Is forensic science in danger of extinction?

Observations of modern day forensic science has prompted asking the question of whether this field is in danger of extinction. Although there have undoubtedly been meaningful advancements in analytical capabilities, we have overlooked several unintended practical and philosophical consequences. This article addresses three main areas of concern: the declining role of the generalist in an era of increased specialization, the role of education in preparing the next generation of forensic scientists, and the implementation of advanced instrumentation with a focus on statistical significance and field deployable instrumentation.

LEGO Blocks as "Standard" Samples for Evaluation of Fluorescence Avoidance and Mitigation in Raman Spectroscopy.

Fluorescence interference in Raman spectroscopy is a well-known problem and is especially significant in portable instruments where the availability of a variety of exciting wavelengths is unlikely. Several fluorescence avoidance and mitigation schemes are described in the literature, and implemented by Raman spectrometer manufacturers, but there is no standard method for evaluating the accuracy and repeatability of these schemes. Some test samples shown in instrument descriptions, such as "dark rum" and "sesame seed oil" are not reproducible. Therefore, we propose a set of colored LEGO blocks as "standard" samples for this purpose; they have the attractive properties of being very low cost, rugged, non-toxic, easy to transport and store, and appear to be manufactured using a standard process. This paper shows the Raman spectra of a set of these blocks at different excitation wavelengths, acquired on laboratory instruments, along with their visible-near-infrared spectra. The goal is to qualitatively understand the origins of the observed fluorescence and lay the groundwork for exploring the effectiveness of methods currently implemented on handheld Raman instruments.

Evaluation of portable gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) for the analysis of fentanyl, fentanyl analogs, and other synthetic opioids.

Potent synthetic opioids including fentanyl and its analogs are frequently encountered in the field and require detection and identification by first responders to maintain the safety of drug abusers, first responders, health-care providers, and the public at large. Due to the low concentration at which these substances may be encountered and the complicating matrices within which they may be dispersed, the use of portable gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) for their identification in the field offers great potential value. This research established that portable GC-MS is a useful method for the detection and identification of a large number of synthetic opioids, especially fentanyl and its analogs. In this study, 250 synthetic opioids and related substances including 210 fentanyl analogs were analyzed using portable GC-MS. It was concluded that 225 of the 250 (90.0%) opioids analyzed were successfully detected onboard at the time of analysis and identified as either the substance (55.2%) or an analog (34.8%). These outcomes have equivalent benefit for the field analysis of illicit drugs due to both initiating the same subsequent actions by first responders.

The influence of biological sex on latent fingermark aging as examined by the color contrast technique.

This research further expands previous studies in which color contrast between ridges and furrows was examined as a possible age indicator for latent fingermarks. Here, the variable biological sex and its influence on aging were investigated. A total of 756 sebaceous-rich impressions from seven males and seven females were deposited on glass and polystyrene plastic and aged in the dark for three months. At nine discrete times, random fingermarks were visualized with a titanium dioxide-based powder (TiO2 ), photographed, and edited in Photoshop® to collect pixel color data. Two color contrast-related metrics, mean color intensity (MI) and intensity amplitude (IA), were analyzed to determine whether the aging processes of biological male and female fingermarks were equivalent. These metrics revealed that impressions from the different biological sexes behaved in a similar manner over time. However, significant effects between substrates were observed. Quadratic regression models best represented the aging trends based on the MI and IA metrics for both male and female fingermarks. The correlation coefficients (R) and coefficients of determination (R2 ) were moderate to strong for impressions on glass but weaker for plastic. These findings indicated that biological male and female fingermarks could be incorporated into a single universal age estimation model per substrate when utilizing color contrast as an age indicator. Nonetheless, future studies are needed to better understand aging processes on plastic when using this methodology and to determine the life expectancy (i.e., the potential for identification) of latent fingermarks beyond three months.

Fingermark ridge drift: Influencing factors of a not-so-rare aging phenomenon.

Fingermark ridge drift is a random modification of (aged) fingermark patterns at a ridge scale. This phenomenon was previously proven to alter key elements used for identifications, such as the appearance of minutiae. Little is currently reported on the underlying factors contributing to its occurrence. The present study was designed to investigate further the variables of a previous study by including a total of 768 fingermarks from a male and female, two substrates (glazed ceramic tile and plastic), two distinct color powder developers (carbon black and titanium dioxide), three indoor lighting conditions (direct natural light, shade, and darkness), and two secretion types (sebaceous- and eccrine-rich). Fingermarks were aged for 2-72 days, powdered, photographed, and drift detected by three independent observers. All aged fingermarks (672) were compared relative to fresh fingermarks (96), and ridge drift was observed in 42 of 672 (6%) fingermarks, while 168 (25%) were reported as indeterminate results. While ridge drift was detected in multiple fingermarks across all independent variables, statistical analysis using a multinomial logistics model showed that only powder type, secretion type, and the substrate indicated a significant correlation with increased incidences of this phenomenon. There was no significant correlation with the donor, time since deposition, or the environmental lighting conditions used. The highest incidence occurred when carbon black powder was used on a plastic substrate (>10%). The average observation of ridge drift is 6% of samples supporting that this phenomenon is not a rare event, particularly considering the conservative analysis approach implemented.

A More Efficient Method for Synthetic Textile Fiber Analysis Using Polarized Light Microscopy.

The efficiency of conventional polarized light microscopy (PLM) methods for analyzing synthetic fiber evidence analyses is improved. Historically, using PLM for fiber identification relied on measuring refractive index. This prior PLM technology is reliable, but it is not efficient. Most fibers are optically anisotropic, having two principal refractive index values, N(High) and N(Low) . When the fiber is mounted in intermediate refractive index medium, efficiency is improved by observing the change in contrast while the polarized light's vector is rotated relative to the fiber's axis. Minimum contrast occurs when the refractive indices of the mounting medium and fiber are equal. This angle of equality is determined by orienting the fiber's highest refractive index parallel to the polarized light's electric field vector, rotating the fiber or polarizing element, observing minimum contrast and measuring the angle of equality. This method is rapid, reduces remounting fibers in different mounting media and provides a quantitative measure for fiber comparisons.

Deploying Portable Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS) to Military Users for the Identification of Toxic Chemical Agents in Theater.

The use of portable gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) is an important capability that has been available commercially for almost 25 years. These systems have been used within a variety of different industries, including their extensive use by environmental scientists for the analysis of hazardous air pollutants. Recently, these systems were deployed to conventional military forces for use in theater to detect and identify toxic chemicals including chemical warfare agents (CWAs). The challenges of deploying such complex analytical instruments to these military users are unique. Among other things, these organizations have considerable and variable mission strains, complex and difficult logistics and coordination needs, and variability in user backgrounds. This review outlines the value portable GC-MS systems offer to these warfighters in theater, discusses some important aspects of the design of portable systems that makes their deployment to this type of end user possible, and proposes methods that can be used to overcome challenges to successful deployment of portable GC-MS to non-scientists working within hostile environments.

Illicit and Counterfeit Drug Analysis by Morphologically Directed Raman Spectroscopy.

Morphologically directed Raman spectroscopy (MDRS) is a novel tool for the forensic analysis of illicit and counterfeit drug samples. MDRS combines Raman microspectroscopy with automated particle imaging so that physical and chemical information about the components of a mixture sample can be obtained. Results of automated particle imaging are used to determine samples for Raman analysis. The use of MDRS for these types of samples can be employed for both forensic investigations and adjudications of cases. The method provides insight about the physical and chemical composition of the sample, as well as about manufacturing and sample history. Here, MDRS was used in four different illicit and counterfeit drug analyses: (1) examination of a multicomponent drug mixture where the results could be used for comparative source attribution, (2) the detection of low (or trace) concentration particles in a drug sample, (3) the analysis of synthetic cathinone samples (i.e., bath salts), and (4) a study of counterfeit pharmaceutical products.

Morphologically-directed Raman spectroscopy for forensic soil analysis.

Morphologically-directed Raman spectroscopy (MDRS) is a novel yet reliable analytical technique that can be used for a variety of forensic applications, enabling scientists to gain more information from samples than they obtain using more traditional methods. In soil forensics, MDRS delivers particle size distribution and microscopic morphological characteristics for the particles present, and at the same time allows secure mineral identification. In this article, we explore the benefits of utilizing soil in forensic investigations, and demonstrate the value of applying MDRS. Two case studies illustrate the real-life potential and applications of this technology.

Collecting Quality Infrared Spectra from Microscopic Samples of Suspicious Powders in a Sealed Cell.

The infrared (IR) microspectroscopical analysis of samples within a sealed-cell containing barium fluoride is a critical need when identifying toxic agents or suspicious powders of unidentified composition. The dispersive nature of barium fluoride is well understood and experimental conditions can be easily adjusted during reflection-absorption measurements to account for differences in focus between the visible and IR regions of the spectrum. In most instances, the ability to collect a viable spectrum is possible when using the sealed cell regardless of whether visible or IR focus is optimized. However, when IR focus is optimized, it is possible to collect useful data from even smaller samples. This is important when a minimal sample is available for analysis or the desire to minimize risk of sample exposure is important. While the use of barium fluoride introduces dispersion effects that are unavoidable, it is possible to adjust instrument settings when collecting IR spectra in the reflection-absorption mode to compensate for dispersion and minimize impact on the quality of the sample spectrum.