What Are Doctors For? A Call for Compassion-Based Metrics as a Measure of Physician Value.

Modern measures of physician value are couched in terms of productivity, volume, finance, outcomes, cure rates, and acquisition of an increasingly vast knowledge base. This inherently feeds burnout and imposter syndrome as physicians experience an inability to measure up to unrealistic standards set externally and perceived internally. Ancient and modern wisdom suggests that where populations fail to flourish, at root is a failure to grasp a vision or true purpose. Traditional philosophical conceptions of a physician's purpose center around compassion, empathy, and humanism, which are a key to thwarting burnout and recovering professional satisfaction. New compassion-based metrics are urgently needed and will positively impact physician well-being and improve population health.

Integrative Care Model of Complementary Therapies and Humanizing Practices in Primary Health Care: Qualitative Meta-synthesis.

Context: The World Health Organization (WHO) seeks to support member states in providing Traditional, Complementary, and Integrative Medicine (TCIM) services within Primary Health Care (PHC). Health professionals' offer of and referral to complementary therapies and humanizing practices can encounter some difficulties due to both conventional medical knowledge and institutional organizations. An integrative care model of complementary therapies and humanizing practices may be a strategy to overcome such difficulties. Objective: The study aimed to identify an integrative care model of complementary therapies and humanizing practices and to determine their influence on PHC. Design: The research team performed: (1) a qualitative meta-synthesis based on data from two systematic reviews that included more than 15000 professionals from 18 countries, and (2) qualitative research conducted with 24 participants, professionals from the South and Southeast regions of São Paulo, SP, Brazil. Setting: The study occurred at the Paulista School of Medicine at the Federal University of Sao Paulo (UNIFESP) in Sao Paulo, Brazil. Results: The analysis of the integrative care model resulted in two syntheses: (1) that PHC is offering complementary therapies and humanizing practices that have had a positive and subjective influence on PHC and (2) complementary therapies and humanizing practices improve PHC's service quality and resolvability and reduce medicalization. Conclusions: The work process in PHC may pose difficulties for the provision of integrative and holistic care yet promoting a model to integrate complementary therapies and humanizing practices with conventional medicine in health services may improve PHC and the perceptions of health professionals, managers, and patients about the positive and subjective effects of these practices.

Examining nurses' humanistic behaviour ability and empathy levels in clinical practice: A descriptive and exploratory study.

BACKGROUND: It is critical for nurses to provide healthcare services to healthy/sick individuals with a humanistic approach and with empathy. AIMS: This research aimed to determine nurses' humanistic behaviour ability, empathy levels and related factors in clinical practice. DESIGN: A descriptive cross-sectional and exploratory study. METHODS: Probability sampling method was used, and 337 nurses working in two public hospitals were included in the study. Data was collected using the Humanistic Practice Ability of Nursing Scale and the Empathy Level Determination Scale. Structural equation model analysis and descriptive statistics were used to evaluate the hypothesised model. This study adhered to the STROBE checklist for reporting. RESULTS: Nurses' humanistic ability and empathy level in nursing practices were found to be above average. Both the ability to act humanely in nursing practices and their empathy levels were found to be significantly higher in nurses who were married and had children. A significant relationship was found between empathy levels and humanistic behaviours. Accordingly, nurses' empathy levels positively affected their humanistic care behaviours, and the model established between the two concepts was found to be statistically appropriate. CONCLUSIONS: Nurses' empathy levels positively affect their ability to act humanistically. The result of the model established between the two concepts also supports this. Care strategies should be developed that consider factors that will improve empathetic and humanistic behaviours in nurses and maximise individualised care practices. IMPLICATIONS FOR THE PROFESSION: Increasing the awareness of nurses about the factors affecting humanistic behaviours and empathic attitudes while caring for individuals in clinical practice, will contribute to improving the quality of nursing care.

Some Considerations on a Patient's Sense of Immortality: Bringing a Human Dimension to the Process.

One of the most frequent, although widely understandable, reactions of people diagnosed with an incurable tumor is represented by incredulity, anger, and the denial of the impossibility of a definitive cure. Often, a picture of intense anxiety quickly takes over, overlapping the ever-growing collective hysteria of modern society, the result of a complex cultural mechanism in which technocracy often prevails over thought, introspection, and, in a broader sense, humanism. In this health drama, all actors often complain of formal inaccuracies while paying little attention to substantive ones. We argue that a more human emphatic patient-family-doctor relationship training to consider the undeniable progress of medicine and the fragility of all of us.

No evidence that belief in conspiracy theories is negatively related to attitudes toward transhumanism.

Transhumanism is a movement that emphasizes the improvement of the human condition by developing technologies and making them widely available. Conspiracy theories regularly refer to the allegedly transhumanist agenda of elites. We hypothesized that belief in conspiracy theories would be related to more unfavorable attitudes toward the transhumanist movement. We examined this association through two pre-registered studies (based on two French samples, total N after exclusion = 550). We found no evidence of a negative relationship between belief in conspiracy theories and attitudes toward transhumanism. This null result was further corroborated by Bayesian analysis, an equivalence test, and an internal mini meta-analysis. This work plays a precursory role in understanding attitudes toward an international cultural and intellectual movement that continues to grow in popularity and influence.

[The humanization of medical education: publications review].

The humanization of medical education is targeted at integration of humanitarian values and approaches into system of education of medical personnel to improve their professional and personal training. This process includes education in medical ethics, development of communication skills, stress management and implementation of humanitarian disciplines into the curriculum. The humanization contributes into formation of empathy, responsibility and professionalism in future physicians that helps to better understand and consider psychological, social and emotional needs of patients. The problems of including humanitarian sciences into medical education are associated with lack of systematic approach, adequate curricula and qualified lecturers. To optimize process, it is necessary to focus on education of ideals and beliefs, development of integrated curricula and enhancement of humanitarian component of education.

[Humanization of Assistance; Building the path from the university]. / Cuidados en salud humanizados: Construyendo camino desde la universidad.

BACKGROUND: The training of health students regarding good treatment and humanized care is essential; it is a quality benchmark in health care. The relevance of good treatment and humanized care should be consistent with the treatment students receive from teachers and clinical tutors, modeling humanized cultures. However, research shows the normalization of mistreatment of medical and nursing students. A Humanized Training Unit was implemented in a Chilean nursing school, which included promoting a support Program for students by their teachers between 2020 and 2021. AIM: Explore the Program's impact on the exercise of humanized care from the student's perspective. MATERIAL AND METHODS: An intrinsic case study with a qualitative approach, with the objective of 12 semi-structured interviews carried out via Zoom with young people who had been tutored virtually by program teachers for one month and two years during their student period. We performed the data analysis using the constant comparisons method and in compliance with qualitative rigor criteria. RESULTS: The Program positively impacted personal, academic, and professional areas, allowing students to feel cared for by their teachers and recognizing the development of skills transferable to their relationship with users for more humanized care. CONCLUSIONS: The Program is replicable to other careers and institutions, requiring time, disposition, and teacher training, which can be a limitation. The benefits evidenced by our study demonstrate the program's usefulness in promoting cultures of more humanized care in educational and health spaces.

[Phenomenology of moral distress: implications for the humanization of medical education and practice]. / Fenomenología de la angustia moral: implicancias para la humanización de la educación y la práctica médica.

In the healthcare context, moral distress (MD) refers to the negative emotions that arise when a person knows the correct course of action in a given situation but is not able to follow it due to personal, hierarchical or institutional impediments. MD has been related to various professional problems, such as vocational disorientation, low work motivation, depersonalized treatment of patients, abandonment of duties, and changes of specialty or profession. Although this phenomenon has not been sufficiently studied in Chile, it presumably exists and would have even increased during the COVID-19 pandemic, leaving its repercussions unknown. Accordingly, this article has the objectives, firstly, to promote the phenomenological study of MD in our country, considering the importance of preventing its potential adverse impact on the mental health of future professionals, and, secondly, to highlight the need to include narrative approaches in medical education, in order to develop a more holistic approach to understanding patients and their condition of vulnerability. Ultimately, it is expected that addressing the implications of MD in medical education and practice will contribute to its humanization, optimizing the quality of healthcare.

Hydraulic Engineers and Antiquarians: Political Use of the Past in Nineteenth-Century Venice.

The article analyzes the relationship between hydraulics and history in the nineteenth century, often described as a period when the humanities and the sciences split into "two separate cultures." Venice, amphibious city par excellence, is a good starting point for exploring the use of history in water management debates. In the early nineteenth century, humanists and hydraulic engineers came together through multiple disciplinary approaches and in constant confrontation with the Republic of Venice's water policies. In the following decades, while making extensive use of history, these engineers realized and emphasized the diversity of both disciplines' methodologies. This evolution-seen through the writings of renowned hydraulic engineer at the time Pietro Paleocapa-illustrates how history was no longer a source of empirical knowledge but came to be used for rhetorical and political purposes.

Living the Art of Nursing.

The article that follows reflects on the importance, the precision, and the guidance provided through theoretical foundations, science, and art of nursing as directed by these paradigmatic theoretical frameworks and their corresponding practice methodologies. The mainstay element common across all frameworks is the precise essentials contained within the nursing theoretical frameworks that, in turn, guide the contributions of the nursing discipline. The humanbecoming paradigm serves as the primary highlighted focus of the article.

Living a Threatening Circumstance from a Nursing Perspective.

This introduction reminds nurses to use a nursing perspective in their work with other clinicians and researchers. In this introduction, the humanbecoming perspective is used to help nurses see a group of persons with specific challenges or threatening circumstances as a case study of an important phenomenon, so as to remain as humane as possible in their practice, teaching, and research.

Paradoxes in Humanbecoming Hermeneutic Sciencing.

The author explores humanbecoming hermeneutic sciencing and provides exemplars of paradoxes that are used by scholars in this mode of inquiry.

Policy Crafting: Humanbecoming and the Rainbow PRISM Model.

It is important that nurses guide practice with crafted policies based in nursing knowledge that is distinctive and specific to the values and beliefs of all persons, such as humanbecoming. As policy crafters in nursing, a nursing theory or model must serve as the foundation in service to others. In this article, the author explores crafting policy with the Rainbow PRISM model (Cody, 2003; Ortiz, 2018), in light of Parse's (2021a) humanbecoming paradigm, the humanbecoming community change concepts (Parse, 2003, 2021a), and Parse's (1987, 2021a) principles of inquiry construction.

The Humanbecoming Concept Inventing Model: Feeling Betrayed.

The author of this paper discusses the phenomenon of feeling betrayed theoretically and conceptually. Through the use of the humanbecoming concept inventing model, the author illuminates the now-truth of feeling betrayed as agonizing anguish arising with the shattered trust of communion-aloneness. At the level of science, feeling betrayed was declared as imaging the powering of connecting-separating as an ingenuous proclamation with the scholar's chosen artform.

The Waiting.

The following article uses storytelling, poetry, and findings from a humanbecoming inquiry on waiting to describe the arduous universal humanuniverse living experience of waiting.

A Humanbecoming Perspective on Art and Sciencing.

The author in this paper explores the connections between art and sciencing in the humanbecoming paradigm. Relevant examples of artforms used by Parse scholars are illustrated. A brief discussion on art sciencing is illuminated. Finally, an example of feeling overwhelmed through the lens of the performing arts is shared.

Conceptual Foreknowings: Integrative Review on Having Courage.

Having courage is a humanuniverse living experience that is common to all humans. Individuals experience courage in one way or another at different times. Hence, it is imperative to understand having courage from various standpoints. To explore the different perspectives on the phenomenon of courage, the scholar dwelled with printed material across the disciplines of theology, psychology, philosophy, sociology, social work, education, business, and nursing. Two themes were crafted from the literature as (a) courage is steadfastness in the midst of fear and (b) unfaltering commitment to the cherished.