RESUMO
OBJECTIVE: As part of assessment of long-term care needs, Medical Services of the compulsory German Health Insurance have to decide whether medical rehabilitation is indicated. The aim of this study was to identify uncertainties and associated factors while deciding whether rehabilitation was indicated in this standardized review process. METHOD: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with a total of twelve nursing experts and six physician experts from six different Medical Services. In the interviews of the two professional groups, thinking aloud and problem-centered methods were used. They were subjected to a cognitive pretest prior to data collection. All interviews were conducted over telephone in May 2021, digitally recorded and transcribed thereafter. They were analyzed based on the method of structuring qualitative content analysis using the MAXQDA software. RESULTS: Uncertainties in decision-making can arise both from case-related characteristics and case-independent contextual factors. Nursing experts associated uncertainties in assessing the criteria of rehabilitation indication primarily with certain diseases (especially dementia or mental illnesses), multimorbidity, an unclear illness and ambulatory care situation, as well as a negative rehabilitation-related attitude of the persons being assessed. The physician experts, who based their decisions on available documentation in the case files, described uncertainties, particularly due to insufficient information relevant to the decision (e. g., on diagnostics, course of disease and treatment, weighting of existing limitations) in the nursing experts' assessments. Across all criteria, the experts' own professional or private rehabilitation experience and their understanding of the role of rehabilitation before and during the need for long-term care, as well as aspects of communication practice and the professional exchange between the nursing and the physician experts also influenced the overall decision-making process. CONCLUSION: The identification of uncertainties in experts' decision-making process and associated factors enables the development of strategies to strengthen specifically the certainty of experts' decision-making and thus may contribute to the promotion of a needs-based rehabilitation access via long-term care assessment.