Ultrafast mass spectrometry based bioanalytical method for digoxin supporting an in vitro P-glycoprotein (P-gp) inhibition screen.

The evaluation of interactions between drug candidates and transporters such as P-glycoprotein (P-gp) has gained considerable interest in drug discovery and development. Inhibition of P-gp can be assessed by performing bi-directional permeability studies with in vitro P-gp-expressing cellular model systems such as Caco-2 (human colon carcinoma) cells, using digoxin as a substrate probe. Existing methodologies include either assaying (3)H-digoxin with liquid scintillation counting (LSC) detection or assaying non-labeled digoxin with liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometric (LC-MS/MS) analysis at a speed of several minutes per sample. However, it is not feasible to achieve a throughput high enough using these approaches to sustain an early liability screen that generates more than a thousand samples on a daily basis. To address this challenge, we developed an ultrafast (9 s per sample) bioanalytical method for digoxin analysis using RapidFire™, an on-line solid-phase extraction (SPE) system, with MS/MS detection. A stable isotope labeled analog, d3-digoxin, was used as internal standard to minimize potential ionization matrix effect during the RF-MS/MS analysis. The RF-MS/MS method was more than 16 times faster than the LC-MS/MS method but demonstrated similar sensitivity, selectivity, reproducibility, linearity and robustness. P-gp inhibition results of multiple validation compounds obtained with this RF-MS/MS method were in agreement with those generated by both the LC-MS/MS method and the (3)H-radiolabel assay. This method has been successfully deployed to assess P-gp inhibition potential as an important early liability screen for drug-transporter interaction.

Rapid Compound Integrity Assessment for High-Throughput Screening Hit Triaging.

Hits from high-throughput screening (HTS) assays are typically evaluated using cheminformatics and/or empirical approaches before a decision for follow-up (activity confirmation and/or sample resynthesis) is made. However, the compound integrity (i.e., identity and purity) of these hits often remains largely unknown at this stage, since many compounds in the screening collection could undergo various changes such as degradation, polymerization, and precipitation during storage over time. When compound integrity is actually assessed for HTS hits postassay to address this issue, the process often increases the overall cycle time by weeks due to the reacquisition of the samples and the lengthy liquid chromatography-ultraviolet/mass spectrometric analysis time. Here we present a novel approach where compound integrity data are collected concurrently with the concentration-response curve (CRC) stage of HTS, with both assays occurring either in parallel on two distributions from the same liquid sample or serially using the original source liquid sample. The rapid generation of compound integrity data has been enabled by a high-speed ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography-ultraviolet/mass spectrometric platform capable of analyzing ~2000 samples per instrument per week. From this parallel approach, both compound integrity and CRC potency results for screening hits become available to medicinal chemists at the same time, which has greatly enhanced the decision-making process for hit follow-up and progression. In addition, the compound integrity results from recent hits provide a real-time and representative "snapshot" of the sample integrity of the entire compound collection, and the data can be used for in-depth analyses of the screening collection.

Microscale purification in support of high-throughput medicinal chemistry.

In recent years, successful assay miniaturization has enabled the exploration of synthesis scale reduction in pharmaceutical discovery. Miniaturization of pharmaceutical synthesis and purification allows a reduction in material consumption and shortens timelines, which ultimately reduces the cost per experiment without compromising data quality. Isolating and purifying the compounds of interest is a key step in the library synthesis process. In this manuscript we describe a high-throughput purification workflow in support of microscale (1-5 µmol or 0.5-2 mg) library synthesis. The optimized microscale purification system can routinely purify 384-well reaction plates with an analysis time of 4 min per sample. Instrument optimization, critical parameters such as column loading, delay time calibration, ultrafast pre- and post-purification analysis and library purification examples are provided.

An integrated bioanalytical platform for supporting high-throughput serum protein binding screening.

Quantification of small molecules using liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry (LC/MS/MS) on a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer has become a common practice in bioanalytical support of in vitro adsorption, distribution, metabolism and excretion (ADME) screening. The bioanalysis process involves primarily three indispensable steps: MS/MS optimization for a large number of new chemical compounds undergoing various screening assays in early drug discovery, high-throughput sample analysis with LC/MS/MS for those chemically diverse compounds using the optimized MS/MS conditions, and post-acquisition data review and reporting. To improve overall efficiency of ADME bioanalysis, an integrated system was proposed featuring an automated and unattended MS/MS optimization, a staggered parallel LC/MS/MS for high-throughput sample analysis, and a sophisticated software tool for LC/MS/MS raw data review as well as biological data calculation and reporting. The integrated platform has been used in bioanalytical support of a serum protein binding screening assay with high speed, high capacity, and good robustness. In this new platform, a unique sample dilution scheme was also introduced. With this dilution design, the total number of analytical samples was reduced; therefore, the total operation time was reduced and the overall throughput was further improved. The performance of the protein binding screening assay was monitored with two controls representing high and low binding properties and an acceptable inter-assay consistency was achieved. This platform has been successfully used for the determination of serum protein binding in multiple species for more than 4000 compounds.

Orthogonality of SFC versus HPLC for small molecule library separation.

Preparative HPLC and HPLC-MS are well established as the methods of choice for purification of pharmaceutical library compounds. Recent advances in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) have now made SFC a viable alternative to HPLC for this application. One of the potential arguments for using SFC in place of, or in addition to, HPLC is that it may offer different selectivity and thus has the potential for improved separation success rates. In this paper, we examine relative success rates for SFC and HPLC in obtaining adequate selectivity for successful separation. Our results suggest that use of SFC in addition to HPLC may result in a slight (1-2%) improvement in success rate compared to use of HPLC alone.

A high-throughput bioanalytical platform using automated infusion for tandem mass spectrometric method optimization and its application in a metabolic stability screen.

Liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry (LC/MS/MS) is the bioanalytical method of choice to support plate-based, in vitro early ADME (Absorption, Distribution, Metabolism and Excretion) screens such as metabolic stability (Metstab) assessment. MS/MS method optimization has historically been the bottleneck in this environment, where samples from thousands of discrete compounds are analyzed on a monthly basis, mainly due to the lack of a high-quality commercially available platform to handle the necessary MS/MS method optimization steps for sample analysis by selected reaction monitoring (SRM) on triple quadrupole mass spectrometers. To address this challenge, we recently developed a highly automated bioanalytical platform by successfully integrating QuickQuan 2.0, a unique high-throughput solution featuring MS/MS method optimization by automated infusion, with a customized in-house software tool in support of a Metstab screen. In this platform, a dual-column setup running parallel chromatography was also implemented to reduce the bioanalytical cycle time for LC/MS/MS sample analysis. A set of 45 validation compounds was used to demonstrate the speed, quality and reproducibility of MS/MS method optimization, sample analysis, and data processing using this automated platform. Metstab results for the validation compounds in microsomes from multiple species (human, rat, mouse) showed good consistency within each batch, and also between batches conducted on different days. We have achieved and maintained a monthly throughput of 1300 compound assays representing 500 discrete compounds per instrument per month on this platform, and it has been used to generate metabolic stability data for more than 25 000 compounds to date with an overall success rate of more than 95%.

HPLC biogram analysis: a powerful tool used for hit confirmation in early drug discovery.

High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) biogram methodology is a powerful pharmaceutical screening hit confirmation strategy that couples analytical HPLC data with functional bioassay data. It is used primarily for screening hit chemical validation and triaging in support of early phase discovery programs and enables further investigation of the source of bioactivity in screening hits. The process combines semi-preparative separation technologies, automated compound handling and distribution, high-throughput biological screening, and informatics tools. The final output is an HPLC retention time versus bioactivity graphical overlay report. In this manner, biograms allow the analyst to determine which component in the sample is responsible for the biological activity, enabling decision making toward chemotype selection and prioritization from a pool of potential candidates. Another powerful aspect of the biogram assay lies in its utility in investigating biological activity in atypical samples, such as degraded samples or mixtures, for detection of minor active impurities or in addressing lot-to-lot activity discrepancies for a given test compound. Biograms are employed to track, isolate, and identify the source of biological activity in such samples, often yielding important information for program decisions.

Comparative assessment of achiral stationary phases for high throughput analysis in supercritical fluid chromatography.

Supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) using open bed fraction collection is becoming more widely used for purification of diverse collections of compounds for drug discovery. This application requires predictable chromatography on scale up from analytical to preparative conditions. We have discovered that the selectivities of many columns used for SFC change over time when ammonium acetate additive is present in the mobile phase as a result of changes in silanophilic interactions. This makes scale up predictions difficult. To address this challenge we have developed a nontraditional comprehensive column ranking. Our system is based on the long-term retention repeatability of basic drugs in ammonium acetate containing mobile phase. The decreases in retention over time were used as a measure of changing silanophilicity of the stationary phases and became the basis for a column ranking system. This system, along with results for 24 commonly used silica-based columns, is presented in this paper.

Comparison of chromatographic techniques for diastereomer separation of a diverse set of drug-like compounds.

Preparative supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) has proven value for isocratic bulk separation of both diastereomers and enantiomers. With the recent availability of SFC equipment suitable for rapid gradient separation [Ebinger et al. JALA (2011) 16 (3) 241], we have become interested in comparing the effectiveness of traditional reverse phase high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with SFC using non-chiral columns for the separation of diastereomeric mixtures. The success rates for separation of a diverse set of 258 synthetic diastereomer pairs were used to determine the relative utility of the aforementioned two techniques. Our results suggest that gradient non-chiral SFC was more successful than the traditional non-chiral HPLC technique for diastereomer separations of the diverse sample set of 258 drug-like compounds.

Addressing the medicinal chemistry bottleneck: a lean approach to centralized purification.

The use of standardized lean manufacturing principles to improve drug discovery productivity is often thought to be at odds with fostering innovation. This manuscript describes how selective implementation of a lean optimized process, in this case centralized purification for medicinal chemistry, can improve operational productivity and increase scientist time available for innovation. A description of the centralized purification process is provided along with both operational and impact (productivity) metrics, which indicate lower cost, higher output, and presumably more free time for innovation as a result of the process changes described.

Evaluation of a new preparative supercritical fluid chromatography system for compound library purification: the TharSFC SFC-MS Prep-100 system.

Preparative HPLC-MS is often the method of choice for purification of small amounts (<100mg) of diverse new molecules, such as compound libraries for drug discovery. The method is robust, well proven, and widely applicable. In contrast, preparative supercritical fluid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (SFC-MS) has seen only slow acceptance for the same application--despite some potential scientific and economic advantages. One of the reasons for slow adoption of SFC-MS is the lack of well-proven, robust, and commercially available instrumentation. In early 2009, TharSFC (a Waters Company, Pittsburgh, PA) introduced a new fully integrated system for preparative SFC-MS: The SFC-MS Prep-100. We report herein an objective evaluation of the SFC-MS Prep-100, including tests for pump and autosampler performance, sample recovery, sample carryover, fraction triggering, detector/fraction collector synchronization, and overall robustness. Our results suggest that the SFC-MS Prep-100 represents a significant advance over previous generation instrumentation.

Application of lean manufacturing concepts to drug discovery: rapid analogue library synthesis.

The application of parallel synthesis to lead optimization programs in drug discovery has been an ongoing challenge since the first reports of library synthesis. A number of approaches to the application of parallel array synthesis to lead optimization have been attempted over the years, ranging from widespread deployment by (and support of) individual medicinal chemists to centralization as a service by an expert core team. This manuscript describes our experience with the latter approach, which was undertaken as part of a larger initiative to optimize drug discovery. In particular, we highlight how concepts taken from the manufacturing sector can be applied to drug discovery and parallel synthesis to improve the timeliness and thus the impact of arrays on drug discovery.