A clinicopathological study of low back pain due to middle cluneal nerve entrapment: case series.

PURPOSE: The middle cluneal nerve (MCN) is a pure sensory nerve around the middle buttock. Its entrapment between the iliac crest and the long posterior sacroiliac ligament elicits low back pain (LBP) that can be treated by MCN neurolysis or neurectomy. Because few studies examined the pathology of MCN entrapment (MCN-E) we subjected 7 neurectomized specimens from 6 LBP patients to pathologic study. METHODS: We present 6 consecutive patients (7 sides) with intractable LBP who underwent successful MCN neurectomy. Their symptom duration ranged from 6 to 96 months (average 47.3 months); the follow-up period ranged from 6 to 17 months (average 11.7 months). The surgical outcomes were evaluated using the numerical rating scale (NRS) for LBP and the Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire (RDQ) score. The resected MCNs underwent neuropathological analysis. RESULTS: Postoperatively, all 6 patients reported immediate LBP amelioration; their NRS and RDQ scores were improved significantly. Pathological study of the 7 resected nerves showed that the myelinated fiber density was decreased in 6 nerves; we observed marked enlargement (n = 5), perineurial thickening and disruption (n = 6), intrafascicular fibrous changes (n = 5), myelinated fibers separated by fibrous cells under the perineurium (n = 4), and Renaut bodies (n = 3). The 7th nerve appeared normal with respect to the density and size of the myelinated fibers, however, the perineurium was slightly thickened. CONCLUSION: We present pathological evidence at the MCN compression site of 7 nerves from 6 patients whose LBP was alleviated by MCN neurectomy, indicating that MCN entrapment can elicit LBP.

Middle cluneal nerve entrapment sites in the surgical field.

INTRODUCTION: Middle cluneal nerve (MCN) entrapment around the sacroiliac joint elicits low back pain (LBP). For surgical decompression to be successful, the course of the MCN must be known. We retrospectively studied the MCN course in 15 patients who had undergone MCN neurolysis. METHODS: Enrolled in this retrospective study were 15 patients (18 sides). We inspected their surgical records and videos to determine the course of the entrapped MCN. The area between the posterior superior- and the posterior inferior iliac spine was divided into areas A-D from the rostral side. The MCN transit points were identified at the midline and the lateral edge connecting the posterior superior- and posterior inferior iliac spine. Before and 6 months after surgery, the patients recorded the degree of LBP on the numerical rating scale and the Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire. RESULTS: We decompressed 24 MCNs. The mean number was 1.3 nerves per patient (range 1-2). The MCN course was oblique in the cranio-caudal direction; the nerve tended to be observed in areas C and D. In six patients (40%), we detected two MCN branches, they were in the same area and adjacent. Postoperatively, LBP was improved significantly in all patients. CONCLUSION: Between the posterior superior- and the posterior inferior iliac spine, the MCN ran obliquely in the cranio-caudal direction; it was prominent in areas on the caudal side. In six (40%) patients, we decompressed two adjacent MCNs. Our findings are useful for MCN decompression surgery.

Long-term outcome after surgery for middle cluneal nerve entrapment neuropathy.

PURPOSE: Entrapment of the middle cluneal nerve (MCN-E) can elicit low back pain (LBP). Patients whose LBP responds only transiently to the analgesic effects of MCN blockage may be candidates for surgery. This study addresses its long-term efficacy. METHODS: We initially subjected 34 MCN-E patients (48 sides) to surgical release. Of these, 4 were excluded from this study because their follow-up was shorter than 24 months. The mean age of the 30 included patients was 71.5 years; the mean postoperative follow-up period was 40.4 months. Clinical outcomes were assessed on the Numerical Rating Scale (NRS) for LBP and the Roland Morris Disability Questionnaire (RDQ) before surgery and at the latest follow-up visit. RESULTS: The 30 patients (44 sides) reported severe LBP, leg symptoms were elicited by 32 sides. A mean of 1.4 MCN branches were surgically released, 32 sides were addressed by neurolysis, 7 by neurectomy, and 5 underwent both procedures due to the presence of 2 nerve branches. There were no complications. In the course of a mean follow-up of 26.3 months, MCN-E elicited recurrent symptoms on 6 sides; all had undergone neurolysis or neurectomy and a second operation improved the symptoms. All patients showed significant improvement at the last follow-up visit. Postoperatively both their NRS for LBP and their RDQ scores were improved (pre- vs. postoperative scores, p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: While surgical release of MCN-E is expected to yield long-term symptom relief, on 6 of 32 sides (18.8%) treated by neurolysis the patients reported pain recurrence. Whether neurectomy effectively prevents the recurrence of MCN-E in the long term requires further study.

Clinical features of middle cluneal nerve entrapment neuropathy.

BACKGROUND: Entrapment of the middle cluneal nerve (MCN), a peripheral nerve in the buttock, can elicit low back pain (LBP). We examined the epidemiology, clinical course, and treatment of MCN entrapment (MCN-EN). METHODS: Among 383 LBP patients who visited our institute, 105 were admitted for intractable LBP. They were 42 men and 63 women; their average age was 64 years. Based on clinical symptoms, palpation, and the effects of MCN block, we suspected MCN-EN in these 105 patients, 50 of whom are our study subjects. Their treatment outcomes were assessed at the time of discharge and at follow-up visits. RESULTS: MCN-EN was diagnosed in 50 of the 383 patients (13.1%) and they were hospitalized. In 43 (11.2%), MCN-EN was associated with other diseases (superior cluneal nerve entrapment, n = 21, sacroiliac joint pain, n = 9, other, n = 13). At the time of discharge, the symptoms of patients with LBP due to MCN-EN were significantly improved by repeat MCN blocks. In 7 of the 383 patients (1.8%), LBP was improved by only MCN blocks; 5 of them had reported leg symptoms in the dorsal part of the thigh. After discharge, 22 of the 50 hospitalized patients required no additional treatments after 2-5 blocks; 19 required only conservative treatment, and 9 underwent microsurgical release of the MCN. CONCLUSIONS: We confirmed MCN-EN in 50 of 105 patients admitted for intractable LBP. Repeat MCN blocks were effective in 22 patients; 19 required additional conservative treatment, and 9 underwent surgery. Buttock pain radiating to the posterior thigh was an MCN-EN symptom that has been diagnosed as pseudo-sciatica. Before subjecting patients with intractable LBP to surgery, the presence of MCN-EN must be ruled out.

High-frequency thermal coagulation to treat middle cluneal nerve entrapment neuropathy.

OBJECTIVE: Middle cluneal nerve entrapment (MCN-E) around the sacroiliac joint can elicit low back pain (LBP). Pain control can be obtained with anesthetic nerve blocks; however, when their effectiveness is transient, surgical release may be necessary. We investigated the efficacy of radiofrequency thermocoagulation (RFTC) in patients with MCN-E. METHODS: Between December 2018 and August 2019, 11 consecutive patients (4 men, 7 women; mean age 76.4 years) with intractable medial buttock pain due to MCN-E underwent MCN RFTC. The mean symptom duration was 49.5 months; pre-RFTC local MCN blocks provided pain relief for a mean of 7.7 days. The severity of pain in the medial buttock due to MCN-E was recorded before and 2, 6, 12, and 24 weeks after RFTC on the numerical rating scale (NRS) and the Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire (RDQ). RESULTS: All patients reported pain alleviation; there were no complications. While there was a significant difference in the pre- and post-RFTC treatment NRS (p < 0.05), the RDQ scores were significantly lower only after 12 weeks. The duration of pain relief was significantly prolonged by RFTC (p < 0.05). Two patients suffered pain relapse 10 weeks post-RFTC; pain alleviation was obtained by re-RFTC performed 2 weeks after pain recurrence. Two other patients relapsed 20 and 21 weeks post-RFTC; their symptoms also disappeared by MCN block administered 24 weeks after they had undergone RFTC. CONCLUSION: RFTC may safely control intractable LBP due to MCN-E.

Middle cluneal nerve entrapment mimics sacroiliac joint pain.

BACKGROUND: Sacroiliac joint (SIJ)-related pain is associated with low back- and buttock pain and the SIJ score is diagnostically useful because it helps to differentiate between SIJ-related pain and pain due to other factors such as lumbar disc herniation and lumbar spinal canal stenosis. Middle cluneal nerve (MCN) entrapment (MCN-E) can produce pain involving the lower back and buttocks. Therefore, the origin of the pain must be identified. We successfully treated patients with a high SIJ score whose pain was attributable to MCN-E. METHODS: Between August 2016 and June 2017, we treated 40 patients with non-specific low back pain. Among them, 18 (45%) presented with a positive SIJ score. Although SIJ treatment was unsuccessful in 4 of these patients, they responded to MCN-E treatment. RESULTS: All 4 patients reported tenderness at the site of the sacrotuberous ligament (STL); 3 were positive for the one-finger test and experienced pain while sitting in a chair. The effect of SIJ block was inadequate in the 4 patients. As they reported severe pain at the trigger point in the area of the MCN, we performed MCN blockage. It resulted in pain control. However, in 1 patient, the effect of MCN block was transient and required MCN neurolysis. At the last visit, our patients' symptoms were significantly improved; their average numerical rating scale score fell from 8.3 to 1.0, their Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire score fell from 12.8 to 0.3, and their average Japanese Orthopaedic Association score rose from 12.5 to 19.5. CONCLUSIONS: In patients with suspected SIJ-related pain, the presence of MCN-E must be considered when the effect of SIJ block is unsatisfactory.

Low back pain due to middle cluneal nerve entrapment neuropathy.

PURPOSE: The etiology of low back pain (LBP) is complicated and the diagnosis can be difficult. Superior cluneal nerve entrapment neuropathy (SCN-EN) is a known cause of LBP, although the middle cluneal nerve (MCN) can be implicated in the elicitation of LBP. METHODS: A 76-year-old woman with a 4-year history of severe LBP was admitted to our department in a wheelchair. She complained of bilateral LBP that was exacerbated by lumbar movement. Her pain was severe on the right side and she also suffered right leg pain and numbness. Based on palpation and nerve blocking findings we diagnosed SCN-EN and MCN entrapment neuropathy (MCN-EN). RESULTS: Her symptoms improved with repeated SCN and MCN blocking; the MCN block was the more effective and her symptoms improved. As her right-side pain around the MCN -EN with severe trigger pain recurred we performed microscopic right MCN neurolysis under local anesthesia. This led to dramatic improvement of her LBP and leg pain and the numbness improved. At the last follow-up, 7 months after surgery, she did not require pain medication. CONCLUSIONS: The MCN consists of sensory branches from the dorsal rami of S1-S4. It sandwiches the sacral ligament between the posterior superior and inferior iliac spine as it courses over the iliac crest. Its entrapment at this hard orifice can lead to severe LBP with leg symptoms. An MCN block effect is diagnostically useful. Less invasive MCN neurolysis under local anesthesia is effective in patients who fail to respond to observation therapy.

Paralumbar Spine Disease as a Cause of Low Back Pain in Older Adults.

Introduction Low back pain (LBP) is a major contributor to decreases in the ability to perform activities of daily living (ADL) in older adults. Paralumbar spine disease (PLSD) is a common cause of LBP. We aimed to investigate the causes of LBP, including PLSD, among older adults. Methods Among 744 consecutive patients with LBP, 75 patients (10.1%) aged >80 years (25 males and 50 females) were included. The average patient age was 83.9 years. All patients were evaluated using lumbar magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and radiography to diagnose the causes of LBP. PLSD was diagnosed based on clinical symptoms, palpation, and the effects of the block. Results Eleven patients (11/75, 14.7%) had acute osteoporotic vertebral fractures. Twenty-eight of the remaining 64 patients exhibited decreased LBP with oral medication, and six (6/75, 8.0%) exhibited lumbar spinal canal stenosis on MRI. PLSD was suspected in 19 of the remaining 30 cases based on clinical symptoms and palpation. Blocks were effective in 16 patients with PLSD, which involved superior cluneal nerve entrapment (SCN-E) in eight patients (10.7%), middle cluneal nerve entrapment (MCN-E) in nine patients (12.0%), sacroiliac joint (SIJ) pain in five patients (6.7%), and gluteus medius muscle (GMeM) pain in three patients (4.0%). The average numerical rating scale (NRS) scores for pain changed from 7.5 ± 1.5 before treatment to 1.3 ± 0.9 at discharge (p < 0.05). Conclusion Osteoporotic acute vertebral fracture (14.7%) was identified as the cause of LBP in older adults. Block therapy for PLSD may aid in the diagnosis and treatment of non-specific LBP.

Middle cluneal nerve entrapment neuropathy attributable to lumbar disc herniation.

BACKGROUND: Middle cluneal nerve entrapment neuropathy (MCN-EN) is a known cause of low back pain (LBP). Here, we succeeded in treating a patient with a lumbar disc herniation who actually had MCN-EN with a nerve block and neurolysis. CASE DESCRIPTION: A 52-year-old female presented with severe left lower back and lateral thigh pain making it difficult to walk. The lumbar MRI revealed a disc herniation on the left at the L5/S1 level. On palpation, we identified a trigger point on the buttock where the MCN penetrates the long posterior sacroiliac ligament between the posterior superior and inferior iliac spine. Two left-sided MCN blocks, followed by the left MCN neurolysis procedure, were performed under local anesthesia. At the last follow-up, 10 months after surgery, the LBP has not recurred, and she requires no medications for pain control. CONCLUSION: Here, a patient with a left-sided L5S1 disc herniation and low back/leg pain was successfully treated for MCN-EN with nerve block followed by neurolysis.

Treatment of Coexisting Paralumbar Spine Diseases in Patients with Lumbar Disc Herniation.

Lumbar disc herniation (LDH) elicits low back pain (LBP) and lower-limb symptoms. Paralumbar spine disease (PLSD), for example, superior cluneal nerve/middle cluneal nerve entrapment (SCN-EN, MCN-EN) and sacroiliac joint pain (SIJ), may be attributable to LDH whose treatment may not ameliorate their symptoms. We treated LDH patients and addressed their coexisting PLSDs. We retrospectively analyzed the effects of targeted block therapy for PLSD in 47 patients with LDH. They were 23 men and 24 women ranging in age from 21 to 79 years. They were seen between August 2014 and October 2018, within 3 weeks of LDH onset. PLSD was diagnosed based on the symptoms of patients whose pain was not controlled by oral medications. The treatment outcome was assessed by comparing the numerical rating scale (NRS) and the Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire (RDQ) score recorded before and 2 weeks after last block treatment. Of the 47 patients with LDH, 2 suffered no LBP and 30 reported tenderness in the low back. We performed block therapy in 13 patients; 9 (19.1%) had concurrent PLSD and experienced pain relief. Their NRS improved from 8.1 ± 1.8 before- to 1.3 ± 0.9 after treatment; their RDQ score fell from 11.2 ± 6.0 to 0.9 ± 1.2 (both, p < 0.01). In an LDH patient with MCN-EN alone, MCN neurolysis was performed 2 weeks after a single MCN block proved to be only transiently effective. Paralumbar diseases may coexist in patients with LDH; treatment of the former may alleviate their LBP.

Revisiting the Middle Cluneal Nerves: An Anatomic Study with Application to Pain Syndromes and Invasive Procedures Around the Sacrum.

OBJECTIVE: The middle cluneal nerves (MCNs) are stated to arise from the sacral dorsal rami of S1 to S3 and supply the gluteal skin, but their detailed anatomy is unclear and often variably depicted and described. Therefore, the goal of this study was to revisit the anatomy of the MCNs and provide a clearer picture of their morphology. METHODS: Five fresh-frozen Caucasian cadavers (10 sides) (2 men and 3 women) were dissected for this study. The sacral dorsal rami from each posterior sacral foramen were identified and traced laterally to identify the MCNs. The contribution, pathway, and distribution of the MCNs were investigated. RESULTS: Each sacral dorsal ramus joined to form the posterior sacrococcygeal plexus. A total of 25 MCNs were identified. The MCNs were formed by the sacral dorsal rami of S1-2 in 48% (12/25), S1-3 in 4% (1/25), S1-4 in 20% (5/25), S2-3 in 8% (2/25), and S2-4 in 20% (5/25). The MCNs pierced the gluteus maximus by 2 different pathways and supplied the gluteal skin or the gluteus maximus muscle. CONCLUSIONS: We clarified the anatomy and variations of the MCNs and revisited its current nomenclature. Such knowledge might improve diagnoses and invasive procedure outcomes in patients with pathology in the region of the MCNs.

Superior and Middle Cluneal Nerve Entrapment as a Cause of Low Back Pain.

Low back pain (LBP) is encountered frequently in clinical practice. The superior and the middle cluneal nerves (SCN and MCN) are cutaneous nerves that are purely sensory. They dominate sensation in the lumbar area and the buttocks, and their entrapment around the iliac crest can elicit LBP. The reported incidence of SCN entrapment (SCN-E) in patients with LBP is 1.6%-14%. SCN-E and MCN entrapment (MCN-E) produce leg symptoms in 47%-84% and 82% of LBP patients, respectively. In such patients, pain is exacerbated by lumbar movements, and the symptoms mimic radiculopathy due to lumbar disorder. As patients with failed back surgery or Parkinson disease also report LBP, the differential diagnosis must include those possibilities. The identification of the trigger point at the entrapment site and the disappearance of symptoms after nerve block are diagnostically important. LBP due to SCN-E or MCN-E can be treated less invasively by nerve block and neurolysis. Spinal surgeons treating patients with LBP should consider SCN-E or MCN-E.

Surgical treatment of middle cluneal nerve entrapment neuropathy: technical note.

OBJECTIVE The etiology of low-back pain (LBP) is heterogeneous and is unknown in some patients with chronic pain. Superior cluneal nerve entrapment has been proposed as a causative factor, and some patients suffer severe symptoms. The middle cluneal nerve (MCN) is also implicated in the elicitation of LBP, and its clinical course and etiology remain unclear. The authors report the preliminary outcomes of a less invasive microsurgical release procedure to address MCN entrapment (MCN-E). METHODS The authors enrolled 11 patients (13 sites) with intractable LBP judged to be due to MCN-E. The group included 3 men and 8 women ranging in age from 52 to 86 years. Microscopic MCN neurolysis was performed under local anesthesia with the patient in the prone position. Postoperatively, all patients were allowed to walk freely with no restrictions. The mean follow-up period was 10.5 months. LBP severity was evaluated on the numerical rating scale (NRS) and by the Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) and the Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire (RDQ) scores. RESULTS All patients suffered buttock pain, and 9 also had leg symptoms. The symptoms were aggravated by standing, lumbar flexion, rolling over, prolonged sitting, and especially by walking. The numbers of nerve branches addressed during MCN neurolysis were 1 in 9 patients, 2 in 1 patient, and 3 in 1 patient. One patient required reoperation due to insufficient decompression originally. There were no local or systemic complications during or after surgery. Postoperatively, the symptoms of all patients improved statistically significantly; the mean NRS score fell from 7.0 to 1.4, the mean RDQ from 10.8 to 1.4, and the mean JOA score rose from 13.7 to 23.6. CONCLUSIONS Less invasive MCN neurolysis performed under local anesthesia is useful for LBP caused by MCN-E. In patients with intractable LBP, MCN-E should be considered.

Anatomical study of middle cluneal nerve entrapment.

OBJECT: Entrapment of the middle cluneal nerve (MCN) under the long posterior sacroiliac ligament (LPSL) is a possible, and underdiagnosed, cause of low-back and/or leg symptoms. To date, detailed anatomical studies of MCN entrapment are few. The purpose of this study was to ascertain, using cadavers, the relationship between the MCN and LPSL and to investigate MCN entrapment. METHODS: A total of 30 hemipelves from 20 cadaveric donors (15 female, 5 male) designated for education or research, were studied by gross anatomical dissection. The age range of the donors at death was 71-101 years with a mean of 88 years. Branches of the MCN were identified under or over the gluteus maximus fascia caudal to the posterior superior iliac spine (PSIS) and traced laterally as far as their finest ramification. Special attention was paid to the relationship between the MCN and LPSL. The distance from the branch of the MCN to the PSIS and to the midline and the diameter of the MCN were measured. RESULTS: A total of 64 MCN branches were identified in the 30 hemipelves. Of 64 branches, 10 (16%) penetrated the LPSL. The average cephalocaudal distance from the PSIS to where the MCN penetrated the LPSL was 28.5±11.2 mm (9.1-53.7 mm). The distance from the midline was 36.0±6.4 mm (23.5-45.2 mm). The diameter of the MCN branch traversing the LPSL averaged 1.6±0.5 mm (0.5-3.1 mm). Four of the 10 branches penetrating the LPSL had obvious constriction under the ligament. CONCLUSION: This is the first anatomical study illustrating MCN entrapment. It is likely that MCN entrapment is not a rare clinical entity.

Entrapment of middle cluneal nerves as an unknown cause of low back pain.

Entrapment of middle cluneal nerves induces low back pain and leg symptoms. The middle cluneal nerves can become spontaneously entrapped where this nerve pass under the long posterior sacroiliac ligament. A case of severe low back pain, which was completely treated by release of the middle cluneal nerve, was presented. Entrapment of middle cluneal nerves is possibly underdiagnosed cause of low-back and/or leg symptoms. Spinal surgeons should be aware of this clinical entity and avoid unnecessary spinal surgeries and sacroiliac fusion. This paper is to draw attention by pain clinicians in this unrecognized etiology.