Prognostic Biomarkers in Kidney Transplantation: A Systematic Review and Critical Appraisal.

SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: Why are there so few biomarkers accepted by health authorities and implemented in clinical practice, despite the high and growing number of biomaker studies in medical research ? In this meta-epidemiological study, including 804 studies that were critically appraised by expert reviewers, the authors have identified all prognostic kidney transplant biomarkers and showed overall suboptimal study designs, methods, results, interpretation, reproducible research standards, and transparency. The authors also demonstrated for the first time that the limited number of studies challenged the added value of their candidate biomarkers against standard-of-care routine patient monitoring parameters. Most biomarker studies tended to be single-center, retrospective studies with a small number of patients and clinical events. Less than 5% of the studies performed an external validation. The authors also showed the poor transparency reporting and identified a data beautification phenomenon. These findings suggest that there is much wasted research effort in transplant biomarker medical research and highlight the need to produce more rigorous studies so that more biomarkers may be validated and successfully implemented in clinical practice. BACKGROUND: Despite the increasing number of biomarker studies published in the transplant literature over the past 20 years, demonstrations of their clinical benefit and their implementation in routine clinical practice are lacking. We hypothesized that suboptimal design, data, methodology, and reporting might contribute to this phenomenon. METHODS: We formed a consortium of experts in systematic reviews, nephrologists, methodologists, and epidemiologists. A systematic literature search was performed in PubMed, Embase, Scopus, Web of Science, and Cochrane Library between January 1, 2005, and November 12, 2022 (PROSPERO ID: CRD42020154747). All English language, original studies investigating the association between a biomarker and kidney allograft outcome were included. The final set of publications was assessed by expert reviewers. After data collection, two independent reviewers randomly evaluated the inconsistencies for 30% of the references for each reviewer. If more than 5% of inconsistencies were observed for one given reviewer, a re-evaluation was conducted for all the references of the reviewer. The biomarkers were categorized according to their type and the biological milieu from which they were measured. The study characteristics related to the design, methods, results, and their interpretation were assessed, as well as reproducible research practices and transparency indicators. RESULTS: A total of 7372 publications were screened and 804 studies met the inclusion criteria. A total of 1143 biomarkers were assessed among the included studies from blood ( n =821, 71.8%), intragraft ( n =169, 14.8%), or urine ( n =81, 7.1%) compartments. The number of studies significantly increased, with a median, yearly number of 31.5 studies (interquartile range [IQR], 23.8-35.5) between 2005 and 2012 and 57.5 (IQR, 53.3-59.8) between 2013 and 2022 ( P < 0.001). A total of 655 studies (81.5%) were retrospective, while 595 (74.0%) used data from a single center. The median number of patients included was 232 (IQR, 96-629) with a median follow-up post-transplant of 4.8 years (IQR, 3.0-6.2). Only 4.7% of studies were externally validated. A total of 346 studies (43.0%) did not adjust their biomarker for key prognostic factors, while only 3.1% of studies adjusted the biomarker for standard-of-care patient monitoring factors. Data sharing, code sharing, and registration occurred in 8.8%, 1.1%, and 4.6% of studies, respectively. A total of 158 studies (20.0%) emphasized the clinical relevance of the biomarker, despite the reported nonsignificant association of the biomarker with the outcome measure. A total of 288 studies assessed rejection as an outcome. We showed that these rejection studies shared the same characteristics as other studies. CONCLUSIONS: Biomarker studies in kidney transplantation lack validation, rigorous design and methodology, accurate interpretation, and transparency. Higher standards are needed in biomarker research to prove the clinical utility and support clinical use.

Kidney Transplantation in Patients With AA Amyloidosis: Outcomes in a French Multicenter Cohort.

RATIONALE & OBJECTIVE: Outcomes of kidney transplantation for patients with renal AA amyloidosis are uncertain, with reports of poor survival and high rates of disease recurrence. However, the data are inconclusive and mostly based on studies from the early 2000s and earlier. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective multicenter cohort study. SETTING & PARTICIPANTS: We searched the French national transplant database to identify all patients with renal AA amyloidosis who underwent kidney transplantation between 2008 and 2018. EXPOSURES: Age, cause of amyloidosis, use of biotherapies, and C-reactive protein levels. OUTCOMES: Outcomes were all-cause mortality and allograft loss. We also reported amyloidosis allograft recurrence, occurrence of acute rejection episodes, as well as infectious, cardiovascular, and neoplastic disease events. ANALYTICAL APPROACH: Kaplan-Meier estimator for mortality and cumulative incidence function method for allograft loss. Factors associated with patient and allograft survival were investigated using a Cox proportional hazards model and a cause-specific hazards model, respectively. RESULTS: 86 patients who received kidney transplants for AA amyloidosis at 26 French centers were included. The median age was 49.4 years (IQR, 39.7-61.1). The main cause of amyloidosis was familial Mediterranean fever (37 cases; 43%). 16 (18.6%) patients received biotherapy after transplantation. Patient survival rates were 94.0% (95% CI, 89.1-99.2) at 1 year and 85.5% (77.8-94.0) at 5 years after transplantation. Cumulative incidences of allograft loss were 10.5% (4.0-17.0) at 1 year and 13.0% (5.8-20.1) at 5 years after transplantation. Histologically proven AA amyloidosis recurrence occurred in 5 transplants (5.8%). An infection requiring hospitalization developed in 55.8% of cases, and there was a 27.9% incidence of acute allograft rejection. Multivariable analysis showed that C-reactive protein concentration at the time of transplantation was associated with patient survival (HR, 1.01; 95% CI, 1.00-1.02; P=0.01) and allograft survival (HR, 1.68; 95% CI, 1.10-2.57; P=0.02). LIMITATIONS: The study lacked a control group, and the effect of biotherapies on transplantation outcomes could not be explored. CONCLUSIONS: This relatively contemporary cohort of patients who received a kidney transplant for AA amyloidosis experienced favorable rates of survival and lower recurrence rates than previously reported. These data support the practice of treating these patients with kidney transplantation for end-stage kidney disease. PLAIN-LANGUAGE SUMMARY: AA amyloidosis is a severe and rare disease. Kidney involvement is frequent and leads to end-stage kidney disease. Because of the involvement of other organs, these patients are often frail, which has raised concerns about their suitability for kidney transplantation. We reviewed all patients with AA amyloidosis nephropathy who underwent kidney transplantation in France in the recent era (2008-2018) and found that the outcomes after kidney transplantation were favorable, with 85.5% of patients still alive 5 years after transplantation, a survival rate that is comparable to the outcomes of patients receiving a transplant for other forms of kidney diseases. Recurrence of amyloidosis in the transplanted kidney was infrequent (5.8%). These data support the practice of kidney transplantation for patients with AA amyloidosis who experience kidney failure.

Hemolysis is associated with altered heparan sulfate of the endothelial glycocalyx and with local complement activation in thrombotic microangiopathies.

The complement system plays a key role in the pathophysiology of kidney thrombotic microangiopathies (TMA), as illustrated by atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome. But complement abnormalities are not the only drivers of TMA lesions. Among other potential pathophysiological actors, we hypothesized that alteration of heparan sulfate (HS) in the endothelial glycocalyx could be important. To evaluate this, we analyzed clinical and histological features of kidney biopsies from a monocentric, retrospective cohort of 72 patients with TMA, particularly for HS integrity and markers of local complement activation. The role of heme (a major product of hemolysis) as an HS-degrading agent in vitro, and the impact of altering endothelial cell (ECs) HS on their ability to locally activate complement were studied. Compared with a positive control, glomerular HS staining was lower in 57 (79%) patients with TMA, moderately reduced in 20 (28%), and strongly reduced in 37 (51%) of these 57 cases. Strongly reduced HS density was significantly associated with both hemolysis at the time of biopsy and local complement activation (C3 and/or C5b-9 deposits). Using primary endothelial cells (HUVECs, Glomerular ECs), we observed decreased HS expression after short-term exposure to heme, and that artificial HS degradation by exposure to heparinase was associated with local complement activation. Further, prolonged exposure to heme modulated expression of several key genes of glycocalyx metabolism involved in coagulation regulation (C5-EPI, HS6ST1, HS3ST1). Thus, our study highlights the impact of hemolysis on the integrity of endothelial HS, both in patients and in endothelial cell models. Hence, acute alteration of HS may be a mechanism of heme-induced complement activation.

Impact of Preformed Donor-Specific Anti-HLA-Cw and Anti-HLA-DP Antibodies on Acute Antibody-Mediated Rejection in Kidney Transplantation.

Given the risk of rejection, the presence of preformed donor specific antibodies (DSA) contraindicates transplantation in most allocation systems. However, HLA-Cw and -DP DSA escape this censorship. We performed a multicentric observational study, in which the objective was to determinate risk factors of acute antibody-mediated rejection (aABMR) in recipients transplanted with preformed isolated Cw- or DP-DSA. Between 2010 and 2019, 183 patients were transplanted with a preformed isolated Cw- or DP-DSA (92 Cw-DSA; 91 DP-DSA). At 2 years, the incidence of aABMR was 12% in the Cw-DSA group, versus 28% in the DP-DSA group. Using multivariable Cox regression model, the presence of a preformed DP-DSA was associated with an increased risk of aABMR (HR = 2.32 [1.21-4.45 (p = 0.001)]) compared with Cw-DSA. We also observed a significant association between the DSA's MFI on the day of transplant and the risk of aABMR (HR = 1.09 [1.08-1.18], p = 0.032), whatever the DSA was. Interaction term analysis found an increased risk of aABMR in the DP-DSA group compared with Cw-DSA, but only for MFI below 3,000. These results may plead for taking these antibodies into account in the allocation algorithms, in the same way as other DSA.

Primary Graft Function and 5 Year Insulin Independence After Pancreas and Islet Transplantation for Type 1 Diabetes: A Retrospective Parallel Cohort Study.

In islet transplantation (ITx), primary graft function (PGF) or beta cell function measured early after last infusion is closely associated with long term clinical outcomes. We investigated the association between PGF and 5 year insulin independence rate in ITx and pancreas transplantation (PTx) recipients. This retrospective multicenter study included type 1 diabetes patients who underwent ITx in Lille and PTx in Nantes from 2000 to 2022. PGF was assessed using the validated Beta2-score and compared to normoglycemic control subjects. Subsequently, the 5 year insulin independence rates, as predicted by a validated PGF-based model, were compared to the actual rates observed in ITx and PTx patients. The study enrolled 39 ITx (23 ITA, 16 IAK), 209 PTx recipients (23 PTA, 14 PAK, 172 SPK), and 56 normoglycemic controls. Mean[SD] PGF was lower after ITx (ITA 22.3[5.2], IAK 24.8[6.4], than after PTx (PTA 38.9[15.3], PAK 36.8[9.0], SPK 38.7[10.5]), and lower than mean beta-cell function measured in normoglycemic control: 36.6[4.3]. The insulin independence rates observed at 5 years after PTA and PAK aligned with PGF predictions, and was higher after SPK. Our results indicate a similar relation between PGF and 5 year insulin independence in ITx and solitary PTx, shedding new light on long-term transplantation outcomes.

Association Between Deceased Donor Acute Kidney Injury Assessed Using Baseline Serum Creatinine Back-Estimation and Graft Survival: Results From the French National CRISTAL Registry.

RATIONALE & OBJECTIVE: Deceased donor acute kidney injury (AKI) frequently leads to kidney discards, but its impact on long-term graft survival in kidney transplant recipients remains unclear. We investigated the association between deceased donor AKI assessed using back-estimation of baseline serum creatinine (Scr) and graft survival. STUDY DESIGN: Observational cohort study. SETTING & PARTICIPANTS: Adult patients represented within the French CRISTAL registry who received a single kidney allograft from brain-dead deceased donors between January 2006 and December 2017. EXPOSURE: A back-estimated Scr baseline value was derived for an assumed glomerular filtration rate at 75mL/min/1.73m2, using the MDRD Study equation. A refined classification system for donor AKI was implemented as follows: no AKI, undetermined AKI/chronic kidney disease (CKD), recovery from AKI, and ongoing AKI. OUTCOME: Death-censored graft survival. ANALYTICAL APPROACH: Multivariable Cox models using a robust variance estimator for paired kidneys from the same donor. RESULTS: We classified 26,786 recipients as follows: no AKI (n=19,276); undetermined AKI/CKD (n=1,745); recovery from AKI (n=2,392); and ongoing AKI (n=3,373). We observed 4,458 kidney graft losses during a median follow-up period of 5.7 years. Compared with no AKI, ongoing AKI was associated with an increased risk of graft failure (hazard ratio [HR], 1.24 [95% CI, 1.13-1.35]). The HRs for graft failure in the undetermined AKI/CKD and recovery from AKI groups (1.22 [95% CI, 1.07-1.38] and 1.18 [95% CI, 1.06-1.31], respectively) were similar to those observed in the ongoing AKI group. The adverse effect of deceased donor AKI was no longer evident when relying either on the admission or the lowest Scr throughout the procurement procedure as baseline Scr. LIMITATIONS: No measurement of urine output in donors. CONCLUSIONS: Deceased donor ongoing AKI, undetermined AKI/CKD, and recovery from AKI according to back-estimated baseline Scr are associated with decreased graft survival. The definition of baseline Scr as the first value measured on admission would have led to a misclassification bias and erroneous estimates.

Post-Transplantation Early Blood Transfusion and Kidney Allograft Outcomes: A Single-Center Observational Study.

The association between blood transfusion and the occurrence of de novo HLA donor specific antibodies (DSA) after kidney transplantation remains controversial. In this single-center observational study, we examined the association between early blood transfusion, i.e. before 1-month post-transplantation, and the risk of DSA occurrence, using Luminex based-methods. In total, 1,424 patients with a minimum of 1-month follow-up were evaluated between January 2007 and December 2018. During a median time of follow-up of 4.52 years, we observed 258 recipients who had at least one blood transfusion during the first month post-transplantation. At baseline, recipients in the transfused group were significant older, more sensitized against HLA class I and class II antibodies and had a higher 1-month serum creatinine. Cox proportional hazards regression analyses did not show any significant association between blood transfusion and the risk of de novo DSA occurrence (1.35 [0.86-2.11], p = 0.19), the risk of rejection (HR = 1.33 [0.94-1.89], p = 0.11), or the risk of graft loss (HR = 1.04 [0.73-1.50], p = 0.82). These data suggest then that blood transfusion may not be limited when required in the early phase of transplantation, and may not impact long-term outcomes.

Association between acute graft pyelonephritis and kidney graft survival: A single-center observational study.

The association between acute graft pyelonephritis (AGPN) and graft failure in kidney transplant recipients (KTR) remains controversial. In this single-center observational study, we aimed to assess the incidence of AGPN as a time-dependent posttransplantation event. We also examined the association between the diagnosis of AGPN and graft outcomes. In total, we evaluated 1480 patients who underwent kidney transplantation between January 2007 and December 2017. During a median follow-up of 5.04 years, we observed 297 AGPN episodes that occurred in 158 KTR. To evaluate the association between AGPN and clinical outcomes, we performed Cox proportional hazards regression analyses in which AGPN was entered as a time-dependent covariate. AGPN was independently associated with an increased risk of graft loss (hazard ratio = 1.66; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.05-2.64, p < .03) and a persistently decreased eGFR (fixed effect on intercept: -2.29 ml/min/1.73 m2 ; 95% CI: from -3.23 to -1.35, p < .01). However, neither mortality nor biopsy-proven acute rejection was found to correlate with AGPN. Moreover, recurrent AGPN episodes did not appear to have an additive detrimental impact on graft loss. These data represent a promising step in understanding whether AGPN prevention may decrease the risk of graft loss in KTR.

Successful Reuse of Kidney Graft After Early Recurrence of Primary Focal and Segmental Glomerulosclerosis.

Primary focal and segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) frequently recurs after transplantation and is associated with a poor prognosis. We describe here the successful kidney graft reuse in an adult recipient, 8 months after early primary FSGS recurrence resistant to all available therapeutics. Patient 1, a 23-year-old man, followed for kidney failure secondary to primary FSGS, was first transplanted in 2018 with a deceased donor graft. Unfortunately, we observed an immediate recurrence of biopsy-proven primary FSGS. After 4 lines of treatment (intravenous cyclosporine+corticosteroids, plasma exchanges, immunoadsorption, and rituximab), the patient was still highly nephrotic and kidney function was slowly deteriorating. After approval from both the patient and the health authority (Biomedicine Agency), the graft was detransplanted 8 months after transplantation and reimplanted in patient 2, a 78-year-old nonimmunized and anephric recipient (bi-nephrectomy 2 years previously for bilateral renal carcinoma). We observed immediate kidney function and progressive resolution of proteinuria (serum creatinine of 1.2mg/dL and proteinuria of 0.1 g/d 1 year later). Biopsies performed after surgery showed persistent FSGS lesions with a decrease in overall foot-process effacement. To our knowledge, this is the first reported case showing that kidney graft transfer may still be a viable option for refractory primary FSGS several months after transplantation.

Pushing the boundaries of organs before it's too late: pre-emptive regeneration.

Solid organ transplantation is marked by accelerated aging and inexorable fibrosis. It is crucial to promote strategies to attenuate, or to reverse, damage before organ failure. Hence, the objective of this article is to provide insight into strategies, which aim to regenerate or rejuvenate the transplanted organs. Cell therapy with mesenchymal stromal cells is currently under investigation because of their antifibrotic properties. Their ability to promote mitochondrial biogenesis, and to transfer mitochondria to wounded cells, is another approach to boost the organ regeneration. Other teams have investigated bioengineered organs, which consists of decellularization of the damaged organ followed by recellularization. Lastly, the development of CAR-T cell-based technologies may revolutionize the field of transplantation, as recent preclinical studies showed that CAR-T cells could efficiently clear senescent cells from an organ and reverse fibrosis. Ultimately, these cutting-edge strategies may bring the holy grail of a pre-emptive regenerated organ closer to reality.

Donor-to-recipient transmission and reactivation in a kidney transplant recipient of an inherited chromosomally integrated HHV-6A: Evidence and outcomes.

Human herpesvirus (HHV)-6A can be inherited and chromosomally integrated (iciHHV-6A), and donor-to-recipient transmission has been reported in solid organ transplant. However, when HHV-6A reactivation happens after transplant, the source of HHV-6A is often not evident and its pathogenicity remains unclear. Here, we present an exhaustive case of donor-to-recipient transmission and reactivation of iciHHV-6A through kidney transplant. The absence of HHV-6A genome from the nails of the recipient excluded a recipient-related iciHHV-6A. Viral loads > 7 log10 copies/106 cells in donor blood samples and similarities of U38, U39, U69, and U100 viral genes between donor, recipient, and previously published iciHHV-6A strains are proof of donor-related transmission. Detection of noncoding HHV-6 snc-RNA14 using fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis and immunofluorescence staining of HHV-6A gp82/gp105 late proteins on kidney biopsies showed evidence of reactivation in the transplanted kidney. Because HHV-6A reactivation can be life threatening in immunocompromised patients, we provide several tools to help during the complete screening and diagnosis.

Vascular bioengineering of scaffolds derived from human discarded transplant kidneys using human pluripotent stem cell-derived endothelium.

The bioengineering of a replacement kidney has been proposed as an approach to address the growing shortage of donor kidneys for the treatment of chronic kidney disease. One approach being investigated is the recellularization of kidney scaffolds. In this study, we present several key advances toward successful re-endothelialization of whole kidney matrix scaffolds from both rodents and humans. Based on the presence of preserved glycosoaminoglycans within the decelullarized kidney scaffold, we show improved localization of delivered endothelial cells after preloading of the vascular matrix with vascular endothelial growth factor and angiopoietin 1. Using a novel simultaneous arteriovenous delivery system, we report the complete re-endothelialization of the kidney vasculature, including the glomerular and peritubular capillaries, using human inducible pluripotent stem cell -derived endothelial cells. Using this source of endothelial cells, it was possible to generate sufficient endothelial cells to recellularize an entire human kidney scaffold, achieving efficient cell delivery, adherence, and endothelial cell proliferation and survival. Moreover, human re-endothelialized scaffold could, in contrast to the non-re-endothelialized human scaffold, be fully perfused with whole blood. These major advances move the field closer to a human bioengineered kidney.

Proteinuria reduction with SGLT2 inhibitors in a patient treated with tyrosine kinase inhibitor lenvatinib.

We describe the case of a 66-year-old woman treated with tyrosine kinase inhibitor Lenvatinib for thyroid carcinoma who had persistent proteinuria above 2 g/24 h despite maximal dose of angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor. We initiated a treatment with SGLT2 inhibitor Dapagliflozin. Three months after Dapagliflozin initiation, her proteinuria decreased to 1 g/24 h, and after 6 months of follow-up was 0.6 g/24 h. To our knowledge, this is the first case of successful proteinuria reduction with SGLT2i in a patient treated with Lenvatinib. Specific renal effects of SGLT2i seem promising and their effects on tyrosine kinase inhibitor renal adverse effects need to be validated in clinical trials involving cancer patients.

Use of a Belatacept-based Immunosuppression for Kidney Transplantation From Donors After Circulatory Death: A Paired Kidney Analysis.

Background: Efficacy and safety of belatacept have not been specifically reported for kidney transplantations from donors after circulatory death. Methods: In this retrospective multicenter paired kidney study, we compared the outcome of kidney transplantations with a belatacept-based to a calcineurin inhibitor (CNI)-based immunosuppression. We included all kidney transplant recipients from donors after uncontrolled or controlled circulatory death performed in our center between February 2015 and October 2020 and treated with belatacept (n = 31). The control group included the recipients of the contralateral kidney that were treated with CNI in 8 other centers (tacrolimus n = 29, cyclosporine n = 2). Results: There was no difference in the rate of delayed graft function. A higher incidence of biopsy-proven rejections was noted in the belatacept group (24 versus 6 episodes). Estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) was significantly higher in the belatacept group at 3-, 12-, and 36-mo posttransplant, but the slope of eGFR was similar in the 2 groups. During a mean follow-up of 4.1 y, 12 patients discontinued belatacept and 2 patients were switched from CNI to belatacept. For patients who remained on belatacept, eGFR mean value and slope were significantly higher during the whole follow-up. At 5 y, eGFR was 80.7 ± 18.5 with belatacept versus 56.3 ± 22.0 mL/min/1.73 m2 with CNI (P = 0.003). No significant difference in graft and patient survival was observed. Conclusions: The use of belatacept for kidney transplants from either uncontrolled or controlled donors after circulatory death resulted in a better medium-term renal function for patients remaining on belatacept despite similar rates of delayed graft function and higher rates of cellular rejection.

Extracorporeal Photopheresis Reduces Fibrotic and Inflammatory Transcriptomic Biological Marker of Chronic Antibody-mediated Kidney Rejection.

Background: The benefit of extracorporeal photopheresis on the course of kidney transplant rejection is unknown. The aim of our study was to investigate the variations in transcriptomics on graft biopsies when extracorporeal photopheresis was used to treat chronic humoral rejection after kidney transplantation. Methods: We retrospectively analyzed the mRNA expression of 770 genes of interest in graft biopsies performed before and after treatment. Eight patients received an average of 23 extracorporeal photopheresis sessions over 4 mo between the 2 biopsies. Results: Transcriptomic analysis of the graft biopsies identified a significant (adjusted P < 0.05) increase in CAV1 mRNA in all patients and a significant decrease in CD19, IL21, PAX5, and SFTPA2 mRNAs in 7 of 8 patients. Conclusions: In patients treated with extracorporeal photopheresis for chronic humoral rejection after renal transplantation, omic analysis of repeated biopsies shows a reduction in fibrotic and inflammatory transcriptomic biologicals markers.