Mechanisms of Tolerance Induction in Liver Transplantation: Lessons Learned from Fetomaternal Tolerance, Autoimmunity and Tumor Immunity.

Since the first published report of experimental kidney transplantation in dogs in 1902, there were many experimental and clinical trials of organ transplantation, with many sacrifices. After the establishment of the surgical technique and the discovery of immunosuppressive drugs, transplantation became the definitive treatment strategy for patients with terminal organ failure. However, this is not a common therapy method due to the difficulty of solving the fundamental issues behind organ transplantation, including the shortage of donor graft, potential risks of transplant surgery and economic capability. The pre- and post-transplant management of recipients is another critical issue that may affect transplant outcome. Most liver transplant recipients experience post-transplant complications, including infection, acute/chronic rejection, metabolic syndrome and the recurrence of hepatocellular carcinoma. Therefore, the early prediction and diagnosis of these complications may improve overall and disease-free survival. Furthermore, how to induce operational tolerance is the key to achieving the ultimate goal of transplantation. In this review, we focus on liver transplantation, which is known to achieve operational tolerance in some circumstances, and the mechanical similarities and differences between liver transplant immunology and fetomaternal tolerance, autoimmunity or tumor immunity are discussed.

Decreased serum soluble programmed cell death ligand-1 level as a potential biomarker for missed miscarriage.

STUDY QUESTION: Can maternal serum levels of soluble programmed cell death-1 (sPD-1) and its ligand (sPD-L1) serve as biomarkers for missed miscarriage (MM)? SUMMARY ANSWER: Serum sPD-L1 levels are significantly decreased in MM patients and may serve as a potential predictive biomarker for miscarriage. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Programmed cell death-1 (PD-1) and its ligand (PD-L1) comprise important immune inhibitory checkpoint signaling to maintain pregnancy. Their soluble forms are detectable in human circulation and are associated with immunosuppression. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: Three independent cohorts attending tertiary referral hospitals were studied. The first (discovery) cohort was cross-sectional and included MM patients and healthy pregnant (HP) women matched on BMI. The second validation cohort contained MM patients and women with legally induced abortion (IA). The third prospective observational study recruited subjects requiring IVF treatment. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: In the discovery cohort, we enrolled 108 MM patients and 115 HP women who had a full-term pregnancy at 6-14 weeks of gestation. In the validation cohort, we recruited 25 MM patients and 25 women with IA. Blood samples were collected at the first prenatal visit for HP women or on the day of dilatation and curettage surgery (D&C) for MM and IA subjects to determine serum sPD-1 and sPD-L1 levels. Placenta samples were harvested during the D&C within the validation cohort to measure gene and protein expression. The prospective cohort collected serial blood samples weekly from 75 volunteers with embryo transfer (ET) after IVF. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Circulating sPD-L1 levels were reduced by 50% in patients with MM (55.7 ± 16.04 pg/ml) compared to HP controls (106.7 ± 58.46 pg/ml, P < 0.001) and the difference remained significant after adjusting for maternal age and gestational age, whereas no significant differences in sPD-1 level were observed. Likewise, serum sPD-L1 was lower in MM patients than in IA subjects and accompanied by downregulated PD-L1-related gene expression levels in the placenta. In the IVF cohort, applying the changing rate of sPD-L1 level after ET achieved a predictive performance for miscarriage with receiver operating characteristics = 0.73 (95% CI: 0.57-0.88, P < 0.01). LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: The study was mainly confined to East Asian pregnant women. Further large prospective pregnancy cohorts are required to validate the predictive performance of sPD-L1 on miscarriage. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: Reduced circulating sPD-L1 level and downregulated placental PD-L1 expression in miscarriage indicate that dysfunction in PD-L1 signals is a potential underlying mechanism for pregnancy loss. Our findings further extend the importance of the PD-L1 axis in pregnancy maintenance in early pregnancy. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): This study was financially supported by grants from the Subject Innovation Team of Shaanxi University of Chinese Medicine (2019-Y502), General Research Fund (14122021), and Key Laboratory of Model Animal Phenotyping and Basic Research in Metabolic Diseases (2018KSYS003). The authors declare that they have no competing interests to be disclosed. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.

Fetomaternal Immune Tolerance: Crucial Mechanisms of Tolerance for Successful Pregnancy in Humans.

For many years, the question of how the maternal immune system tolerates the foreign fetus has remained unanswered, and numerous studies have considerably attempted to elucidate underlying mechanisms for fetomaternal tolerance. This review aimed at discussing various significant mechanisms in fetomaternal compatibility. At the fetomaternal interface, in addition to having efficient control against infections, innate and adaptive maternal immune systems selectively prevent fetal rejection. In general, understanding the complex mechanisms of fetomaternal tolerance is critical for immunologic tolerance induction and spontaneous abortion prevention in high-risk populations. Different cells and molecules, such as regulatory T-cells, dendritic cells, decidua cells, IDO, Class I HLA molecules, TGF-ß, and IL-10, induce maternal immune tolerance in the fetus in numerous ways. The findings on fetomaternal immune tolerance have remained controversial and require further research.

Seminal CD38 is a pivotal regulator for fetomaternal tolerance.

A successful pregnancy depends on a complex process that establishes fetomaternal tolerance. Seminal plasma is known to induce maternal immune tolerance to paternal alloantigens, but the seminal factors that regulate maternal immunity have yet to be characterized. Here, we show that a soluble form of CD38 (sCD38) released from seminal vesicles to the seminal plasma plays a crucial role in inducing tolerogenic dendritic cells and CD4(+) forkhead box P3(+) (Foxp3(+)) regulatory T cells (Tregs), thereby enhancing maternal immune tolerance and protecting the semiallogeneic fetus from resorption. The abortion rate in BALB/c females mated with C57BL/6 Cd38(-/-) males was high compared with that in females mated with Cd38(+/+) males, and this was associated with a reduced proportion of Tregs within the CD4(+) T-cell pool. Direct intravaginal injection of sCD38 to CBA/J pregnant mice at preimplantation increased Tregs and pregnancy rates in mice under abortive sonic stress from 48 h after mating until euthanasia. Thus, sCD38 released from seminal vesicles to the seminal plasma acts as an immunoregulatory factor to protect semiallogeneic fetuses from maternal immune responses.

Sphingolipid pathway regulates innate immune responses at the fetomaternal interface during pregnancy.

For a successful pregnancy, the mother's immune system has to tolerate the semiallogeneic fetus. A deleterious immune attack is avoided by orchestration of cellular, hormonal, and enzymatic factors. However, the precise mechanisms underlying fetomaternal tolerance are not yet completely understood. In this study, we demonstrate that sphingolipid metabolism constitutes a novel signaling pathway that is indispensable for fetomaternal tolerance by regulating innate immune responses at the fetomaternal interface. Perturbation of the sphingolipid pathway by disruption of the sphingosine kinase gene (Sphk) during pregnancy caused unusually high expression of neutrophil chemoattractants, CXCL1 and CXCL2, in the decidua, leading to a massive infiltration of neutrophils into the fetomaternal interface with enhanced oxidative damage, resulting in early fetal death. Sphk-deficient mice also exhibited neutrophilia in the peripheral blood, enhanced generation of granulocytes in the bone marrow, and a decrease in the number of decidual natural killer cells. The blockage of neutrophil influx protected Sphk-deficient mice against pregnancy loss. Notably, a similar result was obtained in human decidual cells, in which Sphk deficiency dramatically increased the secretion of CXCL1 and IL-8. In conclusion, our findings suggest that the sphingolipid metabolic pathway plays a critical role in fetomaternal tolerance by regulating innate immunity at the fetomaternal interface both in mice and humans, and it could provide novel insight into the development of therapeutic strategies to treat idiopathic pregnancy loss in humans.

TIGIT-Fc as a Potential Therapeutic Agent for Fetomaternal Tolerance.

The perfect synchronization of maternal immune-endocrine mechanisms and those of the fetus is necessary for a successful pregnancy. In this report, decidual immune cells at the maternal-fetal interface were detected that expressed TIGIT (T cell immunoreceptor with Ig and ITIM domains), which is a co-inhibitory receptor that triggers immunological tolerance. We generated recombinant TIGIT-Fc fusion proteins by linking the extracellular domain of TIGIT and silent Fc fragments. The treatment with TIGIT-Fc of human decidual antigen presenting cells (APCs), the decidual dendritic cells (dDCs), and decidual macrophages (dMϕs) increased the production of interleukin 10 and induced the decidua APCs to powerfully polarize the decidual CD4+ T cells toward a classic TH2 phenotype. We further proposed that Notch signaling shows a pivotal effect on the transcriptional regulation in decidual immune cell subsets. Moreover, the administration of TIGIT-Fc to CBA/J pregnant mice at preimplantation induced CD4+ forkhead box P3+ (Foxp3+) regulatory T cells and tolerogenic dendritic cells and increased pregnancy rates in an abortion-prone animal model stress. The results suggested the therapeutic potential of the TIGIT-Fc fusion protein in reinstating immune tolerance in failing pregnancies.

Medawar's Paradox and Immune Mechanisms of Fetomaternal Tolerance.

Brazilian-born British biologist Dr. Peter Medawar played an integral role in developing the concepts of immunologic rejection and tolerance, which led to him receiving the Nobel Prize "for the discovery of acquired immunologic tolerance" and eventually made organ transplantation a reality. However, at the time of his early work in tolerance, a paradox to his theories was brought to his attention; how was pregnancy possible? Pregnancy resembles organ transplantation in that the fetus, possessing paternal antigens, is a semi-allogeneic graft that can survive without immunosuppression for 9 months. To answer this question, Medawar proposed three hypotheses of how a mother supports her fetus in utero, now known as "Medawar's Paradox." The mechanisms that govern fetomaternal tolerance are still incompletely understood but may provide critical insight into how to achieve immune tolerance in organ transplantation. Here, we review current understanding of the immune factors responsible for fetomaternal tolerance during pregnancy and discuss the potential implications for advances in transplantation science.

Biomarkers in Fetomaternal Tolerance.

Multiple mechanisms of tolerance operate in the immune cross-talk at the fetomaternal interface, contributing to successful pregnancy outcome. The cross-talk includes interaction between various cell subsets and between cytokines and molecules of the endocrine system. A depiction of how all these components interact with each other and contribute to tolerance of the fetus is not clearly understood. Dysregulation in one or more of these mechanisms leads to fetal loss. Few effective biomarkers are available that can safely predict fetal loss. This review discusses some potential biomarkers that can predict failure of tolerance at the fetomaternal interface.

The Pleiotropic Effect of Glycodelin-A in Early Pregnancy.

Successful pregnancy depends largely on adequate placentation and maternal tolerance of the fetus. Glycodelin-A is a glycoprotein abundant in the decidua during early pregnancy. It plays an important role in placental development and fetomaternal defense. Glycodelin-A interacts by its unique carbohydrate side chains with the cell surface of various cell types in the human fetomaternal interface, particularly the trophoblasts and the immune cells, and modulates their functions and differentiation to permit successful pregnancy. Abnormal levels of glycodelin-A in the endometrium, uterine flushings, and/or maternal serum correlate with unexplained infertility, early pregnancy loss, and recurrent miscarriage. This review integrates recent studies on the role of glycodelin-A in placental development and fetomaternal tolerance in early pregnancy.

Transfusion-associated graft versus host disease (TAGVHD)--with reference to neonatal period.

Transfusion-associated graft versus host disease [TAGVHD] results from the engraftment of transfused immuno-competent cells in blood transfusion recipients, whose immune system is unable to reject them. All blood products containing viable, immuno-competent T cells have been implicated in TAGVHD. Presence of a "one-way HLA match between donor and recipient" is associated with a significantly increased risk of TAGVHD. Though sharing of haplotype is the most probable explanation, it is far from adequate. Since TAGVHD is not seen in patients with AIDS, and an acute GVHD-like syndrome has been noted in some identical twins and autologous (self) transplants, some other processes, possibly of an "autoimmune" nature are responsible for TAGVHD. Most of the cases have been reported from Japan. This clustering in space and time is rather intriguing. We offer here alternative hypothesis. Foetal and then neonatal lymphocytes exhibit tolerance towards donor cytotoxic T lymphocytes; and consequently very few cases of TAGVHD have been reported in neonates than expected. This tolerance is a part of altered immunology of pregnancy. We feel that it is possible to use maternal blood for transfusion to her newborn baby by following certain protocol and procedure and TAGVHD is no barrier.

A feasibility study on the prediction of acute graft-vs.-host disease before hematopoietic stem cell transplantation based on fetomaternal tolerance.

The contact between the immune systems of mother and child during pregnancy affects an immune response of the child against noninherited maternal antigens (NIMA) and the mother against inherited paternal antigens (IPA). However, the immunologic effects of developmental exposure to NIMA or IPA are heterogeneous, and can be either tolerogenic or immunogenic. Although we have reported that prediction of acute graft-vs.-host disease (GVHD) is feasible in a murine model, there has been no literature in human. We devised a novel method for predicting a tolerogenic effect by using mixed lymphocyte reaction combined with enzyme-linked immunospot (MLR-ELISPOT) assay. The assay can evaluate reactivity of interferon-γ spot-forming cells of donor against the recipient. Although we have shown only two examples of mother to child reactivity so far, our preliminary results suggest that this pre-screened assay may be used to predict acute GVHD. The clinical trial is in progress to evaluate MLR-ELISPOT assay as a predicting measure of acute GVHD in haploidentical transplantation from NIMA or IPA-mismatched family donor.