Routine pathological evaluation after tonsillectomy: is it necessary?

OBJECTIVES: There is still no consensus regarding the necessity of sending every tonsil specimen for histological examination following tonsillectomy. To add to this discussion, we assessed the incidence of preoperatively unexpected malignancy in the postoperative tonsil specimens of adults and children in our ENT department. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective study of the histopathology results of all patients who underwent tonsillectomy between January 1999 and February 2006 in the ENT department of East Limburg Hospital in Genk. The charts of patients with postoperative histopathological malignancy were further analysed and reviewed for preoperative indications of the tonsillectomy and for preoperative suspicion of malignancy. RESULTS: A total of 2989 patients were included in the study: 2058 children (defined as 16 years or younger) and 931 adults. No malignancy was found among the children. In 20 adults, malignancy was diagnosed, but in all cases there was a preoperative suspicion of malignancy. No patient without preoperative risk factors was found to have malignancy on pathological evaluation of the tonsils. CONCLUSION: Our results indicate that routine histopathological examination of tonsils removed for benign disease in adults and children is clinically unnecessary. We propose that on an individual basis, the surgeon should decide the need for histological examination depending on preoperative risk factors and peroperative gross examination. Such a strategy will only be medicolegally possible where there are national and scientifically (evidence)based ENT consensus reports or guidelines on this issue.

Completion thyroidectomy after the unexpected diagnosis of thyroid cancer.

The optimal surgical management of well-differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) remains a controversial topic. Preoperative and peroperative investigations quite frequently fail to detect thyroid cancer in cold nodules, and only postoperative histological examination reveals malignancy. In these cases many physicians perform a completion thyroidectomy. Others recommend a conservative approach with close follow-up because of the increased risk of complications after re-operation. In our department, routine management includes completion thyroidectomy once the histopathological report concludes that there is carcinoma, except in cases of papillary carcinoma measuring less than 1 cm. The aim of our study was to determine the incidence of contralateral malignancy and of complications after completion thyroidectomy. We reviewed the records of 29 patients--25 women and 4 men-- who all underwent completion thyroidectomy because of an unexpected diagnosis of DTC. Residual malignancy was found in 12 patients (41.4%) after completion thyroidectomy. In ten patients (34.5%) the malignancy was localised in the contralateral lobe and two patients (6.9%) had lymph node metastases. Postoperative transient hypocalcaemia (< 8.0 mg/dl) occurred in five patients (17.2%) and permanent hypocalcaemia (lasting longer than 6 months) was a feature in two patients. One patient suffered transient laryngeal nerve injury occurred in one patient and there were no permanent lesions. In conclusion, we found residual DTC in 41.4% of patients undergoing reintervention. Because of the rather low re-operation rate, we prefer to perform a completion thyroidectomy to remove potential occult malignancy and to allow for postoperative 131I-treatment in all patients with a diagnosis of malignancy in their thyroid lobectomy specimen, with the exception of papillary carcinoma < 1 cm.