Can compliance with nonpharmacologic treatments for cardiovascular disease be improved?

OBJECTIVE: To critically review the literature regarding the effectiveness of interventions aimed at improving cardiovascular patient compliance with nonpharmacologic treatments. METHODS: We searched Medline, Healthplan, and Psychlit from 1985 to 1996; searched the bibliographies of located studies; contacted Australian government departments and nongovernment organizations; and two experts examined the resulting study list. We selected 27 studies, which randomly allocated patients to groups and were published in English, and we evaluated interventions aimed at increasing compliance with nonpharmacologic treatments for cardiovascular disease. These trials were critically appraised against eight methodologic criteria and, subsequently, classified as of good, fair, or poor quality. Information about target groups, samples, trial intervention strategies and their effectiveness were extracted from the 18 good- and fair-quality trials. Interrater reliability was high on the 20% of references that were double-coded. The 18 studies reviewed described the effectiveness of 27 intervention strategies at improving compliance with dietary, smoking-cessation, exercise, weight-loss, stress-reduction, general lifestyle, relaxation, and blood pressure screening programs. RESULTS: Tentative recommendations were made for or against most trial strategies: partner-focused and structural strategies showed the most consistent benefits, physician-focused strategies were unanimously unsuccessful, and patient-focused strategies were of mixed benefit. CONCLUSIONS: The methodologic quality of many of the located trials was less than optimal. Therefore, further good-quality, randomized trials are necessary to clarify the effectiveness of those strategies identified as potentially useful in this review.

A critical review of interventions to increase compliance with medication-taking, obtaining medication refills, and appointment-keeping in the treatment of cardiovascular disease.

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to critically review the literature regarding interventions to improve cardiovascular patients' compliance with medication-taking, obtaining medication refills, or appointment keeping. METHODS: The search for relevant randomized trials involved searching the Medline, Healthplan, and Psychlit databases from 1985 to 1996; searching the bibliographies of located studies; contacting Australian government departments, non-government organizations, and pharmaceutical companies; and ultimate review of the resulting list by two field experts. The 33 located trials were critically appraised and classified as being of good, fair, or poor methodological quality. Descriptive and effectiveness data were then extracted from the 20 good and fair quality trials. Interrater reliability was high on the 20% of references double-coded. RESULTS: The 20 studies reviewed evaluated the effectiveness of 18 intervention strategies. Tentative recommendations were made for many patient-focused and structural strategies across all three target behaviors. Physician-focused strategies, tested only for appointment keeping, were all tentatively recommended against. CONCLUSIONS: The methodological quality of many of the located trials was less than optimal, prohibiting strong recommendations. Therefore, further good-quality, randomized trials are necessary in order to clarify the effectiveness of those strategies identified as potentially useful in this review.