Outcomes of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy after fellowship training.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Experienced surgeons at select high-volume centers have reported favorable outcomes of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy (LPN) in their contemporary experience. However, it is unclear whether recently fellowship-trained surgeons can replicate such outcomes. We evaluated LPNs performed by 3 surgeons in their initial years of independent practice following laparoscopic fellowship training. METHODS: Prospectively maintained databases were queried for LPNs performed during the first 3.5 years of practice. Intraoperative parameters, oncological efficacy, and postoperative complications were analyzed. RESULTS: Of 138 total LPNs (76 left, 62 right), the mean patient age was 57 years, mean tumor size was 2.52cm, and mean depth of invasion was 1.68cm. Mean OR time was 252 minutes, mean warm ischemia time (WIT) was 26 minutes, and mean estimated blood loss (EBL) was 202 mL. Complications occurred in 7 patients (5%), and conversions occurred in 9 patients (7%). Comparison of the first 15 vs. the last 15 cases demonstrated a significant reduction in mean OR time (204 min vs. 253 min, P=0.007), and mean WIT (24 min vs. 32 min, P<0.001). No significant change was demonstrated for tumor size (2.6 cm vs. 2.4 cm, P=0.390) or EBL (226 mL vs. 220 mL, P=0.922). CONCLUSION: Newly fellowship-trained surgeons performing LPN achieve initial outcomes comparable to those reported by highly experienced surgeons. Further experience reduced total operative and warm ischemia times.

Effects of commonly used hemostatic agents on the porcine collecting system.

PURPOSE: Topical hemostatic agents have been particularly useful for preventing bleeding in tubeless percutaneous nephrolithotomy. In the present study, we investigated the effect of gelatin matrix hemostatic sealant (FloSeal), fibrin glue (Tisseel,), polyethylene glycol polymers (CoSeal), and bovine serum albumin/ glutaraldehyde (BioGlue) in the pig urinary collecting system after injection through a percutaneous nephrostomy (PCN) tract. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Percutaneous nephrostomy was performed in 40 kidneys in 24 domestic pigs. Animals were divided into four groups of six each: (1) FloSeal; (2) Tisseel; (3) CoSeal; and (4) BioGlue. In 16 animals that tolerated the procedure, the contralateral kidney was used as a control for PCN only. All tracts were dilated to 30F with the Amplatz dilator, and 2 mL of the hemostatic agent was injected into the collecting system before pulling back to seal the puncture. RESULTS: Among the control PCN kidneys, no obstruction was detected at the end of a 5-day period. However, three of six kidneys injected with FloSeal, Tisseel, or CoSeal and four of six kidneys injected with BioGlue were obstructed. In each of these cases, there was an associated retroperitoneal urinoma. CONCLUSION: FloSeal, Tisseel, CoSeal, and BioGlue, if injected directly into the porcine collecting system, can result in significant obstruction that does not resolve over a 5-day period. Until there are clinical data to the contrary, we believe that when using one of these hemostatic agents in association with a tubeless percutaneous procedure, a retrograde occlusion balloon catheter should be considered to prevent inadvertent injection of these materials into the collecting system.

Quantification of Long-term Stability and Specific Relief of Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms (LUTS) After Robot-assisted Radical Prostatectomy.

OBJECTIVE: To assist in preoperative counseling by assessing long-term changes in American Urological Association symptom scores (AUAss) and lower urinary tract symptom (LUTS)-related quality of life (QOL) in patients undergoing robot-assisted radical prostatectomy (RARP). MATERIALS AND METHODS: RARP was performed on 666 men by one surgeon from 2002 to 2007 at a single institution. AUAss and QOL were queried preoperatively and at 3, 9, 15, 24-48, 60-84, and 96+ months postoperatively. LUTS subgroups were compared pre-/postsurgery using univariate and multivariate statistics. RESULTS: The mean and median follow-up for all responders was 3.0 and 2.4 years. Pad-free continence at 12 months was 89%. A subset of 174 men reported preoperative and long-term responses; average follow-up was 5.8 years (range 4.0-10.3 years). AUAss for all men declined from baseline to 5 years by 3.7 (8.6 to 4.8) whereas QOL/Bother scores decreased by 0.5 (1.7 to 1.2) (all P < .05). Men with baseline mild LUTS remained clinically unchanged with long-term AUAss. Individuals with moderate and severe preoperative LUTS had marked improvements in AUA and QOL scores (all P ≤ .05). CONCLUSION: Men with mild LUTS have short-term increases in AUAss but most return to baseline and are stable at 5 years. Benefits were found for men with preoperative moderate and severe LUTS in that 63% had significant QOL improvements and 68% reduced their AUAss to mild LUTS, persisting years after RARP. This study suggests that certain patients with preoperative urinary symptoms and bother may experience improvements in LUTS and associated QOL after RARP.

Rapid communication: early potency outcomes with cautery-free neurovascular bundle preservation with robotic laparoscopic radical prostatectomy.

PURPOSE: To report short-term potency outcomes with a cautery-free technique (CFT) to preserve the neurovascular bundles (NVB) during robotic laparoscopic radical prostatectomy (LRP). PATIENTS AND METHODS: All men were <66 years of age and had a Sexual Health Inventory in Men (SHIM) score of 22 to 25. They underwent unilateral or bilateral dissections. Group 1 (N = 23), the study group, had preservation of the NVB with CFT. Group 2 (N = 36) had traditional dissection using bipolar cautery. Data were collected prospectively via validated questionnaires. Potency was defined as an erection adequate for vaginal penetration. RESULTS: At 3 months, 10 patients (43%) in the CFT group reported potency versus just 3 (8.3%) in the bipolar-cautery group (P = 0.003). Additionally, only 2 (18%) of those having CFT reported zero penile fullness compared with 15 (68%) in the bipolar-cautery group (P = 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: The technique of controlling the vascular pedicle of the prostate and dissecting the NVB without cautery produced significant improvement in potency outcomes at just 3 months.

Ureteral pseudodiverticulum associated with absorbable suture clips after laparoscopic pyeloplasty: case report.

A 48 year-old woman with pyelonephritis was found to have bilateral ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) obstruction and a nonfunctioning right kidney. She initially underwent a laparoscopic left nondismembered pyeloplasty using absorbable polydioxanone Lapra-Ty suture clips (Ethicon Endosurgery, Cincinnati, OH) to secure the anastomosis. An antegrade endopyelotomy was later necessitated. Both procedures were complicated by postoperative bacteruria and funguria. She then underwent a laparoscopic dismembered pyeloplasty, again utilizing Lapra-Ty suture clips to secure the anastomosis. Postoperatively, her course was complicated by anastomotic extravasation, bacteriuria, and funguria. Subsequently, an antegrade nephrostogram revealed a 2.5-cm diverticulum just distal to the UPJ, which contained numerous 2- to 4-mm filling defects. Nephroscopic exploration of the pseudodiverticulum revealed numerous Lapra-Ty clips, which were basket extracted. The pseudodiverticulum was fulgurated with a holmium laser. She eventually had restricturing with recurrence of the pseudodiverticulum and was treated successfully by open ureterocalicostomy.

Tubeless percutaneous nephrolithotomy using hemostatic gelatin matrix.

We describe using hemostatic gelatin matrix (FloSeal; Baxter Inc., Irvine, CA) to provide hemostasis of the tract after percutaneous nephrolithotomy, thereby obviating a nephrostomy tube. For patients who are rendered stone free, a 7F, 11.5-mm occlusion balloon catheter, passed retrograde, is used to occlude the collecting system at the level of entry of the 30F Amplatz sheath. FloSeal is then injected through the partially retracted Amplatz sheath while withdrawing the applicator and the sheath in tandem. The guidewire is withdrawn per urethra until its tip resides in the renal pelvis. A 36-cm, 7F tail stent is passed retrograde, and the skin is closed with cyanoacrylate adhesive (Ethicon, Somerville, NJ). A Foley catheter is placed, to be removed the next morning; the patient can be discharged on postoperative day 1. The ureteral stent is removed in 5 to 7 days as an outpatient procedure.

Effect of holmium:YAG laser pulse width on lithotripsy retropulsion in vitro.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The effect of laser pulse width on calculus retropulsion during ureteroscopic lithotripsy is poorly defined because of the limited availability of variable pulse-width lasers. We used an adjustable pulse-width Ho:YAG laser to test the effect of pulse width on in vitro phantom-stone retropulsion and fragmentation efficiency. METHODS AND MATERIALS: An Odyssey 30 Ho:YAG laser (Convergent Laser Technologies, Oakland, CA) with adjustable pulse width (350 or 700 microsec) was used to treat spherical 10-mm plaster calculi in a model ureter (N = 40) and calix (N = 16) utilizing 200- and 400-microm fibers (10 Hz, 1.0 J). Calculi were placed in a waterfilled clear polymer tube, and laser energy was applied continuously in near contact until the stone had moved 8 cm. The time (seconds) and energy (joules) needed to cause the stone to traverse this distance was recorded. Stones were also placed in a stainless-steel mesh calix model in which retropulsion was limited. Laser energy was applied for 5 minutes at each pulse width. A laser-energy meter (Molectron Detector Inc, Portland OR) was used to quantify fiber transmission efficiency after 1 minute of continuous lithotripsy for each fiber at each pulse width. RESULTS: Retropulsion was greater for stones treated at 350 microsec, indicated by a shorter time to traverse the model ureter. For the 200-microrm fiber at 350 microrsec, the average time was 11.5 seconds v 20.3 seconds at 700 microsec (P < 0.001). The average total energy delivered was 114.9 J at 350 microsec v 199.8 J at 700 microsec (P < 0.001). For the 400-microm fiber at 350 microsec, the average time was 5.8 seconds v 11.9 seconds at 700 microsec (P < 0.001). The average total energy was 57.1 J at 350 microsec v 127.3 J at 700 microsec (P < 0.001). In the caliceal model, at 350 and 700 microsec with the 200- and 400-microm fibers, mass loss was 34.9% and 33.4% (P = 0.8) and 14.6% and 21.6% (P = 0.04), respectively. The reduction in energy transmission at 350 microsec and 700 microsec with the 200- microm fiber after 60 seconds of continuous lasing was 8.82% v 9%, respectively (P = 0.95). For the 400-microm fiber, the transmission loss was 18.4% at 350 microsec v 4.4% at 700 microsec (P = 0.0002). CONCLUSION: When treating ureteral calculi, retropulsion can be reduced by using a longer pulse width without compromising fragmentation efficiency. For caliceal calculi, the longer pulse width in combination with a 400-microm fiber provides more effective stone fragmentation.

Effect of urine specific gravity on effectiveness of shockwave lithotripsy.

PURPOSE: To determine the effect of urine specific gravity (SG) and radiographic contrast medium on the efficiency of extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy (SWL) fragmentation using a previously published in vitro model. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Artificial kidney stones (BegoStone [BEGO USA, Smithfield, RI]) of a standard size (10 x 10 mm) and weight (mean 1.90 g; range 1.89-1.91 g) were randomly allotted to one of four test media with differing SG: group 1: synthetic urine, SG 1.003; group 2: synthetic urine, SG 1.040; group 3: 50% radiographic contrast (Cysto-Conray II, Mallinckrodt Inc., Hazelwood, MO), 50% synthetic urine, SG 1.069; and group 4: 100% contrast, SG 1.121. The stones were placed in cups made of 2.2-mm screen mesh and exposed to 500 shockwaves at 20 KV from a spark-gap lithotripter (Econolith 2000; Medispec, Germantown, MD). The stone fragmentation rate (i.e., percent fragmentation) was determined by dividing the dry residual stone weight by the prelithotripsy dry weight (X 100). RESULTS: The mean fragmentation rate for the four groups was 31.7%, 37.6%, 31.8%, and 27.2%, respectively. Statistical significance was not achieved (P = 0.1). CONCLUSION: Stone breakage tends to be more effective when urine SG is about 1.040 than at higher or lower values. Hence, the recommendation for an overnight fast prior to SWL is well founded. Introduction of contrast medium may inhibit stone breakage because it increases the specific gravity.

Third Prize: Comparison of radical nephrectomy, laparoscopic microwave thermotherapy, cryotherapy, and radiofrequency ablation for destruction of experimental VX-2 renal tumors in rabbits.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Currently available minimally invasive renal tumor-ablation procedures include cryotherapy, radiofrequency ablation, and microwave thermotherapy. In this study, we investigated the ability of these three approaches to destroy experimental renal tumors in rabbits. The mechanism of potential tumor metastasis was also explored. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The VX-2 tumor line is an aggressive rabbit epidermoid tumor with a high metastatic potential. An initial experiment comparing cooled-tip microwave thermotherapy with cryotherapy and radical nephrectomy for treatment of small VX-2 tumors revealed that all microwave-treated rabbits had local recurrence and that several also had diffuse intraperitoneal carcinomatosis. In view of these results, a second experiment was performed in which 45 New Zealand White rabbits were implanted laparoscopically with VX-2 xenografts underneath the kidney capsule and divided into five groups of 9 each. The test groups were microwave thermotherapy with a 3.5-mm cooled-tip probe, microwave thermotherapy with a 3.5-mm noncooled- tip probe, radiofrequency ablation with a 1.5-mm cooled-tip probe, radiofrequency ablation with a 1.5- mm non-cooled tip probe, and cryotherapy with a 2.3-mm cryoprobe. The control groups were five rabbits that were not treated, five rabbits with tumors that had the tumor pierced with a probe but were untreated, and five rabbits that underwent nephrectomy after piercing of the tumor. Treatment was initiated 5 days after tumor implantation. One month later, all animals were euthanized and autopsied. RESULTS: At 5 days after tumor implantation, laparoscopic inspection revealed no visible peritoneal metastases. At 1 month, in the cooled and non-cooled microwave-thermotherapy groups, carcinomatosis occurred in five and six of nine animals, respectively. In comparison, carcinomatosis was detected in two of nine animals in the cryotherapy group at autopsy. With respect to cooled and non-cooled radiofrequency ablation, carcinomatosis was observed in four of nine rabbits in each group. In the control groups, none of the animals with unpierced tumors exhibited carcinomatosis, while carcinomatosis was seen in two of the five rabbits with tumor violated by piercing and in three of the five rabbits that underwent immediate nephrectomy after piercing of the tumor. CONCLUSION: Carcinomatosis occurred most frequently in animals treated with microwave thermotherapy, followed by radiofrequency ablation, and lastly cryoablation. The simple act of piercing a highly aggressive tumor can result in local spread. More disconcerting, and less well understood, is why certain ablative modalities appear to increase the rate of intraperitoneal spread.

What happens to hemostatic agents in contact with urine? An in vitro study.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: As the indications for topical hemostatic agents increase in urology, the question arises: what happens to these agents when they enter the urinary collecting system? To answer this question, we performed a series of in-vitro experiments mixing three hemostatic agents with normal and sanguineous urine. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Four commercially available topical hemostatic products: oxidized regenerated cellulose (Surgicel; Ethicon, Somerville, NJ), fibrin sealant (Tisseel VH Kit; Baxter Health Care Corporation, Irvine, CA), gelatin matrix hemostatic sealant (FloSeal; Baxter Health Care), and polyethylene glycol (CoSeal; Cohesion Technologies, Palo Alto, CA) were studied. Human urine (10 mL) was added to samples of each substance; this was done in triplicate. The 12 sample tubes were then capped and placed on a tube shaker at slow speed and 37 degrees C. Observations regarding consistency of the material were made at 6, 12, 24, 48, 72, 96, and 120 hours (5 days). Gelatin matrix hemostatic sealant was further tested in urine with various amounts of blood or blood clot; observations were again recorded out to 5 days. RESULTS: Surgicel maintained its solid form when it initially came in contact with urine, but over a period of 5 days, it transformed into a mucoid substance with visible free-floating fibers. It did not dissolve completely in urine within 5 days. Gelatin matrix was immediately transformed by urine into a fine colloidal suspension that did not change over the 5 days of the study. Fibrin glue, after mixing of the two components (fibrinogen and thrombin) directly in the urine, and polyethylene glycol immediately formed a solid clot at the bottom of the test tube on contact with the urine. When the mixture of fibrin sealant was allowed to form for 15 minutes and then added to urine, it again maintained a solid form. After 72 hours, the fibrin glue became a semisolid gelatinous plug. On analysis at 5 days, the fibrin sealant clot had transformed into a cohesive mucoid gel, and the polyethylene glycol clot had not changed. The gelatin matrix hemostatic sealant, when in contact with blood or blood clot, appeared to either become part of a clot or to remain in a colloidal suspension. At 5 days, all clots had dissolved to fine particulate suspensions, and the gelatin matrix appeared as a fine suspension. CONCLUSION: Fibrin glue and oxidized regenerated cellulose maintain a solid form when initially placed in direct contact with urine and then assume a semisolid gelatinous state, which is still present at 5 days. Polyethylene glycol forms a solid clot initially and does not change after 5 days. Only hemostatic gelatin matrix remained as a fine particulate suspension in both normal and sanguineous urine. The implications of these findings with regard to sealing the renal parenchyma or small violations of the collecting system after percutaneous or laparoscopic surgery await in-vivo testing.

Initial impact of a dedicated postgraduate laparoscopic mini-residency on clinical practice patterns.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Laparoscopic surgical techniques are difficult to master, especially for surgeons who did not receive this type of training during their residencies. We have established a 5-day mentor-preceptor- proctor-guided postgraduate "mini-residency" (M-R) experience in minimally invasive surgery. The initial results from the first 16 participants in the laparoscopic M-R modules are presented. PARTICIPANTS AND METHODS: On the first and the last day of the M-R, all participants underwent surgical skills testing using an open-surgery, standard laparoscopic, and robot-assisted laparoscopic format. A written examination was also administered on the last day. The influence of M-R on the participants' practice pattern was then assessed by a follow-up questionnaire survey 1 to 7 months after their attendance. RESULTS: Data from the first 16 participants were analyzed. Of note, the score was significantly improved for only one of the four tested laparoscopic skills (i.e., threading a suture through loops). Nonetheless, on the follow-up survey, of the 15 respondents, two laparoscopically naïve participants had performed laparoscopic nephrectomy, and of the eight participants who had prior renal-ablative laparoscopic experience, four had performed advanced reconstructive laparoscopic cases. CONCLUSIONS: A 5-day dedicated postgraduate M-R in laparoscopy appears to be helpful for urologists wishing to incorporate this surgical approach into their practices. The "take rate" among participants is initially at the 40% level, similar to what has been previously reported after a 1 to 2-day hands-on didactic laparoscopy course.

Current trends in urologic laparoscopic surgery.

PURPOSE: We examined the status of laparoscopy in urology and the impact of residency and fellowship training on the performance of laparoscopy as primary surgeon. We also examined whether performing nonsurgical tasks requiring two-handed dexterity had any link to the adoption of laparoscopic techniques by urologists. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 8760 laparoscopy questionnaires containing 135 queries were mailed to urologists listed on the American Urological Association practicing urologists mailing list. The questions sought information on area of practice, time in practice, fellowship training, ambidexterity, laparoscopic experience, and experience with robotics. The response rate was 1.8% (155 of 8760). RESULTS: There appeared to be no significant correlation between the performance of laparoscopic surgery and participation in activities requiring bimanual dexterity. However, a correlation of strong statistical significance did exist between laparoscopic residency training and performance of laparoscopy after residency (p=0.003. There also was a correlation between fellowship training in laparoscopy/endourology and doing laparoscopy as primary surgeon. CONCLUSIONS: Participation in laparoscopic surgery during residency training is a major determining factor in performance of laparoscopy as a primary surgeon in practice. Younger surgeons trained in laparoscopy during residency are performing more laparoscopy post residency than those without laparoscopic training during residency. At present, there is a need to train more urologists in laparoscopy at the postgraduate level.

Role of robotics in laparoscopic urologic surgery.

Robotic surgery is in its infancy. Small series of cases are emerging from various centers that indicate a strong role for robotics in the future of urology, surgery, and general medicine. Robotic technology is progressing on every level and will continue to be a driving force in the progress of science and medicine.

Ureteroscopes: flexible, rigid, and semirigid.

Since its introduction, the ureteroscope has undergone significant improvements. Using the currently available rigid, semirigid, and flexible ureteroscopes and working instruments, urologists can diagnose and treat lesions throughout the upper urinary tract. Over the past 25 years, the ureteroscope in combination with shock wave lithotripsy has transformed the diagnosis and treatment of more than 90% of upper urinary tract pathology from an open to an endourologic procedure. With endoscope manufacturers continually incorporating new technology into their ureteroscopes, future models will undoubtedly provide better optics, increased durability, and improved capabilities, resulting in greater success when urologists perform endoscopic forays into the upper urinary tract.

Comparison of the Ti-knot device and Hem-o-lok clips with other devices commonly used for laparoscopic renal-artery ligation.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: New devices such as the Ti-knot and Hem-o-lok clips have been developed for laparoscopic surgical applications. We compared the effectiveness of Ti-knot TK5 (LSI Solutions), Hem-o-lok MLK clips (Weck Closure), Ligaclip 5-mm titanium clips (Ethicon), and Endopath vascular staples (35 mm long, 12.3 mm wide) (Ethicon). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Renal artery segments from 5 to 6 mm in diameter were harvested from fresh porcine kidneys. One end of the vessel was intubated with a 25-gauge ball-tipped needle and fastened with two silk ties. The other end was occluded with one of the test devices. Saline was infused into each arterial segment at 3 mL/min with the maximum pump pressure at 800 mm Hg. The maximum pressure with leakage was recorded. Each of the five test devices was tested eight times on a rotating basis. Saline infusion was stopped when the maximum pump pressure was reached or when leakage was observed. RESULTS: All Ti-knot devices, Hem-o-lok clips, titanium metal clips, and standard hand ties tolerated pressures >800 mm Hg with no leakage, but 4 of the 8 vascular staple lines (50%) leaked before this maximum pump pressure was reached. For those that leaked, the mean leak pressure was 273 mm Hg (range 237-322 mm Hg). CONCLUSIONS: All devices tested are capable of occluding renal arteries under physiologic conditions. Ti-knot devices and Hem-o-lok clips occluded renal arteries to pressures that exceeded 800 mm Hg. They are equivalent to hand ties under supraphysiologic conditions.

One-knot pyeloplasty.

Laparoscopic pyeloplasty represents one of the more advanced reconstructive procedures for the urologist. While early reports were replete with long operative times, there have been several changes that have added to the efficiency of the procedure. In our practice, we have found three changes to be of greatest value: (1) an upper-midline port placement; (2) use of a continuous suture for the anastomosis with a double-armed, knotted suture; and (3) antegrade stent placement.

Preventing perioperative complications of robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy.

OBJECTIVE: To report the change in complication rates after the identification and modification of technique to reduce their incidence during robot-assisted radical prostatectomy (RARP). METHODS: This study retrospectively reviewed 1000 consecutive patients who underwent RARP from June 2002 to June 2011. A number of technical changes were made after complications were noted and changes in technique were documented. The Fisher exact test and multivariate analysis were used for comparison of techniques, and values of P <.05 were considered significant. RESULTS: The overall rate of major and minor complications was 10.8% (108 of 1000). The complication rates of lymphoceles (0.4%), ileus (0.4%), and wound infection (0.4%) were low and did not require technical changes. There were no significant changes in rates of femoral nerve palsies, rectal injuries, or bladder neck contractures. There was statistically significant change in corneal abrasions (P = .03), fossa navicularis strictures (P = .03), and camera-site hernias (P <.001) after a directed intervention adjusted for age, body mass index, and learning curve. Clavien 3 and 4 complications all significantly decreased to ≤ 0.6%, with the most occurring in the first 200 cases. CONCLUSION: Identification and correction of perioperative complications in patients undergoing robotic prostatectomy has decreased the incidence of major and minor complications adjusted for learning curve. The conscientious monitoring of adverse events can provide targeted change in technique to decrease complications and provide information to those early in learning robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy.

The impact of robotics on treatment of localized prostate cancer and resident education in Rochester, New York.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Robot-assisted radical prostatectomy (RARP) has been performed in Rochester, NY, since 2003. Currently, 10 area urologists perform RARP, and robotic training has become an important component of the residency. We present data describing the timeline for adoption, both in clinical practice and in the residency program. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We reviewed the operating logs for all surgeons who were performing prostatectomies in all hospitals in Rochester, NY, from 2003 to 2007. We examined the influence RARP had on other treatments, including brachytherapy and cryotherapy. Surgical logs of graduating chief residents were also reviewed. RESULTS: Eleven surgeons in Rochester regularly perform radical prostatectomy (10 perform primarily RARP, one performs only open prostatectomy). Three of the city's four hospitals have robotic systems. In 2003-2004, there were 30 open prostatectomies performed monthly and fewer than 10 performed robotically. By 2006, the trend was reversed, with 50 robot-assisted prostatectomies performed each month and fewer than 10 open prostatectomies (P<0.05). The rate of brachytherapy fluctuated, increasing in centers without a robot. The number of open prostatectomies in centers without a robot dropped significantly to fewer than 10 cases per year. There was also a significant decrease in the number of open prostatectomies performed by chief residents. CONCLUSIONS: Since the introduction of surgical robotics, significant changes have been seen. The volume of radical prostatectomies performed by surgeons at institutions with robotics has increased; the volume at robot-free institutions has become nominal. There is a trend toward increased radiation therapy at robot-free institutions. While radical prostatectomies logged by graduating chief residents have increased, open prostatectomy experience is now minimal.

Evaluation of long-term thermal injury using cautery during nerve sparing robotic prostatectomy.

OBJECTIVE: In our initial 125 cases, we used cautery during preservation of the neurovascular bundles (NVBs). We previously reported the short-term benefit of a cautery-free versus cautery technique. To assess long-term consequences of cautery, we report 2-year potency outcomes for these robot-assisted laparoscopic radical prostatectomies (RLP). METHODS: Between June 2002 and February 2004, 125 consecutive patients underwent RLP by 1 surgeon. All data were entered prospectively into an electronic database. In cases 1 to 15, the vascular pedicle and nerve were dissected with monopolar cautery. In cases 16 to 125, the dissection used bipolar cautery and scissors. Preoperatively, 42 met inclusion criteria: age younger than 66 years, International Index of Erectile Function (IIEF-5) of 22 to 25 and uni (12) or bilateral (35) nerve sparing. Postoperatively all patients were encouraged to use 5-PDE inhibitors. Potency was assessed by self-administered validated questionnaires. RESULTS: Four were excluded because of treatment intervention (3) or refusal to follow-up (1). Thirty-eight have follow-up data of 24 or more months. At 3, 9, and 15 months only 3 of 36 (8.3%), 5 of 34 (14.7%), and 16 of 37 (43.2%) were potent. However at 24+ months, 5 of 10 (50%) of unilateral and 19 of 28 bilateral nerve-sparing (68%) were potent with an average IIEF-5 of 18.4 and erectile firmness of 75% to 100% of baseline. CONCLUSION: These findings suggest that in addition to other injury, thermal injury to the NVB is dense with very low recovery rates in the first 12 to 18 months. However, with nearly two-thirds ultimately reporting potency return, these injuries are generally not permanent and recovery approaches 75% to 100% of baseline.