Retrovirus-mediated gene transfer as an approach to analyze neuroblastoma relapse after autologous bone marrow transplantation.

Disseminated neuroblastoma is a malignancy of children often treated by intensive chemotherapy/radiotherapy followed by autologous bone marrow transplantation (ABMT). A high proportion of those treated subsequently relapse. It is unknown if relapse is a consequence of residual disease in the patient or of contaminating malignant cells remaining in the infused marrow, which, of necessity, is harvested and stored prior to ablative chemotherapy/radiotherapy. The assumption that residual cells in the infused marrow contribute to relapse has lead to the adoption of marrow purging prior to reinfusion. However, neither the necessity nor the efficacy of the procedure have been established. We now show how retroviral-mediated gene transfer using the LNL6 vector may resolve this issue. Clonogenic neuroblastoma cells in patient marrow can be transduced and the NEOR gene detected by observing individual neuroblastoma cell colony growth in G418, and by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of individual colonies. Efficiency of transduction is between 0 and 13.5%. If marrow is exposed to LNL6 prior to infusion and marked cells are detected at the time of relapse, this would demonstrate that infused marrow contributed to disease recurrence. The technique could then be used to analyze the efficacy of marrow purging techniques. Since normal progenitor cells from these patients are also marked, the technique can be used to study factors that modify reconstitution and transducibility of infused marrow. Clinical studies using this approach have now begun.

Gene marking and autologous bone marrow transplantation.

If residual cancer cells in harvested bone marrow could be marked and subsequently detected in patients at relapse, valuable information would be obtained about the source of recurrent disease after autologous marrow transplantation. If normal progenitor cells were also marked, the study would provide useful data on the susceptibility of these human cells to gene transfer and their capacity to express newly introduced genes. We transferred the neomycin-resistance gene (NeoR) into bone marrow cells harvested from 20 children with acute myeloid leukemia (n = 12) or neuroblastoma (n = 8) in clinical and cytological remission using a retrovirus vector. The cells were then returned to the patients as part of an autologous bone marrow transplantation protocol. Two AML and three neuroblastoma patients have relapsed. In all, the resurgent cells contained the NeoR marker by analysis with PCR. These results prove that so-called remission marrow can contribute to relapse in patients who receive autologous transplants. The gene marking technique is now being used to evaluate techniques of pretransplant purging.

Gene marking to improve the outcome of autologous bone marrow transplantation.

The neomycin resistance gene in a retroviral vector has been used to mark the marrow of patients receiving autologous bone marrow transplantation for neuroblastoma and acute myeloid leukemia. We have shown that the marker gene can be detected in the resurgent malignant cells at the time of relapse, directly demonstrating that tumorigenic cells contaminate "remission" marrow. We have also shown effective gene transfer to normal primitive progenitor cells and demonstrated a long lasting contribution of the infused marrow to hematopoiesis. The gene marking technique is now being used to evaluate the efficacy of purging and the impact of growth factor treatment on long and short term hematopoietic reconstitution.

Gene marking and gene therapy for transplantation medicine.

The classic application for gene therapy is in the correction of single gene defects, although this has been complicated by the low efficiency of gene transfer into hematopoietic cells. Gene therapy, however, has potential for the modulation of tumor cell growth, drug sensitivity, and antitumor immune responses. In addition, gene marking can be used, in spite of this limited transfer efficiency, to provide information on hematopoiesis, sources of cancer relapse after stem cell transplant, and the relative efficacy of graft manipulation techniques. This article reviews the applications of gene therapy and gene marking in transplantation medicine.

Use of gene marking in bone marrow transplantation.

We have used gene marking to investigate the mechanism of relapse and biology of reconstitution following bone marrow transplantation (BMT). The rationale for our initial protocols was to learn if residual malignant cells in autologous marrow contribute to subsequent relapse. Marked malignant cells were found at the time of relapse in 6/8 patients relapsing after autologous BMT for AML or neuroblastoma showing the infused marrow contributed to disease recurrence. Modifications of this marker approach with two distinguishable vectors are now being used to compare the efficacy of purging techniques. We were also able to evaluate gene transfer to normal progenitors and demonstrated that the marker gene was expressed for up to 36 months. Gene marking is also being used to trace the fate of EBV-specific CTLs that we are administering to recipients of allogeneic BMT and has provided evidence of persistence of adoptively transferred CTL for up to 10 months.

Mechanisms of selective killing of neuroblastoma cells by natural killer cells and lymphokine activated killer cells. Potential for residual disease eradication.

Widely disseminated neuroblastoma in children older than infancy remains a very poor prognosis disease. Even the introduction of marrow ablative chemotherapy with autologous rescue has not significantly improved the outlook for these children, presumably because of a failure to eradicate minimal residual disease. One additional approach which may hold promise is the use of immunomodulation with cytokines such as IL2 in the setting of minimal residual disease (MDR), for example after intensive chemotherapy and ABMT. However, considerable variability in the susceptibility of neuroblastoma cells to natural killer (NK) and lymphokine-activated (LAK) killing has been observed, and it is presently unclear how NK and LAK cells recognise neuroblastoma cells. In this paper we examine expression of cell adhesion molecules on neuroblastoma to determine which of these modify interaction with NK and LAK cells. We find that LFA-3 (CD58), the ligand for CD2 is of predominant importance in predicting susceptibility of neuroblastoma to the cytotoxic actions of NK and LAK cells, while expression of ICAM-1 (CD54) may also modify susceptibility. These findings were confirmed by blocking experiments in which co-culture of target cells with ICAM-1 and LFA-3 reduced LAK and NK cytotoxicity. Study of the immunophenotypic features of each patient's neuroblastoma cells before induction of MRD may be valuable in determining the likely effect of IL2 in predicting disease reactivation.

Gene-marking to trace origin of relapse after autologous bone-marrow transplantation.

Bone marrow harvested for autologous bone-marrow transplantation may contain residual malignant cells even when it is judged to be in remission. Genetic marking and subsequent detection of these cells in recipients would give useful information about the origin of relapse after transplantation. We transferred the neomycin-resistance gene into bone-marrow cells harvested from children with acute myeloid leukaemia in remission. Two patients have relapsed since reinfusion of the marked cells. In both, the resurgent blast cells contained the neomycin-resistance gene marker; thus, remission marrow can contribute to disease recurrence. This method of tracking malignant cells should enable the development of better marrow purging strategies.

An approach for the analysis of relapse and marrow reconstitution after autologous marrow transplantation using retrovirus-mediated gene transfer.

Autologous bone marrow transplantation (ABMT) is widely used as treatment for malignant disease. Although the major cause of treatment failure is relapse, it is unknown if this arises entirely because of residual disease in the patient or whether contaminating cells in the rescuing marrow contribute. Attempts to purge marrow of its putative residual malignant cells may delay hematopoietic reconstitution and are of uncertain efficacy. We now describe how retrovirus-mediated gene transfer may be used to elucidate the source of relapse after ABMT for acute myeloid leukemia and to evaluate the efficacy of purging. Clonogenic myeloid leukemic blast cells in patient marrow can be transduced with the NeoR gene-containing helper-free retrovirus, LNL6, with an efficacy of 0% to 23.5% (mean, 10.5%). Transduced colonies grow in selective media and the presence of the marker gene can be confirmed in individual malignant colonies by polymerase chain reaction. If such malignant cells remain in harvested "remission" marrow, they will therefore be marked after exposure to LNL6. Detection of the marker gene in the malignant cells present at any later relapse would be firm evidence that residual disease contributed to disease recurrence, and would permit rapid subsequent evaluation of purging techniques. The technique also marks normal marrow progenitors from patients with acute myeloblastic leukemia. These colony-forming cells can be detected in long-term marrow cultures at a frequency of 1% to 18% for up to 10 weeks after exposure to the vector. Animal models and analysis of probability tables both suggest that these levels of marking in vitro are sufficient to provide information about the mechanisms of relapse and the biology of marrow regeneration in vivo. These preclinical data form part of the basis for current clinical studies of gene transfer into marrow before ABMT.

Gene marking to determine whether autologous marrow infusion restores long-term haemopoiesis in cancer patients.

The contribution of infused bone marrow cells to long-term haemopoietic recovery in patients undergoing autologous bone marrow transplantation is unknown. Such information would help to clarify the role of this procedure in cancer therapy and would aid in the development of strategies to reduce the risk of subsequent aplasia. By transferring a neomycin resistance marker gene into the marrow cells of 20 patients before transplantation, we were able to trace the pattern of haemopoietic reconstitution postinfusion. The marker gene was present and expressed in all haemopoietic lineages in vivo in 15 of 18 evaluable patients at 1 month post-transplantation, in 8 of 9 patients at 6 months, and in 5 of 5 at 1 year. The marker has remained detectable for up to 18 months--the duration of our study. Our findings indicate that harvested bone marrow consistently contributes to long-term multilineage recovery of haemopoiesis after autologous marrow transplantation in cancer patients. These results provide a rationale for the continued exploration of more ablative preparative regimens with single or sequential autologous marrow transplants.

Direct demonstration that autologous bone marrow transplantation for solid tumors can return a multiplicity of tumorigenic cells.

Patients with solid tumors are increasingly being treated by autologous bone marrow transplantation (BMT). Although response rates appear to be increased, disease recurrence is the commonest cause of treatment failure. Whether relapse is entirely due to residual disease in the patient or arises also from infiltrating malignant cells contained in the autologous marrow transplant has not been resolved. If the latter explanation is correct, then purging would be required as part of the transplantation procedure. We used retrovirally mediated transfer of the neomycin-resistance gene to mark BM harvested from eight patients with neuroblastoma in clinical remission. The marked marrow cells were subsequently reinfused as part of an autologous BMT. At relapse, we sought the marker gene in malignant cell populations. Three patients have relapsed, and in each the marker gene was detected by phenotypic and genetic analyses of resurgent malignant cells at medullary and extramedullary sites. Analysis of neuroblast DNA for discrete marker gene integration sites suggested that at least 200 malignant cells, each capable of tumor formation, were introduced with the autologous marrow transplant and contributed to relapse. Thus, autologous BMTs administered to patients with this solid tumor may contain a multiplicity of malignant cells that subsequently contribute to relapse. The marker-gene technique we describe should permit evaluation of the mechanisms of relapse and the efficacy of purging in patients receiving autologous marrow transplantation for other solid tumors that infiltrate the marrow.