Combined MRI and MRS improves pre-therapeutic diagnoses of pediatric brain tumors over MRI alone.

ABSTRACT

INTRODUCTION: The specific goal of this study was to determine whether the inclusion of MRS had a measureable and positive impact on the accuracy of pre-surgical MR examinations of untreated pediatric brain tumors over that of MRI alone in clinical practice. METHODS: Final imaging reports of 120 pediatric patients with newly detected brain tumors who underwent combined MRI/MRS examinations were retrospectively reviewed. Final pathology was available in all cases. Group A comprised 60 subjects studied between June 2001 and January 2005, when MRS was considered exploratory and radiologists utilized only conventional MRI to arrive at a diagnosis. For group B, comprising 60 subjects studied between January 2005 and March 2008, the radiologists utilized information from both MRI and MRS. Furthermore, radiologists revisited group A (blind review, time lapse >4 years) to determine whether the additional information from MRS would have altered their interpretation. RESULTS: Sixty-three percent of patients in group A were diagnosed correctly, whereas in 10% the report was partially correct with the final tumor type mentioned (but not mentioned as most likely tumor), while in 27% of cases the reports were wrong. For group B, the diagnoses were correct in 87%, partially correct in 5%, and incorrect in 8% of the cases, which is a significant improvement (p < 0.005). Re-review of combined MRI and MRS of group A resulted 87% correct, 7% partially correct, and 7% incorrect diagnoses, which is a significant improvement over the original diagnoses (p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: Adding MRS to conventional MRI significantly improved diagnostic accuracy in preoperative pediatric patients with untreated brain tumors.