Accelerating the Field of Epigenetic Histone Modification Through Mass Spectrometry-Based Approaches.

Histone post-translational modifications (PTMs) are one of the main mechanisms of epigenetic regulation. Dysregulation of histone PTMs leads to many human diseases, such as cancer. Because of its high throughput, accuracy, and flexibility, mass spectrometry (MS) has emerged as a powerful tool in the epigenetic histone modification field, allowing the comprehensive and unbiased analysis of histone PTMs and chromatin-associated factors. Coupled with various techniques from molecular biology, biochemistry, chemical biology, and biophysics, MS has been used to characterize distinct aspects of histone PTMs in the epigenetic regulation of chromatin functions. In this review, we will describe advancements in the field of MS that have facilitated the analysis of histone PTMs and chromatin biology.

A Multiple Protease Strategy to Optimise the Shotgun Proteomics of Mature Medicinal Cannabis Buds.

Earlier this year we published a method article aimed at optimising protein extraction from mature buds of medicinal cannabis for trypsin-based shotgun proteomics (Vincent, D., et al. Molecules 2019, 24, 659). We then developed a top-down proteomics (TDP) method (Vincent, D., et al. Proteomes 2019, 7, 33). This follow-up study aims at optimising the digestion of medicinal cannabis proteins for identification purposes by bottom-up and middle-down proteomics (BUP and MDP). Four proteases, namely a mixture of trypsin/LysC, GluC, and chymotrypsin, which target different amino acids (AAs) and therefore are orthogonal and cleave proteins more or less frequently, were tested both on their own as well as sequentially or pooled, followed by nLC-MS/MS analyses of the peptide digests. Bovine serum albumin (BSA, 66 kDa) was used as a control of digestion efficiency. With this multiple protease strategy, BSA was reproducibly 97% sequenced, with peptides ranging from 0.7 to 6.4 kD containing 5 to 54 AA residues with 0 to 6 miscleavages. The proteome of mature apical buds from medicinal cannabis was explored more in depth with the identification of 27,123 peptides matching 494 unique accessions corresponding to 229 unique proteins from Cannabis sativa and close relatives, including 130 (57%) additional annotations when the list is compared to that of our previous BUP study (Vincent, D., et al. Molecules 2019, 24, 659). Almost half of the medicinal cannabis proteins were identified with 100% sequence coverage, with peptides composed of 7 to 91 AA residues with up to 9 miscleavages and ranging from 0.6 to 10 kDa, thus falling into the MDP domain. Many post-translational modifications (PTMs) were identified, such as oxidation, phosphorylations, and N-terminus acetylations. This method will pave the way for deeper proteome exploration of the reproductive organs of medicinal cannabis, and therefore for molecular phenotyping within breeding programs.

Complementary middle-down and intact monoclonal antibody proteoform characterization by capillary zone electrophoresis - mass spectrometry.

High-resolution capillary zone electrophoresis - mass spectrometry (CZE-MS) has been of increasing interest for the analysis of biopharmaceuticals. In this work, a combination of middle-down and intact CZE-MS analyses has been implemented for the characterization of a biotherapeutic monoclonal antibody (mAb) with a variety of post-translational modifications (PTMs) and glycosylation structures. Middle-down and intact CZE separations were performed in an acidified methanol-water background electrolyte on a capillary with a positively charged coating (M7C4I) coupled to an Orbitrap mass spectrometer using a commercial sheathless interface (CESI). Middle-down analysis of the IdeS-digested mAb provided characterization of PTMs of digestion fragments. High resolution CZE enabled separation of charge variants corresponding to 2X-deamidated, 1X-deamidated, and non-deamidated forms at baseline resolution. In the course of the middle-down CZE-MS analysis, separation of glycoforms of the FC /2 fragment was accomplished due to hydrodynamic volume differences. Several identified PTMs were confirmed by CZE-MS2 . Incorporation of TCEP-HCl reducing agent in the sample solvent resulted in successful analysis of reduced forms without the need for alkylation. CZE-MS studies on the intact mAb under denaturing conditions enabled baseline separation of the 2X-glycosylated, 1X-glycosylated, and aglycosylated populations as a result of hydrodynamic volume differences. The presence of a trace quantity of dissociated light chain was also detected in the intact protein analysis. Characterization of the mAb under native conditions verified identifications achieved via intact analysis and allowed for quantitative confirmation of proteoforms. Analysis of mAbs using CZE-MS represents a complementary approach to the more conventional liquid-chromatography - mass spectrometry-based approaches.

Dynamic changes of histone H3 marks during Caenorhabditis elegans lifecycle revealed by middle-down proteomics.

We applied a middle-down proteomics strategy for large-scale protein analysis during in vivo development of Caenorhabditis elegans. We characterized PTMs on histone H3 N-terminal tails at eight time points during the C. elegans lifecycle, including embryo, larval stages (L1-L4), dauer, and L1/L4 postdauer. Histones were analyzed by our optimized middle-down protein sequencing platform using high mass accuracy MS/MS. This allows quantification of intact histone tails and detailed characterization of distinct histone tails carrying cooccurring PTMs. We measured temporally distinct combinatorial PTM profiles during C. elegans development. We show that the doubly modified form H3K23me3K27me3, which is rare or nonexistent in mammals, is the most abundant PTM in all stages of C. elegans lifecycle. The abundance of H3K23me3 increased during development and it was mutually exclusive of the active marks H3K18ac, R26me1, and R40me1, suggesting a role for H3K23me3 in silent chromatin. We observed distinct PTM profiles for normal L1 larvae and for L1-postdauer larvae, or L4 and L4 postdauer, suggesting that histone PTMs mediate an epigenetic memory that is transmitted during dauer formation. Collectively, our data describe the dynamics of histone H3 combinatorial code during C. elegans lifecycle and demonstrate the feasibility of using middle-down proteomics to study in vivo development of multicellular organisms. All MS data have been deposited in the ProteomeXchange with identifier PXD002525 (http://proteomecentral.proteomexchange.org/dataset/PXD002525).

The top-down, middle-down, and bottom-up mass spectrometry approaches for characterization of histone variants and their post-translational modifications.

Epigenetic regulation of gene expression is, at least in part, mediated by histone modifications. PTMs of histones change chromatin structure and regulate gene transcription, DNA damage repair, and DNA replication. Thus, studying histone variants and their modifications not only elucidates their functional mechanisms in chromatin regulation, but also provides insights into phenotypes and diseases. A challenge in this field is to determine the best approach(es) to identify histone variants and their PTMs using a robust high-throughput analysis. The large number of histone variants and the enormous diversity that can be generated through combinatorial modifications, also known as histone code, makes identification of histone PTMs a laborious task. MS has been proven to be a powerful tool in this regard. Here, we focus on bottom-up, middle-down, and top-down MS approaches, including CID and electron-capture dissociation/electron-transfer dissociation based techniques for characterization of histones and their PTMs. In addition, we discuss advances in chromatographic separation that take advantage of the chemical properties of the specific histone modifications. This review is also unique in its discussion of current bioinformatic strategies for comprehensive histone code analysis.

Middle-down hybrid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry workflow for characterization of combinatorial post-translational modifications in histones.

We present an integrated middle-down proteomics platform for sensitive mapping and quantification of coexisting PTMs in large polypeptides (5-7 kDa). We combined an RP trap column with subsequent weak cation exchange-hydrophilic interaction LC interfaced directly to high mass accuracy ESI MS/MS using electron transfer dissociation. This enabled automated and efficient separation and sequencing of hypermodified histone N-terminal tails for unambiguous localization of combinatorial PTMs. We present Histone Coder and IsoScale software to extract, filter, and analyze MS/MS data, including quantification of cofragmenting isobaric polypeptide species. We characterized histone tails derived from murine embryonic stem cells knockout in suppressor of zeste12 (Suz12(-/-) ) and quantified 256 combinatorial histone marks in histones H3, H4, and H2A. Furthermore, a total of 713 different combinatorial histone marks were identified in purified histone H3. We measured a seven-fold reduction of H3K27me2/me3 (where me2 and me3 are dimethylation and trimethylation, respectively) in Suz12(-) (/) (-) cells and detected significant changes of the relative abundance of 16 other single PTMs of histone H3 and other combinatorial marks. We conclude that the inactivation of Suz12 is associated with changes in the abundance of not only H3K27 methylation but also multiple other PTMs in histone H3 tails.

Database Creator for Mass Analysis of Peptides and Proteins, DC-MAPP: A Standalone Tool for Simplifying Manual Analysis of Mass Spectral Data to Identify Peptide/Protein Sequences.

Proteomic studies typically involve the use of different types of software for annotating experimental tandem mass spectrometric data (MS/MS) and thereby simplifying the process of peptide and protein identification. For such annotations, these softwares calculate the m/z values of the peptide/protein precursor and fragment ions, for which a database of protein sequences must be provided as an input file. The calculated m/z values are stored as another database, which the user usually cannot view. Database Creator for Mass Analysis of Peptides and Proteins (DC-MAPP) is a novel standalone software that can create custom databases for "viewing" the calculated m/z values of precursor and fragment ions, prior to the database search. It contains three modules. Peptide/Protein sequences as per user's choice can be entered as input to the first module for creating a custom database. In the second module, m/z values must be queried-in, which are searched within the custom database to identify protein/peptide sequences. The third module is suited for peptide mass fingerprinting, which can be used to analyze both ESI and MALDI mass spectral data. The feature of "viewing" the custom database can be helpful not only for better understanding the search engine processes, but also for designing multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) methods. Post-translational modifications and protein isoforms can also be analyzed. Since, DC-MAPP relies on the protein/peptide "sequences" for creating custom databases, it may not be applicable for the searches involving spectral libraries. Python language was used for implementation, and the graphical user interface was built with Page/Tcl, making this tool more user-friendly. It is freely available at https://vit.ac.in/DC-MAPP/.

The ubiquitin proteoform problem.

The diversity of ubiquitin modifications is immense. A protein can be monoubiquitylated, multi-monoubiquitylated, and polyubiquitylated with chains varying in size and shape. Ubiquitin itself can be adorned with other ubiquitin-like proteins and smaller functional groups. Considering different combinations of post-translational modifications can give rise to distinct biological outcomes, characterizing ubiquitylated proteoforms of a given protein is paramount. In this Opinion, we review recent advances in detecting and quantifying various ubiquitin proteoforms using mass spectrometry.

Mimicking LysC Proteolysis by 'Arginine Modification-cum-Trypsin Digestion': Comparison of Bottom-up & Middle-down Proteomic Approaches by ESI Q-TOF MS.

BACKGROUND: Middle-down (MD) proteomics is an emerging approach for reliable identification of post-translational modifications and isoforms, as this approach focuses on proteolytic peptides containing > 25-30 amino acid residues (a.a.r.), which are longer than typical tryptic peptides. Such longer peptides can be obtained by AspN, GluC, and LysC proteases. Additionally, some special proteases were developed specifically to effect MD approach, e.g., OmpT, Sap9, etc. However, these proteases are expensive. Herein we report a cost-effective strategy 'arginine modification- cum trypsin digestion', which can produce longer tryptic peptides resembling LysC peptides derived from proteins. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to obtain proteolytic peptides that resemble LysC peptides by using 'trypsin', which is a less expensive protease. METHODS: This strategy is based on the simple principle that trypsin cannot act at the C-termini of those arginines in proteins, whose sidechain guanidine groups are modified by 1,2-cyclohexanedione or phenylglyoxal. RESULTS: As a proof of concept, we demonstrate this strategy on four models: ß-casein (bovine), ß- lactoglobulin (bovine), ovalbumin (chick) and transferrin (human), by electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) involving hybrid quadrupole time-of-flight. From the ESI-MS of these models, we obtained several arginine modified tryptic peptides, whose lengths are in the range of 30-60 a.a.r. The collision induced dissociation MS/MS characteristics of some of the arginine modified longer tryptic peptides are compared with the unmodified standard tryptic peptides. CONCLUSION: The strategy demonstrated in this proof-of-concept study is not only useful to obtain longer tryptic peptides that mimic LysC proteolytic peptides, but also facilitates in enhancing the probability of missed cleavages by the trypsin. Hence, this method aids in evading the possibility of obtaining very short peptides that are <5-10 a.a.r. Therefore, this is indeed a cost-effective alternative/ substitute for LysC proteolysis and, in turn, for those MD proteomic studies that utilize LysC. Additionally, this methodology can be fruitful for mass spectrometry-based de novo protein and peptide sequencing.

The Power of Three in Cannabis Shotgun Proteomics: Proteases, Databases and Search Engines.

Cannabis research has taken off since the relaxation of legislation, yet proteomics is still lagging. In 2019, we published three proteomics methods aimed at optimizing protein extraction, protein digestion for bottom-up and middle-down proteomics, as well as the analysis of intact proteins for top-down proteomics. The database of Cannabis sativa proteins used in these studies was retrieved from UniProt, the reference repositories for proteins, which is incomplete and therefore underrepresents the genetic diversity of this non-model species. In this fourth study, we remedy this shortcoming by searching larger databases from various sources. We also compare two search engines, the oldest, SEQUEST, and the most popular, Mascot. This shotgun proteomics experiment also utilizes the power of parallel digestions with orthogonal proteases of increasing selectivity, namely chymotrypsin, trypsin/Lys-C and Asp-N. Our results show that the larger the database the greater the list of accessions identified but the longer the duration of the search. Using orthogonal proteases and different search algorithms increases the total number of proteins identified, most of them common despite differing proteases and algorithms, but many of them unique as well.

One-Pot Quantitative Top- and Middle-Down Analysis of GluC-Digested Histone H4.

Histone post-translational modifications (PTMs) have been intensively investigated due to their essential function in eukaryotic genome regulation. Histone modifications have been effectively studied using modified bottom-up proteomics approaches; however, the methods often do not capture single-molecule combinations of PTMs (proteoforms) that mediate known and expected biochemical mechanisms. Both middle-down mass spectrometry (MS) and top-down MS quantitation of H4 proteoforms present viable access to this important information. Histone H4 middle-down has previously avoided GluC digestion due to complex digestion products and interferences; however, the common AspN digestion cleaves at amino acid 23, disconnecting K31ac from other PTMs. Here, we demonstrate the effective use of GluC-based middle-down quantitation and compare it to top-down-based quantitation of proteoforms. Despite potential interferences in the m/z space, the proteoforms arising from all three GluC products (E52, E53, and E63) and intact H4 are chromatographically resolved and successfully analyzed in a single LC-MS analysis. Quantitative results and associated analytical metrics are compared between the different analytes of a single sample digested to different extents to reveal general concordance as well as the relative biases and complementarity of each approach. There is moderate proteoform discordance between digestion products (e.g., E52 and E53); however, each digestion product exhibits high concordance, regardless of digestion time. Under the conditions used, the GluC products are better chromatographically resolved yet show greater variance than the top-down quantitation that are more extensively sampled for MS2. GluC-based middle-down of H4 is thus viable. Both top-down and middle-down approaches have comparable quantitation capacity and are complementary.

Proteomics beyond trypsin.

Peptide-centered shotgun analysis of proteins has been the core technology in mass spectrometry based proteomics and has enabled numerous biological discoveries, such as the large-scale charting of protein-protein interaction networks, the quantitative analysis of protein post-translational modifications and even the first drafts of the human proteome. The conversion of proteins into peptides in these so-called bottom-up approaches is nearly uniquely done by using trypsin as a proteolytic reagent. Here, we argue that our view of the proteome still remains incomplete and this is partially due to the nearly exclusive use of trypsin. Newly emerging alternative proteases and/or multi-protease protein digestion aim to increase proteome sequence coverage and improve the identification of post-translational modifications, through the analysis of complementary and often longer peptides, introducing an approach termed middle-down proteomics. Of pivotal importance for this purpose is the identification of proteases beneficial for use in proteomics. Here, we describe some of the shortcomings of the nearly exclusive use of trypsin in proteomics and review the properties of other proteomics-appropriate proteases. We describe favorable protease traits with an emphasis on middle-down proteomics and suggest potential sources for the discovery of new proteases. We also highlight a few examples wherein the use of other proteases than trypsin enabled the generation of more comprehensive data sets leading to previously unexplored knowledge of the proteome.

Extended bottom-up proteomics with secreted aspartic protease Sap9.

We investigate the benefits and experimental feasibility of approaches enabling the shift from short (1.7 kDa on average) peptides in bottom-up proteomics to about twice longer (~3.2 kDa on average) peptides in the so-called extended bottom-up proteomics. Candida albicans secreted aspartic protease Sap9 has been selected for evaluation as an extended bottom-up proteomic-grade enzyme due to its suggested dibasic cleavage specificity and ease of production. We report the extensive characterization of Sap9 specificity and selectivity revealing that protein cleavage by Sap9 most often occurs in the vicinity of proximal basic amino acids, and in select cases also at basic and hydrophobic residues. Sap9 is found to cleave a large variety of proteins in a relatively short, ~1 h, period of time and it is efficient in a broad pH range, including slightly acidic, e. g., pH5.5, conditions. Importantly, the resulting peptide mixtures contain representative peptides primarily in the target 3-7 kDa range. The utility and advantages of this enzyme in routine analysis of protein mixtures are demonstrated and the limitations are discussed. Overall, Sap9 has a potential to become an enzyme of choice in an extended bottom-up proteomics, which is technically ready to complement the traditional bottom-up proteomics for improved targeted protein structural analysis and expanded proteome coverage. BIOLOGICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Advances in biological applications of mass spectrometry-based bottom-up proteomics are oftentimes limited by the extreme complexity of biological samples, e.g., proteomes or protein complexes. One of the reasons for it is in the complexity of the mixtures of enzymatically (most often using trypsin) produced short (<3 kDa) peptides, which may exceed the analytical capabilities of liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry. Information on localization of protein modifications may also be affected by the small size of typically produced peptides. On the other hand, advances in high-resolution mass spectrometry and liquid chromatography have created an intriguing opportunity of improving proteome analysis by gradually increasing the size of enzymatically-derived peptides in MS-based bottom-up proteomics. Bioinformatics has already confirmed the envisioned advantages of such approach. The remaining bottle-neck is an enzyme that could produce longer peptides. Here, we report on the characterization of a possible candidate enzyme, Sap9, which may be considered for producing longer, e.g., 3-7 kDa, peptides and lead to a development of extended bottom-up proteomics.