Future challenges facing the development of specific active-site-directed synthetic inhibitors of MMPs.

Despite a deep knowledge on the 3D-structure of several catalytic domains of MMPs, the development of highly specific synthetic active-site-directed inhibitors of MMPs, able to differentiate the different members of this protease family, remains a strong challenge. Due to the flexible nature of MMP active-site, the development of specific MMP inhibitors will need to combine sophisticated theoretical and experimental approaches to decipher in each MMP the specific structural and dynamic features that can be exploited to obtain the desired selectivity.

Crystal structure of the stromelysin-3 (MMP-11) catalytic domain complexed with a phosphinic inhibitor mimicking the transition-state.

Stromelysin-3 (ST3) is a matrix metalloproteinase (MMP-11) whose proteolytic activity plays an important role in tumorigenicity enhancement. In breast cancer, ST3 is a bad prognosis marker: its expression is associated with a poor clinical outcome. This enzyme therefore represents an attractive therapeutic target. The topology of matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) is remarkably well conserved, making the design of highly specific inhibitors difficult. The major difference between MMPs lies in the S(1)' subsite, a well-defined hydrophobic pocket of variable depth. The present crystal structure, the first 3D-structure of the ST3 catalytic domain in interaction with a phosphinic inhibitor mimicking a (d, l) peptide, clearly demonstrates that its S(1)' pocket corresponds to a tunnel running through the enzyme. This open channel is filled by the inhibitor P(1)' group which adopts a constrained conformation to fit this pocket, together with two water molecules interacting with the ST3-specific residue Gln215. These observations provide clues for the design of more specific inhibitors and show how ST3 can accommodate a phosphinic inhibitor mimicking a (d, l) peptide. The presence of a water molecule interacting with one oxygen atom of the inhibitor phosphinyl group and the proline residue of the Met-turn suggests how the intermediate formed during proteolysis may be stabilized. Furthermore, the hydrogen bond distance observed between the methyl of the phosphinic group and the carbonyl group of Ala182 mimics the interaction between this carbonyl group and the amide group of the cleaved peptidic bond. Our crystal structure provides a good model to study the MMPs mechanism of proteolysis.

Synthesis and pharmacological properties of the N-terminal decapeptide of the vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP).

The decapeptide derivative, L-histidyl-L-seryl-L-aspartyl-L-alanyl-L-valyl-L-phenylalanyl-L-threonyl-L-aspartyl-L-asparaginyl-L-tyrosine methyl ester, corresponding to the N-terminal sequence of both porcine and chicken VIP was synthesized in solution, by the stepwise strategy. Its pharmacological properties resemble those of VIP itself, but with a much lower potency, comparable to that of peptides with C-terminal sequences. The presence of two independent sequences carrying similar instructions was recognized in VIP.

Three-dimensional structure of cyclohexapeptides containing a phosphinic bond in aqueous solution: a template for zinc metalloprotease inhibitors. A NMR and restrained molecular dynamics study.

The 3D structures of two phosphinic cyclic hexapeptide inhibitors of bacterial collagenase, cyclo-(Gly1-Pro2-Phe3 psi[PO2-CH2]Gly4-Pro5-Nle6) (compound I) and cyclo(Gly1-Pro2-D-Phe3 psi[PO2-CH2]-Gly4-Pro5-Nle6) (compound II), in aqueous solution, as derived from NMR spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations, are described. The general structures of these cyclic hexapeptides closely resemble the "canonic" two-reverse-turn structure, with the proline occupying the (i + 1) position of the turns and the glycine the connecting positions. The phosphinic bond is located between the (i + 2) and (i + 3) positions of one of these turns. However, a striking feature of the backbone structure of these peptides is the presence of double type VIII-turns in compound I, and in compound II of type VIII- and tentatively named type IX-turns. The comparison of the 3D structures of these two cyclic hexapeptides shows that the stereochemistry of the phenylalanylphosphinyl residue influences not only the local conformation but also the global topology of the peptide macrocycle. The differences in the 3D structure of these compounds are discussed in relation to their inhibitory potencies and with the view of using these constrained cyclic peptides as a scaffold for the development of rigid metalloproteases inhibitors.

Cyclic peptides with a phosphinic bond as potent inhibitors of a zinc bacterial collagenase.

A series of cyclic peptides containing a phosphinic bond were synthesized and evaluated as inhibitors of a zinc bacterial collagenase from Corynebacterium rathaii. Among this series of pseudopeptides of different sizes of cycles, only two molecules Ia (cyclo[Gly-Pro-Phe psi(PO2CH2)-Gly-Pro-Ahx]) and Va (cyclo[beta Ala-Pro-Phe psi (PO2CH2)Gly-Pro-Ahx]) were found to be rather potent inhibitors of this protease, with Ki values of 120 and 90 nM, respectively. Besides the influence of the peptide ring size, this study suggests that both the stereochemical and the conformational properties of the pseudophenylalanine residue in these cyclic peptides may determine their potency. Interestingly, the kinetic analysis for the binding of the cyclic peptide inhibitors Ia and Va to the collagenase, as compared to a linear parent compound, reveals that the lower potency of the cyclic peptides is mostly the consequence of a lower rate constant for association to the enzyme. To our knowledge, this is the first report on cyclic phosphinic peptides and on their activities as inhibitors of a zinc protease.

Phosphinic pseudo-tripeptides as potent inhibitors of matrix metalloproteinases: a structure-activity study.

Several phosphinic pseudo-tripeptides of general formula R-XaaPsi(PO(2)-CH(2))Xaa'-Yaa'-NH(2) were synthesized and evaluated for their in vitro activities to inhibit stromelysin-3, gelatinases A and B, membrane type-1 matrix metalloproteinase, collagenases 1 and 2, and matrilysin. With the exception of collagenase-1 and matrilysin, phosphinic pseudo-tripeptides behave as highly potent inhibitors of matrix metalloproteinases, provided they contain in P(1)' position an unusual long aryl-alkyl substituent. Study of structure-activity relationships regarding the influence of the R and Xaa' substituents in this series may contribute to the design of inhibitors able to block only a few members of the matrix metalloproteinase family.

Phosphorus-containing peptides as mixed inhibitors of endopeptidase 3.4.24.15 and 3.4.24.16: effect on neurotensin degradation in vitro and in vivo.

1. We have examined several phosphorus-containing peptides as potential mixed inhibitors of two neurotensin-degrading zinc metallopeptidases, endopeptidase 3.4.24.15 and endopeptidase 3.4.24.16. 2. Among a series of 13 phosphonamide peptides, N-(2-(2-naphtyl)ethylphosphonyl-glycyl-prolyl-norleucine (phosphodiepryl 08) was found to inhibit potently the hydrolysis of neurotensin by purified endopeptidase 3.4.24.15 and 3.4.24.16 with an identical Ki value of 0.4 nM. 3. Phosphodiepryl 08 displayed a strong selectivity towards the two peptidases since it failed to inhibit several other zinc-containing peptidases such as endopeptidase 3.4.24.11, angiotensin-converting enzyme, aminopeptidase M, leucine aminopeptidase and carboxypeptidases A and B. 4. The protective effect of phosphodiepryl 08 on neurotensin degradation was examined in vitro and in vivo in central and peripheral bioassays. 5. Phosphodiepryl 08 virtually abolished neurotensin degradation by 4-day-old plated pure cultured neurones from mouse embryos and greatly potentiated neurotensin-induced antinociception in the mouse hot plate test. 6. In the periphery, phosphodiepryl 08 inhibited neurotensin degradation by membranes prepared from isolated longitudinal smooth muscle of guinea-pig ileum and greatly potentiated the neurotensin-induced contraction of the same longitudinal smooth muscle preparation. 7. Our study indicates that phosphodiepryl 08 behaves as a potent and selective mixed inhibitor of endopeptidase 3.4.24.15 and 3.4.24.16 and can be used as a powerful agent to prevent neurotensin degradation, in vitro and in vivo, in central and peripheral assays.

Convenient synthesis and diversification of dehydroalaninyl phosphinic peptide analogues.

[structure: see text]. Dehydroalaninyl phosphinic dipeptide analogues were synthesized, via an efficient tandem Arbuzov addition/allylic rearrangement, in high yields. The susceptibility of the conjugate system to 1,4 nucleophilic additions was investigated. C-Elongation of the dipeptides was performed, and the efficiency of 1,4 addition to the resulting acrylamidic moiety was evaluated. Derivatization of such phosphinic templates is a powerful approach for rapid access to large number of phosphinic pseudopeptides bearing various side chains in the P1' position.

[Peptide inhibitors of a bacterial collagenase]. / Inhibiteurs peptidiques d'une collagénase bactérienne.

The properties of the cleavage site of collagen by collagenases remain discussed. The authors report their studies on the active site of the collagenase of a bacteria, achromobacter, based on two types of methods. The first type uses synthetic substrates, the second one enzymatic inhibitors. The results of both methods are reviewed. The inhibitors seem more sensitive than substrates to study the relation between structure and activity of the enzyme.

New thiol inhibitor of Achromobacter iophagus collagenase. Specificity of the enzyme's S3' subsite.

New synthetic mercaptotripeptides (HS-CH2-CH2-CO-Pro-Yaa) which inhibit Achromobacter iophagus collagenase were produced in order to obtain more powerful bacterial collagenase inhibitors than currently available, and to investigate the specificity of the S3' subsite of the enzyme. Since similar binding constants were found for inhibitors carrying uncharged residues of various sizes in the P3' position (Yaa = Ala, Leu, Phe, Pro, Hyp) steric hindrance at the collagenase S3' appears relatively limited. The compound (HS-CH2-CH2-CO-Pro-Arg), which carries an arginine residue in the position P3' and had the highest inhibition constant of the series tested (Ki = 0.5 microM), proved to be the strongest inhibitor so far reported in the literature. The weakest in the present series was the compound (HS-CH2-CH2-CO-Pro-Asp) which carries an aspartic residue in position P3' and had a Ki = 70 microM. The present work revealed that the charged groups in the P3' position play a key role in the interaction of the inhibitors with the enzyme.

Synthesis and comparative study on the reactivity of peptidyl-type phosphinic esters: intramolecular effects in the alkaline and acidic cleavage of methyl beta-carboxyphosphinates.

Using the phosphinic analogue of Cbz-Phe-Gly-OEt 1a as a template for this study, several phosphinic esters (2a-g) were prepared, employing an efficient method for each case. The reactivity of these derivatives under conventional deprotection conditions was studied, and the results are listed comparatively. The effect of steric hindrance as well as the contribution of neighboring groups in the rate of hydrolysis of suitably selected beta-carboxyphosphinates under acidic and alkaline deprotection conditions was examined. The results clearly demonstrate that a significant acceleration of phosphinate cleavage occurs due to the intermediacy of a five-membered, mixed anhydride-type species. This was supported by the observation that similar interactions were not observed in the case of hindered alpha-carboxyphosphinate homologous derivatives.

New thiol inhibitors of Clostridium histolyticum collagenase. Importance of the P3' position.

An extensive series of synthetic mercaptotripeptides (HS-CH2-CH2-CO-Pro-Yaa) was prepared, and the inhibitory constants were determined on the Clostridium histolyticum collagenase. Among the factors which control the optimal binding of these inhibitors, we found that the presence of a free C-terminal carboxylate group in the position P3' of the compounds is of primary importance. In general, the esterification of this carboxylate group decreased the potency of the inhibitors by two orders of magnitude. We observed also that the enzyme favored the inhibitors having a long linear apolar or basic side-chain at the position P3'. The present data suggest a large S3' subsite of the C. histolyticum collagenase. The compound which contains a homoarginine residue at the P3' position with a Ki of 0.2 microM proved to be the most potent synthetic inhibitor known to date for the C. histolyticum collagenase.

Inhibition of Clostridium histolyticum collagenases by phosphonamide peptide inhibitors.

Several phosphonamide peptides having the general structure R-PO(OH)-Xaa-Yaa-Zaa were synthesized and tested for inhibition of Clostridium histolyticum collagenase. Inhibition was found to depend on the nature of R, Xaa, Yaa and Zaa such that the maximal affinity (Ki = 5 nM) was observed when R = p-nitrophenylethyl, Xaa = Gly, Yaa = Pro and Zaa = 2-aminohexanoic acid; this represents the tightest binding of inhibitor reported to date for any bacterial collagenase. Substitution of the p-nitrophenylethyl by a methyl group led to a 500-fold decrease of the potency, highlighting the existence of optimal interaction between the nitrophenylethyl side chain and one subsite of the enzyme. Replacement of the NH group in glycine residue (Xaa position) by -O- or -N-CH3 produces significantly less potent inhibitors, presumably due in part to the loss of a hydrogen bond between the inhibitor and collagenase active site. These phosphonamidates are thought to be acting as transition-state analogues of the peptide substrate.

Phosphinic peptides, the first potent inhibitors of astacin, behave as extremely slow-binding inhibitors.

A series of phosphinic pseudo-peptides varying in length and composition have been designed as inhibitors of the crayfish zinc endopeptidase astacin, the prototype of the astacin family and of the metzincin superfamily of metalloproteinases. The most efficient phosphinic peptide, fluorenylmethyloxycarbonyl-Pro-Lys-PhePsi(PO2CH2)Ala-P ro-Leu-Val, binds to astacin with a Ki value of 42 nM, which is about three orders of magnitude below the corresponding values for previously used hydroxamic acid derivatives. However, the rate constants for association (kon = 96.8 M-1.s-1) and dissociation (koff = 4.1 x 10(-6) s-1) are evidence for the extremely slow binding behaviour of this compound. N-terminally or C-terminally truncated phosphinic analogues of this parent molecule are much less potent, indicating a critical role of the peptide size on the potency. In particular, omission of the N-terminal proline residue leads to a 40-fold increase in Ki which is mostly due to a 75-fold higher koff value. These findings are consistent with the previously solved crystal structure of astacin complexed with one of the phosphinic peptides, benzyloxycarbonyl-Pro-Lys-PhePsi(PO2CH2)Ala-Pro-O-methyl, Ki = 14 microM [Grams, Dive, Yiotakis, Yiallouros, Vassiliou, Zwilling, Bode and Stöcker (1996) Nature Struct. Biol. 3, 671-675]. This structure also reveals that the phosphinic group binds to the active site as a transition-state analogue. The extremely slow binding behaviour of the phosphinic peptides is discussed in the light of the conformational changes involving a unique 'tyrosine switch' in the structure of astacin upon inhibitor binding. The phosphinic peptides may provide a rational basis for the design of drugs directed towards other members of the astacin family which, like bone morphogenetic protein 1 (BMP1; i.e. the procollagen C-proteinase), have become targets of pharmacological research.

Development of the first potent and selective inhibitor of the zinc endopeptidase neurolysin using a systematic approach based on combinatorial chemistry of phosphinic peptides.

A new systematic approach, based on combinatorial chemistry of phosphinic peptides, is proposed for rapid development of highly potent and selective inhibitors of zinc metalloproteases. This strategy first evaluates the effects on the inhibitory potency and selectivity of the following parameters: 1) size of the phosphinic peptides, 2) position of the phosphinic bond in the sequence, and 3) the state (free or blocked) of the peptide extremities. After this selection step, the influence of the inhibitor sequence is analyzed in order to determine the identity of the residues that optimized both the potency and the selectivity. We demonstrate the efficiency of this novel approach in rapid identification of the first potent inhibitor of the mammalian zinc endopeptidase neurolysin(24-16), able to discriminate between this enzyme and the related zinc endopeptidase thimet oligopeptidase(24-15). The most potent and selective inhibitor developed in this study, Pro-LPhePsi(PO2CH2)Gly-Pro, displays a Ki value of 4 nM for 24-16 and is 2000 times less potent on 24-15. The specific recognition of such a free phosphinic tetrapeptide by 24-16, as well as the unique specificity of the 24-16 S2 and S2' subsites for proline, unveiled by this study, are discussed in terms of their possible significance for the function of this enzyme and its related zinc endopeptidase activities.

Allomalformin.

In an attempt to find explanation for the initial erroneous sequence assignment for malformin, a sequence-isomer of the natural product, 3-isoleucine-5-valine malformin or briefly "allomalformin" that on partial acid hydrolysis could have given rise to misleading fragments, was synthesized and compared with both natural and synthetic preparations of malformin. Allomalformin is identical to the parent microbial peptide (malformin A, or briefly malformin) with respect to biological activity and conformation (ORD and CD spectra) and is indistinguishable from it by high pressure liquid chromatography. Yet, the two isomers have slightly different Rf values on thin-layer chromatograms and by this method no allomalformin could be detected in samples of the natural product. On the other hand both high pressure liquid chromatography and thin-layer chromatography demonstrated the presence of the lower homolog, 5-valine malformin, in the samples examined. On partial acid hydrolysis this natural analog should liberate Val-Cys, while Cys-Val forms from malformin itself. Similarly, the corresponding desthio cyclopentapeptides should give rise to Val-Ala and Ala-Val respectively; the former being more resistant to further hydrolysis persists in the partial hydrolysates. The presence of Val-Cys in partial hydrolysates of malformin and of Val-Ala in the partial hydrolysates of desthiomalformin, both originating from the accompanying lower homolog rather than from malformin itself, is likely to have led to the postulation of the erroneous Cys-Val-Cys partial sequence.

Proton and tritium NMR relaxation studies of peptide inhibitor binding to bacterial collagenase: conformation and dynamics.

The interaction of succinyl-Pro-Ala, a competitive inhibitor of Achromobacter iophagus collagenase, with the enzyme was studied by longitudinal proton and tritium relaxation. Specific deuterium and tritium labeling of the succinyl part at vicinal positions allowed the measurement of the cross-relaxation rates of individual proton or tritium spin pairs in the inhibitor-enzyme complex as well as in the free inhibitor. Overall correlation times, internuclear distances, and qualitative information on the internal mobility in Suc1 (as provided by the generalized order parameter S2) could be deduced by the comparison of proton and tritium cross-relaxation of spin pairs at complementary positions in the -CH2- CH2- moiety as analyzed in terms of the model-free approach by Lipari and Szabo. The conformational and motional parameters of the inhibitor in the free and enzyme-bound state were directly compared by this method. The measurement of proton cross-relaxation in the Ala residue provided additional information on the inhibitor binding. The determination of the order parameter in different parts of the inhibitor molecule in the bound state indicates that the succinyl and alanyl residues are primarily involved in the interaction with the enzyme activity site. The succinyl moiety, characterized in solution by the conformational equilibrium among the three staggered rotamers--i.e., trans: 50%; g+: 20%; g-: 30%--adopted in the bound state the unique trans conformation.

Peptide inhibitors of E. collagenolyticum bacterial collagenase--effect of N-methylation. Consequences on biological activity and conformational properties.

Peptide inhibitors of E. collagenolyticum bacterial collagenase, HS-CH2-CH2-CO-Pro-Yaa (Yaa = Ala, Leu, Nle), have been N-methylated at the Yaa position. The N-methylation slightly increases the inhibitory potency of the modified peptides as compared to the parent compounds. The conformational effects of the N-methylation have been investigated by both 1H 2D-NMR and molecular mechanics energy minimization. Three low-energy conformers have been predicted for the unmethylated parent compounds (Yaa = Ala, Leu, Nle). They are characterized by the psi value of the central proline residue: psi Pro = 150 degrees (trans' conformation), psi Pro = 70 degrees (C7 conformation) and psi Pro = -50 degrees (cis' conformation). The N-methylation has been found to strongly increase the energy of the C7 conformer and to a less extent the energy of the cis' conformer. This leaves the trans' conformation as the only low-energy conformer. The ROESY experiments have established that both the N-methyl peptides and the parent compounds adopt the same preferred backbone conformation in water solution, i.e. the trans' conformation. Based on these results, the activities of the N-methyl peptides are discussed and a possible conformation of the inhibitor in the bound state is proposed.

Phosphinic peptide analogues as potent inhibitors of Corynebacterium rathayii bacterial collagenase.

Pseudo-substrate analogues of collagenase from Corynebacterium rathayii, in which the scissile peptide bond is replaced by a phosphinic moiety, were synthesized and evaluated as inhibitors of this enzyme. The phosphinic tetrapeptide, Z-Phe-psi(PO2CH2)-Gly-Pro-Nle (1), was found to be a potent inhibitor of collagenase with a Ki value of 8 nM. Increasing the length of the phosphinic-containing inhibitors from tetra- to hepta-peptide size further improves the potency of these compounds. The heptapeptide analogue, Z-Phe-Gly-Pro-Phe-psi(PO2CH2)-Gly-Pro-Nle-OMe, with a Ki value of 0.6 nM, is the most potent inhibitor reported to date for bacterial collagenases. A comparison between the phosphinic analogue Z-Phe-psi(PO2CH2)-Gly-Pro-Nle (1) and the phosphonamide peptide Z-Phe-psi(PO2NH)-Gly-Pro-Nle (2) shows that for bacterial collagenase the replacement of a CH2 by an NH group results only in a modest increase in affinity from Ki = 8 nM for compound 1 to Ki = 6 nM for compound 2. Most of the phosphorus-containing inhibitors of this series are slow- or slow-tight-binding inhibitors with second-order rate constants for association and dissociation varying respectively for the kon values from 1 x 10(3) to 26 x 10(3) M-1.s-1 and for the koff values from 3 x 10(-4) to 2 x 10(-5) s-1. Interestingly, the lower affinity of the molecule containing a D residue in the P1 position of the inhibitor, compared with the molecule with an L residue in this position, is mainly the consequence of a lower rate constant for association of these D stereoisomers with the enzyme. This study demonstrates that phosphinic peptide analogues are potent inhibitors of a bacterial collagenase. The development of new phosphinic peptides should lead to the discovery of potent inhibitors of other zinc metalloproteases. Details of how the analogues were synthesized are given in Supplementary Publication SUP 50176 (14 pages), which has been deposited with the British Library Document Supply Centre, Boston Spa, Wetherby, W. Yorkshire LS23 7BQ, from whom copies can be obtained on the terms indicated in Biochem. J. (1994) 297, 9.

Phosphinic peptides as zinc metalloproteinase inhibitors.

Solid-phase synthesis of phosphinic peptides was introduced 10 years ago. A major application of this chemistry has been the development of potent synthetic inhibitors of zinc metalloproteases. Specific properties of the inhibitors produced in recent years are reviewed, supporting the notion that phosphinic pseudo-peptides are useful tools for studying the structural and functional biology of zinc proteases.