Effectiveness of continuous chelation irrigation protocol in endodontics: a scoping review of laboratory studies.

This scoping review aimed to synthesize and explore the current boundaries and limitations of laboratory research on the effectiveness of continuous chelation irrigation protocol in endodontics. This scoping review was reported according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) Extension for Scoping Reviews. Literature search was conducted on Pubmed and Scopus to identify all laboratory studies evaluating smear layer and hard-tissue debris removal or, antimicrobial efficacy, or dentine erosion induced by continuous chelation. Two independent reviewers performed the all review steps and the relevant items were recorded. Seventy-seven potentially relevant studies were identified. Finally, 23 laboratory studies met the eligibility criteria for qualitative synthesis. Seven studies focused on the smear layer/debris removal outcome, 10 on antimicrobial activity, and 10 on dentine erosion. In general, the continuous chelation protocol was equally or more effective in the cleanliness of root canals and antimicrobial activity compared with traditional sequential protocol. In addition, etidronate solutions seemed to be milder chelating agents compared to those with EDTA, thus resulting in reduced or no dentine erosion and roughness modification. Yet, the methodological differences among the included studies limit the results' generalizability. The continuous chelation seems to be equally or more effective in all investigated outcomes when compared with the traditional sequential protocol. The methodological variability among the studies and shortcomings in the methods employed limit the generalizability and clinical relevance of the results. Standardized laboratory conditions combined with reliable three-dimensional investigation approaches are necessary to obtain clinically informative findings.

Effects of continuous chelation on the instrumentation of curved canals with a martensitic NiTi file system: an ex vivo micro-CT evaluation.

This study aimed to evaluate the influence of continuous chelation on apical transportation and centrality in shaped curved canals prepared with a martensitic file system and evaluated by micro-CT. Twenty-four lower molar canals with a curvature of 25º-40º were scanned pre-operatively with micro-CT and divided into 2 groups according to two different irrigation regimens (n = 12). Group 1 was irrigated with NaOCl, group 2 with Dual Rinse. All canals were prepared with VDW.ROTATE system. The samples were scanned post-operatively and evaluated at 1, 3 and 5 mm from the apex to determine apical transportation and canal centrality using VG Studio software. Statistical analysis was performed with SPSS software using the non-parametric Mann-Whitney test. No statistically significant differences were found between the two groups for both apical transportation and canal centrality at any of the levels studied (p < 05). The use of continuous chelation during the instrumentation of the canals with martensitic alloy files does not produce greater transportation and does not generate changes in centralization compared to NaOCl-only irrigation. Combined chelation and disinfection while shaping with martensitic NiTi can simplify the irrigation regimen without inducing iatrogenic aberrations.

Effect of continuous chelation on the dentinal tubule penetration of a calcium silicate-based root canal sealer: a confocal laser microscopy study.

BACKGROUND: This study aimed to evaluate the effect of various irrigation protocols on the penetration depth of a calcium silicate-based sealer into dentinal tubules using confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM). METHODS: Twenty single-rooted mandibular premolars were endodontically prepared and divided into the following two groups according to the irrigation protocol used (n = 10): Group I: NaOCl + EDTA and Group II: continuous chelation (NaOCl/Dual Rinse). Obturation was performed with the warm vertical compaction technique using TotalFill HiFlow bioceramic sealer mixed with a fluorophore dye. Samples were observed using CLSM at 10× to measure the percentage of sealer penetration and its maximum depth into the dentinal tubules. Data were analysed using one-way ANOVA followed by Tukey's post-hoc test. The significance level was set at p < 0.05 within all tests. RESULTS: Comparing the overall results of all sections tested, no statistically significant differences existed between the groups regarding the percentage of sealer penetration (p = 0.612) and maximum depth of penetration (p > 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: With both types of irrigation used, dentinal tubule penetration was higher in the coronal section than in the apical section. Continuous chelation using NaOCl/Dual Rinse HEDP performed better in the coronal segments, while irrigation using NaOCl + EDTA promoted a higher percentage of sealer penetration in the apical segment.

From an assessment of multiple chelators, clodronate has potential for use in continuous chelation.

AIM: To identify chelators which when mixed with sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) are stable, exhibiting minimal loss of free available chlorine (FAC) over 80 min and to further investigate potential mixtures by assessing FAC over 18 h and the capacity to remove smear layer. METHODOLOGY: 0.25 mol L-1 EDTA (10%), 0.25 mol L-1 EGTA (egtazic acid), 0.25 mol L-1 CDTA (cyclohexanediaminetetraacetic acid), 0.25 mol L-1 DTPA (pentetic acid), 0.5 mol L-1 ATMP (aminotri(methylene phosphonic acid)) and 1 mol L-1 HPAA, (hydroxyphosphonoacetic acid), all at alkaline pH, were mixed equally with 5% NaOCl. 0.5 mol L-1 alkaline clodronate and 0.5 mol L-1 Na4 etidronate (15%) were mixed equally with 10% NaOCl. For all mixtures, the pH and temperature were measured over 80 min and additionally for the clodronate mixture over 18 h. Iodometric titration was used to measure the FAC of all mixtures except for HPAA. The following were compared with respect to their ability to remove smear layer: 1 mol L-1 clodronate + 10% NaOCl, 0.5 mol L-1 clodronate + 10% NaOCl, 1 mol L-1 etidronate + 10% NaOCl, 0.5 mol L-1 clodronate + 10% NaOCl and the sequences 5% NaOCl/17% EDTA/5% NaOCl and 5% NaOCl/17% EDTA. The area fraction occupied by open dentinal tubules as a percentage of the total area (% AF) from scanning electron microscopy micrographs was calculated using Image J. The results were statistically analysed with alpha set at 0.05. RESULTS: Compared to its control, the mixture 0.5 mol L-1 clodronate + 10% NaOCl lost no FAC over 18 h (P > 0.05). The FAC of 0.25 mol L-1 CDTA mixed with 5% NaOCl fell to 96%, 92%, 75% and 4.9% at 20, 40, 60 and 80 min, respectively. Temperature rises were observed in all cases except in the etidronate and clodronate mixtures. Only in the clodronate mixture did the pH remain above pH 12 for the whole experiment. Although smear layer was removed, the % AF in 1 mol L-1 clodronate + 10% NaOCl, 0.5 mol L-1 clodronate + 10% NaOCl, 1 mol L-1 etidronate + 10% NaOCl was less than for 0.5 mol L-1 etidronate + 10% NaOCl and 5% NaOCl/17% EDTA/5% NaOCl and 5% NaOCl/17% EDTA. CONCLUSION: Alkaline 0.5 mol L-1 clodronate mixed equally with 10% NaOCl has potential for use in continuous chelation, based on this assessment of stability and smear layer removal. Further research is needed to establish its efficacy and safety.

Removal of calcium hydroxide intracanal medicament by different irrigants and irrigating techniques: a cone beam computed tomography analysis.

The aim of this study was to use cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) to evaluate the removal of calcium hydroxide (Ca[OH]2) from root canals after using different irrigation and activation protocols. Root canals (n = 128) were filled with Ca(OH)2 and scanned using CBCT. The Ca(OH)2 was removed after 1 week using 1 of 12 groups (G1-G12) according to the final irrigating solution: G1, 6% sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) + 18% etidronic acid (EA) with no activation; G2, NaOCL + EA + passive ultrasonic irrigation (PUI); G3, NaOCl + EA + Finishing File (FF); G4, NaOCl + EA + NaviTip FX irrigation needle (NTFX); G5, 3% NaOCl + 17% ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) with no activation; G6, NaOCl + EDTA + PUI; G7, NaOCl + EDTA + FF; G8, NaOCl + EDTA + NTFX; G9, 3% NaOCl with no activation; G10, NaOCl + PUI; G11, NaOCl + FF; G12, NaOCL + NTFX. The amount of residual Ca(OH)2 was assessed by CBCT. Group comparisons were performed using 1-way analysis of variance and Student-Newman-Keuls post hoc test (P = 0.05). Group 7 showed the least residual Ca(OH)2 (10.83%), which was not significantly different from G6 (13.79%) (P > 0.05). The percentage of residual Ca(OH)2 found in these 2 groups was significantly less than that found in the other groups (P < 0.05). None of the protocols could completely remove Ca(OH)2 from the root canal system, but the plastic rotary FF and PUI, in conjunction with NaOCl and EDTA, removed significantly more Ca(OH)2 than the other irrigation activation protocols tested.

Antibiofilm activity of three irrigation protocols activated by ultrasonic, diode laser or Er:YAG laser in vitro.

AIM: To investigate the impact of three irrigation protocols, activated by three different methods, on mature biofilms of Enterococcus faecalis in vitro. METHODOLOGY: Root canals in 280 single-rooted teeth were instrumented using a rotary Ni-Ti system. Biofilms of E. faecalis were generated based on a previously established protocol. Samples were randomly divided into three experimental (n = 80) and one control (n = 40) group based on the irrigation protocol employed: group 1 (NaOCl + Etidronic acid), 1 : 1 mixture of 6% NaOCl and 18% etidronic acid; group 2 (NaOCl-EDTA), 3% NaOCl followed by 17% EDTA; group 3 (NaOCl-EDTA-NaOCl), 3% NaOCl followed by 17% EDTA and a final flush of 3% NaOCl. Saline served as the control. Samples were further divided into four subgroups (n = 20) based on the activation method: subgroup A, no activation; subgroup B, ultrasonic activation; group C, diode laser; group D, Er:YAG laser. Confocal laser scanning microscopy was used to assess bacterial viability in situ. Root dentine powder was obtained for determining the colony-forming units (CFU mL(-1) ). Data were analysed by appropriate statistical analyses with P = 0.05. RESULTS: All experimental irrigation protocols caused complete destruction of the biofilm in the root canal lumen. Within the dentinal tubules, all groups had a significantly higher percentage of dead bacteria than the saline control (P < 0.05). There was no significant difference between NaOCl + etidronic acid and NaOCl-EDTA-NaOCl (P > 0.05), whereas both groups brought about more bacterial reduction than NaOCl-EDTA (P < 0.05). There was no significant difference between diode laser and Er:YAG laser in any of the groups (P > 0.05). Both diode and Er:YAG laser were more effective than ultrasonic activation and conventional syringe irrigation in reducing E. fecalis biofilms (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The use of NaOCl after or in combination with a chelator caused the greatest reduction of E. faecalis. Diode laser and Er:YAG laser activation were superior to ultrasonics in dentinal tubule disinfection.

Compatibility of Dual Rinse 1-Hydroxyethane-1,1-Diphosphonic Acid with Sodium Hypochlorite Solutions Containing Proprietary Additives.

INTRODUCTION: A salt of 1-hydroxyethylidene-1,1-diphosphonic acid (HEDP) was commercialized some years ago. This so-called Dual Rinse (DR) HEDP has been tested for its combined actions and interactions with pure sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) solutions. The aim of this study was to assess DR interactions with NaOCl solutions containing proprietary additives. METHODS: Designated endodontic NaOCl solutions that come at 2 different strengths (2% and 5.25%), and without or with additives (Chloraxid and Chloraxid Extra, respectively) were tested. Some of their key chemical and physical properties were determined in the presence or absence of HEDP (9%) in the solution. In addition, soft tissue dissolution efficacy of test and control solutions was assessed in extracted teeth (n = 10 per group, 90 teeth in total). RESULTS: The NaOCl content in the 2% Chloraxid solutions was slightly above, that in the 5.25% solutions below the labeled concentration. The additives in the Chloraxid Extra solutions neither altered their surface tension nor their viscosity. The addition of HEDP to any of the tested NaOCl solutions reduced their pH, and increased their surface tension and viscosity. HEDP-induced available chlorine loss over the first hour was similar between all NaOCl solutions. Soft tissue dissolution in the root canals was affected by NaOCl concentration, but neither by any proprietary NaOCl additive in the Chloraxid solutions, nor the addition of DR HEDP. CONCLUSIONS: Proprietary additives had no influence on any of the tested parameters, including surface tension of the "Extra" solutions. The increased viscosity of combined NaOCl/HEDP solutions deserves further attention.

Resistance to compressive force in continuous chelation.

Continuous chelation involves the simultaneous use of sodium hypochlorite and a chelating agent. Given the combination of a proteolytic agent and a demineralising chelator, this study aimed to investigate whether mixtures containing the weak chelators etidronate or clodronate and sodium hypochlorite could adversely affect the mechanical strength of teeth compared to the sequence sodium hypochlorite/EDTA/sodium hypochlorite. Matching pairs of bovine teeth were tested on a universal testing machine, and the compressive load at fracture was recorded. One root from each pair was prepared with the sequence, and the matching tooth was prepared with either water, the clodronate mixture or the etidronate mixture. No differences in load at fracture were seen between either mixture and the sequence. However, loads were higher in the teeth irrigated with water compared to the sequence. The results indicated that the continuous chelation mixtures did not alter tooth mechanical properties compared to the standard sequence.

Influence of 1-Hydroxyethylidene-1,1-Diphosphonic Acid on the Soft Tissue-Dissolving and Gelatinolytic Effect of Ultrasonically Activated Sodium Hypochlorite in Simulated Endodontic Environments.

The addition of Dual Rinse HEDP, an etidronate powder, to a sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) solution can create a combined single endodontic irrigant with a soft tissue-dissolving and a decalcifying effect, which can replace traditional alternating irrigation with chemically non-compatible solutions. While the short-term compatibility between NaOCl and 1-hydroxyethylidene-1,1-diphosphonic acid (HEDP) has been shown, it remains unclear whether ultrasonic activation of a combined NaOCl & HEDP solution immediately reduces the available chlorine and/or renders the NaOCl ineffective in dissolving organic tissue remnants. This was tested in three experiments: (1) direct activation in test tubes in an ultrasonic bath and then the activation by an ultrasonically oscillating tip (IrriSafe) in (2) an epoxy resin model containing a simulated isthmus filled with gelatin, and (3) extracted teeth with simulated resorption cavities filled with soft tissue. The control solutions were physiological saline and 2.5% NaOCl without HEDP. In (1), available chlorine after 30 s of ultrasonic activation (37 kHz) of test and control solution was assessed, as well as shrimp tissue weight loss in direct exposure. In (2) and (3), the ultrasonic tip was driven at 1/3 of full power using the respective unit, and areas of removed gelatin from the isthmus and tissue weight loss were used as the outcomes, respectively. Experiment (1) revealed no negative impact by HEDP on available chlorine (1), while all three experiments showed a highly significant (p > 0.001) synergistic effect, which was not hampered by HEDP, between NaOCl and ultrasonic activation regarding tissue weight loss (1, 3) and dissolution of gelatin (2).

Effect of intracanal and extracanal heating on pulp dissolution property of continuous chelation irrigant.

Context: Extracanal and intracanal heating of sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) improve its pulp dissolution, but limited literature is available on its effect as a combined single irrigant with etidronate. Aim: The aim of this study is to compare the effect of temperature on the effectiveness of NaOCl and continuous chelation protocol on the time required for the dissolution of vital and necrotic pulp. Materials and Methods: Dissolution time of 120 standardized bovine (buffalo) pulp fragments, divided into 12 subgroups based on tissue type (vital/necrotic), irrigant (NaOCl/continuous chelation), and temperature (extracanal, intracanal, and nonheated irrigant), was noted. Conical glass tips mimicking the root canal were considered specimen containers. About 0.2 ml of irrigant corresponding to the irrigation protocol was taken in them and then pulp samples were added to it. Samples were observed using loupes under 2.5 X magnification. Dissolution time was recorded using a stopwatch. The study was approved by the Institutional Ethical Committee (SDC/2019/591). Statistical Analysis Used: Two-way analysis of variance; statistical product and service solutions version 25. The level of significance was set at P < 0.05. Results: Time for pulp dissolution by continuous chelation mixture was significantly more as compared to NaOCl alone in all subgroups. Pulp tissue dissolution for both vital and necrotic pulp was improved by the increase in temperature of both irrigants and dissolution time was more for necrotic than vital tissue. Pulp tissue dissolution was significantly better by intracanal heating as compared to extracanal heating. Conclusion: Although intracanal heating of continuous chelation mixture improves its pulp dissolution capacity significantly as compared to extracanal heating and nonheating protocol but pulpal dissolution capacity of nonheated 5% NaOCl still remains significantly better as compared to intracanal and extracanal heated continuous chelation mixture.

Multiple assessment methodologies in determining the antibiofilm actions of sodium hypochlorite mixed with clodronate or etidronate in endodontic irrigation.

This study aimed to use multiple methodologies, including a novel usage of scanning electron microscopy (SEM), to evaluate the antimicrobial actions of sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) admixed with clodronate or etidronate in root canal irrigation. The study also examined the usefulness of colony counting as a biofilm assessment methodology. Seven day Enterococcus faecalis biofilms were grown on hydroxyapatite discs. The discs were disinfected with 0.26 M clodronate-5% NaOCl, 0.26 M etidronate-5% NaOCl, 5% NaOCl, or treated with phosphate buffered saline (PBS). Assessments were performed using colony counting, SEM and the XTT reduction assay. The XTT assessment used the same groups but with 2.5% NaOCl. For colony counting, bacteria were removed from the discs by vortex mixing, followed by plating. The discs were subsequently fixed for SEM imagining and evaluators scored the SEM micrographs for remaining bacteria. Antibiofilm actions were assessed with the Kruskal-Wallis and Dunn's multiple comparison tests. SEM micrographs and the XTT assay revealed no differences between the NaOCl controls and the clodronate or etidronate mixtures with NaOCl (P > 0.05). It was concluded that the chelator mixtures with NaOCl had antibiofilm actions comparable to NaOCl. Furthermore, vortex mixing incompletely removed biofilm from HA discs in the PBS controls and hence colony counting using E. faecalis biofilms on hydroxyapatite discs could not be used for intergroup comparisons involving PBS. Additionally, colony counting could not be used for comparisons between the NaOCl treatment groups because the removal of bacteria from the substrate by vortex mixing was affected by the irrigant type.

Novel Approaches to Detect and Treat Biofilms within the Root Canals of Teeth: A Review.

Biofilms located within the root canals of teeth are a unique and pressing concern in dentistry and in medical microbiology. These multispecies biofilms, which include fungi as well as bacteria, form in a protected site with low shear stress and low oxygen tension. Systemic antibiotics are of limited value because of the lack of blood flow of the site, and issues with innate and acquired resistance. Physical disruption using hand or rotary powered instruments does not reach all locations in the root canal system where biofilms are present. Alternative strategies including agitated irrigation fluids, continuous chelation, materials with highly alkaline pH, and antimicrobial nanoparticles are being explored to meet the challenge. Detection and quantification of biofilms using fluorescence-based optical methods could provide an indication of successful biofilm removal and an endpoint for physical and chemical treatments.

Organic Tissue Dissolution in Clodronate and Etidronate Mixtures with Sodium Hypochlorite.

INTRODUCTION: Mixtures of clodronate with sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) better maintain free available chlorine (FAC) than etidronate-hypochlorite mixtures. This research aimed to compare organic tissue dissolution and residual FAC between clodronate and etidronate mixtures. Additionally, clodronate-hypochlorite mixtures lose no FAC over several hours. The second aim was to examine how well such mixtures dissolve organic material 6 hours from mixing. METHODS: Soon after mixing, porcine palatal mucosa samples were added to 32°C solutions containing 0.26 mol/L clodronate and 5% NaOCl (0.26 mol/L-5% NaOCl), 0.26 mol/L etidronate-5% NaOCl, 5% NaOCl, 0.26 mol/L clodronate, 0.26 mol/L etidronate, or phosphate-buffered saline. Weights and FAC, where applicable, were recorded initially and at 15 minutes. FAC was measured by iodometric titration. Secondly, 6 hours after mixing, mucosa was added to 0.26 mol/L clodronate-2.5% NaOCl, 2.5% NaOCl, 0.52 mol/L clodronate-5% NaOCl, 5% NaOCl, or phosphate-buffered saline. Sample weights at 0, 5, 10, and 15 minutes were recorded. Analysis of variance was used for statistical analyses (α < .05). RESULTS: Soon after mixing, 0.26 mol/L clodronate-5% NaOCl dissolved mucosa as well as 5% NaOCl and better than 0.26 mol/L etidronate-5% NaOCl compared with which it retained more FAC. At 6 hours after mixing, 0.26 mol/L clodronate-2.5% NaOCl dissolved organic material as well as 2.5% NaOCl. However, 0.52 mol/L clodronate-5% NaOCl dissolved less mucosa than 5% NaOCl. CONCLUSIONS: Soon after mixing, clodronate mixtures better dissolve organic material than etidronate mixtures and have higher residual FAC. Six hours from mixing, 0.26 mol/L clodronate-2.5% NaOCl mixtures dissolve organic material similarly to controls.

The effect of temperature on the stability of sodium hypochlorite in a continuous chelation mixture containing the chelator clodronate.

This study evaluated the stability of continuous chelation mixtures of clodronate admixed with sodium hypochlorite at room temperature (23°C), at root canal temperature (34-35°C) and in refrigerated storage (2-4°C). In continuous chelation, one solution containing a chelator and sodium hypochlorite simultaneously disinfects and removes organic matter and smear layer. This technique is thought to enhance antimicrobial action and debris removal. However, hypochlorite stability and free available chlorine (FAC) levels may decline with elevated temperature and through chemical interactions with the chelator, thus reducing the therapeutic window of these mixtures. Employing iodometric titration, the FAC for clodronate-hypochlorite mixtures was measured at 34-35°C, 23°C and 2-4°C. Clodronate-hypochlorite solutions were stable for 180 min at 34-35°C. When kept at 2-4°C over 3 months, they maintain 95% of the FAC compared with baseline. It was concluded that the therapeutic window of clodronate-hypochlorite mixtures is unaffected at root canal temperature.