Adaptive Supramolecular Networks: Emergent Sensing from Complex Systems.

Molecular differentiation by supramolecular sensors is typically achieved through sensor arrays, relying on the pattern recognition responses of large panels of isolated sensing elements. Here we report a new one-pot systems chemistry approach to differential sensing in biological solutions. We constructed an adaptive network of three cross-assembling sensor elements with diverse analyte-binding and photophysical properties. This robust sensing approach exploits complex interconnected sensor-sensor and sensor-analyte equilibria, producing emergent supramolecular and photophysical responses unique to each analyte. We characterize the basic mechanisms by which an adaptive network responds to analytes. The inherently data-rich responses of an adaptive network discriminate among very closely related proteins and protein mixtures without relying on designed protein recognition elements. We show that a single adaptive sensing solution provides better analyte discrimination using fewer response observations than a sensor array built from the same components. We also show the network's ability to adapt and respond to changing biological solutions over time.

Binding Methylarginines and Methyllysines as Free Amino Acids: A Comparative Study of Multiple Host Classes.

Methylated free amino acids are an important class of targets for host-guest chemistry that have recognition properties distinct from those of methylated peptides and proteins. We present comparative binding studies for three different host classes that are each studied with multiple methylated arginines and lysines to determine fundamental structure-function relationships. The hosts studied are all anionic and include three calixarenes, two acyclic cucurbiturils, and two other cleft-like hosts, a clip and a tweezer. We determined the binding association constants for a panel of methylated amino acids using indicator displacement assays. The acyclic cucurbiturils display stronger binding to the methylated amino acids, and some unique patterns of selectivity. The two other cleft-like hosts follow two different trends, shallow host (clip) following similar trends to the calixarenes, and the other more closed host (tweezer) binding certain less-methylated amino acids stronger than their methylated counterparts. Molecular modelling sheds some light on the different preferences of the various hosts. The results identify hosts with new selectivities and with affinities in a range that could be useful for biomedical applications. The overall selectivity patterns are explained by a common framework that considers the geometry, depth of binding pockets, and functional group participation across all host classes.

Molecular recognition of methylated amino acids and peptides by Pillar[6]MaxQ.

We report the molecular recognition properties of Pillar[n]MaxQ (P[n]MQ) toward a series of (methylated) amino acids, amino acid amides, and post-translationally modified peptides by a combination of 1H NMR, isothermal titration calorimetry, indicator displacement assays, and molecular dynamics simulations. We find that P6MQ is a potent receptor for N-methylated amino acid side chains. P6MQ recognized the H3K4Me3 peptide with Kd = 16 nM in phosphate buffered saline.

Host-guest binding in water, salty water, and biofluids: general lessons for synthetic, bio-targeted molecular recognition.

Synthetic molecular recognition systems are increasingly being used to solve applied problems in the life sciences, and bio-targeted host-guest chemistry has rapidly arisen as a major field of fundamental research. This tutorial review presents a set of fundamental lessons on how host-guest molecular recognition can be programmed in water. The review uses informative examples of aqueous host-guest chemistry organized around generalizable themes and lessons, building towards lessons focused on molecular recognition in salty solutions and biological fluids. It includes selected examples of macrocyclic host systems that work well, as well as common pitfalls and how to avoid them. The review closes with a survey of the most important and inspirational recent advances, which involve host-guest chemistry in living cells and organisms.

Template-Directed Synthesis of Bivalent, Broad-Spectrum Hosts for Neuromuscular Blocking Agents.

We report on the synthesis of bivalent water-soluble calix[4]arene and calix[5]arene hosts, Super-sCx4 and Super-sCx5 as new broad-spectrum supramolecular binders of neuromuscular blocking agents (NMBAs). Synthesis was achieved using the target bisquaternary amine NMBAs as a template to link two highly anionic p-sulfonatocalixarene building blocks in aqueous solution. Bivalent anionic hosts Super-sCx4 and Super-sCx5 bind by engaging both quaternary amines present on a variety of NMBAs. We report low µM binding to structurally diverse alkyl, steroidal, curarine and benzylisoquinoline NMBAs with high selectivity over the neurotransmitter acetylcholine and a variety of other hydrophobic amines.

Mechanism of a Disassembly-Driven Sensing System Studied by Stopped-Flow Kinetics.

We carried out steady-state and stopped-flow photophysical measurements to determine the kinetics of a discrete disassembly driven turn-on fluorescent system. On and off rates for both DimerDye1 assembly and nicotine binding were determined. Relative rates for these competing processes provide insight on how this system can be optimized for sensing applications. Kinetics studies in artificial saliva showed that moving to more complex media has minimal effects on the sensing ability of the system.

An easily accessible, lower rim substituted calix[4]arene selectively binds N,N-dimethyllysine.

Post-translational modifications (PTMs) are critical controllers of protein functions. One set of important PTMs are N-methylated side chains of lysine and arginine, which exist in several functionally distinct forms. Multiple groups have demonstrated the selective binding of the most hydrophobic family member, trimethyllysine (Kme3), using various macrocyclic hosts, but the selective binding of lower methylation states remains challenging. Herein we report that the installation of a sulfonate ester on the lower rim phenol of p-sulfonatocalix[4]arene efficiently generates a potent, N,N-dimethyllysine (Kme2)-selective host in one step from commercially available starting materials. We characterize its binding behaviors in solution, and examine the relationship between its unusual conformational dynamics and its guest-binding properties.

Pan-specific and partially selective dye-labeled peptidic inhibitors of the polycomb paralog proteins.

Epigenetic regulation of gene expression is in part controlled by post-translational modifications on histone proteins. Histone methylation is a key epigenetic mark that controls gene transcription and repression. There are five human polycomb paralog proteins (Cbx2/4/6/7/8) that use their chromodomains to recognize trimethylated lysine 27 on histone 3 (H3K27me3). Recognition of the methyllysine side chain is achieved through multiple cation-pi interactions within an 'aromatic cage' motif. Despite high structural similarity within the chromodomains of this protein family, they each have unique functional roles and are linked to different cancers. Selective inhibition of different CBX proteins is desirable for both fundamental studies and potential therapeutic applications. We report here on a series of peptidic inhibitors that target certain polycomb paralogs. We have identified peptidic scaffolds with sub-micromolar potency, and will report examples that are pan-specific and that are partially selective for individual members within the family. These results highlight important structure-activity relationships that allow for differential binding to be achieved through interactions outside of the methyllysine-binding aromatic cage motif.

Parallel Synthesis and Screening of Supramolecular Chemosensors That Achieve Fluorescent Turn-on Detection of Drugs in Saliva.

Programming and controlling molecular recognition in aqueous solutions is increasingly common, but creating supramolecular sensors that detect analytes in biologically relevant solutions remains a nontrivial task. We report here a parallel synthesis-driven approach to create a family of self-assembling dimeric sensors that we call DimerDyes and its use for the rapid identification of salt-tolerant sensors for illicit drugs. We developed an efficient method that involves parallel synthesis and screening in crude form without the need to purify each potential sensor. Structurally diverse "hit" DimerDyes were resynthesized and purified and were each shown to assemble into homodimers in water in the programmed way. DimerDyes provided a "turn-on" fluorescence detection of multiple illicit drugs at low micromolar concentrations in water and in saliva. The combination of multiple agents into a sensor array was successfully able to detect and discriminate between closely related drugs and metabolites in multiple important drug families.

Using reversible non-covalent and covalent bonds to create assemblies and equilibrating molecular networks that survive 5 molar urea.

The limits of self-assembly and host-guest chemistry in water solutions containing competitive solutes are largely unexplored. We report here a new family of self-assembling systems that are stitched together at two levels by reversible hydrazone bonds and by non-covalent self-assembly in strongly denaturing conditions. Three different hydrazides of various charge and hydrophobicity are combined with an aldehyde-containing calixarene, and each system spontaneously forms AB hydrazones that subsequently self-assemble into four-component (AB)2 structures in water. The assemblies display varying responses to added NaCl and/or urea. The most robust assembly survives completely intact in solution up to 5 M urea. We also combine the aldehyde calixarene with two different hydrazides in the same tube to create complex, competitive dynamic libraries. We report experiments in which the composition of the dynamic equilibrating library is under the control of self-assembly, allowing the systems to choose the components that form the most stable assemblies under a variety of competitive solutions conditions. These dynamic networks of equilibrating molecules maintain remarkably similar equilibrium positions under widely varying concentrations of urea and NaCl.

KdgF, the missing link in the microbial metabolism of uronate sugars from pectin and alginate.

Uronates are charged sugars that form the basis of two abundant sources of biomass-pectin and alginate-found in the cell walls of terrestrial plants and marine algae, respectively. These polysaccharides represent an important source of carbon to those organisms with the machinery to degrade them. The microbial pathways of pectin and alginate metabolism are well studied and essentially parallel; in both cases, unsaturated monouronates are produced and processed into the key metabolite 2-keto-3-deoxygluconate (KDG). The enzymes required to catalyze each step have been identified within pectinolytic and alginolytic microbes; yet the function of a small ORF, kdgF, which cooccurs with the genes for these enzymes, is unknown. Here we show that KdgF catalyzes the conversion of pectin- and alginate-derived 4,5-unsaturated monouronates to linear ketonized forms, a step in uronate metabolism that was previously thought to occur spontaneously. Using enzyme assays, NMR, mutagenesis, and deletion of kdgF, we show that KdgF proteins from both pectinolytic and alginolytic bacteria catalyze the ketonization of unsaturated monouronates and contribute to efficient production of KDG. We also report the X-ray crystal structures of two KdgF proteins and propose a mechanism for catalysis. The discovery of the function of KdgF fills a 50-y-old gap in the knowledge of uronate metabolism. Our findings have implications not only for the understanding of an important metabolic pathway, but also the role of pectinolysis in plant-pathogen virulence and the growing interest in the use of pectin and alginate as feedstocks for biofuel production.

Analyte-Driven Disassembly and Turn-On Fluorescent Sensing in Competitive Biological Media.

Many indicator displacement assays can detect biological analytes in water, but these often have reduced performance in the presence of an unavoidable component: NaCl. We report here a new self-assembled sensor, DimerDye, that uses a novel photochemical guest-sensing mechanism and that is intrinsically tolerant of cosolutes. We synthetically integrated a dye into a calixarene macrocycle, forming two new merocyanine calixarenes (MCx-1 and MCx-2). Both compounds self-assemble into nonemissive dimers in water. The addition of good guests like trimethyllysine induces a turn-on fluorescence response of MCx-1 due to simultaneous dimer dissociation and formation of an emissive host-guest complex. DimerDyes remain functional in solutions containing the various salts, metal ions, and cofactors that are needed for enzymatic reactions. MCx-1 provides a real-time, turn-on fluorescence signal in response to the lysine methyltransferase reaction of PRDM9.

Aza-amino acid scanning of chromobox homolog 7 (CBX7) ligands.

An aza-amino acid scan of peptide inhibitors of the chromobox homolog 7 (CBX7) was performed to study the conformational requirements for affinity to the methyllysine reader protein. Twelve azapeptide analogues were prepared using three different approaches employing respectively N-(Fmoc)aza-amino acid chlorides and submonomer azapeptide synthesis to install systematically aza-residues at the first four residues of the peptide, as well as to provide aza-lysine residues possessing saturated and unsaturated side chains. The aza-peptide ligands were evaluated in a chromobox homolog 7 binding assay, providing useful insight into structural requirements for affinity. Copyright © 2017 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Chemical Inhibitors of Epigenetic Methyllysine Reader Proteins.

Protein methylation is a common post-translational modification with diverse biological functions. Methyllysine reader proteins are increasingly a focus of epigenetics research and play important roles in regulating many cellular processes. These reader proteins are vital players in development, cell cycle regulation, stress responses, oncogenesis, and other disease pathways. The recent emergence of a small number of chemical inhibitors for methyllysine reader proteins supports the viability of these proteins as targets for drug development. This article introduces the biochemistry and biology of methyllysine reader proteins, provides an overview of functions for those families of readers that have been targeted to date (MBT, PHD, tudor, and chromodomains), and reviews the development of synthetic agents that directly block their methyllysine reading functions.

Molecular Insights into Inhibition of the Methylated Histone-Plant Homeodomain Complexes by Calixarenes.

Plant homeodomain (PHD) finger-containing proteins are implicated in fundamental biological processes, including transcriptional activation and repression, DNA damage repair, cell differentiation, and survival. The PHD finger functions as an epigenetic reader that binds to posttranslationally modified or unmodified histone H3 tails, recruiting catalytic writers and erasers and other components of the epigenetic machinery to chromatin. Despite the critical role of the histone-PHD interaction in normal and pathological processes, selective inhibitors of this association have not been well developed. Here we demonstrate that macrocyclic calixarenes can disrupt binding of PHD fingers to methylated lysine 4 of histone H3 in vitro and in vivo. The inhibitory activity relies on differences in binding affinities of the PHD fingers for H3K4me and the methylation state of the histone ligand, whereas the composition of the aromatic H3K4me-binding site of the PHD fingers appears to have no effect. Our approach provides a novel tool for studying the biological roles of methyllysine readers in epigenetic signaling.

Supramolecular Affinity Chromatography for Methylation-Targeted Proteomics.

Proteome-wide studies of post-translationally methylated species using mass spectrometry are complicated by high sample diversity, competition for ionization among peptides, and mass redundancies. Antibody-based enrichment has powered methylation proteomics until now, but the reliability, pan-specificity, polyclonal nature, and stability of the available pan-specific antibodies are problematic and do not provide a standard, reliable platform for investigators. We have invented an anionic supramolecular host that can form host-guest complexes selectively with methyllysine-containing peptides and used it to create a methylysine-affinity column. The column resolves peptides on the basis of methylation-a feat impossible with a comparable commercial cation-exchange column. A proteolyzed nuclear extract was separated on the methyl-affinity column prior to standard proteomics analysis. This experiment demonstrates that such chemical methyl-affinity columns are capable of enriching and improving the analysis of methyllysine residues from complex protein mixtures. We discuss the importance of this advance in the context of biomolecule-driven enrichment methods.

Salicylates are interference compounds in TR-FRET assays.

Given the importance of high-throughput screening in drug discovery, the identification of compounds that interfere with assay readouts is crucial. The pursuit of false positives wastes time and money, while distracting development teams from more promising leads. In the context of TR-FRET assays, most interfering compounds are dyes or aggregators. In the course of our studies on the PD1-PDL2 interaction, we discovered that salicylic acids, an extremely common compound subclass in screening libraries, interfere with TR-FRET assays. While the precise mechanism of interference was not established, our data suggest that interaction of the salicylate with the cryptand-ligated europium FRET donor is responsible for the change in assay signal.

Inhibition of histone binding by supramolecular hosts.

The tandem PHD (plant homeodomain) fingers of the CHD4 (chromodomain helicase DNA-binding protein 4) ATPase are epigenetic readers that bind either unmodified histone H3 tails or H3K9me3 (histone H3 trimethylated at Lys9). This dual function is necessary for the transcriptional and chromatin remodelling activities of the NuRD (nucleosome remodelling and deacetylase) complex. In the present paper, we show that calixarene-based supramolecular hosts disrupt binding of the CHD4 PHD2 finger to H3K9me3, but do not affect the interaction of this protein with the H3K9me0 (unmodified histone H3) tail. A similar inhibitory effect, observed for the association of chromodomain of HP1γ (heterochromatin protein 1γ) with H3K9me3, points to a general mechanism of methyl-lysine caging by calixarenes and suggests a high potential for these compounds in biochemical applications. Immunofluorescence analysis reveals that the supramolecular agents induce changes in chromatin organization that are consistent with their binding to and disruption of H3K9me3 sites in living cells. The results of the present study suggest that the aromatic macrocyclic hosts can be used as a powerful new tool for characterizing methylation-driven epigenetic mechanisms.

The cation-π interaction at protein-protein interaction interfaces: developing and learning from synthetic mimics of proteins that bind methylated lysines.

First discovered over 60 years ago, post-translational methylation was considered an irreversible modification until the initial discoveries of demethylase enzymes in 2004. Now researchers understand that this process serves as a dynamic and complex control mechanism that is misregulated in numerous diseases. Lysine methylation is most often found on histone proteins and can effect gene regulation, epigenetic inheritance, and cancer. Because of this connection to disease, many enzymes responsible for methylation are considered targets for new cancer therapies. Although our understanding of the biology of post-translational methylation has advanced at an astonishing rate within the last 5 years, chemical approaches for studying and disrupting these pathways are only now gaining momentum. In general, enzymes methylate lysine and arginine residues with very high specificity for both the location and methylation state. Each methylated target serves as the focused hot spot for an inducible protein-protein interaction (PPI). Conceptually, lysine or arginine methylation is a subtle modification that leads to no change in charge and small changes in size, but it significantly alters the hydration energies and hydrogen bonding potential of these side chains. Nature has evolved a special motif for recognizing the methylation states of lysine, called the "aromatic cage", a collection of aromatic protein residues, often accompanied by one or more neighboring anionic residues. The combination of favorable cation-π, electrostatic, and van der Waals interactions, as well as size matching, gives these proteins a high degree of specificity for the methylation state. This Account summarizes the development of various supramolecular host system scaffolds developed to recognize and bind to ammonium cations, such as trimethyllysine, on the basis of their methylation state. Early systems bound to their targets in pure, buffered water but failed to achieve biochemically relevant affinities and selectivities. Surprisingly, the use of the simple and very well-known p-sulfonatocalix[4]arene provides protein-like affinities and selectivities for trimethyllysine in water. New analogs, created by synthetic modification of the same scaffold, allow for further tuning of affinities and selectivities for trimethyllysine. Our studies of each family of hosts paint a consistent picture: cation-π interactions and electrostatics are important, and solvation effects are complex. Rigidity is especially important for host-guest systems that function in pure water. Despite their simplicity, synthetic systems that take these lessons into account can achieve affinities that rival or surpass those of their naturally evolved counterparts. The stage is now set for the next act: the use of such compounds as tunable and adaptable tools for modern chemical biology.

Minimalist synthetic host with stacked guanidinium ions mimics the weakened hydration shells of protein-protein interaction interfaces.

Protein surfaces are complex solutes, and protein-protein interactions are specifically mediated by surface motifs that modulate solvation shells in poorly understood ways. We report herein a supramolecular host that is designed to mimic one of the most important recognition motifs that drives protein-protein interactions, the stacked arginine side chain. We show that it binds its guests and displays good selectivity in the highly competitive medium of pure, buffered water. We use a combination of experimental studies of binding and molecular dynamics simulations to build a cohesive picture of how this biomimetic host achieves the feat. The presence of the stacking element next to the guanidinium groups causes a decrease in the number of host-water hydrogen bonds, a decrease in the density of water around the host, and a decrease in water-water hydrogen bonds near the host. Experimental data using mixed organic/aqueous solvent systems confirm that this host relies on the hydrophobic effect in a way that the two control hosts do not. Our simulations and analysis provide detailed information on the linkage between (de)hydration and binding events in water in a way that could be applied to many aqueous supramolecular systems.