Polyanionic agents as inhibitors of phagosome-lysosome fusion in cultured macrophages: evolution of an alternative interpretation.

Various natural and synthetic substances classified as polyanionics have been implicated in antagonizing phagosome-lysosome fusion in cultured macrophages. The phenomenon has been judged by comparing the transfer of selected markers from secondary lysosomes to phagosomes in control and in "polyanion" cells. Our earlier studies showed that use of one of the markers, the membrane-permeating acridine orange, was plagued with artifacts that were especially misleading in the presence of polyanionic agents. We now question the validity of data obtained by the alternative technique, electron microscopy. Our present evidence shows that nonionic hydrocolloids of sufficiently high molecular weight prevent the transfer of various colloidal electron-opaque markers from lysosomes to phagosomes in the same manner as does the powerful polyanionic "fusion inhibitor" dextran sulfate. Both kinds of hydrocolloids, however, allow delivery of lysosomal, low-molecular-weight highly charged non-permeant fluorescent markers to phagosomes, probably by a fusion process. We propose that neither type of hydrocolloid inhibits fusion; instead, when sufficiently concentrated, they trap particulate electron-opaque markers in a gelatinous matrix, which may move only slowly out of lysosomes. The polyanionics trap the electron-opaque markers physically and acridine orange ionically. Hence, the semblance of "fusion inhibition."

Polyanionic agents do not inhibit phagosome-lysosome fusion in cultured macrophages.

The survival of some intracellular pathogens within macrophages may be aided by an ability of the organism to antagonize, from within the entrapping phagosome, its fusion with lysosomes. On the other hand, certain polyanionic agents have been implicated in imposing a similar block to fusion from the lysosomal domain--because the transfer of various foreign markers from lysosomes to newly formed phagosomes is remarkably inhibited in these polyanion-containing cells. Based on an analysis of various observations and our own recent data, we propose that the polyanionics do not, in fact, prevent phagosome-lysosome fusion but, instead, physically entrap the usual markers in a gelatinous matrix within the lysosomes. This view accounts for many paradoxical consequences of polyanionic accumulation and for the curiously normal behavior of macrophages that are presumed to be suffering from such a crucial intracellular dysfunction.

Fluorescent markers for studying phagosome-lysosome fusion.

Lysosomotropic fluorescent aminoacridines such as acridine orange and quinacrine have achieved prominence as markers for studying lysosome-phagosomes fusion, especially in macrophages. Experiments described demonstrate that because the aminoacridines traverse biological membranes with facility, they diffuse throughout the system, and ultimately accumulate intra- or extracellularly where they are most efficiently bound. Their presence or absence in phagosomes is therefore not unequivocally indicative of fusion or nonfusion. Alternative fluorescent lysosomal markers are described, and systems defined for which the aminoacridines may probably be used with confidence.