Guidelines for Models of Skeletal Muscle Injury and Therapeutic Assessment.

Volumetric muscle loss (VML) injuries present a large clinical challenge with a significant need for new interventions. While there have been numerous reviews on muscle injury models, few have critically evaluated VML models. The objective of this review is to discuss current preclinical models of VML in terms of models, analytical outcomes, and therapeutic interventions, and to provide guidelines for the future use of preclinical VML models. This is a work of the US Government and is not subject to copyright protection in the USA. Foreign copyrights may apply. Published by S. Karger AG, Basel.

Enhanced in vivo retention of low dose BMP-2 via heparin microparticle delivery does not accelerate bone healing in a critically sized femoral defect.

Bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) is an osteoinductive growth factor used clinically to induce bone regeneration and fusion. Some complications associated with BMP-2 treatment have been attributed to rapid release of BMP-2 from conventional collagen scaffolds, motivating the development of tunable sustained-release strategies. We incorporated BMP-2-binding heparin microparticles (HMPs) into a hydrogel scaffold to improve spatiotemporal control of BMP-2 delivery to large bone defects. HMPs pre-loaded with BMP-2 were mixed into alginate hydrogels and compared to hydrogels containing BMP-2 alone. BMP-2 release from scaffolds in vitro, BMP-2 retention within injury sites in vivo, and bone regeneration in a critically sized femoral defect were evaluated. Compared to hydrogel delivery alone, BMP-2-loaded HMPs reduced BMP-2 release in vitro and increased early BMP-2 retention in the bone defect. BMP-2-loaded HMPs induced bone formation at both ectopic and orthotopic sites; however, the volume of induced bone was lower for defects treated with BMP-2-loaded HMPs compared to hydrogel delivery. To better understand the effect of HMPs on BMP-2 release kinetics, a computational model was developed to predict BMP-2 release from constructs in vivo. The model suggested that HMPs limited BMP-2 release into surrounding tissues, and that changing the HMP density could modulate BMP-2 release. Taken together, these experimental and computational results suggest the importance of achieving a balance of BMP-2 retention within the bone defect and BMP-2 release into surrounding soft tissues. HMP delivery of BMP-2 may provide a method of tuning BMP-2 release in vivo that can be further investigated to improve current methods of bone regeneration. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: The development of effective biomaterials for sustained protein delivery is a crucial component of tissue engineering strategies. However, in most applications, including bone repair, the optimal balance between protein presentation in the injury site and protein release into the surrounding tissues is unknown. Herein, we introduced heparin microparticles (HMPs) into a tissue engineered construct to increase in vivo retention of bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) and enhance healing in femoral defects. Although HMPs induced bone regeneration, no increase in bone volume was observed, leading to further experimental and computational analysis of the effect of HMP-BMP-2 interactions on protein retention and release. Ultimately, this work provides insight into designing tunable protein-material interactions and their implications for controlling BMP-2 delivery.

Functional augmentation of naturally-derived materials for tissue regeneration.

Tissue engineering strategies have utilized a wide spectrum of synthetic and naturally-derived scaffold materials. Synthetic scaffolds are better defined and offer the ability to precisely and reproducibly control their properties, while naturally-derived scaffolds typically have inherent biological and structural properties that may facilitate tissue growth and remodeling. More recently, efforts to design optimized biomaterial scaffolds have blurred the line between these two approaches. Naturally-derived scaffolds can be engineered through the manipulation of intrinsic properties of the pre-existing backbone (e.g., structural properties), as well as the addition of controllable functional components (e.g., biological properties). Chemical and physical processing techniques used to modify structural properties of synthetic scaffolds have been tailored and applied to naturally-derived materials. Such strategies include manipulation of mechanical properties, degradation, and porosity. Furthermore, biofunctional augmentation of natural scaffolds via incorporation of exogenous cells, proteins, peptides, or genes has been shown to enhance functional regeneration over endogenous response to the material itself. Moving forward, the regenerative mode of action of naturally-derived materials requires additional investigation. Elucidating such mechanisms will allow for the determination of critical design parameters to further enhance efficacy and capitalize on the full potential of naturally-derived scaffolds.

Functional analysis of limb recovery following autograft treatment of volumetric muscle loss in the quadriceps femoris.

Severe injuries to the extremities often result in muscle trauma and, in some cases, significant volumetric muscle loss (VML). These injuries continue to be challenging to treat, with few available clinical options, a high rate of complications, and often persistent loss of limb function. To facilitate the testing of regenerative strategies for skeletal muscle, we developed a novel quadriceps VML model in the rat, specifically addressing functional recovery of the limb. Our outcome measures included muscle contractility measurements to assess muscle function and gait analysis for evaluation of overall limb function. We also investigated treatment with muscle autografts, whole or minced, to promote regeneration of the defect area. Our defect model resulted in a loss of muscle function, with injured legs generating less than 55% of muscle strength from the contralateral uninjured control legs, even at 4 weeks post-injury. The autograft treatments did not result in significant recovery of muscle function. Measures of static and dynamic gait were significantly decreased in the untreated, empty defect group, indicating a decrease in limb function. Histological sections of the affected muscles showed extensive fibrosis, suggesting that this scarring of the muscle may be in part the cause of the loss of muscle function in this VML model. Taken together, these data are consistent with clinical findings of reduced muscle function in large VML injuries. This new model with quantitative functional outcome measures offers a platform on which to evaluate treatment strategies designed to regenerate muscle tissue volume and restore limb function.

Recovery from hind limb ischemia enhances rhBMP-2-mediated segmental bone defect repair in a rat composite injury model.

Although severe extremity trauma is often inclusive of skeletal and vascular damage in combination, segmental bone defect repair with concomitant vascular injury has yet to be experimentally investigated. To this end, we developed a novel rat composite limb injury model by combining a critically-sized segmental bone defect with surgically-induced hind limb ischemia (HLI). Unilateral 8mm femoral defects were created alone (BD) or in combination with HLI (BD + HLI), and all defects were treated with rhBMP-2 via a hybrid biomaterial delivery system. Based on reported clinical and experimental observations on the importance of vascular networks in bone repair, we hypothesized that HLI would impair bone regeneration. Interestingly, the BD+HLI group displayed improved radiographic bridging, and quantitative micro-CT analysis revealed enhanced bone regeneration as early as week 4 (p < 0.01) that was sustained through week 12 (p < 0.001) and confirmed histologically. This effect was observed in two independent studies and at two different doses of rhBMP-2. Micro-CT angiography was used to quantitatively evaluate vascular networks at week 12 in both the thigh and the regenerated bone defect. No differences were found between groups in total blood vessel volume in the thigh, but clear differences in morphology were present as the BD+HLI group possessed a more interconnected network of smaller diameter vessels (p < 0.001). Accordingly, while the overall thigh vessel volume was comparable between groups, the contributions to vessel volume based on vessel diameter differed significantly. Despite this evidence of a robust neovascular response in the thigh of the BD + HLI group, differences were not observed between groups for bone defect blood vessel volume or morphology. In total, our results demonstrate that a transient ischemic insult and the subsequent recovery response to HLI significantly enhanced BMP-2-mediated segmental bone defect repair, providing additional complexity to the relationship between vascular tissue networks and bone healing. Ultimately, a better understanding of the coupling mechanisms may reveal important new strategies for promoting bone healing in challenging clinical scenarios.

Attenuated human bone morphogenetic protein-2-mediated bone regeneration in a rat model of composite bone and muscle injury.

Extremity injuries involving large bone defects with concomitant severe muscle damage are a significant clinical challenge often requiring multiple treatment procedures and possible amputation. Even if limb salvage is achieved, patients are typically left with severe short- and long-term disabilities. Current preclinical animal models do not adequately mimic the severity, complexity, and loss of limb function characteristic of these composite injuries. The objectives of this study were to establish a composite injury model that combines a critically sized segmental bone defect with an adjacent volumetric muscle loss injury, and then use this model to quantitatively assess human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2)-mediated tissue regeneration and restoration of limb function. Surgeries were performed on rats in three experimental groups: muscle injury (8-mm-diameter full-thickness defect in the quadriceps), bone injury (8-mm nonhealing defect in the femur), or composite injury combining the bone and muscle defects. Bone defects were treated with 2 µg of rhBMP-2 delivered in the pregelled alginate injected into a cylindrical perforated nanofiber mesh. Bone regeneration was quantitatively assessed using microcomputed tomography, and limb function was assessed using gait analysis and muscle strength measurements. At 12 weeks postsurgery, treated bone defects without volumetric muscle loss were consistently bridged. In contrast, the volume and mechanical strength of regenerated bone were attenuated by 45% and 58%, respectively, in the identically treated composite injury group. At the same time point, normalized muscle strength was reduced by 51% in the composite injury group compared to either single injury group. At 2 weeks, the gait function was impaired in all injury groups compared to baseline with the composite injury group displaying the greatest functional deficit. We conclude that sustained delivery of rhBMP-2 at a dose sufficient to induce bridging of large segmental bone defects failed to promote regeneration when challenged with concomitant muscle injury. This model provides a platform with which to assess bone and muscle interactions during repair and to rigorously test the efficacy of tissue engineering approaches to promote healing in multiple tissues. Such interventions may minimize complications and the number of surgical procedures in limb salvage operations, ultimately improving the clinical outcome.