Mechanistically Guided Materials Chemistry: Synthesis of Ternary Nitrides, CaZrN2 and CaHfN2.

Recent computational studies have predicted many new ternary nitrides, revealing synthetic opportunities in this underexplored phase space. However, synthesizing new ternary nitrides is difficult, in part because intermediate and product phases often have high cohesive energies that inhibit diffusion. Here, we report the synthesis of two new phases, calcium zirconium nitride (CaZrN2) and calcium hafnium nitride (CaHfN2), by solid state metathesis reactions between Ca3N2 and MCl4 (M = Zr, Hf). Although the reaction nominally proceeds to the target phases in a 1:1 ratio of the precursors via Ca3N2 + MCl4 → CaMN2 + 2 CaCl2, reactions prepared this way result in Ca-poor materials (CaxM2-xN2, x < 1). A small excess of Ca3N2 (ca. 20 mol %) is needed to yield stoichiometric CaMN2, as confirmed by high-resolution synchrotron powder X-ray diffraction. In situ synchrotron X-ray diffraction studies reveal that nominally stoichiometric reactions produce Zr3+ intermediates early in the reaction pathway, and the excess Ca3N2 is needed to reoxidize Zr3+ intermediates back to the Zr4+ oxidation state of CaZrN2. Analysis of computationally derived chemical potential diagrams rationalizes this synthetic approach and its contrast from the synthesis of MgZrN2. These findings additionally highlight the utility of in situ diffraction studies and computational thermochemistry to provide mechanistic guidance for synthesis.

Selective Synthesis of Defect-Rich LaMnO3 by Low-Temperature Anion Cometathesis.

The synthesis of complex oxides at low temperatures brings forward aspects of chemistry not typically considered. This study focuses on perovskite LaMnO3, which is of interest for its correlated electronic behavior tied to the oxidation state and thus the spin configuration of manganese. Traditional equilibrium synthesis of these materials typically requires synthesis reaction temperatures in excess of 1000 °C, followed by subsequent annealing steps at lower temperatures and different p(O2) conditions to manipulate the oxygen content postsynthesis (e.g., LaMnO3+x). Double-ion exchange (metathesis) reactions have recently been shown to react at much lower temperatures (500-800 °C), highlighting a fundamental knowledge gap for how solids react at lower temperatures. Here, we revisit the metathesis reaction, LiMnO2 + LaOX, where X is a halide or mixture of halides, using in situ synchrotron X-ray diffraction. These experiments reveal low reaction onset temperatures (ca. 450-480 °C). The lowest reaction temperatures are achieved by a mixture of lanthanum oxyhalide precursors: 2 LiMnO2 + LaOCl + LaOBr. In all cases, the resulting products are the expected alkali halide salt and defective La1-ϵMn1-ϵO3, where ϵ = x/(3 + x). We observe a systematic variation in defect concentration, consistent with a rapid stoichiometric local equilibration of the precursors and the subsequent global thermodynamic equilibration with O2 (g), as revealed by computational thermodynamics. Together, these results reveal how the inclusion of additional elements (e.g., Li and a halide) leads to the local equilibrium, particularly at low reaction temperatures for solid-state chemistry.

Thiocyanate-Stabilized Pseudo-cubic Perovskite CH(NH2)2PbI3 from Coincident Columnar Defect Lattices.

α-FAPbI3 (FA+ = CH(NH2)2+) with a cubic perovskite structure is promising for photophysical applications. However, α-FAPbI3 is metastable at room temperature, and it transforms to the δ-phase at a certain period of time at room temperature. Herein, we report a thiocyanate-stabilized pseudo-cubic perovskite FAPbI3 with ordered columnar defects (α'-phase). This compound has a √5ap × âˆš5ap × ap tetragonal unit cell (ap: cell parameter of primitive perovskite cell) with a band gap of 1.91 eV. It is stable at room temperature in a dry atmosphere. Furthermore, the presence of the α'-phase in a mixed sample with the δ-phase drastically reduces the δ-to-α transition temperature measured on heating, suggesting the reduction of the nucleation energy of the α-phase or thermodynamic stabilization of the α-phase through epitaxy. The defect-ordered pattern in the α'-phase forms a coincidence-site lattice at the twinned boundary of the single crystals, thus hinting at an epitaxy- or strain-based mechanism of α-phase formation and/or stabilization. In this study, we developed a new strategy to control defects in halide perovskites and provided new insight into the stabilization of α-FAPbI3 by pseudo-halide and grain boundary engineering.

Correlating Broadband Photoluminescence with Structural Dynamics in Layered Hybrid Halide Perovskites.

The emission of white light from a single material is atypical and is of interest for solid-state lighting applications. Broadband light emission has been observed in some layered perovskite derivatives, A2PbBr4 (A = R-NH3+), and correlates with static structural distortions corresponding to out-of-plane tilting of the lead bromide octahedra. While materials with different organic cations can yield distinct out-of-plane tilts, the underlying origin of the octahedral tilting remains poorly understood. Using high energy resolution (e.g., quasi-elastic) neutron scattering, this contribution details the rotational dynamics of the organic cations in A2PbBr4 materials where A = n-butylammonium (nBA), 1,8-diaminooctammonium (ODA), and 4-aminobutyric acid (GABA). The organic cation dynamics differentiate (nBA)2PbBr4 from (ODA)PbBr4 or (GABA)2PbBr4 in that the larger spatial extent of dynamics of nBA yields a larger effective cation radius. The larger effective volume of the nBA cation in (nBA)2PbBr4 yields a closer to ideal A-site geometry, preventing the out-of-plane tilt and broadband luminescence. In all three compounds, we observe hydrogen dynamics attributed to rotation of the ammonium headgroup and at a time scale faster than the white light photoluminescence studied by time-correlated single photon counting spectroscopy. This supports a previous assignment of the broadband emission as resulting from a single ensemble, such that the emissive excited state experiences many local structures faster than the emissive decay. The findings presented here highlight the role of the organic cation and its dynamics in hybrid organic-inorganic perovskites and white light emission.

Selectivity in Yttrium Manganese Oxide Synthesis via Local Chemical Potentials in Hyperdimensional Phase Space.

In sharp contrast to molecular synthesis, materials synthesis is generally presumed to lack selectivity. The few known methods of designing selectivity in solid-state reactions have limited scope, such as topotactic reactions or strain stabilization. This contribution describes a general approach for searching large chemical spaces to identify selective reactions. This novel approach explains the ability of a nominally "innocent" Na2CO3 precursor to enable the metathesis synthesis of single-phase Y2Mn2O7: an outcome that was previously only accomplished at extreme pressures and which cannot be achieved with closely related precursors of Li2CO3 and K2CO3 under identical conditions. By calculating the required change in chemical potential across all possible reactant-product interfaces in an expanded chemical space including Y, Mn, O, alkali metals, and halogens, using thermodynamic parameters obtained from density functional theory calculations, we identify reactions that minimize the thermodynamic competition from intermediates. In this manner, only the Na-based intermediates minimize the distance in the hyperdimensional chemical potential space to Y2Mn2O7, thus providing selective access to a phase which was previously thought to be metastable. Experimental evidence validating this mechanism for pathway-dependent selectivity is provided by intermediates identified from in situ synchrotron-based crystallographic analysis. This approach of calculating chemical potential distances in hyperdimensional compositional spaces provides a general method for designing selective solid-state syntheses that will be useful for gaining access to metastable phases and for identifying reaction pathways that can reduce the synthesis temperature, and cost, of technological materials.

Amide-Assisted Synthesis of Iron Germanium Sulfide (Fe2GeS4) Nanostars: The Effect of LiN(SiMe3)2 on Precursor Reactivity for Favoring Nanoparticle Nucleation or Growth.

Olivine Fe2GeS4 has been identified as a promising photovoltaic absorber material introduced as an alternate candidate to iron pyrite, FeS2. The compounds share similar benefits in terms of elemental abundance and relative nontoxicity, but Fe2GeS4 was predicted to have higher stability with respect to decomposition to alternate phases and, therefore, more optimal device performance. Our initial report of the nanoparticle (NP) synthesis for Fe2GeS4 was not well understood and required an inefficient 24 h growth to dissolve an iron sulfide impurity. Here, we report an amide-assisted Fe2GeS4 NP synthesis that directly forms the phase-pure product in minutes. This significant advance was achieved by the replacement of the poorly understood hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS) additive and TMS2S by the conjugate base, lithium bis(trimethylsilyl)amide (LiN(SiMe3)2), and elemental S, respectively. We hypothesized that fragments of both TMS2S and HMDS had carried out the roles that Brønsted bases play in amide-assisted NP syntheses and were necessary for Ge incorporation. Convolution of this role with the supply of S in TMS2S caused the iron sulfide impurities. Separating these effects in the use of LiN(SiMe3)2 and elemental S resulted in synthetic control over the ternary phase. Herein we explore the Fe-Ge-S reaction landscape and the role of the base. Its concentration was found to increase the reactivities of the Fe, Ge, and S precursors, and we discuss possible metal-amide intermediates. This affords tunability in two areas: favorability of NP nucleation versus growth and phase formation. The phase-purity of Fe2GeS4 depends on the molar ratios of the cations, base, and amine as well as the Fe:Ge:S molar ratios. The resultant Fe2GeS4 NPs exhibit an interesting star anise-like morphology with stacks of nanoplates that intersect along a 6-fold rotation axis. The optical properties of the Fe2GeS4 NPs are consistent with previously published measurements showing a measured band gap of 1.48 eV.

Ferroelastic Phase Transition in Formamidinium Tin(IV) Iodide Driven by Organic-Inorganic Coupling.

Hybrid perovskites are a technologically relevant family of materials, with potential applications in photovoltaics, solid-state lighting, and radiation detection. Interactions between the inorganic octahedral framework and the organic sublattice have been implicated in the structure and optoelectronic properties, but characterization of these interactions has been challenging, because of competition between organic-inorganic coupling and intraoctahedral interactions. Owing to their decreased octahedral connectivity, vacancy-ordered double perovskites present an ideal case study to examine organic-inorganic coupling in hybrid perovskites and their derivatives. Here, we describe the low-temperature, hysteretic phase transition of formamidinium tin(IV) iodide from the high-symmetry cubic phase to a lower-symmetry monoclinic phase. We propose that the hysteresis stems from organic-inorganic coupling mediated by local and spontaneous strain from the orientations of the formamidinium cations, which result in a ferroelastic phase transition.

Structure and Optical Properties of Layered Perovskite (MA)2PbI2-xBrx(SCN)2 (0 ≤ x < 1.6).

The layered perovskite (MA)2PbI2(SCN)2 (MA = CH3NH3+) is a member of an emerging series of compounds derived from hybrid organic-inorganic perovskites. Here, we successfully synthesized (MA)2PbI2-xBrx(SCN)2 (0 ≤ x < 1.6) by using a solid-state reaction. Despite smaller bromide substitution for iodine, 1% linear expansion along the a axis was observed at x ∼ 0.4 due to a change of the orientation of the SCN- anions. Diffuse reflectance spectra reveal that the optical band gap increases by the bromide substitution, which is supported by the DFT calculations. Curiously, bromine-rich compounds where x ≥ 0.8 are light sensitive, leading to partial decomposition after ∼24 h. This study demonstrates that the layered perovskite (MA)2PbI2(SCN)2 tolerates a wide range of bromide substitution toward tuning the band gap energy.

Defect-Accommodating Intermediates Yield Selective Low-Temperature Synthesis of YMnO3 Polymorphs.

In the synthesis of complex oxides, solid-state metathesis provides low-temperature reactions where product selectivity can be achieved through simple changes in precursor composition. The influence of precursor structure, however, is less understood in solid-state synthesis. Here we present the ternary metathesis reaction (LiMnO2 + YOCl → YMnO3 + LiCl) to target two yttrium manganese oxide products, hexagonal and orthorhombic YMnO3, when starting from three different LiMnO2 precursors. Using temperature-dependent synchrotron X-ray and neutron diffraction, we identify the relevant intermediates and temperature regimes of reactions along the pathway to YMnO3. Manganese-containing intermediates undergo a charge disproportionation into a reduced Mn(II,III) tetragonal spinel and oxidized Mn(III,IV) cubic spinel, which lead to hexagonal and orthorhombic YMnO3, respectively. Density functional theory calculations confirm that the presence of Mn(IV) caused by a small concentration of cation vacancies (∼2.2%) in YMnO3 stabilizes the orthorhombic polymorph over the hexagonal. Reactions over the course of 2 weeks yield o-YMnO3 as the majority product at temperatures below 600 °C, which supports an equilibration of cation defects over time. Controlling the composition and structure of these defect-accommodating intermediates provides new strategies for selective synthesis of complex oxides at low temperatures.

Selective Formation of Yttrium Manganese Oxides through Kinetically Competent Assisted Metathesis Reactions.

The synthesis of complex oxides requires high temperatures to overcome barriers imparted by solid-state diffusion; as such, reactions typically yield the most stable polymorph for a given composition. To synthesize new or metastable complex oxides, kinetically competent reactions with lower initial energy barriers must be devised to control the reaction pathway and resulting products. This contribution details the selective synthesis of different yttrium manganese oxides through assisted metathesis reactions between Mn2O3, YCl3, and A2CO3 under flowing oxygen; where A = Li, Na, K. With lithium carbonate, the orthorhombic perovskite o-YMnO3 (o-YMnO3+δ) forms over the temperature range of 550-850 °C. With sodium carbonate, the pyrochlore Y2Mn2O7 forms at 650 °C. No apparent selectivity is observed with K2CO3, and all alkalis yields hexagonal YMnO3 at T > 950 °C. The alkali species modify the reaction pathway and thus impart kinetic control in the formation of both phases.

Yttrium Manganese Oxide Phase Stability and Selectivity Using Lithium Carbonate Assisted Metathesis Reactions.

In solid-state chemistry, stable phases are often missed if their synthesis is impractical, such as when decomposition or a polymorphic transition occurs at relatively low temperature. In the preparation of complex oxides, reaction temperatures commonly exceed 1000 °C with little to no control of the reaction pathway. Thus, a prerequisite for exploring the synthesis of complex oxides is to identify reactions with intermediates that are kinetically competent at low temperatures, as provided by assisted metathesis reactions. Here, we study the assisted metathesis reaction Mn2O3 + 2.2YCl3·6H2O + 3Li2CO3 → 2YMnO3 + 5.8LiCl + 0.2LiYCl4 + 3CO2 using in situ synchrotron X-ray diffraction. By changing the atmosphere, oxygen vs inert gas, the reaction product changes from the overoxidized perovskite YMnO3+δ to the hexagonal YMnO3 polymorph at the reaction temperature of 850 °C, respectively. Analysis of the reaction pathways reveals two parallel reaction pathways in forming YMnO3 phases: (1) the slow reaction of metal oxides in a LiCl flux (Y2O3 + Mn2O3 [Formula: see text] 2YMnO3) and (2) the fast reaction from ternary intermediates (YOCl + LiMnO2 → LiCl + YMnO3). Control reactions reveal that both proposed pathways in isolation result in product formation, but the direct preparation of ternary intermediates (YOCl + LiMnO2 → LiCl + YMnO3) occurs at lower temperatures (500 °C) and shorter times (<24 h) and forms nominally stoichiometric orthorhombic YMnO3. These ternary intermediates react at a faster rate than the slow stepwise oxygenation of yttrium chloride to Y2O3 (YCl3 → YOCl → Y3O4Cl → Y2O3), which is relatively inert. These results support a kinetically controlled reaction pathway to form YMnO3 phases in assisted metathesis reactions with phase selectivity achievable through changes to reaction atmosphere.

Hybrid Charge-Transfer Semiconductors: (C7H7)SbI4, (C7H7)BiI4, and Their Halide Congeners.

Hybrid metal halides yield highly desirable optoelectronic properties and offer significant opportunity due to their solution processability. This contribution reports a new series of hybrid semiconductors, (C7H7)MX4 (M = Bi3+, Sb3+; X = Cl-, Br-, I-), that are composed of edge-sharing MX6 chains separated in space by π-stacked tropylium (C7H7+) cations; the inorganic chains resemble the connectivity of BiI3. The Bi3+ compounds have blue-shifted optical absorptions relative to the Sb3+ compounds that span the visible and near-IR region. Consistent with observations, DFT calculations reveal that the conduction band is composed of the tropylium cation and valence band primarily the inorganic chain: a charge-transfer semiconductor. The band gaps for both Bi3+ and Sb3+ compounds decrease systematically as a function of increasing halide size. These compounds are a rare example of charge-transfer semiconductors that also exhibit efficient crystal packing of the organic cations, thus providing an opportunity to study how structural packing affects optoelectronic properties.

Circumventing Diffusion in Kinetically Controlled Solid-State Metathesis Reactions.

Solid-state diffusion is often the primary limitation in the synthesis of crystalline inorganic materials and prevents the potential discovery and isolation of new materials that may not be the most stable with respect to the reaction conditions. Synthetic approaches that circumvent diffusion in solid-state reactions are rare and often allow the formation of metastable products. To this end, we present an in situ study of the solid-state metathesis reactions MCl2 + Na2S2 → MS2 + 2 NaCl (M = Fe, Co, Ni) using synchrotron powder X-ray diffraction and differential scanning calorimetry. Depending on the preparation method of the reaction, either combining the reactants in an air-free environment or grinding homogeneously in air before annealing, the barrier to product formation, and therefore reaction pathway, can be altered. In the air-free reactions, the product formation appears to be diffusion limited, with a number of intermediate phases observed before formation of the MS2 product. However, grinding the reactants in air allows NaCl to form directly without annealing and displaces the corresponding metal and sulfide ions into an amorphous matrix, as confirmed by pair distribution function analysis. Heating this mixture yields direct nucleation of the MS2 phase and avoids all crystalline binary intermediates. Grinding in air also dissipates a large amount of lattice energy via the formation of NaCl, and the crystallization of the metal sulfide is a much less exothermic process. This approach has the potential to allow formation of a range of binary, ternary, or higher-ordered compounds to be synthesized in the bulk, while avoiding the formation of many binary intermediates that may otherwise form in a diffusion-limited reaction.

Defect Tolerance to Intolerance in the Vacancy-Ordered Double Perovskite Semiconductors Cs2SnI6 and Cs2TeI6.

Vacancy-ordered double perovskites of the general formula A2BX6 are a family of perovskite derivatives composed of a face-centered lattice of nearly isolated [BX6] units with A-site cations occupying the cuboctahedral voids. Despite the presence of isolated octahedral units, the close-packed iodide lattice provides significant electronic dispersion, such that Cs2SnI6 has recently been explored for applications in photovoltaic devices. To elucidate the structure-property relationships of these materials, we have synthesized solid-solution Cs2Sn1-xTexI6. However, even though tellurium substitution increases electronic dispersion via closer I-I contact distances, the substitution experimentally yields insulating behavior from a significant decrease in carrier concentration and mobility. Density functional calculations of native defects in Cs2SnI6 reveal that iodine vacancies exhibit a low enthalpy of formation, and that the defect energy level is a shallow donor to the conduction band rendering the material tolerant to these defect states. The increased covalency of Te-I bonding renders the formation of iodine vacancy states unfavorable and is responsible for the reduction in conductivity upon Te substitution. Additionally, Cs2TeI6 is intolerant to the formation of these defects, because the defect level occurs deep within the band gap and thus localizes potential mobile charge carriers. In these vacancy-ordered double perovskites, the close-packed lattice of iodine provides significant electronic dispersion, while the interaction of the B- and X-site ions dictates the properties as they pertain to electronic structure and defect tolerance. This simplified perspective based on extensive experimental and theoretical analysis provides a platform from which to understand structure-property relationships in functional perovskite halides.

Paracrystalline Disorder from Phosphate Ion Orientation and Substitution in Synthetic Bone Mineral.

Hydroxyapatite is an inorganic mineral closely resembling the mineral phase in bone. However, as a biological mineral, it is highly disordered, and its composition and atomistic structure remain poorly understood. Here, synchrotron X-ray total scattering and pair distribution function analysis methods provide insight into the nature of atomistic disorder in a synthetic bone mineral analogue, chemically substituted hydroxyapatite. By varying the effective hydrolysis rate and/or carbonate concentration during growth of the mineral, compounds with varied degrees of paracrystallinity are prepared. From advanced simulations constrained by the experimental pair distribution function and density functional theory, the paracrystalline disorder prevalent in these materials appears to result from accommodation of carbonate in the lattice through random displacement of the phosphate groups. Though many substitution modalities are likely to occur in concert, the most predominant substitution places carbonate into the mirror plane of an ideal phosphate site. Understanding the mineralogical imperfections of a biologically analogous hydroxyapatite is important not only to potential bone grafting applications but also to biological mineralization processes themselves.

Polymorph selectivity of superconducting CuSe2 through kinetic control of solid-state metathesis.

Rational preparation of materials by design is a major goal of inorganic, solid-state, and materials chemists alike. Oftentimes, the use of nonmetallurgical reactions (e.g., chalcogenide fluxes, hydrothermal syntheses, and in this case solid-state metathesis) alters the thermodynamic driving force of the reaction and allows new, refractory, or otherwise energetically unfavorable materials to form under softer conditions. Taking this a step further, alteration of a metathesis reaction pathway can result in either the formation of the equilibrium marcasite polymorph (by stringent exclusion of air) or the kinetically controlled formation of the high-pressure pyrite polymorph of CuSe2 (by exposure to air). From analysis of the reaction coordinate with in situ synchrotron X-ray diffraction and pair distribution function analysis as well as differential scanning calorimetry, it is clear that the air-exposed reaction proceeds via slight, endothermic rearrangements of crystalline intermediates to form pyrite, which is attributed to partial solvation of the reaction from atmospheric humidity. In contrast, the air-free reaction proceeds via a significant exothermic process to form marcasite. Decoupling the formation of NaCl from the formation of CuSe2 enables kinetic control to be exercised over the resulting polymorph of these superconducting metal dichalcogenides.

Hybrid inorganic-organic materials with an optoelectronically active aromatic cation: (C7H7)2SnI6 and C7H7PbI3.

Inorganic materials with organic constituents-hybrid materials-have shown incredible promise as chemically tunable functional materials with interesting optical and electronic properties. Here, the preparation and structure are reported of two hybrid materials containing the optoelectronically active tropylium ion within tin- and lead-iodide inorganic frameworks with distinct topologies. The crystal structures of tropylium tin iodide, (C7H7)2SnI6, and tropylium lead iodide, C7H7PbI3, were solved using high-resolution synchrotron powder X-ray diffraction informed by X-ray pair distribution function data and high-resolution time-of-flight neutron diffraction. Tropylium tin iodide contains isolated tin(IV)-iodide octahedra and crystallizes as a deep black solid, while tropylium lead iodide presents one-dimensional chains of face-sharing lead(II)-iodide octahedra and crystallizes as a bright red-orange powder. Experimental diffuse reflectance spectra are in good agreement with density functional calculations of the electronic structure. Calculations of the band decomposed charge densities suggest that the deep black color of tropylium tin iodide is attributed to iodide ligand to tin metal charge transfer, while the bright red-orange color of tropylium lead iodide arises from charge transfer between iodine and tropylium states. Understanding the origins of the observed optoelectronic properties of these two compounds, with respect to their distinct topologies and organic-inorganic interactions, provides insight into the design of tropylium-containing compounds for potential optical and electronic applications.

Evolutionary selection of enzymatically synthesized semiconductors from biomimetic mineralization vesicles.

The way nature evolves and sculpts materials using proteins inspires new approaches to materials engineering but is still not completely understood. Here, we present a cell-free synthetic biological platform to advance studies of biologically synthesized solid-state materials. This platform is capable of simultaneously exerting many of the hierarchical levels of control found in natural biomineralization, including genetic, chemical, spatial, structural, and morphological control, while supporting the evolutionary selection of new mineralizing proteins and the corresponding genetically encoded materials that they produce. DNA-directed protein expression and enzymatic mineralization occur on polystyrene microbeads in water-in-oil emulsions, yielding synthetic surrogates of biomineralizing cells that are then screened by flow sorting, with light-scattering signals used to sort the resulting mineralized composites differentially. We demonstrate the utility of this platform by evolutionarily selecting newly identified silicateins, biomineralizing enzymes previously identified from the silica skeleton of a marine sponge, for enzyme variants capable of synthesizing silicon dioxide (silica) or titanium dioxide (titania) composites. Mineral composites of intermediate strength are preferentially selected to remain intact for identification during cell sorting, and then to collapse postsorting to expose the encoding genes for enzymatic DNA amplification. Some of the newly selected silicatein variants catalyze the formation of crystalline silicates, whereas the parent silicateins lack this ability. The demonstrated bioengineered route to previously undescribed materials introduces in vitro enzyme selection as a viable strategy for mimicking genetic evolution of materials as it occurs in nature.

Pyrite formation via kinetic intermediates through low-temperature solid-state metathesis.

The preparation of materials with limited phase stabilities yet high kinetic activation barriers is challenging. Knowledge of their possible formation pathways aids in addressing these challenges. Metathesis reactions present an approach to circumvent these barriers; however, solid-state metathesis reactions are often too rapid from extensive self-heating to understand the reaction. The stoichiometric reaction of MCl2 salts (M = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn) with Na2S2 enables the formation of pyrite (FeS2), CoS2, and NiS2 at low temperatures (250-350 °C). Na2S2 has the same polyanionic dimer as found in the pyrite structure, which would suggest the possibility of a facile ion-exchange reaction. However, from high-resolution synchrotron X-ray diffraction and differential scanning calorimetry, the energetic driving force does not appear to result solely from NaCl formation but also from formation of intermediate and pyrite phases. It is apparent that the reaction proceeds through polyanionic disproportionation and formation of a low-density alkali-rich intermediate, followed by anionic comproportionation and atomic rearrangement into the pyrite phase. These results have profound implications for the use of low-temperature metathesis in achieving materials by design.