Quantitative or qualitative carbon dioxide monitoring for manual ventilation: a mannequin study.

AIM: To compare the effectiveness of an in-line EtCO2 detector (DET) and a quantitative EtCO2 detector (CAP), both attached to a t-piece resuscitator, during PPV via a face mask. METHODS: Paediatric trainees were randomly assigned to determine the method of PPV they commenced with (No device (ND), DET or CAP). Participants used each method for 2 min. Participants were video-recorded to determine the amount of effective ventilations delivered with each method. RESULTS: Twenty-three paediatric trainees provided a total of 6035 ventilations, and 91.2% were deemed effective. The percentages of median effective ventilations with the ND, the DET and the CAP were 91.0%, 93.0% and 94.0%, respectively. Fourteen (61%) of the trainees indicated a preference for the DET method, 8 (35%) for the CAP method, and 1 (4%) of the trainees indicated a preference for the ND method. Capnography was the most effective method per patient. CONCLUSION: There was no adverse effect with the addition of EtCO2 detectors. Trainees favoured methods of EtCO2 monitoring during ventilation. The NeoStat device was the preferred device by the majority. The greatest efficacy was achieved with the capnography device. Capnography may enhance face mask ventilation.

A review of carbon dioxide monitoring in preterm newborns in the delivery room.

INTRODUCTION: The physiologic adaptation to extra uterine life during the immediate neonatal period is unique. Many newborns require assistance in this adaptive process. Recent evidence now supports titrating oxygen to guide resuscitation but no guidance is provided on utilizing exhaled CO2 measurements. AIM: To review the current evidence relating to the use of CO2 monitoring in preterm newborns in the delivery room. METHODS: Search was performed using the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, MEDLINE (1966-2014) and PREMEDLINE, EMBASE (1980-2014), CINAHL (1982-2014), Web of Science (1975-2014) and the Oxford Database of Perinatal Trials. RESULTS: The search revealed 21 articles relating to CO2 detection, either quantitative or qualitative, in the newborn infant. The majority of these were observational studies, eight relating to CO2 detection as a means of confirming correct endotracheal tube placement in the newborn infant. The other indication is for mask ventilation, and there is one randomized control trial and four observational studies of CO2 detection during mask ventilation. The overall recommendation for CO2 detection for both clinical uses in the delivery suite is level B. DISCUSSION: CO2 detection may be of particular benefit for preterm infants in the delivery suite. However there is a need for further research into CO2 detection, in particular capnography, as a means of confirming effective PPV in neonatal resuscitation.

Effect of cardiac output changes on exhaled carbon dioxide in newborn piglets.

INTRODUCTION: International neonatal resuscitation guidelines recommend that correct tube placement should be confirmed by clinical assessment and exhaled CO2 detection. Absence of exhaled CO2 after intubation suggests oesophageal intubation, non-aerated lungs, low tidal volume delivery, or low cardiac output. The relationship between changes in cardiac output and exhaled CO2 in neonates is unknown. The aim of the study was to determine if changes in cardiac output affect exhaled carbon dioxide in a porcine model of neonatal resuscitation. METHOD: Term piglets (n=5) aged 3-4 days were anesthetised, intubated, instrumented and exposed to normocapnic hypoxia. Exhaled CO2 was continuously measured using a flow sensor (Respironics NM3(®)). Pulmonary artery blood flow, a surrogate for cardiac output was measured using an ultrasonic flow probe (Transonic(®)). A semi-quantitative CO2-detector (Pedi-Cap(®)) was placed between the tracheal tube and flow sensor to assess colour change at changing levels of cardiac output. RESULTS: Median (IQR) pulmonary artery blood flow significantly decreased from 177 (147-177)mL/kg/min at baseline to 4 (3-26)mL/kg/min during hypoxia (p=0.02). Exhaled CO2 remained similar throughout the experiment, 47 (41-47)mmHg at baseline vs. 40 (38-41)mmHg at the end of the hypoxia (p=1.00). Additionally, at each time point, colour change at the Pedi-Cap(®) was observed. CONCLUSION: A significant decrease in cardiac output was not associated with changes in exhaled CO2 or failure to achieve a Pedi-Cap(®) colour change.