Insight Into the Clinical Practices of US-based Surgical Nongovernmental Organizations.

INTRODUCTION: A growing sector of humanitarian surgical nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) is providing care in low- and middle-income countries. Minimal data exists regarding this extremely heterogeneous community. This study aims to describe the demographics and clinical practices of surgical NGOs. We hypothesize there are identifiable attributes of such organizations which correlate with success. METHODS: A survey was sent to 83 US-based surgical NGOs directly providing general or subspecialty surgical care in low- and middle-income countries. Further information was obtained from organizations' websites. Descriptive statistics were performed to analyze organizational attributes and define protocol-driven practices. RESULTS: Thirty NGOs (36%) responded, averaging 20 ± 11 y of operation. Annually, US humanitarian surgical organizations performed a wide range of operations (10-15,000) with 52% performing fewer than 200 operations per year. Sixty-seven percent of responders were classified as strongly protocol-driven. Only twenty percent reported deviation from standard US practice occurs often or very often, most commonly in pain management (18%), preoperative workup (16%), and operative technique (16%). CONCLUSIONS: To our knowledge, this is the first effort to describe the characteristics and clinical practices of the humanitarian surgical sector. There exists a wide scope of clinical practice among responding surgical NGOs, however mostly consistent with US standards, with a prevalance of protocol-driven clinical approach. Developing consensus-based protocols may help standardize and improve quality of care for surgical NGOs.

Train the Trainer in Bleeding Control: A Two-Year Pilot Study in Low-Income and Middle-Income Countries.

INTRODUCTION: Traumatic hemorrhage represents a major cause of mortality in low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs). Thus, LMICs can benefit from improvements to prehospital hemorrhage management. One strategy is implementation of a bleeding control course using the "train the trainer" model (TTT) to increase course availability. The Stop the Bleed (STB) campaign provides laypeople with basic knowledge and skills of hemorrhage control. While the feasibility and success of the STB course have been demonstrated in the United States, course dissemination in LMICs has been slower and its feasibility using the TTT model has not been established. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From December 2017 to January 2019, instructors from the International Surgical Health Initiative conducted seven surgical humanitarian trips and taught 10 index 1-h STB training sessions across six LMICs. LMIC instructors were encouraged to continue providing STB courses following departure of the visiting instructors. Course data were collected from sign-in sheets and analyzed using Microsoft Excel. RESULTS: Ten index courses conducted by United States-trained STB experts trained 35 LMIC instructors over 2 y. Six of 35 offered 12 additional courses, certifying 323 new trainees, an 823% increase from the initial cohort. Overall, implementation of the TTT model yielded 22 STB courses in six LMICs, producing 358 new trainees. CONCLUSIONS: This pilot study shows the STB TTT model was feasible and effective in expanding bleeding control trainer capacity in four of six LMICs. Use of the TTT model in LMICs may represent a means to increase STB course availability and is one strategy to improve prehospital hemorrhage control in LMICs.

Long-Term Follow-Up of Humanitarian Surgeries: Outcomes and Patient Satisfaction in Rural Ghana.

BACKGROUND: Nongovernmental organizations conduct short-term surgical outreach to lessen the substantial global burden of surgical disease. Long-term outcomes of short-term surgical missions (STSMs) are underreported, raising concern for clinical sequelae and patient satisfaction with essential general surgeries. This study aims to describe long-term follow-up results of one general surgical nongovernmental organization's provision of care in rural Ghana with focus on patient-related outcomes and satisfaction. METHODS: From 2013 to 2018, Tetteh Quarshie Memorial Hospital in Mampong, Ghana, was the host site of annual 1-wk International Surgical Health Initiative (ISHI) STSMs. Beginning in 2016, an ISHI provider-hosted follow-up clinics augmented by mobile telephone support. Surgical patients from 2013 to 2016 were contacted by the local nursing staff and evaluated for long-term outcomes and self-reported satisfaction. RESULTS: Sixty-nine of 256 patients (27%) responded; 39 patients (57%) were interviewed and examined by an ISHI physician, whereas 30 patients (43%) received mobile telephone follow-up. Mean age was 47 (±18) y, with 44% female patients, and mean duration of follow-up was 1.5 (±1) y. Eleven patients (16%) had surgical and anesthesia complications. All patients reported improvement in symptoms and activity level. Eighty-six patients reported complete satisfaction (5/5). Factors associated with reduced patient satisfaction (<5/5) included increased age and complications. CONCLUSIONS: To our knowledge, this is one of the first studies focusing on patient-reported outcomes for the evaluation of long-term follow-up of general surgery STSMs. With mobile technology, long-term follow-up is achievable toward obtaining meaningful outcomes. Complications in this series are within an acceptable range, whereas symptom improvement and overall satisfaction are high.

Integrating Bleeding Control Training Into Surgical Missions in Low- and Middle-Income Countries.

BACKGROUND: Basic bleeding control (BCon) techniques can save lives globally but the knowledge is not widespread in low-income countries where trauma is a common cause of death. Short-term surgical missions (STSMs) are an effective route to share this public health initiative around the world. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Over 2017-2018, the International Surgical Health Initiative organized STSMs to locations in Sierra Leone, Bangladesh, Peru, and Ghana. The hour-long official American College of Surgeons Basic Bleeding Control course was offered to host participants several times over the course of the mission. Data including number and size of classes, type of trainee, instructors trained, and success rate in demonstrating acquisition of core BCon principles and techniques were collected. RESULTS: Over the course of four, week-long STSMs, 748 people were successfully trained in BCon over 27 sessions, with an average of 28 trainees and up to four instructors per class. One-hundred percent of trainees demonstrated acquisition of required skills proficiency. Trainees included health care workers and those in public security roles. CONCLUSIONS: Concurrent with a short-term surgical mission, a substantial number of health care providers and would-be bystanders can be trained in BCon in countries most impacted by trauma. Local instructors can be trained to teach BCon independently to sustain the initiative. STSMs are a feasible modality to teach bleeding control techniques to an international audience that does not have rapid access to effective prehospital care.

Gender Equity in Humanitarian Surgical Outreach: A Decade of Volunteer Surgeons.

BACKGROUND: Workforce trends in surgery demonstrate persistent gender inequity. Humanitarian surgical outreach opportunities exist for surgeons; however, it is unclear as to whether gender disparities exist in this arena. This pilot study examines gender equity among volunteer surgeons using a decade of compiled data from a surgical nongovernmental organization (NGO) that hosts multinational surgical outreach. We aim to evaluate gender proportions among surgical volunteers, compare the gender profiles of NGO surgeons with local and nationwide cohorts, and examine the productive output of surgical volunteers by gender. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective review was conducted of the records of the International Surgical Health Initiative, an NGO that hosts short-term surgical missions, to generate a demographic roster of volunteers between 2009 and 2018. Comparisons were made of gender profiles within volunteer cohorts against local institutional data and nationwide surgical workforce data. Productivity outputs of surgical volunteers were compared. Chi-square tests and Wilcoxon two-sample statistical t-tests were used. RESULTS: A total of 23 short-term surgical trips were inclusive of 227 volunteers, and 61% (139) were female. Physicians were less likely to be female than other volunteers. In addition, nonsurgical volunteers were more likely to be female compared with surgical volunteers (67% versus 44%, P < 0.01). No gender differences were observed by average number of trips or propensity for repeat trips among surgical volunteers. No differences were found in proportions of female surgical attendings and residents in the NGO cohort compared with the local and national cohorts. CONCLUSIONS: Females contribute substantially to surgical outreach, representing more than half the volunteers in this organization. Gender profiles of female surgeons in this NGO are in parity with those of surgical attendings and residents in the national census. Male and female volunteer surgeons are equally productive. There is an equitable gender representation among volunteer surgeons in this NGO. Further studies of other surgical organizations participating in surgical outreach are required toward a more complete understanding of female participation in international humanitarian efforts.

Exploring residents' interest and career aspirations in global surgery.

BACKGROUND: Surgical residents increasingly seek global surgery (GS) experiences during training. Understanding their motives and goals is important to develop the optimal educational programs. A survey for surgical residents was developed to explore this interest. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A survey administered in 2016 to residents in three surgical programs within the same academic institution assessed interest, prior global health experience, preferred training opportunities, and career goals in GS. RESULTS: Seventy-four surgical residents responded (78%) with 82% expressing interest in GS and 86% motivated by a desire for volunteerism. International electives (65%) and volunteer missions (49%) were the preferred experiences during residency over longer commitments such as advanced degrees. A majority of residents planned to incorporate GS into their career (76%) most commonly by volunteering on missions (70%) with a smaller group aiming for a career in GS (13%). Residents with prior global health experience (n = 27, 36%) showed greater interest in GS (96% versus 72%, P = 0.02) and a commitment after residency (93% versus 68%, P = 0.02), and trended toward greater interest in GS careers (22% versus 6%, P = 0.06). CONCLUSIONS: Institutional interest in GS remains high among surgical residents, motivated primarily by a desire for volunteerism. Following training, most residents plan to participate in short-term volunteer commitments, though a small group envisions GS as part of their long-term career goals. Prior global health experience is associated with interest in GS both in the present and long term. Providing these experiences early may be a strategy to support academic interest.

A Post-donation Survey to Assess the Appropriateness of Medical Supply Donations to Freetown, Sierra Leone Following the Ebola Crisis.

The Recovery of Equipment for Capacity building OVERseas (RECOVER) initiative at Rutgers New Jersey Medical School involves collection and donation of clean and unused medical supplies that would otherwise be discarded to those desperately in need of those supplies abroad. RECOVER has recently responded to the aftermath of the Ebola crisis and the even more recent mudslide natural disaster in Freetown, Sierra Leone, which had resulted in a considerable diminishing of the local medical supplies. The goal of this study was to assess the match between donated supplies and local needs by using a post-donation survey. In December 2016, we conducted a pre-donation survey inquiring which of the supplies available from RECOVER were needed by four hospitals in Freetown. The survey also asked about specific barriers to keeping such supplies in stock. After each hospital received a shipment of supplies, we administered an online Qualtrics (Qualtrics, Provo, UT) follow-up survey intending to assess the appropriateness of the donated supplies. The survey asked about which wards used what supplies, most useful items, ability to sterilize, and whether the donation provided supplies that would otherwise need to be bought. Recipient hospitals reported the use of 90% of donated supplies. The most useful supplies were gowns, scalpels, gloves, and drapes; All recipients reported the ability to sterilize donated goods. Supplies were used in operating rooms, emergency rooms, and medical wards. Donated supplies provided hospitals with supplies that would typically need to be bought or that were unavailable in the region. No adverse events were reported related to the use of donated supplies. At first glance, our donations appear usable and appropriate for the recipients. We hope to provide a framework for an objective measure of need for hospitals in other low-income countries, using the Freetown post-Ebola crisis as a pilot for the assessment of medical supply donations and the longitudinal impact it can have on global health and surgery overseas. More studies are required to further explore the possible implications of our program including those relating to medical waste management and environmental considerations when donating and shipping disposable supplies to a developing country.

Short-term surgical missions in resource-limited environments: Five years of early surgical outcomes.

Outcomes of short-term surgical missions (STSMs) hosted in developing countries are underreported, raising quality concerns. This study aims to analyze early outcomes of one humanitarian surgical organization to show that safe essential general surgery can be provided in the context of STSMs. Records from 6 STSMs to Sierra Leone and Ghana were reviewed for early complications and analysis performed to identify associated factors. Missions performed elective, general surgery on low risk patients, with adherence to patient safety protocols. No perioperative mortality occurred from 372 procedures, most frequently inguinal hernia repair (54%). Seventeen surgical (5%), 3 infectious (1.2%), and 6 anesthesia (2%) complications were reported. Only younger age was significantly associated with complications. Essential general surgery can be performed safely on STSM assuming careful patient selection, avoidance of high-risk cases, and adherence to patient safety protocols. Data collection is feasible and should be undertaken to improve the quality of care.