High photochemical trapping efficiency in Photosystem I from the red clade algae Chromera velia and Phaeodactylum tricornutum.

In the present work, we report the first comparative spectroscopic investigation between Photosystem I (PSI) complexes isolated from two red clade algae. Excitation energy transfer was measured in PSI from Chromera velia, an alga possessing a split PsaA protein, and from the model diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum. In both cases, the estimated effective photochemical trapping time was in the 15-25ps range, i.e. twice as fast as higher plants. In contrast to green phototrophs, the trapping time was rather constant across the whole emission spectrum. The weak wavelength dependence was attributed to the limited presence of long-wavelength emitting chlorophylls, as verified by low temperature spectroscopy. As the trapping kinetics of C. velia PSI were barely distinguishable from those of P. tricornutum PSI, it was concluded that the scission of PsaA protein had no significant impact on the overall PSI functionality. In conclusion, the two red clade algae analysed here, carried amongst the most efficient charge separation so far reported for isolated Photosystems.

Carotenoid triplet states in photosystem II: coupling with low-energy states of the core complex.

The photo-excited triplet states of carotenoids, sensitised by triplet-triplet energy transfer from the chlorophyll triplet states, have been investigated in the isolated Photosystem II (PSII) core complex and PSII-LHCII (Light Harvesting Complex II) supercomplex by Optically Detected Magnetic Resonance techniques, using both fluorescence (FDMR) and absorption (ADMR) detection. The absence of Photosystem I allows us to reach the full assignment of the carotenoid triplet states populated in PSII under steady state illumination at low temperature. Five carotenoid triplet ((3)Car) populations were identified in PSII-LHCII, and four in the PSII core complex. Thus, four (3)Car populations are attributed to ß-carotene molecules bound to the core complex. All of them show associated fluorescence emission maxima which are relatively red-shifted with respect to the bulk emission of both the PSII-LHCII and the isolated core complexes. In particular the two populations characterised by Zero Field Splitting parameters |D|=0.0370-0.0373 cm(-1)/|E|=0.00373-0.00375 cm(-1) and |D|=0.0381-0.0385 cm(-1)/|E|=0.00393-0.00389 cm(-1), are coupled by singlet energy transfer with chlorophylls which have a red-shifted emission peaking at 705 nm. This observation supports previous suggestions that pointed towards the presence of long-wavelength chlorophyll spectral forms in the PSII core complex. The fifth (3)Car component is observed only in the PSII-LHCII supercomplex and is then assigned to the peripheral light harvesting system.

Comparative kinetic and energetic modelling of phyllosemiquinone oxidation in Photosystem I.

The oxidation kinetics of phyllo(semi)quinone (PhQ), which acts as an electron transfer (ET) intermediate in the Photosystem I reaction centre, are described by a minimum of two exponential phases, characterised by lifetimes in the 10-30 ns and 150-300 ns ranges. The fastest phase is considered to be dominated by the oxidation of the PhQ molecule coordinated by the PsaB reaction centre subunit (PhQB), and the slowest phase is dominated by the oxidation of the PsaA coordinated PhQ (PhQA). Testing different energetic schemes within a unified theory-based kinetic modelling approach provides reliable limit-values for some of the physical-chemical parameters controlling these ET reactions: (i) the value of ΔG(0) associated with PhQA oxidation is smaller than ∼+30 meV; (ii) the value of the total reorganisation energy (λt) likely exceeds 0.7 eV; (iii) different mean nuclear modes are coupled to PhQB and PhQA oxidation, the former being larger, and both being ≥100 cm(-1).

Wavelength dependence of the fluorescence emission under conditions of open and closed Photosystem II reaction centres in the green alga Chlorella sorokiniana.

The fluorescence emission characteristics of the photosynthetic apparatus under conditions of open (F0) and closed (FM) Photosystem II reaction centres have been investigated under steady state conditions and by monitoring the decay lifetimes of the excited state, in vivo, in the green alga Chlorella sorokiniana. The results indicate a marked wavelength dependence of the ratio of the variable fluorescence, FV=FM-F0, over FM, a parameter that is often employed to estimate the maximal quantum efficiency of Photosystem II. The maximal value of the FV/FM ratio is observed between 660 and 680nm and the minimal in the 690-730nm region. It is possible to attribute the spectral variation of FV/FM principally to the contribution of Photosystem I fluorescence emission at room temperature. Moreover, the analysis of the excited state lifetime at F0 and FM indicates only a small wavelength dependence of Photosystem II trapping efficiency in vivo.

Photochemical trapping heterogeneity as a function of wavelength, in plant photosystem I (PSI-LHCI).

In the present paper the marked changes in photochemical trapping time over the absorption/fluorescence band of isolated PSI-LHCI are studied by means of time resolved fluorescence decay measurements. For emission at 680-690nm the effective trapping time is close to 17-18ps, and represents the effective trapping time from the bulk antenna. At wavelengths above 700nm the effective trapping time increases in a monotonic way, over the entire emission band, to attain values in the range of 70-80ps near 760nm. This is argued to be caused by "uphill" energy transfer from the low energy states to the core antenna and reaction centre. These data, together with the steady state emission spectrum, permit calculation of the overall trapping time for maize PSI-LHCI, which is estimated to be approximately 40ps. The wavelength dependence of the trapping time indicates, that in PSI-LHCI there exists at least one red form which emits at lower energies than the 735nm state. These data indicate that Photosystem I is about 55% diffusion limited.

The Q(y) absorption spectrum of the light-harvesting complex II as determined by structure-based analysis of chlorophyll macrocycle deformations.

The absorption spectrum of the main antenna complex of photosystem II, LHCII, has been modeled using, as starting points, the chlorophyll (chl) atomic coordinates as obtained by the LHCII crystal analysis [Liu, Z., Yan, H., Wang, K., Kuang, T., Zhang, J., Gui, L., An, X., and Chang, W. (2004) Nature 428, 287-292] of three different trimers. The chl site Q(y) transition energies have been obtained in terms of the chl macrocycle deformations influencing the energy level of the chl frontier orbitals. Using these chl site transition energy values and the entire set of interaction energies, calculated in the ideal dipole approximation, the complete Hamiltonians for the three LHCII trimers have been written and the full set of 42 eigenstates of each LHCII trimer have been calculated. With the 42 transition energies and transition dipole strengths, either unperturbed or associated to the eigenstates, the LHCII Q(y) absorption spectrum has been calculated using a chl absorption band shape. These calculations have been performed both in vacuo and in the presence of a medium. Despite the number of approximations, a good correlation with the measured absorption spectrum of a LHCII preparation is obtained. This analysis shows that, although a substantial C3 symmetry of the LHCII trimer in terms of both chl-chl distances and interaction energies is present, a marked variation among monomer subsets of site transition energies is estimated. This leads to a C3 symmetry breaking in the unperturbed chl site transition energies set and, consequently, in the trimer eigenstates. It is also concluded that interactions among chlorophylls do not significantly modify the light absorption role of LHCII in plant leaves.

Reconstituted CP29: multicomponent fluorescence decay from an optically homogeneous sample.

The multiexponential fluorescence decay of the CP29 complex in which the apoprotein and pigments were reconstituted in vitro was examined. Of the three decay components observed only the two dominant ones, with about 3 and 5 ns lifetimes, were studied. The main question addressed was whether the multicomponent decay was associated with sample optical heterogeneity. To this end, we examined the optical absorption and fluorescence of the CP29 sample by means of two different and independent experimental strategies. This approach was used as the wavelength positions of the absorption/fluorescence spectral forms has recently been shown to be a sensitive indicator of the binding site-induced porphyrin ring deformation (Zucchelli et al. Biophys J 93:2240-2254, 2007) and hence of apoprotein conformational changes. The data indicate that this CP29 sample is optically homogeneous. It is hypothesised that the different lifetimes are explained in terms of multiple detergent/CP29 interactions leading to different quenching states, a suggestion that allows for optical homogeneity.

Energy transfer processes in the isolated core antenna complexes CP43 and CP47 of photosystem II.

The energy equilibration and transfer processes in the isolated core antenna complexes CP43 and CP47 of photosystem II have been studied by steady-state and ultrafast (femto- to nanosecond) time-resolved spectroscopy at room temperature. The annihilation-free femtosecond absorption data can be described by surprisingly simple sequential kinetic models, in which the excitation energy transfer between blue and red states in both antenna complexes is dominated by sub-picosecond processes and is completed in less than 2ps. The slowest energy transfer steps with lifetimes in the range of 1-2ps are assigned to transfer steps between the chlorophyll layers located on the stromal and lumenal sides. We conclude that these ultrafast intra-antenna energy transfer steps do not represent a bottleneck in the rate of the primary processes in intact photosystem II. Since the experimental energy equilibration rates are up to a factor of 3-5 higher than concluded previously, our results challenge the conclusions drawn from theoretical modeling.

Band shape heterogeneity of the low-energy chlorophylls of CP29: absence of mixed binding sites and excitonic interactions.

A number of spectroscopic characteristics of three almost isoenergetic, red-shifted chlorophylls (chls) in the PS II antenna complex CP29 are investigated with the aim of (i) determining whether their band shapes are substantially identical or not, (ii) addressing the topical problem of whether they are involved in excitonic interactions with other chls, and (iii) establishing whether their binding sites may be defined as "mixed" with respect to their capacity to bind chls a and b. The three chls A2-CHL612, A3-CHL613, and B3-CHL614 were analyzed after in vitro apoprotein-pigment reconstitution using the CP29 coding sequence from Arabidopsis thaliana for both the wild-type and mutant complexes. Difference spectra thermal broadening analyses indicated that the half-bandwidths varied between 12 and 15 nm (at room temperature), due mainly to differences in the optical reorganization energy (25-40 cm(-1)). Moreover, only the A2 chl displayed an intense vibrational band in the 300-600 cm(-1) interval from the 0-0 transition. We conclude that within the red absorbing (approximately 680 nm) antenna chls of a single chl-protein complex a marked spectral band shape heterogeneity exists. By analysis of the absorption and circular dichroism spectra no evidence was found of significantly strong excitonic interactions. The single gene mutation of the A3 and B3 binding sites causes absorption changes in both the long wavelength chl a absorbing region and in the chl b spectral region. This has previously been observed and was attributed to "mixed" chl a/b binding sites [Bassi, R., Croce, R., Cugini, D., and Sandona, D. (1999) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 96,10056-10061]. This interpretation, while in principle not being unreasonable, is shown to be incorrect for these two chls.

Fluorescence lifetime spectrum of the plant photosystem II core complex: photochemistry does not induce specific reaction center quenching.

The photosystem II kinetic model (diffusion or trap-limited) is still much debated. There is discussion about whether energy transfer from the core antenna (CP47 and CP43) to the reaction center complex (D1-D2-cyt b 559) is rate-limiting (transfer to trap-limited). This study investigates this problem in isolated core particles by exploiting the different optical properties of the core antenna and the reaction center complex near 680 nm, due to P680 and an isoenergetic pheophytin. This was used as a marker feature for the reaction center complex. If the transfer to the trap-limited model were correct, assuming excited-state thermalization, the specific reaction center fluorescence decay lifetime should be shorter near 680 nm, where there is reaction center complex specificity, than at the other emission wavelengths. Such a selective reaction center feature was not observed in fluorescence decay measurements. At the experimental resolution used here, we conclude that the trap-limited energy transfer to the reaction center could, at the most, be 20% limiting. Thus, the transfer to the trap-limited model is not supported. A kinetic, compartmental analysis was also performed on the data, taking into account a large number of separate measurements and the associated errors. Target analysis, considering these intermeasurement errors, yielded two minima which adequately describe the fluorescence lifetime data. The nonunique nature of the description is due to the fact that we have taken into consideration these intermeasurement errors. In our case, due to these errors, a correct kinetic model interpretation required additional experimental information.

Entropy consumption in primary photosynthesis.

Knox and Parson have objected to our previous conclusion on possible negative entropy production during primary photochemistry, i.e., from photon absorption to primary charge separation, by considering a pigment system in which primary photochemistry is not specifically considered. This approach does not address our proposal. They suggest that when a pigment absorbs light and passes to an excited state, its entropy increases by hnu/T. This point is discussed in two ways: (i) from considerations based on the energy gap law for excited state relaxation; (ii) using classical thermodynamics, in which free energy is introduced into the pigment (antenna) system by photon absorption. Both approaches lead us to conclude that the excited state and the ground state are isoentropic, in disagreement with Knox and Parson. A discussion on total entropy changes specifically during the charge separation process itself indicates that this process may be almost isoentropic and thus our conclusions on possible negentropy production associated with the sequence of reactions which go from light absorption to the first primary charge separation event, due to its very high thermodynamic efficiency, remain unchanged.

Photosystem I, when excited in the chlorophyll Qy absorption band, feeds on negative entropy.

It is often suggested that Life may lay outside the normal laws of Physics and particularly of Thermodynamics, though this point of view is refuted by many. As the Living State may be thought of as an open system, often far from equilibrium, most attempts at placing Life under the umbrella of the laws of Physics have been based, particularly in recent years, on non-equilibrium Thermodynamics and particularly the Maximum Entropy Production Principle. In this view it is the dissipation of entropy (heat) which permits the ever increasing complexity of Living Systems in biological evolution and the maintenance of this complexity. However, these studies usually consider such biological entities as whole cells, organs, whole organisms and even Life itself at the entire terrestrial level. This requires making assumptions concerning the Living State, which are often not soundly based on observation and lack a defined model structure. The present study is based on an entirely different approach, in which a classical thermodynamic analysis of a well-defined biological nanoparticle, plant Photosystem I, is performed. This photosynthetic structure, which absorbs light and performs primary and secondary charge separation, operates with a quantum efficiency close to one. It is demonstrated that when monochromatic light is absorbed by the lowest lying electronic transition, the chlorophyll Qy transition, entropy production in the system bath plus entropy changes internal to the system are numerically less than the entropy decrease of the light field. A Second Law violation is therefore suggested for these experimental conditions. This conclusion, while at first sight is supportive of the famous and much discussed statement of Schroedinger, that "Life feeds on negentropy", is analysed and the conditions in which this statement may be considered valid for a Plant Photosystem are defined and delimited. The remarkably high quantum efficiency, leading to minimal entropy production (energy wastage), seems to suggest that evolution of Photosystem I has gone down the road of maximal energy efficiency as distinct from maximal entropy production. Photosystem I cannot be considered a maximum entropy dissipation structure.

Trapping Dynamics in Photosystem I-Light Harvesting Complex I of Higher Plants Is Governed by the Competition Between Excited State Diffusion from Low Energy States and Photochemical Charge Separation.

The dynamics of excited state equilibration and primary photochemical trapping have been investigated in the photosystem I-light harvesting complex I isolated from spinach, by the complementary time-resolved fluorescence and transient absorption approaches. The combined analysis of the experimental data indicates that the excited state decay is described by lifetimes in the ranges of 12-16 ps, 32-36 ps, and 64-77 ps, for both detection methods, whereas faster components, having lifetimes of 550-780 fs and 4.2-5.2 ps, are resolved only by transient absorption. A unified model capable of describing both the fluorescence and the absorption dynamics has been developed. From this model it appears that the majority of excited state equilibration between the bulk of the antenna pigments and the reaction center occurs in less than 2 ps, that the primary charge separated state is populated in ∼4 ps, and that the charge stabilization by electron transfer is completed in ∼70 ps. Energy equilibration dynamics associated with the long wavelength absorbing/emitting forms harbored by the PSI external antenna are also characterized by a time mean lifetime of ∼75 ps, thus overlapping with radical pair charge stabilization reactions. Even in the presence of a kinetic bottleneck for energy equilibration, the excited state dynamics are shown to be principally trap-limited. However, direct excitation of the low energy chlorophyll forms is predicted to lengthen significantly (∼2-folds) the average trapping time.

Photosynthesis and negative entropy production.

The widely held view that the maximum efficiency of a photosynthetic pigment system is given by the Carnot cycle expression (1-T/Tr) for energy transfer from a hot bath (radiation at temperature Tr) to a cold bath (pigment system at temperature T) is critically examined and demonstrated to be inaccurate when the entropy changes associated with the microscopic process of photon absorption and photochemistry at the level of single photosystems are considered. This is because entropy losses due to excited state generation and relaxation are extremely small (DeltaS << T/Tr) and are essentially associated with the absorption-fluorescence Stokes shift. Total entropy changes associated with primary photochemistry for single photosystems are shown to depend critically on the thermodynamic efficiency of the process. This principle is applied to the case of primary photochemistry of the isolated core of higher plant photosystem I and photosystem II, which are demonstrated to have maximal thermodynamic efficiencies of xi > 0.98 and xi > 0.92 respectively, and which, in principle, function with negative entropy production. It is demonstrated that for the case of xi > (1-T/Tr) entropy production is always negative and only becomes positive when xi < (1-T/Tr).

Circular dichroism of the peripheral chlorophylls in photosystem II reaction centers revealed by electrochemical oxidation.

Visible absorption spectra and circular dichroism (CD) of the red absorption band of isolated photosystem II reaction centers were measured at room temperature during progressive bleaching by electrochemical oxidation, in comparison with aerobic photochemical destruction, and with anaerobic photooxidation in the presence of the artificial electron acceptor silicomolybdate. Initially, selective bleaching of peripheral chlorophylls absorbing at 672 nm was obtained by electrochemical oxidation at +0.9 V, whereas little selectivity was observed at higher potentials. Illumination in the presence of silicomolybdate did not cause a bleaching but a spectral broadening of the 672-nm band was observed, apparently in response to the oxidation of carotene. The 672-nm absorption band is shown to exhibit a positive CD, which accounts for the 674-nm shoulder in CD spectra at low temperature. The origin of this CD is discussed in view of the observation that all CD disappears with the 680-nm absorption band during aerobic photodestruction.

The effect of outer antenna complexes on the photochemical trapping rate in barley thylakoid Photosystem II.

We have investigated the previous suggestions in the literature that the outer antenna of Photosystem II of barley does not influence the effective photosystem primary photochemical trapping rate. It is shown by steady state fluorescence measurements at the F(0) fluorescence level of wild type and the chlorina f2 mutant, using the chlorophyll b fluorescence as a marker, that the outer antenna is thermally equilibrated with the core pigments, at room temperature, under conditions of photochemical trapping. This is in contrast with the conclusions of the earlier studies in which it was suggested that energy was transferred rapidly and irreversibly from the outer antenna to the Photosystem II core. Furthermore, the effective trapping time, determined by single photon counting, time-resolved measurements, was shown to increase from 0.17+/-0.017 ns in the chlorina Photosystem II core to a value within the range 0.42+/-0.036-0.47+/-0.044 ns for the wild-type Photosystem II with the outer antenna system. This 2.5-2.8-fold increase in the effective trapping time is, however, significantly less than that expected for a thermalized system. The data can be explained in terms of the outer antenna increasing the primary charge separation rate by about 50%.

Two wavelength-dependent mechanisms of sensitisation of light-induced quenching in the isolated light-harvesting complex II.

The efficiency of visible light in inducing fluorescence quenching in the isolated light-harvesting complex II (LHCII) of higher plants is investigated by action spectroscopy in the visible portion of photosynthetic active radiation. The efficiency spectrum displays a relatively homogenous quenching yield across the most intense electronic transitions of the chlorophyll a and carotenoid pigments, indicating that quenching proceeds from the equilibrated state of the complex. Larger yields are observed in the 510-640-nm window, where weak transitions of LHCII-bound chromophores occur. This observation is interpreted in terms of an additional quenching sensitisation process mediated by these electronic transitions.

The photochemical trapping rate from red spectral states in PSI-LHCI is determined by thermal activation of energy transfer to bulk chlorophylls.

The average fluorescence decay lifetimes, due to reaction centre photochemical trapping, were calculated for wavelengths in the 690- to 770-nm interval from the published fluorescence decay-associated emission spectra for Photosystem I (PSI)-light-harvesting complex of Photosystem I (LHCI) [Biochemistry 39 (2000) 6341] at 280 and 170 K. For 280 K, the overall trapping time at 690 nm is 81 ps and increases with wavelength to reach 103 ps at 770 nm. For 170 K, the 690-nm value is 115 ps, increasing to 458 ps at 770 nm. This underlines the presence of kinetically limiting processes in the PSI antenna (diffusion limited). The explanation of these nonconstant values for the overall trapping time band is sought in terms of thermally activated transfer from the red absorbing states to the "bulk" acceptor chlorophyll (chl) states in the framework of the Arrhenius-Eyring theory. It is shown that the wavelength-dependent "activation energies" come out in the range between 1.35 and 2.7 kcal mol(-1), increasing with the emission wavelength within the interval 710-770 nm. These values are in good agreement with the Arrhenius activation energy determined for the steady-state fluorescence yield over the range 130-280 K for PSI-LHCI. We conclude that the variable trapping time in PSI-LHCI can be accounted for entirely by thermally activated transfer from the low-energy chl states to the bulk acceptor states and therefore that the position of the various red states in the PSI antenna seems not to be of significant importance. The analysis shows that the bulk antenna acceptor states are on the low-energy side of the bulk antenna absorption band.

The low energy emitting states of the Lhca4 subunit of higher plant photosystem I.

The selectively red excited emission spectrum, at room temperature, of the in vitro reconstituted Lhca4, has a pronounced non-equilibrium distribution, leading to enhanced emission from the directly excited low-energy pigments. Two different emitting forms (or states), with maximal emission at 713 and 735nm (F713 and F735) and unusual spectral properties, have been identified. Both high-energy states are populated when selective excitation is into the F735 state and the fluorescence anisotropy spectrum attains the value of 0.3 in the wavelength region where both emission states are present. This indicates that the two states are on the same Lhca4 complex and have transition dipoles with similar orientation.

The room temperature emission band shape of the lowest energy chlorophyll spectral form of LHCI.

Selective excitation, at room temperature, in the long wavelength absorption tail of the photosystem I antenna complexes, known as light harvesting complex I, induces pronounced pre-equilibration fluorescence from the directly excited pigment state. This has allowed determination of the fluorescence band shape of this low energy photosystem I chlorophyll antenna state, at room temperature, for the first time. The emission maximum is near 735 nm. The remarkable band width (55 nm) and asymmetry have never been previously reported for chlorophyll a states.