Impact of investigator initiated trials and industry sponsored trials on medical practice (IMPACT): rationale and study design.

BACKGROUND: The German Research Foundation (DFG) and the Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) initiated large research programs to foster high quality clinical research in the academic area. These investigator initiated trials (IITs) cover important areas of medical research and often go beyond the scope of industry sponsored trials (ISTs). The purpose of this project was to understand to what extent results of randomized controlled IITs and ISTs have an impact on medical practice, measured by their availability for decisions in healthcare and their implementation in clinical practice. We aimed to determine study characteristics influencing a trial's impact such as type of sponsor and place of conduct. In this article, we describe the rationale and design of this project and present the characteristics of the trials included in our study cohort. METHODS: The research impact of the following sub-cohorts was compared: German IITs (funded by DFG and BMBF or by other German non-commercial organizations), international IITs (without German contribution), German ISTs, and international ISTs. Trials included were drawn from the DFG-/BMBF-Websites, the German Clinical Trials Register, and from ClinicalTrials.gov . Research impact was measured as follows: 1) proportion of published trials, 2) time to publication, 3) proportion of publications appropriately indexed in biomedical databases, 4) proportion of openly accessible publications, 5) broadness of publication's target group, 6) citation of publications by systematic reviews or meta-analyses, and 7) appearance of publications or citing systematic reviews or meta-analyses in clinical practice guidelines. We also aimed to identify study characteristics associated with the impact of trials. RESULTS: We included 691 trials: 120 German IITs, 200 International IITs, 171 German ISTs and 200 International ISTs. The median number of participants was 150, 30% were international trials and 70% national trials, 48% drug-trials and 52% non-drug trials. Overall, 72% of the trials had one pre-defined primary endpoint, 28% two or more (max. 36). CONCLUSIONS: The results of this project deepen our understanding of the impact of biomedical research on clinical practice and healthcare policy, add important insights for the efficient allocation of scarce research resources and may facilitate providing accountability to the different stakeholders involved.

Insulin-like growth factor-I-dependent growth and in vitro chemosensitivity of Ewing's sarcoma and peripheral primitive neuroectodermal tumour cell lines.

Serum-free growth of Ewing's sarcoma (ES) and primitive peripheral neuroectodermal tumour (pPNET) cell lines was achieved by supplementing a basal medium with insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I). These cultures were used to investigate the sensitivity of 3 ES (EW-2, RD-ES, SK-ES-1) and 3 pPNET (SIM-1, KAL, SAL) cell lines to a panel of anti-tumour agents in short-term (48-h) proliferation assays. Of the four cytostatic drugs included in the currently used multi-drug regimens, cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin and actinomycin-D inhibit the proliferation of the cell lines with high efficacy, whereas the vinca alkaloids were less effective. Cisplatin, etoposide, mitomycin-C and mitoxanthrone were also found to have a high inhibitory activity in this in vitro ES/pPNET system. The most remarkable effect was observed for cytosine arabinoside (ARA-C), which gave a half-maximal inhibition at drug concentrations approximately 5000 times below the clinical peak plasma concentrations (250 micrograms/ml). The ARA-C sensitivity of ES and pPNET cell lines is comparable with the established ARA-C sensitivities of leukaemia-derived cells. The different ES and pPNET cell lines showed a rather uniform response to the different cytostatic drugs with decreased sensitivity of individual pPNET cell lines to vinblastin, ARA-C and mitoxanthrone. Modulation of the IGF-I/IGF-I receptor/IGF-I binding protein system, which seems to constitute an important stimulator of cell growth in neuroectoderm-derived or -related tumours, can be used to enhance the drug sensitivity of the tumour cells in vivo or in vitro therapeutic procedures. According to our results, serum-free conditions for autologous bone marrow purification are expected to result in significantly increased chemosensitivity of ES and pPNET cells in response to anthracyclines and cisplatin.

In vitro antiproliferative effects of albumin-doxorubicin conjugates against Ewing's sarcoma and peripheral neuroectodermal tumor cells.

The 3-5 year survival rates of patients with disseminated Ewing's sarcoma (ES) or the closely related peripheral primitive neuroectodermal tumors (PNET) remain low, even under aggressive treatment involving highly toxic multidrug chemotherapeutic regimens. ES and PNET are sensitive to doxorubicin, but may escape treatment by expression of the multidrug-resistant phenotype and/or other mechanisms. In this study, we have identified albumin as growth supporting factor for ES and PNET cells in IGF-I-supplemented serum-free tissue culture medium. To investigate the specificity and toxicity of albumin-based drug conjugates, doxorubicin was coupled to bovine serum albumin (BSA) by either a two step glutaraldehyde or carbodiimide-C4-spacer technique, yielding monomeric DOX-albumin conjugates with conjugation numbers ranging from 3-20 moles DOX/mole BSA. Cellular uptake of fluorescein-isothiocyanate-(FITC)-labeled albumin and DOX-albumin conjugates could be demonstrated by flow cytometric measurements of cell-associated fluorescence and confocal microscopy. The cytostatic activity of these conjugates against ES/PNET cell lines, a neuroblastoma (LAN-1) and prostate cancer carcinoma cell line (PC-3) and normal lymphoblasts was tested in short-term proliferation assays (48 h). The results show a high selectivity of the DOX-albumin conjugates for ES/PNET cell lines, with highest growth inhibition by conjugates with low DOX conjugation numbers (n = 3) in serum-supplemented medium (17-32 fold loss of activity compared to free DOX), followed by 20-DOX-C4-albumin in serum-free medium and low activity of the other conjugates. In conclusion, DOX-albumin conjugates inhibit the growth of ES/PNET cell lines selectively, showing low activity against the unrelated carcinoma line PC-3 and sparing normal lymphoblasts. The inverse correlation of activity and conjugation number demonstrates a low cytotoxic activity of DOX in acid-stable binding to monomeric albumin, pointing to a selective cytostatic activity of the modified albumin against ES and PNET cells, even in the presence of a 100 fold excess of unmodified serum albumin.