Ribosome fidelity: tRNA discrimination, proofreading and induced fit.

The ribosome selects aminoacyl-tRNAs with high fidelity. Kinetic studies reveal that codon-anticodon recognition both stabilizes aminoacyl-tRNA binding on the ribosome and accelerates reactions of the productive pathway, indicating an important contribution of induced fit to substrate selection. Similar mechanisms are used by other template-programmed enzymes, such as DNA and RNA polymerases.

Dynamics of translation on the ribosome: molecular mechanics of translocation.

The translocation step of protein elongation entails a large-scale rearrangement of the tRNA-mRNA-ribosome complex. Recent years have seen major advances in unraveling the mechanism of the process on the molecular level. A number of intermediate states have been defined and, in part, characterized structurally. The article reviews the recent evidence that suggests a dynamic role of the ribosome and its ligands during translocation. The focus is on dynamic aspects of tRNA movement and on the role of elongation factor G and GTP hydrolysis in translocation catalysis. The significance of structural changes of the ribosome induced by elongation factor G as well the role of ribosomal RNA are addressed. A functional model of elongation factor G as a motor protein driven by GTP hydrolysis is discussed.

The influence of spermine on the structural dynamics of yeast tRNAPhe.

A tRNAPhe derivative carrying ethidium at position 37 in the anticodon loop has been used to study the effect of spermine on conformational transitions of the tRNA. As previously reported (Ehrenberg, M., Rigler, R. and Wintermeyer, W. (1979) Biochemistry 18, 4588-4599) in the tRNA derivative the ethidium is present in three states (T1-T3) characterized by different fluorescence decay rates. T-jump experiments show two transitions between the states, a fast one (relaxation time 10-100 ms) between T1 and T2, and a slow one (100-1000 ms) between T2 and T3. In the presence of spermine the fast transition shows a negative temperature coefficient indicating the existence of a preequilibrium with a negative reaction enthalpy. Spermine shifts the distribution of states towards T3, as does Mg2+, but the final ratio [T2]/[T1] obtained with spermine is higher than with Mg2+, which we tentatively interpret to mean that spermine stabilizes one particular conformation of the anticodon loop.

NMR investigation of the effect of selective modifications in the anticodon loop on the conformation of yeast transfer RNA-Phe.

Changes in the 300 MHz proton NMR spectrum of yeast tRNA-Phe induced by the removal of the Y-base from the anticodon loop are reversed when the dye proflavine is incorporated in its place. These observations correlate with our earlier interpretation of the NMR data that removal of the Y-base causes a change in the conformation of the anticodon stem. Such changes in stem conformation may in part be responsible for the differences in the biochemical properties of tRNA-Phe, tRNA-PhePF and tRNA-Phe-Y.

Destabilization of codon-anticodon interaction in the ribosomal exit site.

The affinities of the exit (E) site of poly(U) or poly(A)-programmed Escherichia coli ribosomes for the respective cognate tRNA and a number of non-cognate tRNAs were determined by equilibrium titrations. Among the non-cognate tRNAs, the binding constants vary up to about tenfold (10(6) to 10(7) M-1 at 20 mM-Mg2+) or 50-fold (10 mM-Mg2+), indicating that codon-independent binding is modulated to a considerable extent by structural elements of the tRNA molecules other than the anticodon. Codon-anticodon interaction stabilizes tRNA binding in the E site approximately fourfold (20 mM-Mg2+) or 20-fold (10 mM-Mg2+), corresponding to delta G degree values of -3 and -7 kJ/mol (0.7 and 1.7 kcal/mol), respectively. Thus, the energetic contribution of codon-anticodon interaction to tRNA binding in the E site appears rather small, particularly in comparison to the large effects on the binding in A and P sites and to the binding of complementary oligonucleotides or of tRNAs with complementary anticodons. This result argues against a role of the E site-bound tRNA in the fixation of the mRNA on the ribosome. In contrast, we propose that the role of the E site is to facilitate the release of the discharged tRNA during translocation by providing an intermediate, labile binding site for the tRNA leaving the P site. The lowering of both affinity and stability of tRNA binding accompanying the transfer of the tRNA from the P site to the E site is predominantly due to the labilization of the codon-anticodon interaction.

Shielding of the D loop of ribosome-bound tRNA by elongation factor G.

The topography of the complex of elongation factor G with post-translocative ribosomes has been studied in the Escherichia coli system using fluorescence spectroscopy. We find that a fluorophore attached to the D loop of tRNA is shielded from solvent access by the presence of the factor, and this effect is dependent on factor-promoted GTP hydrolysis. The shielding result suggests that (1) the factor could bind to the tRNA during translocation and (2) the tRNA binding site may be close to that of the factor. The alternative explanation, that the factor affects the conformation of the tRNA bound at a distant site, seems less likely.

Mechanism of ribosomal translocation. tRNA binds transiently to an exit site before leaving the ribosome during translocation.

Escherichia coli ribosomes have a site (E) to which deacylated tRNA binds transiently before leaving the ribosome during translocation. The affinity of the site is Mg2+ dependent and low at physiological Mg2+ concentrations. Correct codon-anticodon interaction is unnecessary in this site. With these features, the E site cannot reduce frameshift errors through additional mRNA anchorage. Occupancy of the A site does not influence the tRNA binding in the E site, although a conformational change of elongation factor G, brought about by GTP hydrolysis, is necessary for efficient tRNA release. The tRNA can dissociate unhindered from the E site when the elongation factor is bound to the ribosome by fusidic acid. During elongation, the thermodynamically stable state is not attained, since E site occupation inhibits translocation. However, the E site can aid elongation by providing an intermediate state for tRNA dissociation, dispersing the process into more than one step.

Two tRNA-binding sites in addition to A and P sites on eukaryotic ribosomes.

The interaction of tRNA with 80 S ribosomes from rabbit liver was studied using biochemical as well as fluorescence techniques. Besides the canonical A and P sites, two additional sites were found which specifically bind deacylated tRNA. One of the sites is analogous to the E site of prokaryotic ribosomes, in that binding of tRNA is labile, does not depend on codon-anticodon interaction, does not protect the anticodon loop from solvent access, and requires the presence of the 3'-terminal adenosine of the tRNA. In contrast, the stability of the tRNA complex with the second site (S site) is high. tRNA binding to the S site is also codon-independent; nevertheless, the anticodon loop is shielded from solvent access. Removal of the 3'-terminal adenosine decreases the affinity of tRNA(Phe) for the S site approximately 50-fold. tRNA(Phe) is retained at the S site during translocation and through poly(Phe) synthesis. Thus, the S site does not seem to be an intermediate site for the tRNA during the elongation cycle. Rather, the tRNA bound to the S site may allosterically modulate the function of the ribosome.

Pre-steady-state kinetics of ribosomal translocation.

The two partial reactions of elongation factor G dependent translocation, the release of deacylated tRNA from the P site and the displacement of peptidyl tRNA from the A to the P site, have been studied with the stopped-flow technique. The experiments were performed with poly(U)-programmed ribosomes from Escherichia coli carrying deacylated tRNAPhe in the P site and N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe in the A site in the presence of GTP. The kinetics of the reaction were followed by monitoring either the intensity or the polarization of the fluorescence of both wybutine and proflavine located in the anticodon loop or of proflavine located in the D loop of yeast tRNAPhe or N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe. Both displacement and release fluorescence changes could be described by three exponentials, exhibiting apparent first-order rate-constants (20 degrees C) of 2 to 5 s-1 (15 s-1, 35 degrees C), 0.1 to 0.3 s-1, and 0.01 to 0.02 s-1, measured with a saturating concentration of elongation factor G (1 microM). The activation energy for the fast process of both reactions was found to be 70 kJ/mol (17 kcal/mol), while the intermediate process exhibits an activation energy of 30 kJ/mol (7 kcal/mol). The fast step is assigned to the displacement of the N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe from the A to the P site, and to the release of the tRNAPhe from the P site. The reactions take place simultaneously to form an intermediate post-translocation complex. The latter, in the intermediate step, rearranges to form a post-translocation complex carrying the deacylated tRNAPhe in an exit site and N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe in the P site, both in their equilibrium states. In parallel, or subsequently, the deacylated tRNAPhe spontaneously dissociates from the ribosome, thus completing the translocation process. The slow process has not been assigned.

Topological arrangement of two transfer RNAs on the ribosome. Fluorescence energy transfer measurements between A and P site-bound tRNAphe.

The relative arrangement of two tRNAPhe molecules bound to the A and P sites of poly(U)-programmed Escherichia coli ribosomes was determined from the spatial separation of various parts of the two molecules. Intermolecular distances were calculated from the fluorescence energy transfer between fluorophores in the anticodon and D loops of yeast tRNAPhe. The energy donors were the natural fluorescent base wybutine in the anticodon loop or proflavine in both anticodon (position 37) and D loops (positions 16 and 17). The corresponding energy acceptors were proflavine or ethidium, respectively, at the same positions. Four distances were measured: anticodon loop-anticodon loop, 24(+/- 4) A; anticodon loop (A site)-D loop (P site), 46(+/- 12) A: anticodon loop (P site)-D loop (A site), 38(+/- 10) A: D loop-D loop, 35(+/- 9) A. Assuming that both tRNAs adopt the conformation present in the crystal and that the CCA ends are close to each other, the results are consistent with the two anticodons being bound to contiguous codons and suggest an asymmetric arrangement in which the planes of the two L-shaped molecules enclose an angle of 60 degrees +/- 30 degrees.

Conformational changes in the bacterial SRP receptor FtsY upon binding of guanine nucleotides and SRP.

In cotranslational preprotein targeting in Escherichia coli, the signal recognition particle (SRP) binds to the signal peptide emerging from the ribosome and, subsequently, interacts with the signal recognition particle receptor, FtsY, at the plasma membrane. Both FtsY and the protein moiety of the signal recognition particle, Ffh, are GTPases, and GTP is required for the formation of the SRP-FtsY complex. We have studied the binding of GTP/GDP to FtsY as well as the SRP-FtsY complex formation by monitoring the fluorescence of tryptophan 343 in the I box of mutant FtsY. Thermodynamic and kinetic parameters of the FtsY complexes with GDP, GTP, and signal recognition particle are reported. Upon SRP-FtsY complex formation in the presence of GTP, the fluorescence of tryptophan 343 increased by 50 % and was blue-shifted by 10 nm. We conclude that GTP-dependent SRP-FtsY complex formation leads to an extensive conformational change in the I box insertion in the effector region of FtsY.

Role of domains 4 and 5 in elongation factor G functions on the ribosome.

Elongation factor G (EF-G) is a large, five domain GTPase that catalyses the translocation of the tRNAs on the bacterial ribosome at the expense of GTP. In the crystal structure of GDP-bound EF-G, domain 1 (G domain) makes direct contacts with domains 2 and 5, whereas domain 4 protrudes from the body of the molecule. Here, we show that the presence of both domains 4 and 5 is essential for tRNA translocation and for the turnover of the factor on the ribosome, but not for rapid single-round GTP hydrolysis by EF-G. Replacement of a highly conserved histidine residue at the tip of domain 4, His583, with lysine or arginine decreases the rate of tRNA translocation at least 100-fold, whereas the binding of the factor to the ribosome, GTP hydrolysis and P(i) release are not affected by the mutations. Various small deletions in the tip region of domain 4 decrease the translocation activity of EF-G even further, but do not block the turnover of the factor. Unlike native EF-G, the mutants of EF-G lacking domains 4/5 do not interact with the alpha-sarcin stem-loop of 23 S rRNA. These mutants are not released from the ribosome after GTP hydrolysis or translocation, indicating that the contact with, or a conformational change of, the alpha-sarcin stem-loop is required for EF-G release from the ribosome.

Mechanism of ribosomal translocation. Translocation limits the rate of Escherichia coli elongation factor G-promoted GTP hydrolysis.

The pre-steady-state kinetics of GTP hydrolysis catalysed by elongation factor G and ribosomes from Escherichia coli has been investigated by the method of quenched-flow. The GTPase activities either uncoupled from or coupled to the ribosomal translocation process were characterized under various experimental conditions. A burst of GTP hydrolysis, with a kapp value greater than 30 s-1 (20 degrees C) was observed with poly(U)-programmed vacant ribosomes, either in the presence or absence of fusidic acid. The burst was followed by a slow GTP turnover reaction, which disappears in the presence of fusidic acid. E. coli tRNAPhe, but not N-acetylphenylalanyl-tRNAPhe (N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe), stimulates the GTPase when bound in the P site. If the A site of poly(U)-programmed ribosomes, carrying tRNAPhe in the P site, is occupied by N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe, the burst of Pi discharge is replaced by a slow GTP hydrolysis. Since, under these conditions, N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe is translocated from the A to the P site, this GTP hydrolysis very probably represents a GTPase coupled to the translocation reaction.

Specific recognition of the 3'-terminal adenosine of tRNAPhe in the exit site of Escherichia coli ribosomes.

Ribosomes from Escherichia coli possess, in addition to A and P sites, a third tRNA binding site, which according to its presumed function in tRNA release during translocation has been termed the exit site. The exit site exhibits a remarkable specificity for deacylated tRNA; charged tRNA, e.g. N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe, is not bound significantly. To determine the molecular basis of this discrimination, we have measured the exit site binding affinities of a number of derivatives of tRNAPhe from E. coli, modified at the 3' end. Binding to the exit site of the tRNAPhe derivatives was measured fluorimetrically by competition with a fluorescent tRNAPhe derivative. We show here that removal of the 2' and 3' hydroxyl groups of the 3'-terminal adenosine decreases the affinity of tRNAPhe for the exit site 15 and 40-fold, respectively. Substitutions at the 3' hydroxyl group (aminoacylation, phosphorylation, cytidylation) as well as removal of the 3'-terminal adenosine (or adenylate) of tRNAPhe lower the affinity below the detection limit of 2 x 10(5) M-1, i.e. more than 100-fold. Modification of the adenine moiety (1,N6-etheno adenine) or replacement of it with other bases (cytosine, guanine) has the same dramatic effect. In contrast, the binding to both P and A sites is virtually unaffected by all of the modifications tested. These results suggest that a major fraction (at least -12 kJ/mol, probably about -17 kJ/mol) of the free energy of exit site binding of tRNAPhe (-42 kJ/mol at 20 mM-Mg2+) is contributed by the binding of the 3'-terminal adenine to the ribosome. The binding most likely entails the formation of hydrogen bonds.

Translational elongation factor G: a GTP-driven motor of the ribosome.

EF-G is a large, five-domain GTPase that promotes the directional movement of mRNA and tRNAs on the ribosome in a GTP-dependent manner. Unlike other GTPases, but by analogy to the myosin motor, EF-G performs its function of powering translocation in the GDP-bound form; that is, in a kinetically stable ribosome-EF-G(GDP) complex formed by GTP hydrolysis on the ribosome. The complex undergoes an extensive structural rearrangement, in particular affecting the small ribosomal subunit, which leads to mRNA-tRNA movement. Domain 4, which extends from the 'body' of the EF-G molecule much like a lever arm, appears to be essential for the structural transition to take place. In a hypothetical model, GTP hydrolysis induces a conformational change in the G domain of EF-G which affects the interactions with neighbouring domains within EF-G. The resulting rearrangement of the domains relative to each other generates conformational strain in the ribosome to which EF-G is fixed. Because of structural features of the tRNA-ribosome complex, this conformational strain results in directional tRNA-mRNA movement. The functional parallels between EF-G and motor proteins suggest that EF-G differs from classical G-proteins in that it functions as a force-generating mechanochemical device rather than a conformational switch. There are other multi-domain GTPases that may function in a similar way.

Formation of SRP-like particle induces a conformational change in E. coli 4.5S RNA.

E. coli P48 protein is homologous to the SRP54 component of the eukaryotic signal recognition particle. In vivo, P48 is associated with 4.5S RNA which shares a homology with eukaryotic SRP RNA. To study the interaction between P48 and 4.5S RNA in vitro, we used 4.5S RNA with fluorescein coupled to the 3'-terminal ribose. Upon binding of P48, the fluorescent 4.5S RNA shows a substantial decrease in fluorescence. Fluorescence quenching as well as anisotropy measurements reveal that the effect is not due to a direct interaction of P48 with the dye. This suggests that the binding of P48 induces a conformational change in 4.5S RNA which affects the structure at the 3' end of the RNA. From equilibrium titrations with fluorescent 4.5S RNA, a dissociation constant of 0.15 microns is obtained for the RNA.protein complex. The formation of the complex is not affected by GTP binding to or hydrolysis by P48.

The functioning of the SRP receptor FtsY in protein-targeting in E. coli is correlated with its ability to bind and hydrolyse GTP.

In this study, we have established that FtsY, the E. coli homolog of the mammalian signal recognition particle (SRP) receptor, is a GTP-binding protein which displays intrinsic GTPase activity. GTP was found to influence the protease sensitivity of FtsY indicative of a conformational change. FtsY mutated in the 4th GTP-binding consensus element displayed reduced GTP-binding and -hydrolysis which correlated with a reduced ability to interact with SRP. Overexpression of the mutant proteins had a stronger inhibitory effect on protein translocation than overexpression of wild-type FtsY. These observations suggest that in E. coli GTP is important for proper functioning of FtsY in protein-targeting.

[Mechanism of tRNA translocation on the ribosome]. / Mekhanizm translokatsii tRNK na ribosome.

During the translocation step of the elongation cycle of peptide synthesis two tRNAs together with the mRNA move synchronously and rapidly on the ribosome. Translocation is catalyzed by the elongation factor G (EF-G) and requires GTP hydrolysis. The fundamental biochemical features of the process were worked out in the 1970-80s, to a large part by A.S. Spirin and his colleagues. Recent results from pre-steady-state kinetic analysis and cryoelectron microscopy suggest that translocation is a multistep dynamic process that entails large-scale structural rearrangements of both ribosome and EF-G. Kinetic and thermodynamic data, together with the structural information on the conformational changes of the ribosome and of EF-G, provide a detailed mechanistic model of translocation and suggest a mechanism of translocation catalysis by EF-G.