Community- and genome-based evidence for a shaping influence of redox potential on bacterial protein evolution.

ABSTRACT

Despite deep interest in how environments shape microbial communities, whether redox conditions influence the sequence composition of genomes is not well known. We predicted that the carbon oxidation state (ZC) of protein sequences would be positively correlated with redox potential (Eh). To test this prediction, we used taxonomic classifications for 68 publicly available 16S rRNA gene sequence data sets to estimate the abundances of archaeal and bacterial genomes in river & seawater, lake & pond, geothermal, hyperalkaline, groundwater, sediment, and soil environments. Locally, ZC of community reference proteomes (i.e., all the protein sequences in each genome, weighted by taxonomic abundances but not by protein abundances) is positively correlated with Eh corrected to pH 7 (Eh7) for the majority of data sets for bacterial communities in each type of environment, and global-scale correlations are positive for bacterial communities in all environments. In contrast, archaeal communities show approximately equal frequencies of positive and negative correlations in individual data sets, and a positive pan-environmental correlation for archaea only emerges after limiting the analysis to samples with reported oxygen concentrations. These results provide empirical evidence that geochemistry modulates genome evolution and may have distinct effects on bacteria and archaea. IMPORTANCE The identification of environmental factors that influence the elemental composition of proteins has implications for understanding microbial evolution and biogeography. Millions of years of genome evolution may provide a route for protein sequences to attain incomplete equilibrium with their chemical environment. We developed new tests of this chemical adaptation hypothesis by analyzing trends of the carbon oxidation state of community reference proteomes for microbial communities in local- and global-scale redox gradients. The results provide evidence for widespread environmental shaping of the elemental composition of protein sequences at the community level and establish a rationale for using thermodynamic models as a window into geochemical effects on microbial community assembly and evolution.