Application of various microscopy techniques to study early-age and longer-term behaviour of super sulphated cement microstructure.

Super sulphated cement (SSC) is a very promising substitute for traditional construction materials (i.e. Portland cement), due to its enhanced durability and particularly low environmental impact. This paper explores the microstructure and certain properties of SSC, focusing on the particular complexities of its microstructure and the difficulties of microanalysis of its hydrates. To do so, SSC paste samples were first cast to identify hydration products using X-ray diffraction, then observed at early age using confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) and at early and late age using scanning electron microscopy. In addition, concrete cores impregnated with fluorescein in order to highlight porosity, cracking and aggregates debonding were observed under UV light using optical microscopy (OM), showing a complete absence of cracking and aggregate debonding. Both microscopy techniques (CLSM and UV light OM) have been applied to this type of binder for the first time. The results show that SSC microstructure is characterised by a sophisticated intergrowth of various phases, including ettringite and amorphous calcium-(alumina)-silicate hydrate gels. Finally, Monte-Carlo simulation of electron-matter has been provided for a better understanding of EDS analysis.

Persulfate activation by nanoscale zero-valent iron supported by modified blast furnace slag for degradation of phenol wastewater.

Nano-zero valent iron (nZVI) was anchored and dispersed on the surface of acid-modified blast furnace slag (mBFS) through the liquid phase reduction method. The synthesized nZVI@mBFS composite exhibited remarkable ability to degrade phenol when used in conjunction with persulfate (PDS), 97.8% phenol could be eliminated in 30 min. All the anions like SO42-, HCO3-, H2PO4-, and CO32- were detrimental to the phenol degradation in nZVI@mBFS system. Moreover, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) analysis and radical scavenging tests confirmed that SO4•-, •OH and •O2- were the principal reactive oxygen species (ROSs) generated during the reaction process. The potential degradation pathways were also deduced based on the results obtained from gas chromatograph-mass spectrometer (GC-MS) analysis. Collectively, this study holds substantial significance in regards to recycling industrial solid wastes, devising efficient persulfate-activated materials, and treating wastewater.

Design and properties of ternary alkali-activated binder based on blast furnace slag, recycled powder and waste glass powder.

Ternary alkali-activated binder was prepared by blast furnace slag (GGBS), recycled powder (RP) and waste glass powder (WGP) using simplex centroid design method. By measuring the fluidity, setting time, drying shrinkage and mechanical property of specimen, the complementary effect of GGBS, RP and WGP was discussed. The reaction mechanism and microstructure were explored by X-ray diffraction and scanning electron microscopy. The results reveal that the addition of RP could significantly reduce the fluidity and setting time of paste, while WGP can obviously improve the rheological property and play a retarding role. The workability of paste can be effectively regulated by mixing RP and WGP together. Whether added alone or in combination, RP and WGP can effectively improve the shrinkage performance. In the ternary system, GGBS can be rapidly activated and form a skeleton structure. The fine RP particles can play a good role in filling the structure, and the pozzolanic reaction of WGP gradually occurs, which makes the microstructure more compact. The incorporation of GGBS, RP and WGP can promote the growth of hydration products, improve the density of microstructure, and form a certain complementary effect.

Influence of the chemical composition of leachates on the results of ecotoxicity tests for different slag types.

In this study, four ecotoxicological tests on Vibrio fischeri bacteria, Sinapis alba L. (white mustard), Daphnia magna S. (daphnia's) and earthworms were performed for three types of aqueous slag (ladle, blast furnace and converter) leachates with two-grain sizes (<4 mm, <10 mm). Concentrations of toxic elements and concentrations of Cr(VI), Ca, Na, Al, and other ions were determined. The raw slags were analyzed using X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy (XRFS), and major substances were determined by X-ray powder diffraction (XRD). The aqueous slag leachates passed ecotoxicological tests and met the required criteria, showing no toxicity to Vibrio fischeri and complying with white mustard test criteria. According to the results of the ecotoxicity tests with daphnia, the blast furnace slag samples were not ecotoxic, while two other slag samples were found to be entirely compliant. Characterization of the slags showed that the effect of element/ion leachability and slag grain size is essential. Biplot principal component analysis (PCA) showed that grain size does not significantly affect the separation of individuals on the plane. A positive correlation on toxicity was found with pH, conductivity, calcium content, dissolved content, salinity and fluoride concentration, whereas a negative correlation was found with magnesium concentration, dissolved organic carbon and potassium concentration. The effective concentration at 50% inhibition (EC50) value for Vibrio fischeri correlated with the first dimension of bivariate assessment. In summary, it was found that the investigated slags can be effectively reused as they comply with regulations and do not endanger the environment.

Low-cost optimization of industrial textile landfill sludge re-dewatering using ferrous sulfate and blast furnace slag.

This study was based on an industrial sludge landfill with a scale of 1 million cubic meters, which had been filled for more than 10 years. It focused on the secondary dewatering of industrial textile landfill sludge (LS) with a total organic carbon (TOC) content greater than 50% and a volatile suspended solids to suspended solids (VSS/SS) ratio of 0.59. A response surface methodology (RSM) model was established using the coagulant ferrous sulfate (FeSO4) and conditioning agents such as hydrated magnesium oxide (MgO), blast furnace slag (BFS), and calcium oxide (CaO). By solving the RSM equations for the respective indicators, the optimal dosages of FeSO4, MgO, and BFS were determined to be 90 mg/g of dry sludge (DS), and for CaO 174.85 mg/g DS. Further examinations of the dewatering performance, apparent properties, extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) components, rheological characteristics, moisture distribution, and pollutant content variation led to the development of a green waste-based dewatering agent composed of FeSO4 and BFS. In small-scale diaphragm plate and frame filter press tests, the optimal water content (WC) was 69.11%. In the final production-scale experiments, it was 65.72%, with the actual application cost being only 13.07 $/ton DS. Additionally, when FeSO4 and BFS were used together, the combined action of Fe and Si could significantly reduce the biotoxicity of heavy metals (HMs), cut down 75.2% of the LS's TOC, and effectively reduced the leaching of organic substances from the leachate, which was beneficial for subsequent disposal. In conclusion, the combined use of FeSO4 and BFS for the secondary dewatering of industrial textile LS was economically efficient, effective in dewatering, and had significant harm reduction effects, making it a worthwhile for waste treatment.

Improving landfill liner performance with bentonite-slag blend permeated with ammonia for a Municipal solid waste landfill.

Leachate emanating from landfills contains ammonia which may cause serious health effects on living things. An effectively designed clay barrier should not allow the contaminant to infiltrate the soil and groundwater systems. The utilization of certain industrial by-products in engineered landfill barriers, not only reduces the need for conventional liner materials but also helps in sustainable waste management. This study investigated the hydraulic conductivity, unconfined compressive strength, compaction, and adsorption characteristics of lithomargic clay blended with an optimum percentage of bentonite (10%) and granulated blast furnace slag (15%) permeated with ammonia. The results revealed that increasing the content of granulated blast furnace slag decreased the maximum dry density while increasing the optimum moisture content. In comparison to lithomargic clay, the hydraulic conductivity of the amended soil liner permeated with ammonia decreased from a value of 3 × 10-8 m/s to 5 × 10-10 m/s. The unconfined compressive strength of the amended soil specimens showed an increasing trend with curing times (i.e., 0, 14, 28, and 56 days). The batch adsorption results revealed that Freundlich and Langmuir's isotherm fits the equilibrium adsorption data and the adsorption of ammonia on clay liner follows non-linear behaviour. Overall, the experimental results implied that lithomargic clay blended with 10% bentonite and 15% granulated blast furnace slag can be used as an impermeable soil reactive barrier in engineered landfills.

Fabrication and characterization of ceramic tubular composite membranes using slag waste materials for oily wastewater treatment.

In this study, low-cost tubular ceramic membranes were fabricated by using waste slag and natural raw materials in order to decrease the manufacturing carbon footprints. The effects of incorporation of phosphorus slag (PS) and blast furnace slag (BFS) in the mullite-zeolite membrane body were investigated. The structural characteristics of the fabricated membranes were evaluated using X-ray diffraction (XRD), field emission-scanning electron microscopy (FESEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM), contact angle, porosity and average pore size analyses. Thermal and mechanical stability were studied by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and three-point bending test, respectively. The oily wastewater treatment tests revealed that an increase in the slag percentage from 0 to 30% leads to enhancing the permeate flux from 99 l m-2 h-1 to 349 l m-2 h-1 for PS-based tubular membrane and to 244 l m-2 h-1 for BFS-based tubular membrane under 1 bar applied. The chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal percentage of all membranes was reported almost 99% for oily wastewater feed with a COD concentration of 612 mg l-1. In addition, the investigation of membrane fouling mechanisms was carried out using Hermia models indicating that the best correlation with the experimental data is observed for the complete pore blocking model. This study presents experimental foundations aimed at enhancing the performance of affordable slag-based membranes, thus fostering their applicability in engineering contexts.

Exploring the potential of steel slag waste for carbon sequestration through mineral carbonation: A comparative study of blast-furnace slag and ladle slag.

Steel slag is a by-product of steelmaking which has emerged as a potential CO2 sequestration material due to its high reactivity and abundance. This research investigates the use of steel slag waste for the direct capture of carbon from air and its storage through mineral carbonation. Two abundant wastes, blast-furnace slag (BFS) and ladle slag (LS), were tested for their carbon sequestration potential, and the effects of operational parameters such as reaction time between CO2 and slag waste, temperature, liquid-solid ratio, and pressure on CO2 sequestration were determined. Quantitative and qualitative results reveal that much higher CO2 sequestration was achieved using LS compared to BFS after exposure to CO2 for 1 day at room temperature. By increasing the exposure time to four days, levels of CO2 sequestration increased gradually from 2.71% to 4.19% and 23.46%-28.21% for BFS and LS respectively. Increasing the temperature from 20 ± 2 °C to 90 ± 2 °C positively influenced CO2 sequestration in BFS, resulting in an enhancement from 3.45% to 13.21%. However, the impact on LS was insignificant, with sequestration levels rising from 27.72% to 29.90%. Moreover, better CO2 sequestration was observed for BFS than LS when the liquid-to-solid ratio increased from 3:1 to 4:1, whereupon the sequestration potential reached approximately 15% for BFS and 30% for LS at 90 ± 2 °C. Meanwhile, higher pressure reduced the sequestration potential of slag. The results of this study suggest that there is potential for scaling up the process to industrial applications and contributing to the reduction of CO2 emissions in the steelmaking industry.

Designing low-carbon fly ash based geopolymer with red mud and blast furnace slag wastes: Performance, microstructure and mechanism.

In order to tackle the environmental problems induced by Portland cement production and industrial solid wastes landfilling, this study aims to develop novel ternary cementless fly ash-based geopolymer by recycling red mud and blast furnace slag industrial solid wastes. The fresh-state properties, mechanical strength, water permeability, phase assemblage and microstructure were systematically investigated to evaluate the performance variation and reveal the hydration mechanism for geopolymers with different mixing proportions. The results showed that a higher slag content or a lower red mud content could result in the higher fluidity and shorter setting time for fresh mixture. The existence of slag promoted the transformation of N-A-S-H to C-A-S-H gel, which contributed to higher compressive strength and better resistance to water penetration. However, an excessive incorporation of 30% red mud may impede the generation of N-A-S-H gel and form more flocculent-like loose hydrates, thus to mildly degrade the mechanical strength and anti-permeability. The synergetic utilization of red much and blast furnace slag in fly ash-based geopolymer led to much less CO2 emission compared with the condition that red much or slag was singly added, which demonstrated prominent environmental advantages for such kind of ternary cementless geopolymer with equivalent mechanical strength.

Recycling of Ti and Si from Ti-bearing blast furnace slag and diamond wire saw silicon waste by flux alloying technique.

Two industrial solid wastes, Ti-bearing blast furnace slag (TBFS) and diamond wire saw silicon waste (DWSSW), contain large amounts of Ti and Si, and their accumulation wastes resources and intensifies environmental pollution. In the present study, DWSSW was used as the silicon source to reduce titanium oxide in TBFS by electromagnetic induction smelting, and meanwhile Na3AlF6 was added as a flux to improve the recycling of the wastes. Ti and Si of the two wastes were simultaneously recovered in the form of alloy. The effects of different addition amount of Na3AlF6 flux in the mixture of DWSSW and TBFS on chemical composition, viscosity, basicity and structure of slag were investigated. The dissolution behavior of SiO2 in Na3AlF6 flux was theoretically deduced and experimentally verification. The optimized recovery rate of Ti and Si were obtained, and the research realizes the efficient recycling of DWSSW and TBFS simultaneously.

Synergistic Leaching of Titanium, Aluminum, and Magnesium Components during Dilute Acid Pressure Treatment of High-Titanium Blast Furnace Slag.

This study focuses on an improved leaching process through the combination of pressurized conditions and direct filtration of acid leaching slurry, which is conductive to improving the filterability of acid leaching systems and the extraction rates of Ti, Al, and Mg components. The effects of sulfuric acid concentration, reaction temperature, particle size of materials, acid-slag ratio, and reaction time on the leaching efficiency were systematically investigated. The results showed that pressurization significantly enhances the filtration efficiency of the reaction slurry. Under the same filtration time, the filtration efficiency increased from 46% under ordinary pressure to 78% under pressurized conditions. Moreover, under the optimal reaction conditions, the extraction rates of Ti, Al, and Mg components were more than 88.21%, 97.8%, and 96.31%, respectively. Additionally, XRD and FTIR showed that titanium oxide sulfate hydrate crystals were produced in the acid-leached residues when the reaction temperature exceeded 190 °C, thereby reducing the extraction rate of Ti component. And the XRD pattern shows that when the reaction temperature is maintained at 190 °C and the reaction time is extended to 150 min, titanium oxide sulfate hydrate crystals will be formed to reduce the extraction rate of the Ti component. In summary, this study not only provides important theoretical support for the resource utilization of high-titanium blast furnace slag but also offers a feasible solution for efficient extraction and convenient filtration, thus holding significant academic and practical implications.

Synthesis and Characterization of Eco-Efficient Alkali-Activated Composites with Self-Cleaning Properties for Sustainable Construction.

In this research, we aimed to design an eco-efficient composite based on alkali-activated materials (AAMs) with self-cleaning properties for sustainable construction. Significant emphasis was placed on determining the role of the type of precursor, the amount of sodium silicate, and the addition of titanium dioxide on the rheological and mechanical properties of AAMs. An important aspect of the research was the modification of AAM with titanium dioxide to obtain the self-cleaning properties. Titanium dioxide, thanks to its photocatalytic properties, enables the reduction of organic pollutants and nitrogen oxides in the urban atmosphere and promotes the cleaning of material surfaces. Blast furnace slag (BFS) was used as the source material, which was then substituted in subsequent formulations with metakaolinite at 50% and fly ash and zeolite at 30%. The best-activated AAMs, in which blast furnace slag and its mixture with metakaolinite were used as precursors, achieved compressive strengths of 50 MPa. BFS mixtures with pozzolans were more difficult to polymerize, although their final strengths were still relatively high, in the range of 33-37 MPa. Adding titanium dioxide (T) improved the final strengths and slightly lowered the heat of hydration and spreading of the AAM mortars. The best self-cleaning properties were achieved with composites that comprised a mixture of blast furnace slag, fly ash, and 2% titanium dioxide.

Effects of Pretreated Phosphogypsum and Granulated Blast-Furnace Slag on the Rheological Properties of the Paste Excited by NaOH.

The main component of phosphogypsum (PG) is CaSO4·2H2O. PG contains a few impurities, heavy metals, and radioisotopes, which limit the use of PG and pose a danger to the environment. In this study, under the excitation of a sodium hydroxide solution, the rheological properties of a paste with granulated blast-furnace slag (GGBS) and PG treated with ultrasonic water washing were investigated. Experimental results showed that the ratio of GGBS to PG and the amount of sodium hydroxide solution significantly affect the density and viscosity of the paste, but the effect patterns of both are different. The maximum viscosity was 498 mPa·s when the ratio of GGBS to PG was 4:1. When the ratio changed from 3:2 to 1:4, the viscosity of the paste gradually decreased by 15.5%, 32.1%, 36.1%, and 46.8%, respectively. In contrast, the ratio of GGBS to PG had a greater effect on the viscosity than the amount of sodium hydroxide solution in terms of the standard consistency water consumption, viscosity, and water release ratio. The larger the PG ratio, the smaller the density, viscosity, and water release ratio of the paste. The variation in the ratio of GGBS to PG had a significant effect on the water film thickness of the paste, demonstrating that the larger the PG mixture, the larger the water film thickness of the paste, which reached 1.122 µm, 2.31 times the minimum water film thickness of the paste. At the same time, the water film thickness of the paste was negatively correlated with the water consumption of the standard consistency, viscosity, and water release ratio, and was positively correlated with the fluidity.

A Porous Geopolymer Containing Ti-Bearing Blast Furnace Slag: Synthesis, Characterization, and Adsorption-Photodegradation Studies towards Methylene Blue Removal under Visible Light Condition.

A porous geopolymer with adsorption and photocatalytic degradation functions was successfully developed by utilizing Ti-bearing blast furnace slag (TBBFS) as the raw material. The prepared porous geopolymers were characterized by X-ray diffraction, scanning electron microscope, energy dispersive spectrometer, and Fourier transform infrared spectrum. Selective crystallization, water quenching, and natural cooling methods were employed to investigate the influences of these modifications on the applicability of TBBFS as a precursor for geopolymer synthesis. Water-quenched slag with amorphous content was prone to alkali dissolution, and the resulting geopolymer exhibited the highest adsorption capacity (97.18 mg/g) for methylene blue (MB) removal. Selective crystallization at 1400 °C generated a hybrid microstructure consisting of a non-cementitious CaTiO3 crystallization phase and a cementitious amorphous fraction. The retention of CaTiO3 in the final geopolymer enables a bifunctionality in adsorption-photodegradation. Particularly, the adsorption and photodegradation processes under various conditions were investigated. The superior removal efficiency for MB could be attributed to the synergistic effects between the geopolymer matrix and CaTiO3, leading to an enhancement in the formation of hydroxyl radicals. The conversion of TBBFS into porous geopolymer offers an efficient and straightforward solution for slag utilization and dye removal.

Adsorption of PCE in alkali-activated materials analysed by fluorescence microscopy.

The realisation of high-performance concrete mixtures requires the use of superplasticizers to achieve a low water/binder ratio and thus high strengths. Polycarboxylate ethers (PCE) are mostly used as superplasticizers. The effectiveness of these superplasticizers depends on their chemical structure, the binders' alkaline environment and the ions present in the pore solution of the binder. In high alkaline systems like some alkali-activated materials no effective superplasticizer have been found yet. To unravel the compatibility of certain PCE to such a highly alkaline system a fluorescence microscopy approach was used. In first experiments, the adsorption of APEG (allyl ether) and MPEG (methacrylate) PCE on ground granulated blast furnace slag and fly ash was investigated varying the concentration of the activators. At a certain concentration, a complexation of the PCE can be recognised in fluorescence microscope. APEG shows a better stability compared to MPEG; this correlates with rheological investigations.

EDS Microanalysis of Unhydrated Blast Furnace Slag Grains in Field Concrete with Different Service Life.

Because the essential quality metrics of blast furnace slag are based on its oxide composition, the determination of chemical compositions of unhydrated slag grains in an aged concrete could be useful for understanding its past performance and in predicting the remaining service life of existing slag-bearing concrete. In this research, the authors explored the feasibility of using standard-based energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) microanalysis, in tandem with electron imaging, as a tool for quantitative measurement of the chemical composition of blast furnace slag grains in cement/concrete. In the experimental study, seven concrete samples representing various service life durations were collected in the Netherlands. The microanalysis results of the samples revealed that the change in slag chemistry is insignificant for samples B (1985) to F (2006); however, elevated CaO and SiO2 contents are found in slag used for sample G (2015), opposite to that of Al2O3 and MgO. After discussing compositional characterization, the paper discusses favorable microanalysis protocols for acceptable elemental quantification accuracy. It was concluded that quantitative EDS microanalysis is a strong tool to characterize the chemical composition of unhydrated slag used in field concrete, which could potentially contribute to understanding the correlations between composition and long-term performance in slag concrete structures.

Sustainable and efficient stabilization/solidification of Pb, Cr, and Cd in lead-zinc tailings by using highly reactive pozzolanic solid waste.

Lead-zinc tailings (LZTs) are industrial by-products containing a large number of heavy metals that seriously harm the ecological environment and human health. This study was performed to propose a sustainable and efficient method for immobilizing Pb, Cr, and Cd in LZTs by using solid waste. To better assess the immobilization performance and mechanism, the leaching toxicity, fraction distribution, unconfined compressive strength, environmental risk assessment, and hydration products were explored. The LZTs were mixed and molded with different constituents of ground granulated blast furnace slag (GGBFS) and rice husk ashes (RHAs) at different curing temperatures. Results suggest that ≥99% of the Pb, Cr, and Cd were immobilized mainly in the form of residual fractions in the LZTs. The amounts of Pb, Cr, and Cd in the bioavailable fractions notably decreased by approximately 99.83%, 99.58%, and 97.05%, respectively. After stabilization/solidification (S/S) disposal, Pb, Cr, and Cd showed low to even no risk. The RHAs were effective to stabilize Pb, and GGBFS was effective to stabilize Cr. However, both materials showed almost equal effects to Cd. Ettringite, C-S-H gel, and portlandite were the main hydration products to immobilize Pb, Cr, and Cd, and these hydration products provided a source of strength. Honey-comb or reticular network C-S-H gel possessed higher specific surface area, higher pore volume, and bigger pore size than the other materials. The proposed method could explain the sustainability and efficiency of the S/S of Pb, Cr, and Cd in LZTs by using RHAs. This study opens up new perspectives for disposing heavy metal by using accessible agricultural solid waste (i.e., RHAs) in rural areas, and the solidified block shows certain economic benefits.

Assessment of the Corrosion of Steel Embedded in an Alkali-Activated Hybrid Concrete Exposed to Chlorides.

Hybrid alkali-activated cements (HAACs), also known as cements with high percentages of alkali-activated supplementary materials, are alternative cements that combine the advantages of ordinary Portland cement (OPC) and alkali-activated systems. These cements are composed of a minimum of 70% precursor material and a maximum of 30% OPC mixed with an alkaline activator. This article evaluates the corrosion performance of reinforced HAAC concrete based on fly ash (FA) under exposure to chlorides (FA/OPC, 80/20). Its performance is compared with that of a binary alkali-activated cement (AAC) based on FA and granulated blast furnace slag (GBFS) (FA/GBFS, 80/20). The tests performed on the concrete matrix correspond to the compressive strength and permeability to chloride ions. Using accelerated corrosion techniques (impressed voltage) and electrochemical tests after immersion in 3.5% NaCl, the progress of the corrosive process in the reinforcing steel is evaluated. The FA/OPC exhibit a better corrosion performance than the FA/GBFS concrete. At the end of the exposure to chlorides, the FA/OPC hybrid concrete presents the best performance, with a 49% lower corrosion rate than that of the FA/GBFS. Note that according to the polarization curves, the values of the proportionality constant B in the alkaline-activated concretes differ from the values recommended for concrete based on OPC.

Fresh and hardened properties of alkali-activated slag concrete: The effect of fly ash as a supplementary precursor.

The present study explores the possibility of replacing blast furnace slag (BFS) with coal fly ash (FA) to produce alkali-activated material (AAM) concrete with hybrid precursors. With an increased FA replacement ratio, the reaction kinetics, fresh and hardened properties of AAM mixtures have been investigated. The retardation effect on the reaction kinetics with an increased FA content has been observed, which not only extended the induction period along with the heat flow evolution but also reduced the cumulative heat release up to 24 h. Spherical FA particles can provide a ball-bearing effect to improve the workability of the hybrid AAM mixtures, while FA also slows down the deterioration of fresh properties since they are less reactive compared to BFS particles. Regarding the strength development, FA results in the reduction at all curing ages in the mixtures with a low silicate modulus (Ms0.25). Similarly, reduction in 1-day compressive strength has been detected in high silicate modulus mixtures (Ms0.5) with FA replacement, while the mixture with 10% FA exhibits the highest compressive strength among Ms0.5 concretes at later curing ages. Bigger capillary pores have been detected in AAM mixtures with an increase in FA content. However, AAM with 10% FA shows the lowest porosity in Ms0.5 mixtures, which is in agreement with the compressive strength results.

Report of RILEM TC 281-CCC: outcomes of a round robin on the resistance to accelerated carbonation of Portland, Portland-fly ash and blast-furnace blended cements.

Many (inter)national standards exist to evaluate the resistance of mortar and concrete to carbonation. When a carbonation coefficient is used for performance comparison of mixtures or service life prediction, the applied boundary conditions during curing, preconditioning and carbonation play a crucial role, specifically when using latent hydraulic or pozzolanic supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs). An extensive interlaboratory test (ILT) with twenty two participating laboratories was set up in the framework of RILEM TC 281-CCC 'Carbonation of Concrete with SCMs'. The carbonation depths and coefficients determined by following several (inter)national standards for three cement types (CEM I, CEM II/B-V, CEM III/B) both on mortar and concrete scale were statistically compared. The outcomes of this study showed that the carbonation rate based on the carbonation depths after 91 days exposure, compared to 56 days or less exposure duration, best approximates the slope of the linear regression and those 91 days carbonation depths can therefore be considered as a good estimate of the potential resistance to carbonation. All standards evaluated in this study ranked the three cement types in the same order of carbonation resistance. Unfortunately, large variations within and between laboratories complicate to draw clear conclusions regarding the effect of sample pre-conditioning and carbonation exposure conditions on the carbonation performance of the specimens tested. Nevertheless, it was identified that fresh and hardened state properties alone cannot be used to infer carbonation resistance of the mortars or concretes tested. It was also found that sealed curing results in larger carbonation depths compared to water curing. However, when water curing was reduced from 28 to 3 or 7 days, higher carbonation depths compared to sealed curing were observed. This increase is more pronounced for CEM I compared to CEM III mixes. The variation between laboratories is larger than the potential effect of raising the CO2 concentration from 1 to 4%. Finally, concrete, for which the aggregate-to-cement factor was increased by 1.79 in comparison with mortar, had a carbonation coefficient 1.18 times the one of mortar. Supplementary Information: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1617/s11527-022-01927-7.