Specificity for aminoacylation of an RNA helix: an unpaired, exocyclic amino group in the minor groove.

An acceptor stem G3.U70 base pair is a major determinant of the identity of an alanine transfer RNA. Hairpin helices and RNA duplexes consisting of complementary single strands are aminoacylated with alanine if they contain G3.U70. Chemical synthesis of RNA duplexes enabled the introduction of base analogs that tested the role of specific functional groups in the major and minor grooves of the RNA helix. The results of these experiments indicate that an unpaired guanine 2-amino group at a specific position in the minor groove of an RNA helix marks a molecule for aminoacylation with alanine.

Efficient aminoacylation of tRNA(Lys,3) by human lysyl-tRNA synthetase is dependent on covalent continuity between the acceptor stem and the anticodon domain.

In this work, we probe the role of the anticodon in tRNA recognition by human lysyl-tRNA synthetase (hLysRS). Large decreases in aminoacylation efficiency are observed upon mutagenesis of anticodon positions U35 and U36 of human tRNA(Lys,3). A minihelix derived from the acceptor-TPsiC stem-loop domain of human tRNA(Lys,3)was not specifically aminoacylated by the human enzyme. The presence of an anticodon-derived stem-loop failed to stimulate aminoacylation of the minihelix. Thus, covalent continuity between the acceptor stem and anticodon domains appears to be an important requirement for efficient charging by hLysRS. To further examine the mechanism of communication between the critical anticodon recognition elements and the catalytic site, a two piece semi-synthetic tRNA(Lys, 3)construct was used. The wild-type semi-synthetic tRNA contained a break in the phosphodiester backbone in the D loop and was an efficient substrate for hLysRS. In contrast, a truncated variant that lacked nucleotides 8-17 in the D stem-loop displayedseverely reduced catalytic efficiency. The elimination of key tRNA tertiary structural elements has little effect on anticodon-dependent substrate binding but severely impacts formation of the proper transition state for catalysis. Taken together, our studies provide new insights into human tRNA structural requirements for effective transmission of the anticodon recognition signal to the distal acceptor stem domain.

Importance of discriminator base stacking interactions: molecular dynamics analysis of A73 microhelix(Ala) variants.

Transfer of alanine from Escherichia coli alanyl-tRNA synthetase (AlaRS) to RNA minihelices that mimic the amino acid acceptor stem of tRNA(Ala) has been shown, by analysis of variant minihelix aminoacylation activities, to involve a transition state sensitive to changes in the 'discriminator' base at position 73. Solution NMR has indicated that this single-stranded nucleotide is predominantly stacked onto G1 of the first base pair of the alanine acceptor stem helix. We report the activity of a new variant with the adenine at position 73 substituted by its non-polar isostere 4-methylindole (M). Despite lacking N7, this analog is well tolerated by AlaRS. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations show that the M substitution improves position 73 base stacking over G1, as measured by a stacking lifetime analysis. Additional MD simulations of wild-type microhelix(Ala) and six variants reveal a positive correlation between N73 base stacking propensity over G1 and aminoacylation activity. For the two DeltaN7 variants simulated we found that the propensity to stack over G1 was similar to the analogous variants that contain N7 and we conclude that the decrease in aminoacylation efficiency observed upon deletion of N7 is likely due to loss of a direct stabilizing interaction with the synthetase.

HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein zinc finger structures induce tRNA(Lys,3) structural changes but are not critical for primer/template annealing.

Retroviral reverse transcriptases use host cellular tRNAs as primers to initiate reverse transcription. In the case of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), the 3' 18 nucleotides of human tRNA(Lys,3) are annealed to a complementary sequence on the RNA genome known as the primer binding site (PBS). The HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein (NC) facilitates this annealing. To understand the structural changes that are induced upon NC binding to the tRNA alone, we employed a chemical probing method using the lanthanide metal terbium. At low concentrations of NC, the strong terbium cleavage observed in the core region of the tRNA is significantly attenuated. Thus, NC binding first results in disruption of the tRNA's metal binding pockets, including those that stabilize the D-TPsiC tertiary interaction. When NC concentrations approach the amount needed for complete primer/template annealing, NC further destabilizes the tRNA acceptor-TPsiC stem minihelix, as evidenced by increased terbium cleavage in this domain. A mutant form of NC (SSHS NC), which lacks the zinc finger structures, is able to anneal tRNA(Lys,3) efficiently to the PBS, and to destabilize the tRNA tertiary core, albeit less effectively than wild-type NC. This mutant form of NC does not affect cleavage significantly in the helical regions, even when bound at high concentrations. These results, as well as experiments conducted in the presence of polyLys, suggest that in the absence of the zinc finger structures, NC acts as a polycation, neutralizing the highly negative phosphodiester backbone. The presence of an effective multivalent cationic peptide is sufficient for efficient tRNA primer annealing to the PBS.

Preferential interaction of human immunodeficiency virus reverse transcriptase with two regions of primer tRNA(Lys) as evidenced by footprinting studies and inhibition with synthetic oligoribonucleotides.

Primer tRNA regions involved in the interactions between human immunodeficiency virus reverse transcriptase (HIV RT) and tRNA(Lys) were studied by digestion of primer with pancreatic ribonuclease in the presence or absence of HIV RT. The acceptor stem of tRNA(Lys) is not noticeably protected against nuclease action in the presence of HIV RT, while this enzyme clearly protects part of the anticodon and dihydrouridine loops of tRNA(Lys). The acceptor stem of primer tRNA was digested by RNase A only in the presence of the retroviral enzyme, suggesting a partial destabilization of this region by the HIV RT. Synthetic oligoribonucleotides, corresponding to the anticodon and the dihydrouridine loops, inhibited strongly reverse transcription, confirming the strong interaction of these tRNA regions with the enzyme.

Use of semi-synthetic transfer RNAs to probe molecular recognition by Escherichia coli proline-tRNA synthetase.

BACKGROUND: The attachment of specific amino acids to the 3'-end of cognate transfer of RNAs (tRNAs) is catalyzed by a class of enzymes known as aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRS). We have previously demonstrated that Escherichia coli proline-tRNA synthetase (ProRS) can aminoacylate semi-synthetic tRNAs prepared by annealing two RNA oligonucleotides. We set out to examine the factors that are important in selective recognition of tRNAPro by ProRS, using semi-synthetic tRNAs and full-length tRNA transcripts. RESULTS: Deletion of nucleotides A58, A59, and U60 in the T psi C-loop of semi-synthetic tRNAs has no adverse effect on aminoacylation. Nucleotide deletions that extend into the T psi stem, particularly beyond C61, significantly reduce the efficiency of aminoacylation, however. Site-directed mutagenesis of full-length tRNAPro transcripts shows that, although there is no strict sequence requirement at base pair 52.62 in the T psi C stem, helix destabilizing purine-purine mismatches at this position result in decreased aminoacylation activity. Moreover, aminoacylation is severely affected when a DNA-RNA hybrid helix is incorporated into the acceptor-T psi C stem domain. CONCLUSIONS: At least three nucleotides in the T psi C-loop are dispensable for aminoacylation of E. coli tRNAPro. These results, combined with previous data, demonstrate that four out of five of the so-called 'variable pocket' nucleotides are not important for recognition of tRNAPro by E. coli ProRS. ProRS is also sensitive to changes that are likely to alter the helical conformation in the T psi C stem.

The nucleocapsid protein specifically anneals tRNALys-3 onto a noncomplementary primer binding site within the HIV-1 RNA genome in vitro.

HIV type 1 (HIV-1) specifically uses host cell tRNALys-3 as a primer for reverse transcription. The 3' 18 nucleotides of this tRNA are complementary to a region on the HIV RNA genome known as the primer binding site (PBS). HIV-1 has a strong preference for maintaining a lysine-specific PBS in vivo, and viral genomes with mutated PBS sequences quickly revert to be complementary to tRNALys-3. To investigate the mechanism for the observed PBS reversion events in vitro, we examined the capability of the nucleocapsid protein (NC) to anneal various tRNA primer sequences onto either complementary or noncomplementary PBSs. We show that NC can anneal different full-length tRNAs onto viral RNA transcripts derived from the HIV-1 MAL or HXB2 isolates, provided that the PBS is complementary to the tRNA used. In contrast, NC promotes specific annealing of only tRNALys-3 onto an RNA template (HXB2) whose PBS sequence has been mutated to be complementary to the 3' 18 nt of human tRNAPro. Moreover, HIV-1 reverse transcriptase extends this binary complex from the proline-specific PBS. The formation of the noncomplementary binary complex does not occur when a chimeric tRNALys/Pro containing proline-specific D and anticodon domains is used as the primer. Thus, elements outside the acceptor-TPsiC domains of tRNALys-3 play an important role in preferential primer use in vitro. Our results support the hypothesis that mutant PBS reversion is a result of tRNALys-3 annealing onto and extension from a PBS that specifies an alternate host cell tRNA.

Functional contacts of a transfer RNA synthetase with 2'-hydroxyl groups in the RNA minor groove.

The functional analysis of determinants on RNA has been largely limited to molecules that contain naturally occurring ribonucleotides, so little is known about the role of 2'-hydroxyl groups in protein-RNA recognition. A single base pair (G3.U70) in the acceptor stem of tRNA(Ala) is the principal element for specific recognition by Escherichia coli alanine-tRNA synthetase. This tRNA synthetase aminoacylates small RNA helices that contain the G3.U70 base pair. Furthermore, removal of the G3 exocyclic 2-amino group that projects into the minor groove eliminates aminoacylation. This 2-amino group is flanked on either side by ribose 2'-hydroxyl groups that line the minor groove. Here we use chemical synthesis to construct 32 helices that make deoxy and O-methyl substitutions of individual and multiple 2'-hydroxyl groups near and beyond the G3.U70 base pair and find that functional 2'-hydroxyl contacts are clustered within a few ångstroms of the critical 2-amino group. These contacts are highly specific and make a thermodynamically significant contribution to RNA recognition.

Aminoacylation of RNA oligonucleotides: minimalist structures and origin of specificity.

Aminoacyl tRNA synthetases are divided into two unrelated classes of ten enzymes each. Members from each class specifically aminoacylate small RNA oligonucleotides lacking anticodon sequences. Duplex structures with only four base pairs stabilized by RNA tetraloop motifs are active. Atomic groups on bases and ribose 2'-hydroxyl groups in the RNA minor groove make functional contacts that are essential for aminoacylation and provide the high specificity. A system for specific aminoacylation of small RNA oligonucleotides that is based on sequences proximal to the amino acid attachment site may reflect the small sizes of early synthetases.

Transfer RNA aminoacylation: identification of a critical ribose 2'-hydroxyl-base interaction.

To understand the relationship between tRNA architecture and specific aminoacylation by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, we performed kinetic assays of Escherichia coli tRNA(Pro) molecules containing single deoxynucleotide substitutions. We identified an important 2'-hydroxyl group at position U8 (of 22 positions probed). Chemical modification studies showed that this 2'-hydroxyl interacts with either the N1 or the exocyclic amine of G46 in a hydrogen bonding interaction that contributes 1.8 kcal/mol to the free energy of activation for aminoacylation. Molecular modeling of tRNA(Pro) supports the existence of this interaction. This is the first study to identify a specific ribose 2'-hydroxyl-base interaction in the core region of a tRNA molecule that makes a thermodynamically significant contribution to aminoacylation.

Acceptor helix interactions in a class II tRNA synthetase: photoaffinity cross-linking of an RNA miniduplex substrate.

The 875 amino acid class II Escherichia coli alanine tRNA synthetase aminoacylates hairpin minihelices and miniduplexes comprising complementary base pairs that reconstruct the acceptor helix of alanine tRNA. Aminoacylation is dependent upon a G3:U70 base pair in the tRNA acceptor stem. A synthetic RNA miniduplex with a phosphorothioate internucleotide linkage on the 5'-side of U70 facilitated the stable attachment of a pendant benzophenone to the ribonucleotide backbone. The benzophenone-labeled duplex is active for aminoacylation. Irradiation of the labeled duplex produced a cross-linked RNA protein complex, in which the major site of RNA attachment is the segment between the class II defining sequence motifs 2 and 3. This segment spans a putative zinc-binding motif, which has been implicated in acceptor helix recognition, and is within a 461 amino acid N-terminal fragment that was recently shown to have full activity for minihelix aminoacylation. These results, together with the X-ray crystallographic investigations of the class II aspartate tRNA synthetase-tRNA(Asp) complex, suggest that the segment between motifs 2 and 3 in the 10 class II synthetases contributes generally to the docking of tRNA acceptor helices. The sequence diversity of this segment implies that its mode of interaction with the acceptor helix is idiosyncratic to the class II enzyme.

Transfer RNA recognition by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases.

The aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are an ancient group of enzymes that catalyze the covalent attachment of an amino acid to its cognate transfer RNA. The question of specificity, that is, how each synthetase selects the correct individual or isoacceptor set of tRNAs for each amino acid, has been referred to as the second genetic code. A wealth of structural, biochemical, and genetic data on this subject has accumulated over the past 40 years. Although there are now crystal structures of sixteen of the twenty synthetases from various species, there are only a few high resolution structures of synthetases complexed with cognate tRNAs. Here we review briefly the structural information available for synthetases, and focus on the structural features of tRNA that may be used for recognition. Finally, we explore in detail the insights into specific recognition gained from classical and atomic group mutagenesis experiments performed with tRNAs, tRNA fragments, and small RNAs mimicking portions of tRNAs.

Use of terbium as a probe of tRNA tertiary structure and folding.

Lanthanide metals such as terbium have previously been shown to be useful for mapping metal-binding sites in RNA. Terbium binds to the same sites on RNA as magnesium, however, with a much higher affinity. Thus, low concentrations of terbium ions can easily displace magnesium and promote phosphodiester backbone scission. At higher concentrations, terbium cleaves RNA in a sequence-independent manner, with a preference for single-stranded, non-Watson-Crick base-paired regions. Here, we show that terbium is a sensitive probe of human tRNALys,3 tertiary structure and folding. When 1 microM tRNA is used, the optimal terbium ion concentration for detecting Mg2+-induced tertiary structural changes is 50-60 microM. Using these concentrations of RNA and terbium, a magnesium-dependent folding transition with a midpoint (KMg) of 2.6 mM is observed for unmodified human tRNALys,3. At lower Tb3+ concentrations, cleavage is restricted to nucleotides that constitute specific metal-binding pockets. This small chemical probe should also be useful for detecting protein induced structural changes in RNA.

Species-specific differences in amino acid editing by class II prolyl-tRNA synthetase.

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are a family of enzymes responsible for ensuring the accuracy of the genetic code by specifically attaching a particular amino acid to their cognate tRNA substrates. Through primary sequence alignments, prolyl-tRNA synthetases (ProRSs) have been divided into two phylogenetically divergent groups. We have been interested in understanding whether the unusual evolutionary pattern of ProRSs corresponds to functional differences as well. Previously, we showed that some features of tRNA recognition and aminoacylation are indeed group-specific. Here, we examine the species-specific differences in another enzymatic activity, namely amino acid editing. Proofreading or editing provides a mechanism by which incorrectly activated amino acids are hydrolyzed and thus prevented from misincorporation into proteins. "Prokaryotic-like" Escherichia coli ProRS has recently been shown to be capable of misactivating alanine and possesses both pretransfer and post-transfer hydrolytic editing activity against this noncognate amino acid. We now find that two ProRSs belonging to the "eukaryotic-like" group exhibit differences in their hydrolytic editing activity. Whereas ProRS from Methanococcus jannaschii is similar to E. coli in its ability to hydrolyze misactivated alanine via both pretransfer and post-transfer editing pathways, human ProRS lacks these activities. These results have implications for the selection or design of antibiotics that specifically target the editing active site of the prokaryotic-like group of ProRSs.

Hydrolytic editing by a class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase.

Editing reactions catalyzed by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are critical for accurate translation of the genetic code. To date, this activity, whereby misactivated amino acids are hydrolyzed either before or after transfer to noncognate tRNAs, has been characterized extensively only in the case of class I synthetases. Class II synthetases have an active-site architecture that is completely distinct from that of class I. Thus, findings on editing by class I synthetases may not be applicable generally to class II enzymes. Class II Escherichia coli proline-tRNA synthetase is shown here to misactivate alanine and to hydrolyze the noncognate amino acid before transfer to tRNA(Pro). This enzyme also is capable of rapidly deacylating a mischarged Ala-tRNA(Pro) variant. A single cysteine residue (C443) that is located within the class II-specific motif 3 consensus sequence was shown previously to be dispensable for proline-tRNA synthetase aminoacylation activity. We show here that C443 is critical for the hydrolytic editing of Ala-tRNA(Pro) by this class II synthetase.

Escherichia coli proline tRNA synthetase is sensitive to changes in the core region of tRNA(Pro).

To investigate the relationship between tRNA conformation and specific recognition by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, a full-length tRNA molecule was assembled by annealing together two oligonucleotides representing fragments of Escherichia coli tRNA(Pro). A shorter chemically synthesized 5'-fragment (7-18 nucleotides) was combined with an in vitro transcribed 3'-fragment (59 nucleotides). Despite a break in the phosphodiester backbone between nucleotides U17a and G18, this tRNA molecule was an efficient substrate for class II Escherichia coli proline tRNA synthetase. While the deletion of three D-loop nucleotides (U17a, U17, and C16) was tolerated, removal of G15 and A14 significantly reduced aminoacylation efficiency. Hybrid DNA-RNA "annealed" substrates were also prepared and assayed for aminoacylation. Native gel electrophoresis was used to compare the global folding of the various substrates tested. The results of these studies suggest that proline tRNA synthetase is sensitive to changes in the core region of tRNA(Pro) through which information required for efficient aminoacylation may be transmitted. In particular, nucleotides in the D-loop and backbone functional groups in the D-stem appear to be critical for maintaining a tRNA structure that is optimal for recognition by proline tRNA synthetase in vitro.

Understanding species-specific differences in substrate recognition by Escherichia coli and human prolyl-tRNA synthetases.

Class II human prolyl-tRNA synthetase (ProRS) aminoacylates in vitro transcribed human tRNA(Pro) with kinetic parameters that are similar to those previously determined for aminoacylation of Escherichia coli tRNA(Pro) by its cognate synthetase. As in the bacterial system, large decreases in aminoacylation by human ProRS occur upon mutating anticodon positions G35 and G36 of human tRNA(Pro). The N73 'discriminator' base and the first and third base pairs of the acceptor stem vary between the E.coli and human isoacceptor groups. In contrast to the E. coli synthetase, the human enzyme does not appear to recognize these elements, since mutations at these positions do not significantly affect cognate synthetase charging. E. coli ProRS does not cross-aminoacylate human tRNA(Pro), and the bacterial tRNA(Pro) is a poor substrate for the human enzyme. Mutations in both the tRNAs and the synthetases have been made in an effort to identify elements in each system responsible for blocking cross-species aminoacylation. Alignment of all known ProRS primary sequences from different species reveals particularly low overall sequence homology, as well as two distinct groups of enzymes. The sequence divergence between E. coli and human ProRSs helps to explain the species-specific differences in the RNA code for aminoacylation of tRNA(Pro).

Rotational dynamics of chloroplast ATP synthase in phospholipid vesicles.

The rotational dynamics of the purified dicyclohexylcarbodiimide-sensitive H(+)-ATPase (DSA) reconstituted into phospholipid vesicles and of the DSA coreconstituted with the proton pump bacterio-rhodopsin were examined by using the technique of time-resolved phosphorescence emission anisotrophy. The phosphorescent probe erythrosin isothiocyanate was used to covalently label the gamma-polypeptide of DSA before reconstitution. Rotational correlation times were measured under a variety of conditions. The rotational correlation time was independent of the viscosity of the external medium but increased significantly as the microviscosity of the membrane increased. This indicates the rotational correlation times are a measure of the enzyme motion within the membrane. The activation energy associated with the rotational correlation time is 8-10 kcal/mol. At 4 degrees C, the correlation time, typically approximately 100-180 microseconds, was unaffected by the addition of substrates and the presence of a membrane pH gradient. Therefore, molecular rotation of the DSA does not appear to play an important role in enzyme catalysis or ion pumping.

Enzymatic aminoacylation of single-stranded RNA with an RNA cofactor.

A chemically synthesized single-stranded ribonucleotide tridecamer derived from the 3' end of Escherichia coli alanine tRNA can be charged with alanine in the presence of short complementary RNA oligonucleotides that form duplexes with the 3' fragment. Complementary 5' oligomers of 9, 8, 6, and 4 nucleotides all confer charging of the 3' fragment. Furthermore, in the presence of limiting 5' oligomer, greater than stoichiometric amounts of the single-stranded 3' acceptor fragment can be aminoacylated. This is due to a reiterative process of transient duplex formation followed by charging, dissociation of the 5' oligomer, and then rebinding to an uncharged single-stranded ribotridecamer so as to create another transient duplex substrate. Thus, a short RNA oligomer serves as a cofactor for a charging enzyme, and it thereby makes possible the aminoacylation of single-stranded RNA. These results expand possibilities for flexible routes to the development of early charging and coding systems.

Region of a conserved sequence motif in a class II tRNA synthetase needed for transfer of an activated amino acid to an RNA substrate.

The class II Escherichia coli alanine tRNA synthetase aminoacylates RNA miniduplexes, which reconstruct the acceptor end of alanine tRNA with the critical G3:U70 base pair. A benzophenone photoaffinity label attached adjacent to G3:U70 in a miniduplex substrate was previously cross-linked to a long enzyme peptide that begins at Gly161 between the class-defining motifs 2 and 3 [Musier-Forsyth, K., & Schimmel, P. (1994) Biochemistry 33, 773-779]. To identify side chains in this peptide that potentially contribute hydrogen bonding or catalytic determinants for the RNA-dependent step of the aminoacylation reaction, peptide functional side chains that are conserved among sequenced alanine enzymes (Asp, Asn, Arg, Glu, Gln, and Tyr) were individually replaced. Of the 21 mutant proteins so generated, one was identified that was not viable even though it accumulated in vivo. This Asp235-->Ala mutant enzyme is defective in the rate of transfer of the activated amino acid to the 3'-end of the RNA substrate. The conserved Asp235 is at the beginning of motif 3. By comparison with the crystal structure of the related class II yeast aspartate tRNA synthetase complexed with tRNA(Asp) (Cavarelli et al., 1993), we suggest that D235 is not in direct contact with acceptor helix base pairs such as G3:U70. Instead, we propose that D235 contributes to transfer-step interactions at the 3'-end of alanine tRNA. Because D235 in alanine tRNA synthetase is at the beginning of one of the conserved motifs that define class II tRNA synthetases, this region of the structure may in general be important for the transfer step.