%) were treated operatively. Occult instability was identified on EMS stress in 14 (61%) of those 23 patients and the remainder were determined to be unstable based upon fracture pattern or EUA. All patients went on to successful treatment without significant pelvic deformity (7.8 months mean follow-up). CONCLUSION: The EMS stress XR is a valuable, opportunistic evaluation in LC pelvic ring injuries. This evaluation is a useful diagnostic adjunct to alert the provider that additional stress imaging may be indicated to evaluate for occult pelvic ring instability.

Reduction and fixation of high-energy proximal tibiofibular joint dislocations: a technical trick.

We present our technique for screw stabilization and our clinical experience treating a series of patients presenting with proximal tibiofibular joint fracture-dislocations.

The effect of proximal tibiofibular joint dislocation on knee mechanics: reduction and fixation matters.

PURPOSE: Proximal tibiofibular joint (PTFJ) dislocations are under-investigated injuries. There is scant basic science or clinical evidence to direct management. The purpose of this study was twofold; first to investigate the pathomechanics of PTFJ dislocation on knee mechanics. The second purpose was to evaluate knee mechanics following reduction and fixation. METHODS: Six cadaveric legs were tested on a mechanical platform. A 5 Nm external rotation force was applied to each knee and the external rotation and fibular translation was measured for several study conditions at 0°, 30°, and 90° of flexion. Conditions included: the native state, transection of the posterior PTFJ ligament, transection of the anterior and posterior ligaments, screw fixation, and suspensory fixation. Screw fixation was performed using a single quadricortical 3.5 mm screw. Suspensory fixation was performed using an Arthrex TightRope device RESULTS: Transection of the anterior and posterior ligaments increased external rotation by 4.3°, 5.9°, and 5.6°, at 0°, 30°, and 90° (p ≤ 0.001), respectively. Screw and suspensory fixation returned external rotation to a near native state with mild overconstraint. Complete transection of anterior and posterior ligaments resulted in pathologic anterior fibular translation of 1.51 mm (p = 0.001), 1 mm, (p = 0.02) and 0.44 mm (p = 0.69) for 0°, 30°, 90° of knee flexion. Screw and suspensory fixation restored native translation at all points with a small degree of overconstraint. CONCLUSION: Disruption of the PTFJ causes pathologic external rotation and anterior fibular translation. Fixation restores near native motion with minor overconstraint. Surgeons should consider reduction and fixation of PTFJ injuries to restore native knee mechanics.

AP pelvis radiograph is insufficient for diagnosis of U-type sacral fractures.

PURPOSE: We investigated the sensitivity of a screening test for pelvic ring disruption, the AP pelvis radiograph, for clinically serious U-type sacral fractures which merit consultation with an orthopedic trauma specialist and may require transfer to a higher level of care. METHODS: Retrospective clinical cohort of 63 consecutive patients presenting with U-type sacral fractures at one level 1 trauma referral center from January 2006 through December 2019. The sensitivity of the first AP pelvis radiograph obtained on admission, interpreted without reference to antecedent or concomitant pelvis computed tomography (CT) by a radiologist and a panel of three blinded orthopedic traumatologists, was determined against a reference diagnosis made from review of all pelvis radiographs, CT images, operative reports, and clinical documentation. RESULTS: Sensitivity of AP pelvis radiograph for U-type sacral fractures was 2% as interpreted by a radiologist and mean 12% (range 5-27%) as interpreted by orthopedic traumatologists with poor inter-rater agreement (Fleiss' κ = 0.11). 94% of sacra were at obscured by radiographic artifact. CONCLUSION: The sensitivity of an AP pelvis radiograph is poor for U-type sacral fractures, whether interpreted by radiologists or orthopedic traumatologists. Pelvis CT should be considered as a screening test to rule out sacral fracture when the patient reports posterior pelvic pain, even if plain radiography demonstrates no injury or a minimally displaced pelvic ring disruption. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Diagnostic level III.

The Not-So-Simple Ankle Fracture: Avoiding Problems and Pitfalls to Improve Patient Outcome.

Ankle fractures are among the most common fractures encountered by orthopaedic surgeons and, in the setting of tibiotalar instability, are usually treated surgically. Although orthopaedic surgeons from diverse educational backgrounds often feel comfortable treating such fractures, many controversies and clinical challenges remain. A detailed understanding of the unique issues presented by each patient as well as the best available treatments are required to optimize outcome. Given the unforgiving soft-tissue envelope and the particular importance of both precise reduction and absolute stability, poorly conceived and executed surgery will predictably end in compromised patient outcomes. The purpose of this manuscript is to update practicing surgeons on the best strategies for improving patient outcome after ankle fracture. The focus will be on some of the more nuanced, controversial, and complex ankle fracture-related topics, both in terms of decision making and technical execution. These will include the optimal management of posterior malleolus fractures and syndesmosis injuries as well as the best strategies to minimizing risks in poor hosts such as diabetics, obese patients, and the frail elderly. We will also provide a framework with which surgeons can approach the salvage of patients in whom the initial management has failed.

Complications in patients with intramedullary nails: a case series from a single Cambodian surgical clinic.

PURPOSE: Since its development in 1999, the SIGN nail has been used in over 190,000 surgeries spanning 55 countries. To date, however, evaluation of SIGN nail outcomes has been limited to small prospective studies or large retrospective studies using SIGN's online database. This study uses the experience of a single, independent Cambodian surgical clinic to characterize common complications, provide commentary on ways to reduce the risk of those complications, and determine whether several observed nail fractures were due to metallurgic defects. METHODS: Clinic medical records were queried to identify complications in patients with SIGN nails. Data was abstracted including age, sex, mechanism of injury, and latency between injury, primary implantation, and presentation with a complication. Two nails that fractured in vivo were analyzed by light microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, and polarized light microscopy after chemical etching. RESULTS: Fifty-four complications in 51 patients were identified. The most common complications were non-union (n = 26, 48%), infection (n = 16, 30%), flexion limitation (n = 11, 20%), nail fracture (n = 4, 7%), delayed union (n = 4, 7%), and malunion (n = 4, 7%). Other complications included broken or floating screws. Fractography revealed that two of the fractured nails most likely failed by fatigue followed by fast fracture at the site of non-union. We found no evidence of intrinsic nail defects. We identified multiple inconsistencies between SIGN's database and independent clinic records. CONCLUSIONS: Non-union and infection were common relative to all complications. Based on radiographic review, risk for non-union and malunion can be minimized by selecting an appropriate nail diameter, using multiple interlocking screws, and employing the correct implant and approach for fracture morphology when using SIGN nails. Nail fractures were unlikely to be caused by metallurgical flaws. Further study is necessary to determine the appropriate management of non-unions based on radiographic and clinical factors.

Does the Watson-Jones or Modified Smith-Petersen Approach Provide Superior Exposure for Femoral Neck Fracture Fixation?

BACKGROUND: A well-reduced femoral neck fracture is more likely to heal than a poorly reduced one, and increasing the quality of the surgical exposure makes it easier to achieve anatomic fracture reduction. Two open approaches are in common use for femoral neck fractures, the modified Smith-Petersen and Watson-Jones; however, to our knowledge, the quality of exposure of the femoral neck exposure provided by each approach has not been investigated. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What is the respective area of exposed femoral neck afforded by the Watson-Jones and modified Smith-Petersen approaches? (2) Is there a difference in the ability to visualize and/or palpate important anatomic landmarks provided by the Watson-Jones and modified Smith-Petersen approaches? METHODS: Ten fresh-frozen human pelvi underwent both modified Smith-Petersen (utilizing the caudal extent of the standard Smith-Petersen interval distal to the anterosuperior iliac spine and parallel to the palpable interval between the tensor fascia lata and the sartorius) and Watson-Jones approaches. Dissections were performed by three fellowship-trained orthopaedic traumatologists with extensive experience in both approaches. Exposure (in cm) was quantified with calibrated digital photographs and specialized software. Modified Smith-Petersen approaches were analyzed before and after rectus femoris tenotomy. The ability to visualize and palpate seven clinically relevant anatomic structures (the labrum, femoral head, subcapital femoral neck, basicervical femoral neck, greater trochanter, lesser trochanter, and medial femoral neck) was also recorded. The quantified area of the exposed proximal femur was utilized to compare which approach afforded the largest field of view of the femoral neck and articular surface for assessment of femoral neck fracture and associated femoral head injury. The ability to visualize and palpate surrounding structures was assessed so that we could better understand which approach afforded the ability to assess structures that are relevant to femoral neck fracture reduction and fixation. RESULTS: After controlling for age, body mass index, height, and sex, we found the modified Smith-Petersen approach provided a mean of 2.36 cm (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.45-4.28 cm; p = 0.015) additional exposure without rectus femoris tenotomy (p = 0.015) and 3.33 cm (95% CI, 1.42-5.24 cm; p = 0.001) additional exposure with a tenotomy compared with the Watson-Jones approach. The labrum, femoral head, subcapital femoral neck, basicervical femoral neck, and greater trochanter were reliably visible and palpable in both approaches. The lesser trochanter was palpable in all of the modified Smith-Petersen and none of the Watson-Jones approaches (p < 0.001). All modified Smith-Petersen approaches (10 of 10) provided visualization and palpation of the medial femoral neck, whereas visualization of the medial femoral neck was only possible in one of 10 Watson-Jones approaches (p < 0.001) and palpation was possible in eight of 10 Watson-Jones versus all 10 modified Smith-Petersen approaches (p = 0.470). CONCLUSIONS: In the hands of surgeons experienced with both surgical approaches to the femoral neck, the modified Smith-Petersen approach, with or without rectus femoris tenotomy, provides superior exposure of the femoral neck and articular surface as well as visualization and palpation of clinically relevant proximal femoral anatomic landmarks compared with the Watson-Jones approach. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Open reduction and internal fixation of a femoral neck fracture is typically performed in a young patient (< 60 years old) with the objective of obtaining anatomic reduction that would not be possible by closed manipulation, thus enhancing healing potential. In the hands of surgeons experienced in both approaches, the modified Smith-Petersen approach offers improved direct access for reduction and fixation. Higher quality reductions and fixation are expected to translate to improved healing potential and outcomes. Although our experimental results are promising, further clinical studies are needed to verify if this larger exposure area imparts increased quality of reduction, healing, and improved outcomes compared with other approaches. The learning curve for the exposure is unclear, but the approach has broad applications and is frequently used in other subspecialties such as for direct anterior THA and pediatric septic hip drainage. Surgeons treating femoral neck fractures with open reduction and fixation should familiarize themselves with the modified Smith-Petersen approach.

Intraosseous Shelf Plate Fixation for Depressed Articular Fragments in Tibial Plateau Fractures: A Technical Trick and Case Series.

SUMMARY: Tibial plateau fractures with severely displaced articular injuries and significant deformity to the surrounding metaphyseal bone (including the hyperextension varus bicondylar pattern) can be challenging to stabilize due to resulting large bone voids uncontained by metaphyseal cortex. The purpose of this report was to describe a technique to support the plateau articular surface in these cases and report on outcomes of a small series. This technique uses a small or mini fragment plate, contoured to function as an intraosseous shelf plate, with the "shelf" portion inserted into the bone beneath the articular surface to support it. This technique provides fixed-angle support to the fragment. There are some advantages of this technique compared to structural allograft, large volume ceramic bone void filler, a spine cage, or other trabecular metal object, including the ability to remove the plate later, ability to tension the plate against the depressed articular surface, ability to place screws or other allograft near the implant, wide availability of the implant, and familiarity of orthopaedic trauma surgeons with placing plates and screws to hold reductions. The technique is particularly useful in patterns with uncontained articular depression and a large metaphyseal void.

Pertrochanteric Nonunion: When and Why to Consider a Medullary Implant.

SUMMARY: Pertrochanteric nonunion management is a technically challenging problem. When repair is undertaken rather than conversion arthroplasty, successful treatment revolves around accurate deformity correction, preservation of vascularity, and stable durable fixation. The decision to use an extramedullary or intramedullary implant should be influenced by nonunion-specific characteristics and patient-related conditions. Failure to understand these nuances when selecting an implant strategy often results in treatment failure. The primary purpose of this article was to discuss these variables and delineate when an intramedullary implant should be considered for treatment of a pertrochanteric nonunion. The secondary purpose was to describe the author's preferred surgical technique for implant-driven deformity correction and compression when choosing an intramedullary nail.

A Staged Protocol for Treatment of High-Energy Tongue-Type Calcaneus Fractures: Surgical Technique and Case Series.

SUMMARY: Displaced tongue-type calcaneus fractures are frequently associated with severe soft tissue injuries, and urgent relief of the displaced tongue fragment on the posterior soft tissues is essential to preventing soft tissue complications. If there is a complex articular injury, the soft tissue envelope often needs time for swelling to resolve to allow for a safe open anatomic reduction because premature open reduction internal fixation is often associated with increased complications. We have found that in high-energy tongue-type calcaneus fractures with complex articular injuries, a staged protocol consisting of initial percutaneous reduction and fixation with later definitive reconstruction is soft tissue friendly, allows early restoration of calcaneal morphology, and affords extensile approaches for eventual reconstruction. The purpose of this study was to describe our protocol of staged treatment of high-energy tongue-type calcaneus fractures, along with postoperative surgical outcomes, in a case series of 53 patients.Our series of patients had a high rate of intra-articular injury with marked initial displacement (mean Bohler angle -8.4 ± 20.8 degrees). They were treated initially with percutaneous reduction and fixation at median 1 day postinjury (interquartile range [IQR] 0-1) and definitively at median 16 days postinjury (IQR 10-33). In this series, 2 of 53 (3.8%) patients developed a deep wound infection.In high-energy tongue-type calcaneus fractures at risk for soft tissue compromise or with a significantly displaced tongue fragment without initial soft tissue compromise, we found that staged management represents a feasible management strategy to mitigate risk of soft tissue complications and therefore helps facilitate safe definitive open treatment.

Closed Reduction Technique for Acetabular Fractures with Femoral Head Protrusion and Concomitant Superolateral Impaction: A Case Report.

CASE: Closed reduction of acetabular fractures with femoral head protrusion and superolateral femoral head impaction may be challenging because the intact acetabular roof may block anatomic reduction with traditional maneuvers. We report the use of a 5-step technique for this unique pattern: medializing force to disengage the femoral head, axial traction to clear the intact ilium, lateralizing force to center the head underneath the acetabular roof, confirmation of femoral head stability, and skeletal traction placement. CONCLUSION: Acetabular fractures with femoral head protrusion and concomitant superolateral impaction may be reduced with an initial medializing force followed by axial and lateralizing forces.

Induced Membrane Technique Is Effective for the Management of Acute Traumatic Bone Loss in Both Diaphyseal and Metaphyseal Lower Extremity Fractures.

OBJECTIVE: To compare outcomes of Masquelet-induced membrane technique (IMT) in metaphyseal and diaphyseal fractures with acute bone loss. DESIGN: Retrospective cohort study. SETTING: Four Level 1 Academic Trauma Centers. PATIENTS/PARTICIPANTS: Patients acutely treated with IMT for traumatic lower extremity bone loss at 4 Level 1 trauma centers between 2010 and 2020. INTERVENTION: Operative treatment with placement of cement spacer within 3 weeks of initial injury followed by staged removal and bone grafting to the defect. MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS: Fracture union, infection, revision grafting, time to union, and amputation. RESULTS: One hundred twenty fractures met inclusion criteria, including 43 diaphyseal fractures (DIM) and 77 metaphyseal fractures (MIM). Demographic characteristics were not significantly different, except for age (DIM 34 years vs. MIM 43 years, P < 0.001). Union after treatment with IMT was 89.2% overall. After controlling for age, this was not significantly different between DIM (41/43, 95.3%) and MIM (66/77, 85.7%) ( P = 0.13) nor was the rate of infection between groups. There was no difference in any secondary outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: The overall union rate in the current series of acute lower extremity fractures treated with the induced membrane technique was 89%. There was no difference in successful union between patients with diaphyseal bone loss or metaphyseal bone loss treated with IMT. Similarly, there was no difference in patients with tibial or femoral bone loss treated with induced membrane. Defect size after debridement may be more prognostic for secondary operations rather than the limb segment involved or the degree of soft-tissue injury. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Prognostic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Immediate Fixation of Acetabular Fractures Through an Anterior Approach Does Not Increase Morbidity or Mortality.

INTRODUCTION: Acetabular fractures requiring an anterior approach have historically been delayed, allowing a stable clot to form before creating large surgical exposures. The purpose of this study was to determine whether immediate fixation of acetabular fractures within 24 hours using an anterior approach demonstrates notable difference in blood loss, length of stay (LOS), complications, or mortality compared with acetabular fractures treated after 24 hours. METHODS: Ninety-three patients were optimized for surgery within 24 hours of injury. Thirty-two patients underwent fixation within 24 hours using an anterior approach to the acetabulum. Demographics, hours from injury to operating room, fracture classification, embolization, surgical approach, intraoperative cell salvage use, Charlson Comorbidity Index, American Society of Anesthesiologists class, Injury Severity Score, and Abbreviated Chest Injury Score were recorded. Estimated blood loss, transfusions, intensive care unit stay, total hospital LOS, complications, and mortality rates were compared. RESULTS: No statistically significant differences were observed in fracture classification, blood loss, or intraoperative transfusions between the immediate and delayed fixation groups. Six patients in the delayed group (9.8%) returned to the operating room for a complication compared with one patient (3.1%) in the immediate group ( P = 0.42). Three patients in the delayed group (4.9%) developed a surgical site infection compared with none (0%) in the immediate group ( P = 0.55). The immediate group had an average LOS of 7 days compared with 11 days in the delayed fixation group ( P = 0.01). No notable differences were observed in 30- or 90-day mortality rates. DISCUSSION: Medically optimized patients with acetabular fractures who undergo immediate fixation through an anterior approach do not seem to have an associated increase in blood loss, transfusions, or mortality. Prompt surgical management may also be associated with a shorter preoperative and postoperative LOS. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic level III.

Defining Posterior Wall Fragments in Associated Both Column Acetabular Fractures (OTA/AO 62C).

OBJECTIVE: Associated both column acetabular fractures (OTA/AO 62C) with concomitant posterior wall fracture fragments (ABC + PW) have not been well-defined. The purpose of this study was to report on the incidence and morphology of ABC + PW fractures. METHODS: A retrospective review of associated both column (ABC) fractures between 2014 and 2020 was performed. Computed tomography scans including 3-D surface rendered reformats for each were reviewed to determine whether a posterior wall (PW) fragment was present and its morphologic characteristics. RESULTS: One hundred fifty-two ABC fractures were identified. Sixty-two fractures (41%) were identified as ABC + PW. 3D-computed tomographies were available on 58 fractures. Morphologic analysis was performed based on the relationship of the fracture to the gluteal pillar. Twenty PW fragments were posterior to the gluteal pillar, 19 extended into the gluteal pillar, and 19 extended anterior. Fifty-two fractures were treated with operative fixation; 32 (62%) were clamped and fixed with screws from the same anterior approach whereas 15 (29%) required a separate posterior approach; and no fixation was placed in 5 (9%). 29 of 32 PW fragments (91%) requiring fixation that extended into or anterior to the pillar were fixed from the anterior approach, and 7 of 15 posterior fractures (47%) required a separate posterior approach. CONCLUSIONS: A separate PW fragment was identified in 41% of ABC fractures. Their variation in morphology can be classified into 3 types based on the relation to the gluteal pillar that has potential implications for treatment from the anterior approach compared with requiring a separate posterior approach. We suggest these data could be used to update the 2018 OTA/AO Fracture Compendium. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Prognostic Level IV. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Erectile dysfunction after acetabular fracture.

Objectives: To determine the rate of erectile dysfunction in male patients who have sustained an acetabular fracture with no previously identified urogenital injury. Design: Cross-sectional survey. Setting: Level 1 Trauma Center. Patients/Participants: All male patients treated for acetabular fracture without urogenital injury. Intervention: The International Index of Erectile Function (IIEF), a validated patient-reported outcome measure for male sexual function, was administered to all patients. Main Outcome Measurements: Patients were asked to complete the International Index of Erectile Function score for both preinjury and current sexual function, and the erectile function (EF) domain was used to quantify the degree of erectile dysfunction. Fractures were classified according the OTA/AO classification schema, fracture classification, injury severity score, race, and treatment details, including surgical approach were collected from the database. Results: Ninety-two men with acetabular fractures without previously diagnosed urogenital injury responded to the survey at a minimum of 12 months and an average of 43 ± 21 months postinjury. The mean age was 53 ± 15 years. 39.8% of patients developed moderate-to-severe erectile dysfunction after injury. The mean EF domain score decreased 5.02 ± 1.73 points, which is greater than the minimum clinically important difference of 4. Increased injury severity score and associated fracture pattern were predictive of decreased EF score. Conclusion: Patients with acetabular fractures have an increased rate of erectile dysfunction at intermediate-term follow-up. The orthopaedic trauma surgeon treating these injuries should be aware of this as a potential associated injury, ask their patients about their function, and make appropriate referrals. Level of Evidence: III.

Talus Fractures: An Update on Current Concepts in Surgical Management.

Talus fractures can be challenging injuries to treat because of complex talar shape, an abundance of articular cartilage, a potentially unforgiving soft-tissue envelope, and an easily injured blood supply. In addition, the spectra of energy involved, soft-tissue injury, and the fracture pattern are wide. Temporizing treatment is sometimes required, including débridement of open fractures, reduction of dislocations, and occasionally spanning external fixation. Definitive treatment first requires an understanding of the fracture pattern, including location and fracture line orientation. Multiple options for surgical exposure exist and are selected based on the fracture pattern and condition of the soft tissues. Newer fixation techniques, including the use of fixed-angle and minifragment implants, are useful in achieving stable fixation.

Posteromedial Talar Body Fracture: Case Discussion and Surgical Technique.

SUMMARY: Posteromedial talar body fractures are a rare form of talus fracture that involves the tibiotalar and subtalar joints. In cases of displaced injuries, open reduction and internal fixation is typically recommended to minimize the risk of instability and post-traumatic osteoarthritis. This video presents a case of a posteromedial talar body fracture and highlights the technique for operative fixation through a posteromedial approach. Multiple methods to obtain reduction are discussed, and considerations with implant placement are described. The indications for surgical intervention are reviewed, and published outcomes following operative and nonoperative management of these injuries are presented.

Radiographic Assessment of Ankle Fracture Displacement: A Validation Study.

BACKGROUND: Ankle fracture displacement is an important outcome in clinical research examining the effectiveness of surgical and rehabilitation interventions. However, the assessment of displacement remains subjective without well-described or validated measurement methods. The aim of this study was to assess inter- and intrarater reliability of ankle fracture displacement radiographic measures and select measurement thresholds that differentiate displaced and acceptably reduced fractures. METHODS: Eight fellowship-trained orthopaedic surgeons evaluated a set of 26 postoperative ankle fracture radiographs on 2 occasions. Surgeons followed standardized instructions for making 5 measurements: coronal displacement (3) talar tilt (1), and sagittal displacement (1). Inter- and intraobserver interclass correlations were determined by random effects regression models. Logistic regression was used to determine the optimal sensitivity and specificity for the measurements with the highest correlation. RESULTS: Three of the 5 measures had excellent interobserver reliability (correlation coefficient > 0.75): (1) coronal plane distance between the lateral border of tibia and lateral border of talus, (2) coronal plane talar tilt, and (3) sagittal plane displacement. The threshold that best discriminated displaced from well-aligned fractures was 2 mm for coronal plane distance (sensitivity 82.1%, specificity 85.4%), 3 degrees for talar tilt (sensitivity 80.4%, specificity 82.2%), and 5 mm for sagittal plane distance (sensitivity 83.9%, specificity 84.9%). CONCLUSION: This study identified 3 reliable measures of ankle fracture displacement and determined optimal thresholds for discriminating between displaced and acceptably reduced fractures. These measurement criteria can be used for the design and conduct of clinical research studying the impact of surgical treatment and rehabilitation interventions.

Does a Medial Malleolar Osteotomy or Posteromedial Approach Provide Greater Surgical Visualization for the Treatment of Talar Body Fractures?

BACKGROUND: Surgical management of talar body fractures is influenced by soft-tissue condition and fracture pattern. Two common surgical approaches for the treatment of talar body fractures are the medial malleolar osteotomy (MMO) and the posteromedial approach (PMA). The purpose of this study was to compare the observable talar body surface area with the MMO and the PMA. We hypothesized that visualization following a PMA improves with distraction and distraction with a gastrocnemius recession. METHODS: Five pairs of cadaver limbs were used. Each pair of specimens underwent both approaches to act as an internal control. The laterality of the PMA was determined by randomization, and the MMO was performed on the contralateral ankle. The PMA was performed to visualize the talus, and the talar surface area was recorded using a handheld 3D surface scanner. A distractor was then placed across the joint, and the surface area was remeasured. Finally, a gastrocnemius recession was performed, and the measured surface area under the distraction was recorded. The MMO was performed in standard fashion using fluoroscopy, and the observable talar surface area was recorded. Scans were performed twice for each approach, and the surface areas were averaged. The talus was excised and scanned after each approach in order to compare the visualized surface area with the total surface area of the native talus. RESULTS: The MMO and the PMA exposed a mean of 11.2 and 6.7 cm2, respectively, of the talar surface. Visualization with the PMA was improved with distraction, revealing 8.3 cm2 of the talus (p = 0.01 when compared with an isolated PMA). A PMA with distraction and gastrocnemius recession exposed 9.9 cm2 of the talar dome and body. There was no significant difference in exposure between the MMO and the PMA with distraction and gastrocnemius recession (p = 0.32). CONCLUSIONS: The MMO and the PMA both afford excellent visualization for reduction and fixation of talar body fractures. Visualization using the PMA is improved with distraction and distraction with a gastrocnemius recession. The results of this study may assist surgeons in selecting the optimal approach for surgical repair of talar body fractures.